Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Figures
- Foreword by H. C. Woodhouse
- Acknowledgements
- Introduction
- 1 Art on the rocks
- 2 Myths and meanings
- 3 The emperor's new clothes I: sloppy tailoring
- 4 The emperor's new clothes II: fashion disasters
- 5 Location, location, location
- 6 The votive motive
- 7 Mustn't crumble
- Conclusion
- Select bibliography
- Index
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Figures
- Foreword by H. C. Woodhouse
- Acknowledgements
- Introduction
- 1 Art on the rocks
- 2 Myths and meanings
- 3 The emperor's new clothes I: sloppy tailoring
- 4 The emperor's new clothes II: fashion disasters
- 5 Location, location, location
- 6 The votive motive
- 7 Mustn't crumble
- Conclusion
- Select bibliography
- Index
Summary
The difficulty is to detach the framework of fact – of absolute, undeniable fact – from the embellishment of theorists and reporters. Then, having established ourselves upon this sound basis, it is our duty to see what inferences may be drawn.
Sherlock Holmes, Silver BlazeIn this book, as well as in its predecessor, I have attempted to present some of the very wide variety of information which can be deduced from prehistoric rock art and also some of the pitfalls which arise when one indulges in careless speculation (or relies on erroneous data) instead of recognising the limitations of what can sensibly and reliably be read in these markings.
Today we can ‘read’ the depictions on Greek vases because we can read the names sometimes inscribed there, and we know Greek mythology very well from the surviving Classical literature, but imagine if that literature did not exist, or was indecipherable – how many of those fantastic stories could we possibly work out from the imagery? Where Ice Age cave art is concerned, Leroi-Gourhan and others often illustrated the extreme difficulties of working out its meaning by using the analogy of a Martian visiting a Christian church – how much of Christian belief could be deduced from its layout and its iconography?
Similarly, Bagley (2008) has stated:
As for the notion that prehistoric symbolism is so straightforward that a modern observer can interpret it by inspection, this I find even less defensible. We would not take seriously the suggestion that our own symbols could be understood by an uninformed observer. […]
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Prehistoric Rock ArtPolemics and Progress, pp. 197 - 202Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 2010