Skip to main content
  • Print publication year: 1999
  • Online publication date: March 2008

13 - Theology

Philosophical theology is a rational enterprise or at any rate an attempt to rationalize the irrational. This chapter concentrates on three ingredients of Hellenistic theology which together form a sort of triptych: the issues of the existence and attributes of the gods; the questions of divine providence and theodicy, or the relation between the gods and the world and humans; and problems regarding our knowledge of the divine. The views of the Epicureans and the Stoics on the relation between the gods and the world and men are radically opposed to each other. Nevertheless they share a common purpose in that they both strive to liberate us from fear. Academic theological arguments are ascribed to Carneades, who refutes conclusions, not premisses. One of his lines of attack is to undermine the tenet, held and argued by Stoics as well as Epicureans, that the gods are living beings.
Recommend this book

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this book to your organisation's collection.

The Cambridge History of Hellenistic Philosophy
  • Online ISBN: 9781139053617
  • Book DOI:
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
Babut D. (1974) La Religion des Philosophes Grecs, de Thales aux Stoiciens (Paris).
Barnes J. (1989a) ‘The size of the sun in antiquity’, ACD 25.
Bett R. (1994a) ‘What did Pyrrho think about “the nature of the divine and the good”?’, Phronesis 39.
Boyancé P. (1962) ‘Les preuves stoïciennes de l'existence des dieux d'après Cicéron’, Hermes 90.
Brunschwig J. (1994d) ‘Did Diogenes of Babylon invent the ontological argument?’, in Brunschwig (1994a).
Burnyeat M. F. (1982b) ‘Gods and heaps’, in Schofield & Nussbaum (1982).
Clay D. (1986) ‘The cults of Epicurus’, CErc 16.
Couissin P. (1941) ‘Les sorites de Carnéade contre le polythéisme’, REG 54.
Daiber H. (1992) ‘The Meteorology of Theophrastus in Syriac and Arabic translation’, in Fortenbaugh & Gutas (1992).
Decleva Caizzi F., ed. (1981a) Pirrone: Testimonianze, Elenchos 5 (Naples).
Diels H., ed. (1916/17) Philodemos über die Götter, Erstes und drittes Buch, Abh. der königlich Preussischen Akad. der Wiss. 1915.7/1916.4 and 6, philos.-hist. Klasse (Berlin).
Dionigi I. (1976) ‘Lucr. 6, 1198–1203 e P. Oxy. 215 col. 17–24: L'epicureismo e la venerazione degli dei’, SIFC 48.
Döring K. (1978) ‘Antike Theorien über die staatspolitische Notwendigkeit der Götterfurcht’, A & A 24.
Dragona-Monachou M. (1976) The Stoic Arguments for the Existence and the Providence of the Gods (Athens).
Dumont J.-P. (1982) ‘Diogène de Babylone et la preuve ontologique’, RPh 107.
Erler M. (1992a) ‘Orthodoxie und Anpassung. Philodem, ein Panaitis des Kepos?’, MH 49.
Erler M. (1993) ‘Philologia medicans. Wie die Epikureer die Texte ihres Meisters lasen’, in Kullmann W. & Althoff J., edd., Vermittlung und Tradierung von Wissen in der griechischen Kultur (Tübingen).
Fahr W. (1969) “θEOYσ NOMIZEIN”, Zum Problem der Anfänge des Atheismus bei den Griechen, Spudasmata 26 (Hildesheim/New York).
Festugière A.-J. (1949) La révélation d'Hermès Trismégiste, II: Le Dieu cosmique (Paris, later repr.).
Gercke A., ed. (1885) Chrysippea (Leipzig).
Hankinson R. J. (1995) The Sceptics (London).
Henrichs A. (1974) ‘Die Kritik der stoischen Theologie im PHerc. 1428’, CErc 4.
Henrichs A. (1975) ‘Two doxographical notes: Democritus and Prodicus on religion’, HSPh 79.
Inwood B. (1985) Ethics and Human Action in Early Stoicism (Oxford).
Kattenbusch F. (1930) ‘Die Entstehung einer christlichen Theologie. Zur Geschichte der Ausdrücke θ∊oλoγια, θ∊oλoγ∊ĩν, θ∊oλóγoς’, Zeitschrift für Theologie und Kirche N. F. 11.
Kleve K. (1979) ‘The Epicurean isonomia and its sceptical refutation’, SO 54.
Lange F. A. (1974) Geschichte des Materialismus und Kritik seiner Bedeutung in der Gegenwart, Bd. 1: Geschichte des Materialismus bis auf Kant (Iserlohn 1866, 11 1921; repr. Frankfurt A. M. 1974 with introd. by Schmidt A.).
Lemke D. (1973) Die Theologie Epikurs: Versuch einer Rekonstruktion, Zetemata 57 (Munich).
Long A. A. (1975–6) ‘Heraclitus and Stoicism’, Philosophia 5/6 ; repr. in Long (1996).
Long A. A. (1990) ‘Scepticism about Gods in Hellenistic philosophy’, in Griffith M. & Mastronarde D. J., edd., Cabinet of the Muses, Essays on Classical and Comparative Literature in Honor of Thomas G. Rosenmeyer (Atlanta).
Long A. A. & Sedley D. N., edd. (1987) The Hellenistic Philosophers, 2 vols.: i. Translations of the principal sources with philosophical commentary; ii. Greek and Latin texts with notes and bibliography (Cambridge, various reprints).
Longo Auricchio F., ed. (1988) Ermarco: Frammenti, La scuola di Epicuro 6 (Naples).
Mansfeld J. (1979) ‘Providence and the destruction of the universe in early Stoic thought’, in Vermaseren M. J., ed., Studies in Hellenistic Religions, EPRO 78 (Leiden) ; repr. in Mansfeld (1989b) study 1.
Mansfeld J. (1981) ‘Protagoras on epistemological obstacles and persons’, in Kerferd G. B., ed., The Sophists and their Legacy, Proceedings of the Fourth International Colloquium on Ancient Philosophy, Hermes Einzelschr. 44 (Wiesbaden).
Mansfeld J. (1983b) ‘Techne: a new fragment of Chrysippus’, GRBS 24 ; repr. in Mansfeld (1989b) study III.
Mansfeld J. (1990a) ‘Doxography and dialectic: The Sitz im Leben of the “Placita”’, in Haase W., ed., ANRW 11 36.4 (Berlin/New York).
Mansfeld J. (1992b) ‘A Theophrastean excursus on God and nature and its aftermath in Hellenistic thought’, Phronesis 37.
Mansfeld J. (1992c) ‘Physikai doxai and problemata physika from Aristotle to Aëtius (and beyond)’, in Fortenbaugh & Gutas (1992).
Mansfeld J. (1993) ‘Aspects of Epicurean theology’, Mnemosyne 46.
Mansfeld J. (1994a) ‘Epicurus peripateticus’, in Alberti A., ed., Realtà e ragione, Studi di filosofia antica (Florence).
Obbink D. (1984) ‘P.Oxy. 215 and Epicurean religious θ∊ωρια’, in Atti del XVII Congresso internazionale di papirologia, vol. II (Naples).
Obbink D. (1989) ‘The atheism of Epicurus’, GRBS 30.
Obbink D., ed. (1996) Philodemus On Piety, Part 1: Critical Text with Commentary (Oxford).
Pépin J. (1976) Mythe et allégorie. Les origines grecques et les contestations judéo-chrétiennes, 2nd edn (Paris).
Romeo C. (1979) ‘Demetrio Lacone sulla grandezza del sole (PHerc. 1013)’, CErc 9.
Runia D. T. (1992) ‘The language of excellence in Plato's Timaeus and later Platonism’, in Gersh S. & Kannengiesser C., eds., Platonism in Late Antiquity (Notre Dame).
Runia D. T. (1996b) ‘Atheists in Aëtius. Text, translation and comments on De placitis 1.7.1–10’, Mnemosyne IV.59.
Sandbach F. H. (1985) Aristotle and the Stoics, PCPhS suppl. vol. 10 (Cambridge).
Schian R. (1973) Untersuchungen über das ‘argumentum e consensu omnium’, Spudasmata 28 (Hildesheim).
Schofield M. (1980b) ‘Preconception, argument and god’, in Schofield et al. (1980a).
Schofield M. (1983) ‘The syllogisms of Zeno of Citium’, Phronesis 28.
Verbeke G. (1949) Kleanthes van Assos (Brussels).
Winiarczyk M., ed. (1981) Diagorae Melii et Theodori Cyrenaei reliquiae, Bibl. Teubneriana (Leipzig).
Winiarczyk M. (1984) ‘Wer galt im Altertum als Atheist?’, Philologus 128.
Winiarczyk M. (1992) ‘Wer galt im Altertum als Atheist? 2. Teil’, Philologus 136.
Woodward P. G. (1989) ‘Star gods in Philodemus, PHerc. 152/157’, CErc 19.
Zanker G. (1981) ‘Enargeia in the ancient criticism of poetry’, RhM 124.
Zeller E. (& Wellmann E., ed.) (1909) Die Philosophie der Griechen in ihrer geschichtlichen Entwicklung, III.1: Die nacharistotelische Philosophie, erste Hälfte (Leipzig; 5 1923 = Darmstadt 6 1963).