Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-dnltx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-24T08:04:56.707Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

8 - ALEXANDER IN IRAN

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 March 2008

E. Badian
Affiliation:
Harvard University
Get access

Summary

The pervasive source problem that makes a proper history of relations between Greeks and Persians almost impossible – the absence of any historiographical record and paucity of evidence on the Persian side – must inevitably bedevil any attempt to write the history of Alexander's conquest of Iran, where these relations culminate in temporary fusion. It is clear from earlier periods that even the best evidence on the Greek side, quite apart from its bias and its focus of interest, is factually unreliable where it can be checked. Thus Herodotus gives us a Persian satrapy list differing from the great list of Darius at Behistun, and no modern ingenuity has plausibly reconciled them; to take a small point of fact: Herodotus (III.70.3) makes Hystaspes, the father of Darius, satrap of Persis (a post that may in fact not have existed at the time) when the Persian record shows he was satrap of Parthia and Hyrcania. In the case of Alexander the situation is far more unsatisfactory. The historical record as we have it is not only a Greek record, but is so much centred in Alexander's person that even the history of Greece under his rule is difficult to disentangle, despite the existence of at least some independent primary evidence and our familiarity with the general background. In the case of Iran, evidence on the last generation of Achaemenian rule (not to mention Alexander's) is so far almost nonexistent ; the background must be largely filled in by extrapolation from an earlier age, and it is in part the Alexander sources that provide us with occasional glimpses of the later Achaemenian empire. Not only do these sources give us little that does not concern Alexander's personal actions, but they are vague about, and uninterested in, institutional and topographical details, and difficult to interpret because of multiple layers of distortion due to bias and mere romance; we should be only too grateful for a Herodotus.

Type
Chapter
Information
Publisher: Cambridge University Press
Print publication year: 1985

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Andreotti, R.Il problema di Alessandro Magno della istoriografia dell' ultimo decennio”, (Journal of Ancient History) (Wiesbaden) 1 (1950). A critical survey, concentrating on items relevant to Alexander's character, aims and achievement and covering approximately the previous decade.Google Scholar
Andreotti, R.Die Weltmonarchie Alexanders des Grossen in Überlieferung und geschichtlicher Wirklichkeit”, Saeculum VIII (1957). Noteworthy as the classic statement of the anti-romantic and ‘minimalist’ position on Alexander's aims and motives; Tarn and Schachermeyr (cited above) may, in different ways, be taken as standing at the opposite extreme.Google Scholar
Arrian, . Anabasis and Indica, ed. and tr. Brunt, P. A., 2 vols. 1976, 1983 (Loeb Classical Library (Cambridge, Mass.—London). This supersedes the unsatisfactory edition of E. Iliff Robson.
Arrian, . Anabasis, tr. Selincourt, A., ed. and corrected Hamilton, J. R., with short historical notes. Harmondsworth, 1971 (Penguin Books).
Arrian, . Indica (Arrien, L'Inde ), ed. and tr. Chantraine, P., 2nd ed. Paris, 1952 (Collection Budé).
Atkinson, J. E. A Commentary on Quintus Curtius Rufus' Historiae Alexandri Magni, books 3 and 4. Amsterdam, 1980 (London Studies in Classical Philology 4).
Badian, E.Alexander the Great 1948–67”, Classical World LXV (19711972). A critical survey covering the years 1948–67, with an appendix on 1968.Google Scholar
Badian, E. (ed.) Alexandre le Grand. image et réalité. Entretiens sur l'antiquité classique 25–30 aout 1975. Geneva, 1976 (Fondation Hardt. Entretiens XXII). Articles by seven scholars, each followed by discussion, on aspects of the life, career and posthumous influence of Alexander.
Badian, E.The death of Philip II”, Phoenix (The Journal of the Classical Association of Canada) (Toronto) XVII (1963).Google Scholar
Badian, E.Orientals in Alexander's army”, Journal of Hellenic Studies (London) LXXXV (1965).Google Scholar
Badian, E.The administration of the empire”, Greece and Rome (published for the Classical Association) (Oxford) [section III above]. A brief general survey.
Badian, E.Alexander the Great and the Greeks of Asia”, in Badian, E. (ed.), Ancient Society and Institutions: studies presented to Victor Ehrenberg (Oxford, 1966).Google Scholar
Badian, E.Harpalus”, Journal of Hellenic Studies (London) LXXXI (1961). The reorganization of 324–23 is discussed in the light of the political crisis of that period.Google Scholar
Badian, E.The deification of Alexander the Great”, in Dell, H. J. (ed.), Ancient Macedonian Studies in Honor of Charles F. Edson (Thessaloniki, 1981). (Institute for Balkan Studies 158).Google Scholar
Badian, E.Some recent interpretations of Alexander”, in Alexandre le Grand [section III above].
Badian, E.A king's notebooks”, Harvard Studies in Classical Philology (Cambridge, Mass.) LXXII (1968). On the so-called ‘last plans’ — a problem of critical use of sources rather than of Alexander history.Google Scholar
Balsdon, J. V. P. D.The divinity of Alexander”, (Journal of Ancient History) (Wiesbaden) 1 (1950).Google Scholar
Berve, H. Das Alexanderreich auf prosopographischer Grundlage, 2 vols. Munich, 1926. Probably the most important single work ever written on Alexander. Vol. 1 discusses both civil and military organization; vol. 11 gives a register (with sources and discussion) of all persons known or alleged to have come into contact with Alexander; the numbers allocated to those persons by Berve are now regularly used by specialists to identify them.
Borza, E. N.Alexander's communications”, in Laourdas, B. and Makarras, C. (eds.), Ancient Macedonia 11 (Thessaloniki, 1977).Google Scholar
Bosworth, A. B. A Historical Commentary on Arrian's History of Alexander 1 (Books 1–3). Oxford, 1980.
Bosworth, A. B.The government of Syria under Alexander the Great’, The Classical Quarterly (new series) (Oxford) XXIV (1974).Google Scholar
Briant, P.Brigandage, dissidence et conquête en Asie Achéménide et hellénistique”, Dialogues d'Histoire Ancienne 11 (Paris, 1976), (Annales Litteraires de l'Université de Besançon 188). Studies Alexander's methods in securing frontiers and peaceful communications against barbarians and tribesmen.Google Scholar
Brunt, P. A.Alexander's Macedonian cavalry”, Journal of Hellenic Studies (London) LXXXIII (1963).Google Scholar
Brunt, P. A. A very useful general discussion in LCL edition of Arrian [section II. 1 above].
Cawkwell, G. L., The Classical Quarterly (new series) (Oxford) XIX (1969).
Davis, E. W.The Persian battle plan at the Granicus”, in Gyles, F. and Davis, E. W. (eds.), Laudatores Temporis Acti: studies in memory of Wallace Everett Caldwell (Chapel Hill, North Carolina, 1964). (James Sprunt Studies in History and Political Science 46.)Google Scholar
Demandt, A.Politische Aspekte im Alexanderbilt der Neuzeit”, Archiv für Kulturgeschichte LIV (Vienna, 1972). For background to varying interpretations.Google Scholar
Dieulafoy, M. La bataille d'Issus. Paris, 1914.
Diodorus Siculus. Book XVII, ed. and tr. Welles, C. B.. 1963 (Loeb Classical Library (Cambridge, Mass.—London) Diodorus VIII).
Diodorus Siculus. Book XVII, ed. and tr. Goukowsky, P.. Paris, 1976 (Collection Budé).
Diodorus Siculus. Book XVIII, ed. and tr. Geer, R. M.. 1947 (Loeb Classical Library (Cambridge, Mass.—London) Diodorus IX). Though dealing with events after Alexander's death this book contains many comments relevant to his lifetime.
Diodorus Siculus. Book XVIII, ed. and tr. Goukowsky, P.. Paris, 1978 (Collection Budé).
Droysen, J. G. Geschichte Alexanders des Grossen. Hamburg, 1833; ed. 1877; repr. Dusseldorf, 1966.
Eddy, S. K., The King is Dead (Lincoln, Nebr., 1961), ch. 2.
Edmunds, L.The religiosity of Alexander”, Greek, Roman and Byzantine Studies XII (Durham, North Carolina, 1971). Discusses Alexander's attitude to, and imitation of, gods and heroes.Google Scholar
Eggermont, P. H. L. Alexander's Campaigns in Sind and Baluchistan and the Siege of the Brahmin town of Harmatelia. Leuven, 1975. On the sites of Alexander's cities and colonies
Engels, D. W. Alexander the Great and the Logistics of the Macedonian Army. Berkeley, Calif., 1978. Appendices 4 and 5 deal in detail with the march through Gedrosia.
Engels, W. D. [section VI above].
Fears, J. R.Pausanias the assassin of Philip II”, Athenaeum (Studi Periodici di Letteratura e Storia dell' Antichità; new series 1923–) (Pavia) LIII (1975).Google Scholar
Fischer, K.Zur Lage von Kandahar”, Bonner Jahrbücher CLXVII (1967).Google Scholar
Foss, C. and Badian, E.The battle of the Granicus: a new look”, in Laourdas, B. and Makarras, C. (eds.), Ancient Macedonia 11 (Thessaloniki, 1977). A single article, the two parts to be read together.Google Scholar
Fuller, J. F. C., The Generalship of Alexander the Great (London, 1958).
Goukowsky, P. Essai sur les origines du myhte d'Alexandre (336–270 av. J.-C.), 2 vols. Nancy, 1978, 1981. This work deals in erudite detail with a selection of incidents in Alexander's life deemed important for the genesis of his myth; though discursive and at times fanciful, it should be read by the serious student.
Greece and Rome (published for the Classical Association) (Oxford) XII. 2 (October, 1965, Original articles by various scholars on aspects of Alexander history; all are in English.
Greece and Rome (published for the Classical Association) (Oxford) [ibid.]. Essays by Briunt, P. A. and Welles, C. B..
Green, P. Alexander of Macedon 356–323 b.c. Harmondsworth, 1974 (Penguin Books). Well written and unorthodox.
Griffith, G. T. (ed.) Alexander the Great: the main problems. Cambridge, 1966. Reprints of 16 articles, in English and German, by various authors, over the years 1933–61.
Griffith, G. T.A note on the hipparchies of Alexander”, ibid..
Griffith, (ed.), Alexander [section III above]. Several essays.
Hamilton, J. R. Plutarch Alexander: a Commentary. Oxford, 1969.
Hamilton, J. R.The cavalry battle at the Hydaspes”, Journal of Hellenic Studies (London) LXXVI (1956).Google Scholar
Hammond, N. G. L. Alexander the Great: King, commander and statesman. Park Ridge, N.J., 1980. Some useful discussion of battles and a few interesting topographical photographs.
On the Macedonian background, Philip II and Alexander as crown prince: Hammond, N. G. L. and Griffith, G. T. A History of Macedonia 11. Oxford, 1979.
Hansman, J.The problems of Qūmis”, JRAS 1968. Identifies Hecatompylus with Shahr-i Qūmis.Google Scholar
Hauben, H.The command structure in Alexander's Mediterranean fleets”, Ancient Society 111 (Leuven, 1972).Google Scholar
Hedin, S. A. Overland to India II (London, 1910), ch. 49, “Alexander's march through southern Baluchistan.” Outdated, but a pioneer effort.
Janke, A. Auf Alexanders des Grossen Pfaden. Berlin, 1904. A detailed investigation, by a team of Imperial German officers, of Issus and parts of Asia Minor, including the Granicus.
Lock, R. A.The Macedonian army assembly in the time of Alexander the great”, Classical Philology (Chicago) LXXII (1977). Demolishes the traditional view of a Macedonian system of Staatsrecht, in which King and People-in-arms are thought to have had clearly defined rights.Google Scholar
Luschey, H., Archäologische Mitteilungen aus Iran (old series 9 vols 1929–38; new series 1968–) (Berlin) 1 (1968).
Markle, M. M. III. “Use of the sarissa by Philip and Alexander of Macedon”, American Journal of Archaeology (Baltimore) LXXXII (1978). On the technical side, probably the most important article of recent years. Cf. his study of weapons in American Journal of Archaeology (Baltimore) LXXXI.Google Scholar
Marquart, J.Alexanders Marsch von Persepolis nach Herat” in “Untersuchungen zur Geschichte von Eran II”, Philologus (Zeitschrift für das classische Alterthum) (Göttingen—Leipzig—Berlin), Supplement X.1 (1907).Google Scholar
Marsden, E. W. The campaign of Gaugamela. Liverpool, 1964 (Liverpool Monographs in Archaeology and Oriental Studies). Impaired by failure to notice source problems.
Milns, R. D. in Alexandre le Grand [section III above].
Nicol, M. B., East and West XX (1970).
Pédech, P.Strabon Historien d'Alexandre”, Grazer Beiträge II (Amsterdam, 1974).Google Scholar
Plutarch, . “Alexander” in Plutarch's Lives, vol. VII, ed. and tr. Perrin, B.. 1919 (Loeb Classical Library (Cambridge, Mass.—London).Google Scholar
,Quintus Curtius Rufus. History of Alexander, 10 books in 2 vols, ed. and tr. Rolfe, J. C.. 1946 (Loeb Classical Library (Cambridge, Mass.—London).
,Quintus Curtius Rufus. (Quinte-Curce, Histoires) ed. and tr. Bardon, H., 2 vols. Paris, 19471948 (Collection Budé).
Quintus Curtius Rufus De gestis Alexandri Magni, ed. Mützell, J., with critical and exegetical commentary, 2 vols. Berlin, 1841. This is still the only complete edition of this kind of any of the major sources except Plutarch.
Schachermeyr, F. Alexander der Grosse. Vienna, 1973 (SW AW 85). New edition of 1949 publication, considerably revised and enlarged; it contains full annotation and appendices, unusually fine photographs and extensive discussion of modern interpretations.
Schachermeyr, F. Alexander in Babylon. Vienna, 1970 (SW AW 268.3). This collection of important studies is perhaps most useful in its discussion of the topography of Achaemenian Babylon; it also deals with Alexander's actions in Babylon and (in the second half) with the events at Babylon, after his death, that led to the compromise among the marshals.
Seibert, J. Alexander der Grosse. Darmstadt, 1972 (Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft, Erträge der Forschung 10). This is a full bibliography of (in principle) all scholarship from Droyson's Geschichte (1877) [section IV below] down to about 1970, with occasional reference to important earlier items; it consists chiefly of classified lists, with summaries and occasional critical evaluations on selected problems; it is basic for serious research; its chief strength is in work written in (or translated into) German; work in English is usually inadequately reported and sometimes misunderstood.
Stahl, A. F.. “Notes on the march of Alexander the Great from Ecbatana to Hyrcania”, The Geographical Journal (London) LXIV (1924). Fixed the site of Ecbatana at Hamadān and traced the route of Alexander's pursuit of Darius, suggesting a site for Hecatompylus that Hansman (below) later excavated.Google Scholar
Stein, M. A. Old routes of Western Iran (London, 1940). For the route from Behbahān to Persepolis.
Stein, M. A.On Alexander's route into Gedrosia”, The Geographical Journal (London) CII (1943).Google Scholar
Stein, M. A. On Alexander's track to the Indus. London, 1929.
Stein, M. A.The site of Alexander's passage of the Hydaspes and the battle with Poros”, The Geographical Journal (London) LXXX (1932).Google Scholar
Stein, M. A. Archaeological Reconnaissances in North-Western India and South-Eastern Iran (London, 1937), ch. 1, “On Alexander's campaign in the Panjab”.
Strak, F.Alexander's minor campaigns in Turkey”, The Geographical Journal (London) CXXII (1956).Google Scholar
Strak, F.Alexander's march from Miletus to Phrygia”, Journal of Hellenic Studies (London) LXXVIII (1958).Google Scholar
Strasburger, H.Zur Route Alexanders durch Gedrosien”, (Zeitschrift für klassische Philologie) (Wiesbaden) LXXXII (1954).Google Scholar
Taeger, F. Charisma: Studien zur Geschichte des Antiken Herrscherkultes, vol. 1 (books 1 & 2), Stuttgart, 1957; vol. 11 (book 3), Stuttgart, 1960. Book 2 is basic.
Tarn, W. W. Bibliographies to Chapters 12, 13, 14, The Cambridge Ancient History, 12 vols; 1st edition Cambridge, 19241939. Revised edition 1970– VI (1927). A full bibliography down to about 1925.
Tarn, W. W. Alexander the Great, 2 vols. Cambridge, 1948; repr. 1979. Vol. 1 is largely the text of his chapter in The Cambridge Ancient History, 12 vols; 1st edition Cambridge, 19241939. Revised edition 1970– VI and closely follows Arrian's account; vol. II contains essays and studies of varying quality (some basic).
Tscherikower, V.Die hellenistischen Städtegründungen von Alexander dem Grossen bis auf die Römerzeit”, Philologus (Zeitschrift für das classische Alterthum) (Göttingen—Leipzig—Berlin), Supplement XIX. I (1927).Google Scholar
Whatley, N., Journal of Hellenic Studies (London) LXXXIV (1964)
Wilcken, U. Alexander der Grosse. Leipzig, 1931. Tr. Richards, G. C. as Alexander the Great, 2nd ed. revised by Borza, E. N.. New York—London, 1967. Borza added notes drawing attention to changes in interpretation from Wilcken's days to date of publication.
Wirth, G., Chiron (Mitteilungen der Kommission fur alte Geschichte und Epigraphik des Deutschen archaologischen Instituts) (Munich) 1 (1971).

Save book to Kindle

To save this book to your Kindle, first ensure coreplatform@cambridge.org is added to your Approved Personal Document E-mail List under your Personal Document Settings on the Manage Your Content and Devices page of your Amazon account. Then enter the ‘name’ part of your Kindle email address below. Find out more about saving to your Kindle.

Note you can select to save to either the @free.kindle.com or @kindle.com variations. ‘@free.kindle.com’ emails are free but can only be saved to your device when it is connected to wi-fi. ‘@kindle.com’ emails can be delivered even when you are not connected to wi-fi, but note that service fees apply.

Find out more about the Kindle Personal Document Service.

  • ALEXANDER IN IRAN
  • Edited by I. Gershevitch
  • Book: The Cambridge History of Iran
  • Online publication: 28 March 2008
  • Chapter DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/CHOL9780521200912.009
Available formats
×

Save book to Dropbox

To save content items to your account, please confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies. If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your account. Find out more about saving content to Dropbox.

  • ALEXANDER IN IRAN
  • Edited by I. Gershevitch
  • Book: The Cambridge History of Iran
  • Online publication: 28 March 2008
  • Chapter DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/CHOL9780521200912.009
Available formats
×

Save book to Google Drive

To save content items to your account, please confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies. If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your account. Find out more about saving content to Google Drive.

  • ALEXANDER IN IRAN
  • Edited by I. Gershevitch
  • Book: The Cambridge History of Iran
  • Online publication: 28 March 2008
  • Chapter DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/CHOL9780521200912.009
Available formats
×