No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
Lost in Transplantation: Revisiting Indigenous Principles as a Panacea to Natural Resource Sustainability in Nigeria
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 06 November 2023
Abstract
Although legal transplants are a most fertile source of legal development, a failure to adapt their methods to local traditions and cultures before putting them into practice often results in the loss of indigenous legal cultures. This article examines environmental jurisprudence in Nigeria. It aims to determine whether the failure of these laws to curb the trend of unsustainable natural resource use in the country is traceable to the indigenous legal cultures of sustainability that were lost in the process of transplanting colonial ideologies into the Nigerian legal system. The article submits that neglecting the innate standards of sustainability in Nigeria's environmental law-making (a practice adopted since the period of colonization) has made the extant laws on natural resource sustainability largely ineffective. It recommends reworking some of the laws to reflect the lost traditions and notes the cultural imperative for natural resource sustainability.
Keywords
- Type
- Research Article
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © The Author(s), 2023. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of SOAS University of London
Footnotes
*
Lecturer, Department of Public Law, Faculty of Law, University of Ibadan.
References
1 Graziadei, M “Legal transplants and the frontiers of legal knowledge” (2009) 10/2 Theoretical Inquiries in Law 723 at 730CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
2 Markovits, I “Exporting law reform: But will it travel” (2004) 37 Cornell International Law Journal 95Google Scholar.
3 Perju, V “Constitutional transplants, borrowing and migrations” in Rosenfeld, M and Sajo, A (eds) Oxford Handbook of Comparative Constitutional Law (2012, Oxford University Press) 1304 at 1311Google Scholar.
4 Beckstrom, JH “Transplantation of legal systems: An early report on the reception of western laws in Ethiopia” (1973) 21 American Journal of Comparative Law 557CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
5 Legrand, P “The impossibility of ‘legal transplants’” (1997) 4/2 Maastricht Journal of European and Comparative Law 111 at 113CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
6 Omitola, B, Akinrinde, OO and Omitola, A “Traditional institutions and socio-economic development in Nigeria: A critical analysis” (2021) 2/4 Journal of Law and Legal Reform 539 at 541CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
7 Ilesanmi, SI “Customary law, the environment, and sustainable development” (2019) 3 Uniport Law Review 219 at 221Google Scholar.
8 Pereira, C and Tsikata, D “Contextualising extractivism in Africa” (2021) 2/1 Feminist Africa 14 at 30Google Scholar.
9 Yahaya, MY “The political economy of oil exploration and environmental degradation in the south-south: Paradoxis of poverty and endowment” (2020) 2/1 International Journal of Political Science and Governance 75 at 77CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
10 Schorr, DB “Horizontal and vertical influences in colonial legal transplantation: Water by-laws in British Palestine” (2021) 61/3 American Journal of Legal History 308 at 312CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
11 Geller, PW “Legal transplant in international copyright: Some problems of methods” (1994) 3 Pacific Basin Law Journal 199 at 199Google Scholar.
12 See Örücü, E “Comparative motley: Offerings from a comparative lawyer” (2021) 8/2 Critical Analysis of Law 9 at 12CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
13 Husa, J “Comparative law, literature, and imagination: Transplanting law into works of fiction” (2021) 28/3 Maastricht Journal of European and Comparative Law 371 at 375CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
14 See Liljeblad, J “The nature of the disciplinary system over Myanmar lawyers: Differences from international standards and implications for international legal transplants” (2021) 28/2 International Journal of the Legal Profession 181 at 187CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
15 C Montesquieu “The spirit of laws” (complete works, 1748) at 19, available at: <https://cutt.ly/9MMYhJa> (last accessed 12 September 2023).
16 Collins, JK Tracing British West Indian Slavery Laws: A Comparative Analysis of Legal Transplants (2021, Routledge) at 21CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
17 Id at 45.
18 Watson, A Legal Transplants: An Approach to Comparative Law (1993, University of Georgia Press)Google Scholar.
19 Cited in A Hoshi “Interpretation of corporate acquisition contracts in Japan: A legal transplant through contract drafting” (2021) 16/1 Asian Journal of Comparative Law 106 at 115.
20 See Legrand “The impossibility”, above at note 5 at 115.
21 G Teubner “Societal constitutionalism: Background, theory, debates” (2021) 15/4 International Constitutional Law Journal 357 at 360.
22 Id at 365.
23 Cited in TS Goldbach “Why legal transplants?” (2019) 15 Annual Review of Law and Social Science 583 at 598.
24 W Ewald “Comparative jurisprudence (II): The logic of legal transplants” (1995) 43/4 The American Journal of Comparative Law 489.
25 H Xanthaki “Legal transplants in legislation: Defusing the trap” (2008) 57/3 International & Comparative Law Quarterly 659.
26 G Ajani “By chance and prestige: Legal transplants in Russia and Eastern Europe” (1995) 43/1 The American Journal of Comparative Law 93.
27 J Husa “Developing legal system, legal transplants, and path dependence: Reflections on the rule of law” (2018) 6/2 The Chinese Journal of Comparative Law 129; JW Cairns “Watson, Walton and the history of legal transplants” (2012–13) 41 Georgia Journal of International and Comparative Law 638; N Garoupa and A Ogus “A strategic interpretation of legal transplants” (2006) 35/2 The Journal of Legal Studies 339.
28 P Shah “Globalisation and the challenge of Asian legal transplants in Europe” (2005) Singapore Journal of Legal Studies 348.
29 J Gillespie “Globalisation and legal transplantation: Lessons from the past” (2001) 6/2 Deakin Law Review 286 at 295.
30 JM Miller “A typology of legal transplants: Using sociology, legal history, and Argentine examples to explain the transplant” (2003) 51/4 The American Journal of Comparative Law 839.
31 SJ Heim “Predicting legal transplants: The case of servitudes in the Russian Federation (1996) 6 Transnational Law and Contemporary Problems 187 at 191.
32 JB Wiener “Something borrowed for something blue: Legal transplants and the evolution of global environmental law” (2000) 27 Ecology Law Quarterly 1295 at 1297.
33 C Alkon “Plea bargaining as a legal transplant: A good idea for troubled criminal justice systems” (2010) 19 Transnational Law and Contemporary Problems 355.
34 B Schafer “Legal transplants and legal downloads” (2001) 15/3 International Review of Law, Computers & Technology 301 at 311.
35 See Liljeblad “The nature of the disciplinary system” above at note 14 at 187.
36 OE Khalil and A Seleim “Culture and knowledge transfer capacity: A cross-national study” (2010) 6/4 International Journal of Knowledge Management 60.
37 MO Nwalutu “The dictum, Igbo enwe eze (Igbo has no king): Socio-cultural underpinnings for understanding the current Igbo peoples’ political dilemma” (2018) 9/1 Sociology Mind 86 at 90.
38 BA Adeyeye “African indigenous knowledge and practices and the 2030 Sustainable Development Goals: Exploring its uniqueness for quality knowledge sharing” (2019) 1/4 Journal of Humanities and Education Development 147 at 149.
39 See id at 151.
40 JO Leke and EN Leke “Environmental sustainability and development in Nigeria: Beyond the rhetoric of governance” (2019) 14/1 International Journal of Development and Management Review 25 at 32.
41 B Archibong “Explaining divergence in the long-term effects of precolonial centralization on access to public infrastructure services in Nigeria” (2019) 121 World Development 123 at 127.
42 YA Collins et al “Plotting the coloniality of conservation” (2021) 28/1 Journal of Political Ecology, available at: <https://eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/180709/3/Collinsetal_2021_Plottingthecolonialityofconservation_Proof_V2.pdf> (last assessed 12 September 2023).
43 C Müller-Crepon “Continuity or change? (In) direct rule in British and French colonial Africa” (2020) 74/4 International Organization 707 at 712.
44 UJ Akpan “Economic diplomacy in Ibibioland: The pre-colonial perspective” (2019) 12/1 International Journal of Social Sciences 1 at 10.
45 Id at 15.
46 GE Odok “Commodification of forestlands and assault on indigenous knowledge within forest-dependent communities of Cross River State, Nigeria” (2019) 74/2 Transactions of the Royal Society of South Africa 126 at 129.
47 Id at 128.
48 SS Ibrahim, H Ozdeser and B Cavusoglu “Testing the impact of environmental hazards and violent conflicts on sustainable pastoral development: Micro-level evidence from Nigeria” (2020) 22/5 Environment, Development and Sustainability 4169 at 4171.
49 FU Asikhia Festus “Nigeria: The anatomy of her existence”, available at: <https://cutt.ly/8MMIXqo> (last accessed 12 September 2023).
50 I Bassey and CE Ekpo “Evaluating the place of the Ekpe traditional institution as a tool for nation-building in pre-colonial Cross River region” (2019) 4 Historical Research Letter 8 at 12.
51 S Ocheni and BC Nwankwo “Analysis of colonialism and its impact in Africa” (2012) 8/3 Cross Cultural Communication 46 at 55.
52 Id at 52.
53 O Nwodim and RU Adah “Colonial policies and post-independence development in Nigeria” (2021) 4/4 International Journal of Social Science and Human Research 795 at 799–801.
54 Ibid.
55 A Ogunba “An appraisal of the evolution of environmental legislation in Nigeria” (2016) 40 Vermont Law Review 673 at 675–78.
56 KC Nnadozie “Pollution control in Nigeria: The legal framework”, cited in Ogunba, id at 676.
57 SG Ogbodo “Environmental protection in Nigeria: Two decades after the Koko Incident” (2009) 15/1 Annual Survey of International & Comparative Law, available at: <https://digitalcommons.law.ggu.edu/annlsurvey/vol15/iss1/2> (last assessed 12 September 2023).
58 BB Orubebe “Soil governance and sustainable land use system in Nigeria: The paradox of inequalities, natural resource conflict and ecological diversity in a federal system” in H Yahyah et al (eds) Legal Instruments for Sustainable Soil Management in Africa. International Yearbook of Soil Law and Policy (2020, Springer) 97 at 101–03.
59 R Home “From cantonments to townships: Lugard's influence upon British colonial urban governance in Africa” (2019) 34/1 Planning Perspectives 43 at 50.
60 See Ogunba “An appraisal of the evolution”, above at note 55 at 677.
61 Now cited as cap C38, Laws of the Federation of Nigeria (LFN) 2004.
62 Id, sec 243.
63 Id, secs 244–45.
64 Ibid.
65 Id, sec 247.
66 N Cornelius, O Amujo and E Pezet “British ‘colonial governmentality’: Slave, forced and waged worker policies in colonial Nigeria, 1896–1930” (2019) 14/1 Management & Organizational History 10 at 25.
67 M Gandy “Planning, anti-planning and the infrastructure crisis facing metropolitan Lagos” (2006) 43 Urban Studies 371 at 375–78.
68 Ibid.
69 See Cornelius, Amujo and Pezet “British ‘colonial governmentality’”, above at note 66 at 28.
70 ON Njoku “Towards building Nigeria into a nation” (2019) 28 Journal of the Historical Society of Nigeria 1 at 13–14.
71 E Akpotor “Crude oil exploration and exploitation in Niger Delta: A Christian concern” (2019) 7/2 International Journal of Innovative Development and Policy Studies 38 at 40.
72 A Nwozor “Depoliticizing environmental degradation: Revisiting the UNEP environmental assessment of Ogoniland in Nigeria's Niger Delta region” (2020) 85/3 GeoJournal 883 at 885–86.
73 T Bodo and BG Gimah “Oil crisis in the Niger Delta Region of Nigeria: Genesis and extent” (2019) 15/36 European Scientific Journal 141 at 149.
74 Now cited as cap 07, LFN 2004.
75 Id, preamble.
76 Emphasis added.
77 Oil Pipelines Act, sec 5(1).
78 Usman, Y “Green criminology and degradation of the environment by activities of multinational oil companies in Nigeria's Niger Delta” (2021) 9/12 Open Journal of Social Sciences 317 at 320CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
79 Now cited as cap H1 7, LFN 2004.
80 Id, sec 1.
81 Id, sec 13.
82 Id, sec 10.
83 Izoukumor, NA “A critical assessment of the pollution prevention laws and regulations of Nigeria: Why they failed to protect the environment of Nigeria” (2019) 87 Journal of Law Policy and Globalization 47 at 50Google Scholar.
84 Now cited as cap P10, LFN 2004.
85 Petroleum Act 1969, sec 1.
86 The Petroleum Products and Distribution (Anti-Sabotage) Act 1975, sec 2.
87 Cap L5, LFN 2004.
88 Cap R9, LFN 2004.
89 Cap E9, LFN 2004.
90 See Ogbodo “Environmental protection”, above at note 57 at 24.
91 The National Policy on the Environment has been revised a number of times, most recently in 2016.
92 Egunjobi, L “Issues in environmental management for sustainable development” (1993) 13 Environmentalist 33CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
93 Cap E12, LFN 2004.
94 EC Enoguanbhor et al “Key challenges for land use planning and its environmental assessments in the Abuja city-region, Nigeria” (2021) 10/5 Land 443 at 445–46.
95 The roadmap to creating an environmentally conscious constitution in Nigeria began with the 1979 constitution. Although this constitution did not contain intuitive provisions on the environment or natural resource use, its specific provisions on refuse clearance and solid and liquid waste management may have set the pace for environmental management in Nigeria. However, with heightened environmental awareness and the environment becoming more of a political priority, it became imperative for the Nigerian apex law to reflect in definite terms its environmental consciousness.
96 The Constitution of the Democratic Republic of Congo 1992, sec 42 guarantees every citizen the right to a satisfactory and sustainable healthy environment with a duty to defend it. It further provides that the state shall regulate the use, protection and conservation of natural resources. The South African Constitution 1996, sec 24 not only covers a right to a healthy environment but one protected for the benefit of both present and future generations through legislative means. This constitution's reflection of sustainable natural resource use also stipulates the policy direction that these legislative means must take to guarantee a healthy environment for all. Any environmental legislation must first forestall pollution and ecological degradation, aggrandize conservation and, most importantly, secure the sustainable use of natural resources while promoting justifiable economic and social development.
97 The section provides: “The judicial powers vested per the foregoing provisions of this section shall not except as otherwise provided by this Constitution, extend to any issue or question as to whether any act or omission by any authority or person or as to whether any law or any judicial decision conforms with the Fundamental Objectives and Directive Principles of State Policy set out in Chapter II of this Constitution.”
98 It is important to note that, despite the restrictions placed on the justiciability of sec 20 by the reading it in combination with sec 6(6)(C), a number of judicial decisions are beginning to establish the importance of sustainable natural resource use. Two such cases are Jonah Gbemre v Shell (2005) AHRLR 151 and Centre for Oil Pollution Watch v Nigerian National Petroleum Corporation [2019] 5 NWLR (pt 1666). These decisions are certainly laudable, but a significant impact is yet to be felt across the overall spectrum of sustained natural resource use in Nigeria.
99 Nwauzi, LO “How fundamental are the fundamental objectives and directive principles under chapter II of the Constitution of Nigeria 1999” (2017) 3/3 Donnish Journal of Law and Conflict Resolution 29 at 31–32Google Scholar.
100 Since 2007 when NESREA came into force, 35 sets of regulations have been made: National Environmental (Wetlands, River Banks and Lake Shores) Regs, SI No 26, 2009; National Environmental (Watershed, Mountainous, Hilly and Catchments Areas) Regs, SI No 27, 2009; National Environmental (Sanitation and Wastes Control) Regs, SI No 28, 2009; National Environmental (Permitting and Licensing System) Regs, SI No 29, 2009; National Environmental (Access to Genetic Resources and Benefit Sharing) Regs, SI No 30, 2009; National Environmental (Mining and Processing of Coal, Ores and Industrial Minerals) Regs, SI No 31, 2009; National Environmental (Ozone Layer Protection) Regs, SI No 65, 2022; National Environmental (Food, Beverages and Tobacco Sector) Regs, SI No 33, 2009; National Environmental (Textile, Wearing Apparel, Leather and Footwear Industry) Regs, SI No 34, 2009; National Environmental (Noise Standards and Control) Regs, SI No 35, 2009; National Environmental (Chemicals, Pharmaceuticals, Soap and Detergent Manufacturing Industries) Regs, SI No 36, 2009; National Environmental (Standards for Telecommunications / Broadcasting Facilities) Regs, SI No 11, 2011; National Environmental (Soil Erosion and Flood Control) Regs, SI No 12, 2011; National Environmental (Desertification Control and Drought Mitigation) Regs, SI No 13, 2011; National Environmental (Base Metals, Iron and Steel Manufacturing / Recycling Industries) Regs, SI No 14, 2011; National Environmental (Control of Bush / Forest Fire and Open Burning) Regs, SI No 15, 2011; National Environmental (Protection of Endangered Species in International Trade) Regs, SI No 16, 2011; National Environmental (Domestic and Industrial Plastic, Rubber and Foam Sector) Regs, SI No 17, 2011; National Environmental (Coastal and Marine Area Protection) Regs, SI No 18, 2011; National Environmental (Construction Sector) Regs, SI No 19, 2011; National Environmental (Control of Vehicular Emissions from Petrol and Diesel Engines) Regs, SI No 20, 2011; National Environmental (Non-Metallic Minerals Manufacturing Industries Sector) Regs, SI No 21, 2011; National Environmental (Surface and Groundwater Quality Control) Regs, SI No 22, 2011; National Environmental (Electrical / Electronic Sector) Regs, SI No 79, 2022; National Environmental (Quarrying and Blasting Operations) Regs, SI No 33, 2013; National Environmental (Control of Alien and Invasive Species) Regs, SI No 32, 2013; National Environmental (Pulp and Paper, Wood and Wood Products) Regs, SI No 34, 2013; National Environmental (Motor Vehicle and Miscellaneous Assembly) Regs, SI No 35, 2013; National Environmental (Air Quality Control) Regs, SI No 88, 2021 (amended); National Environmental (Control of Charcoal Production and Export) Regs, SI No 62, 2014; National Environmental (Dams and Reservoirs) Regs, SI No 66, 2014; National Environmental (Hazardous Chemicals and Pesticides) Regs, SI No 65, 2014; National Environmental (Energy Sector) Regs, SI No 63, 2014; National Environmental (Healthcare Waste Control) Regs, B 2565–92, 2021; and National Environmental (Polychlorinated Biphenyls (PBCs) Control and Disposal) Regs 2020 B249–98. For further information, see the NESREA website at: <www.nesrea.gov.ng> (last assessed 12 September 2023).
101 Cap 164, LFN 2004. This act represented the first major initiative by a duly elected legislature to enact versatile environmental legislation to give effect to the provisions of the 1999 Constitution, sec 20. It established NESREA to serve as the nation's lead agency on environmental protection.
102 Adetiba, A “What Britain did to Nigeria: A short history of conquest and rule” (2021) 20/4 African Studies Quarterly 99 at 99–100Google Scholar.
103 Atanda, JO and Olukoya, OA “Green building standards: Opportunities for Nigeria” (2019) 227 Journal of Cleaner Production 366 at 370CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
104 Owolabi, A and Olorunfemi, F “Reflections on environmental security, indigenous knowledge and the reflections for sustainable development in Nigeria” (2014) 12/1 Journal of Research in National Development 46 at 51Google Scholar; Diver, S “Negotiating indigenous knowledge at the science-poly interphase: Insights from the Xaxli'p community forest” (2017) 73 Environmental Science and Policy 1 at 7–8CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Mwanga, E “The role of by-laws in enhancing the integration of indigenous knowledge” (2019) 13/1 Carbon & Climate Law Review 19 at 21–22CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Bairal, O, Heras-Saizabitoria, I and Brotherton, MC “Improving environmental management through indigenous people's involvement” (2020) 103 Environmental Science and Policy 10 at 12–13Google Scholar.
105 Oyebode, OJ “Impact of environmental laws and regulations on Nigerian environment” (2018) 7/3 World Journal of Research and Review 9Google Scholar.
106 Chiwendu, OB and Osimiri, UJ “The jurisprudence of compliance and enforceability of environmental protection laws in Nigeria” (2020) 93 Journal of Law Policy & Globalization 147Google Scholar.
107 Aluko, YA “Rural women's indigenous knowledge of the nutritional and medicinal use of vegetables in southwest Nigeria” (2016) 46/2 Journal of Social Sciences 98 at 99–100CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
108 Agbontale, A, Omotayo, A and Issa, F “Indigenous knowledge of the techniques for preservation of vegetables in Niger State, Nigeria” (2017) 8/1–2 Journal of Sustainable Development 31Google Scholar.
109 See Yahaya “The political economy”, above at note 9 at 77; Akinsulore, A “The effects of legislation on corporate social responsibility in the minerals and mines sector of Nigeria” (2016) 7 Journal of Sustainable Development Law and Policy 97Google Scholar; BO Nwankwo “Conflict in the Niger Delta and corporate social responsibility of multinational oil companies: An assessment” (PhD thesis, University of Derby, 2017), available at: <https://repository.derby.ac.uk/item/9484z/conflict-in-the-niger-delta-and-corporate-social-responsibility-of-multinational-oil-companies-an-assessment> (last accessed 12 September 2023).
110 3 PLR/2010/59 (CA). See further Ogiale v Shell (1976) 4 NWLR (pt 445) 657; Agbara & Others v Shell Petroleum Development Company of Nigeria Limited & Others unreported suit no FHC/ASB/CS/231/2001; and Elf Nigeria Limited v Opere Sillo [1994] 6 NWLR (pt 350) 258.
111 Asogwa, IS, Okoye, JI and Oni, K “Promotion of indigenous food preservation and processing knowledge and the challenge of food security in Africa” (2017) 5/3 Journal of Food Security 75 at 80–82Google Scholar.