The Romantic Economist
Since economies are dynamic processes driven by creativity, social norms and emotions, as well as rational calculation, why do economists largely study them through the prism of static equilibrium models and narrow rationalistic assumptions? Economic activity is as much a function of imagination and social sentiments as of the rational optimisation of given preferences and goods. Richard Bronk argues that economists can best model and explain these creative and social aspects of markets by using new structuring assumptions and metaphors derived from the poetry and philosophy of the Romantics. By bridging the divide between literature and science, and between Romanticism and narrow forms of rationalism, economists can access grounding assumptions, models and research methods suitable for comprehending the creativity and social dimensions of economic activity. This is a guide to how economists and other social scientists can broaden their analytical repertoire to encompass the vital role of sentiments, language and imagination.
Educated at Merton College, Oxford, Richard Bronk gained a first class degree in Classics and Philosophy. He spent the first seventeen years of his career working in the City of London, where he acquired a wide expertise in international economics, business and politics. His first book, Progress and the Invisible Hand (1998) was well received critically, and anticipated millennial angst about the increasingly strained relationship between economic growth and progress in welfare. Having returned to academic life in 2000, Bronk is now a writer and part-time academic.
richard bronk is currently a Visiting Fellow in the European Institute at the London School of Economics and Political Science.
The Romantic Economist
Imagination in Economics
Richard Bronk
London School of Economics and Political Science
CAMBRIDGE UNIVERSITY PRESS
Cambridge, New York, Melbourne, Madrid, Cape Town, Singapore, São Paulo, Delhi
Cambridge University Press
The Edinburgh Building, Cambridge CB2 8RU, UK
Published in the United States of America by Cambridge University Press, New York
www.cambridge.org
Information on this title: www.cambridge.org/9780521735155
© Richard Bronk 2009
This publication is in copyright. Subject to statutory exception and to the provisions of relevant collective licensing agreements, no reproduction of any part may take place without the written permission of Cambridge University Press.
First published 2009
Printed in the United Kingdom at the University Press, Cambridge
A catalogue record for this publication is available from the British Library
Library of Congress Cataloguing in Publication data
Bronk, Richard.
The romantic economist : imagination in economics / Richard Bronk.
p. cm.
Includes bibliographical references and index.
ISBN 978-0-521-51384-5
1. Economics. 2. Romanticism – Economic aspects.
3. Economics – Philosophy. I. Title.
HB71.B7786 2009
330–dc22
2008041688
ISBN 978-0-521-51384-5 hardback
ISBN 978-0-521-73515-5 paperback
Cambridge University Press has no responsibility for the persistence or accuracy of URLs for external or third-party internet websites referred to in this book, and does not guarantee that any content on such websites is, or will remain, accurate or appropriate.
In memory of my father
John Ramsey Bronk (1929–2007)
The histories and political economy of the present and preceding century partake in the general contagion of its mechanic philosophy, and are the product of an unenlivened generalizing understanding.
Samuel Taylor Coleridge, The Statesman’s Manual (1816)
In weakness we create distinctions, thenBelieve that all our puny boundaries are thingsWhich we perceive and not which we have made.William Wordsworth, Fragment (c. 1799)
Strange as it may seem, if we read History with any degree of thoughtfulness, we shall find, that the checks and balances of Profit and Loss have never been the grand agents with men; that they have never been roused into deep, thorough, all-pervading efforts by any computable prospect of Profit and Loss, for any visible, finite object; but always for some invisible and infinite one.
Thomas Carlyle, Signs of the Times (1829)
Valuation is expectation and expectation is imagination.
George Shackle, Epistemics and Economics (1972)
Contents
|
Preface
|
xi |
|
Acknowledgements
|
xvi |
|
1 Preface to The Romantic Economist
|
1 |
|
1 The Romantic and imaginative aspects of economics
|
1 |
|
2 Romantic Economist: neither revolutionary nor mainstream
|
7 |
|
3 Using the history of ideas
|
11 |
|
4 Wordsworth and Marshall
|
15 |
|
5 The structuring role of metaphor
|
22 |
|
6 Romantic economics prefigured
|
25 |
|
Part I The Prelude: The Romantic Economist and the History of Ideas
|
29 |
|
2 The great divide
|
31 |
|
1 Mill on Bentham and Coleridge
|
31 |
|
2 Nervous breakdown of an economist
|
37 |
|
3 The philosophy and history of two cultures
|
40 |
|
4 Mill and a bridge too short
|
50 |
|
3 Debates within political economy
|
57 |
|
1 Smith and the emergence of a discipline
|
59 |
|
2 Recurring disagreements
|
67 |
|
3 The triumph of social physics and Rational Choice
|
78 |
|
4 Lessons from Romanticism
|
84 |
|
1 Interdependent themes and lessons
|
87 |
|
2 Unity and fragments
|
103 |
|
Part II Fragments of Unity: Romantic Economics in Practice
|
117 |
|
5 Using organic metaphors in economics
|
119 |
|
1 Economic models of interdependence and growth
|
122 |
|
2 Complexity Theory: moving towards a new template
|
128 |
|
3 The lessons of organicism
|
133 |
|
4 Some applications of the organic metaphor
|
141 |
|
6 Economics and the nation state
|
149 |
|
1 National versus universal solutions
|
149 |
|
2 Early advocates of national economics
|
154 |
|
3 Varieties of Capitalism and beyond
|
158 |
|
4 Globalisation and national economics
|
168 |
|
7 Incommensurable values
|
172 |
|
1 No single scale of value
|
172 |
|
2 The measurement and ethical definition of policy success
|
180 |
|
3 Consistency and indifference
|
190 |
|
8 Imagination and creativity in markets
|
196 |
|
1 The nature of imagination
|
198 |
|
2 The economy as creative process
|
207 |
|
3 Imagination and the microfoundations of economics
|
214 |
|
9 Homo romanticus and other homines
|
225 |
|
1 Homo economicus through thick and thin
|
225 |
|
2 Homo economicus in symbiosis with homo romanticus
|
234 |
|
3 Homo sociologicus: cohabiting with cousins
|
241 |
|
4 The role of sentiment and sympathy
|
247 |
|
5 ‘Superman’ and self-creation in economics
|
252 |
|
10 Imagination and perspective in economics
|
256 |
|
1 After Kant: a disconcerting or liberating philosophy?
|
256 |
|
2 Reading the interpretations that structure social reality
|
263 |
|
3 Kuhn, imagination and the nature of paradigms
|
267 |
|
4 The creative use of metaphor
|
273 |
|
5 Romantic pointers to best research practice
|
276 |
|
11 The Romantic Economist: conclusion
|
288 |
|
Notes
|
305 |
|
Bibliography
|
354 |
|
Index
|
367 |
© Cambridge University Press
