Skip to main content
×
Home

The Japanese voluntary sector's responses to the increasing unmet demand for home care from an ageing population

  • MAYUMI HAYASHI (a1)
Abstract
ABSTRACT

As Japan faces the challenge of the increasing demand for home care from its ageing population in an era of economic constraints, the expectation has evolved that the voluntary sector will fill the shortfall in statutory provision through semi-volunteers providing affordable home care. Drawing on qualitative interviews with managers from 15 voluntary organisations, this article explores their experiences in trying to meet this expectation. Even though most organisations provided supplementary home-care services, the empirical evidence indicates a limited capacity to deliver this expectation, with respondents aware of the deteriorating situation. It has been ascertained that supply mechanisms differ between the traditional voluntary – and the new hybrid – organisations. The former employ ‘cost-efficient’ labour such as ‘paid volunteers’ on below minimum pay rates. In contrast, the ‘hybrids’ use paid employees at regular pay rates, a finding that contradicts optimistic assumptions about the ideological role of ‘traditional’ voluntary organisations. This article suggests the importance of acknowledging diverse responses from the voluntary sector, including the new hybrids with their acknowledgement of voluntary and commercial imperatives. Open mindedness and a preparedness to revise interpretations of the earlier ‘models’ of the voluntary sector are essential. The conclusion proposes that the best strategy to unlock the voluntary sector's full potential to deliver supplementary home care is a multi-platformed approach, with adequate public purse funding, which pragmatically maximises resources.

Copyright
Corresponding author
Address for correspondence: Mayumi Hayashi, Institute of Gerontology, Department of Social Science, Health & Medicine, Faculty of Social Science & Public Policy, Strand, London WC2R 2LS, UK. E-mail: mayumi.1.hayashi@kcl.ac.uk
References
Hide All
Adachi K. 2000. The development of social welfare services in Japan. In Long S. O. (ed.), Caring for the Elderly in Japan and the US. Routledge, London, 191205.
Adachi K. 2008. Fukushi-NPO-no Shakai-gaku [The Sociology of Non-profit Welfare Organisations]. University of Tokyo Press, Tokyo.
Bode I. 2006. Disorganized welfare mixes: voluntary agencies and new governance regimes in Western Europe. Journal of European Social Policy, 16, 4, 346–59.
Campbell J. C. and Ikegami N. 2003. Japan's radical reform of long-term care. Social Policy and Administration, 37, 1, 2134.
Colombo F., Llena-Nozal A., Mercier J. and Tjadens F. 2011. Help Wanted? Providing and Paying for Long-term Care. OECD Health Policy Studies, OECD Publishing, Paris.
Costa-Font J. 2011. Reforming Long-term Care in Europe. Blackwell, Chichester, UK.
Coulmas F. 2007. Population Decline and Ageing in Japan. Routledge, London.
Cyoju ShakaiBunka Kyokai (ed.) 1998. NPO-ga-egaku fukushi-chizu [A Welfare Map Drawn By NPOs]. Gyosei, Tokyo.
Evers A. 2005. Mixed welfare systems and hybrid organisations: changes in the governance and provision of social services. International Journal of Public Administration, 28, 9/10, 737–48.
Fujimura M. 1999. Fukushikokka-no saihensei [Restructuring Welfare State]. University of Tokyo Press, Tokyo.
Hashimoto S. 2000. Koteki kaigohoken seido-ka ni okeru shimin katsudo dantai no doko [Trends of civic-led organisations under the long-term care insurance system]. In Jichitai OsakaKenkyujo Mondai (ed.), Kaigohoken [The Long-term Care Insurance System, Number 3]. Bunrikaku, Kyoto, Japan, 95113.
Hayashi M. 2011. The care of older people in Japan: myths and realities of family ‘care’. History and Policy, 3 June. Available online at http://www.historyandpolicy.org/papers/policy-paper-121.html [Accessed 1 April 2014].
Hayashi M. 2012. Japan's Fureai Kippu time-banking in elderly care: origins, development, challenges and impact. International Journal of Community Currency Research, 16A, 3044.
Hayashi M. 2013. The Care of Older People: England and Japan, A Comparative Study. Pickering and Chatto, London.
Hayashi M. 2014. What Japan teaches us about better care for older people. Health Service Journal, 4 April, 26–7.
Hongo H., Araki T., Matsuoka S. and Sodei T. 2011. Kaigo-kei-NPO-no genjo-to seido-gai-sa-bisu tenkai-ni muketa kadai [The situation of care-giving NPOs and the challenges of non-statutory service functions]. Fukuoka-kenritsu daigaku ningenshakaigakubu kiyo [Journal of Fukuoka Prefecture University, Faculty of Integrated Human Studies and Social Sciences], 19, 2, 118.
Hotta S. 2007. Toward maintaining and improving the quality of long-term care: the current state and issues regarding home-helpers in Japan under the long-term care insurance system. Social Science Japan Journal, 10, 2, 265–79.
Hyogon Fukushi Net 2010. Kobe-no hieirisoshiki ni-yoru kaigohoken-seido-gai-sabisu jittai-chosa hokokusho [Report on the Current State of Supplementary Services of Kobe Non-profit Sector Outside the Long-term Care Insurance System]. Kobe-no Hieiri-soshiki-ni-yoru Kaigohoken Seido-gai-Sabisu Jittai- Chosa-Iinkai, Kobe, Japan.
Ito S. 1996. Shakaifukushi ni okeru riyosha-sanka [User participation in social welfare]. In Social Security Research Institute (ed.), Shakaifukushi-ni-okeru shimin-sanka [Citizen Participation in Social Welfare]. University of Tokyo Press, Tokyo, 4161.
JSZSDZR (Jumin Sanka-gata Zaitaku-fukushi Sabisu Dantai Zenkoku Renraku-kai) 2006. Jumin sanka-gata zaitakufukushi sabisu [Report on Resident Participatory-type Homecare Provider Organisastions]. JSZSDZR, Tokyo.
Kanaya N. 1999. Fukushi, iryo-to NPO [Welfare, health and NPO]. In Yamauchi N. (ed.), NPO De-ta Bukku [NPO Data Book]. Yuhikaku, Tokyo, 114–31.
Kanaya N. 2003. Is the home-visit care market on equal footing? Differential of conditions affecting performance [Homon-kaigo-shijo wa equal-fotting-ka? – kakusa-no sonzai-to sono-eikyo]. The Nonprofit Review, 3, 1, 123.
Kanaya N. 2012. Kaigo-kei NPO-no jizokusei-to tayosei: kaigohoken seido-gai-sa-bisu no jittai-bunseki-kara [Sustainability and diversity of citizen-driven nonprofit care providers for the elderly: an analysis of services of non-profit organisations extending beyond statutory long-term care insurance services]. Hiroshima Journal of International Studies, 18, 5570.
Kase H. 1993. Zaitaku-kea-to shiruba-sa-bisu [Homecare and silver service]. Jurist, April, 6068.
Kawai K. (ed.) 1990. Korekara-no zaitaku-fukushi-sa-bisu [Home-based Care for the Future]. Akebi-Shobo, Tokyo.
Kingston J. 2004. Japan's Quiet Transformation: Social Change and Civil Society in the Twenty-first Century. RoutledgeCurzon, London.
Kono M. 2000. The impact of modernisation and social policy on family care for older people in Japan. Journal of Social Policy, 29, 2, 181203.
Lee H. K. 1987. The Japanese welfare state in transition. In Friedmann R. R., Gilbert N. and Sherer M. (eds), Modern Welfare States. Wheatsheaf, Brighton, UK, 243–63.
Ministry of Health and Welfare (MHW) 1975. Kosei Hakusho [The Year 1975 Annual Report of the Ministry of Health and Welfare]. Gyosei, Tokyo.
Ministry of Health and Welfare (MHW) 1993 a. Kokumin-no shakaifukushi ni kansuru katsudo e no sanka-no sokushin-wo hakaru tame-no sochi ni kansuru kihonteki-na shishin [Announcement Number 117: Basic Guidelines to Achieve Greater Public Participation in Welfare Activity], 14 April. MHW, Tokyo.
Ministry of Health and Welfare (MHW) 1993 b. Vorantia-katsudo no cyu-choki-tekina shinko-hosaku ni tsuite [Mid- to Long-term Plans for Voluntary Activity], 29 July. MHW, Tokyo.
Ministry of Health and Welfare (MHW) 1996. Kosei hakusho [The Year 1996 Annual Report of the Ministry of Health and Welfare]. Gyosei, Tokyo.
Ministry of Health and Welfare (MHW) 2001. 1999nen shakai-fukushi gyousei-gyoumu-houkoku [The Year 1999 Report on Social Welfare Administration]. Kosei-Tokei-Kyokai, Tokyo.
Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare (MHLW) 2002. Heisei-12nen kaigo-sabisu-shisetsu jigyosho-chosa [The 2000 Survey of Long-term Care Insurance Care-provider Agencies]. Kosei-Tokei-Kyokai, Tokyo.
Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare (MHLW) 2012 a. Kaogohoken-seido kaisei-no gaiyo oyobi chiiki-hokatsu-kea no rinen [Summary of Long-term Care Reform and the Philosophy of Comprehensive Community Care]. MHLW, Tokyo.
Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare (MHLW) 2012 b. Heisei-23nen kaigo-sabisu-shisetsu jigyosho-chosa [The 2011 Survey of Long-term Care Insurance Care-provider Agencies]. Kosei-Tokei-Kyokai, Tokyo.
Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare (MHLW) 2013. Seikatsu-shien-sa-bisu no jujitsu- to koreisha-no shakai-sanka [Enhancing the Daily-living Support Service and Public Participation Among Older People]. Available online at http://www.mhlw.go.jp/seisakunitsuite/bunya/hukushi_kaigo/kaigo_koureisha/chiiki-houkatsu/dl/link5.pdf [Accessed 1 April 2014].
Mori U. 2008. Gendai nihon no kaigohoken kaikaku [Long-term Care Insurance Reform in Contemporary Japan]. Horitsu Bunkasha, Kyoto, Japan.
Morikawa M. 1999. Zaiitaku-kaigo-rodo-no seiritsu-katei [The process of systemising home care work]. The Journal of Ohara Institute for Social Research, 486, 2339.
Nakanishi S. and Ueno C. 2003. Toujisha-shuken [Person-centred rights]. Iwanami-Shoten, Tokyo.
National Institute of Population and Social Security Research 2012. Nihon-no shorai-suitei-jinko [Population Estimation of Japan]. National Institute of Population and Social Security Research, Tokyo.
National Welfare Council (NWC) 2011. Heisei-22nendo jumin-sanka-gata-zaitaku-fukushi-sabisu-dantai katsudo-jittaicyosa [The Year 2011 Annual Report on Resident Participatory-style Homecare-giving Organisations]. Zenkoku-shakai-fukushi-kyogikai, Tokyo.
Noguchi S. 1990. Fukushi-kosha-gata zaitaku-fukushi-sa-bisu [Homecare services of welfare corporations]. In Kawai K. (ed.), [Home-based Care for the Future]. Akebi-Shobo, Tokyo, 5684.
Okifuji N. 2010. Kaigohoken-wa oi-wo-mamoruka [Can the LTCI Scheme Guarantee a Good Old Age?]. Iwanami-Shoten, Tokyo.
Pekkanen R. and Simon K. 2003. The legal framework for voluntary and non-profit activity. In Osborne S. P. (ed.), The Voluntary and Non-Profit Sector in Japan: The Challenge of Change. RoutledgeCurzon, London, 76101.
Peng I. 2002. Social care in crisis: gender, demography, and welfare state restructuring in Japan. Social Politics: International Studies in Gender, State and Society, 9, 3, 411–43.
Shibukawa T. 2001. Fukushi NPO [Non-profit Welfare Organisations]. Iwanami-Shoten, Tokyo.
Shimizutani S. and Suzuki W. 2007. Quality and efficiency of home-help elderly care in Japan: evidence from micro-level data. Journal of the Japanese and International Economies, 21, 2, 287301.
Silver Service Shinkokai 2009. Homonkaig- sabisu ni okeru ‘kongokaigo’-no sokushin-ni-muketa cyosakenkyu-jigyo hokokusho [Report of Research to Promote ‘Mixed Care Services’ in Homecare Provision]. Silver Service Shinkokai, Tokyo.
Suda Y. 2011. For-profit and nonprofit dynamics and providers’ failures: the long-term care insurance system in Japan. Public Management Review, 13, 1, 2142.
Swartz K. 2013. Searching for a balance of responsibilities: OECD countries’ changing elderly assistance policies. Annual Review of Public Health, 34, 397412.
Takagi K. 1992. Koreisha-no zaitakufukushi [Home-based care for older people]. In Sumitomo Life and Health Foundation (ed.), Zaitaku-koreisha-no life-plan [Life-plan for Older People at Home]. Yuhikaku, Tokyo, 119.
Takano K. 1993. Zaitakufukushi-sabisu no zairitu-kozo [The structure of home-based social services]. Kikan Shakai-hosho Kenkyu [Quarterly of Social Security Research], 29, 2, 155–64.
Takechi H. 1993. Fukushi-kosha ni yoru zaitakufukushi-sa-bisu [Homecare services of welfare corporations]. In Imamura T. (ed.), Daisan-sector no kenkyu [Research on the Third Sector]. Chuohoki-shuppan, Tokyo, 347–94.
Tanaka N. 1996. Shimin-shakai no borantia [Volunteering in Civil Society]. Maruzen, Tokyo.
Tanaka N., Asakawa S. and Adachi K. 2003. Kaigo-kei-NPO no saizensen: zenkoku top-16 no jutsuzo [The Frontier of Welfare Non-profit Organisations: The State of National Top 16 Welfare NPOs]. Minerva, Kyoto, Japan.
Totsuka K. 1992. Zaitaku koreisha-wo enjo-suru hieiri-soshiki [Non-profit organisations supporting older people at home]. In Life Sumitomo and Foundation Health (ed.), Zaitaku-koreisha-no life-plan [Life-plan for Older People at Home]. Yuhikaku, Tokyo, 2066.
Tsutsui T. and Muramatsu N. 2007. Japan's universal long-term care system reform of 2005: containing costs and realizing a vision. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, 55, 9, 1458–63.
Ueno C. 2011. Kea-no Shakai-gaku [Sociology of Care]. Ota-Shuppan, Tokyo.
Yamada M. (ed.) 2005. Kaigohoken to 21seikigata chiikifukushi [Long-term Care Insurance Scheme and 21st-century Community Care]. Minerva, Kyoto, Japan.
Yamaguchi M. 2000. Syakaifukushikyogikai-riron-no keisei-to-hatten [Formation and Development of the Theory of the Welfare Council]. Yachiyo-shuppan, Tokyo.
Yamaguchi N. and Takahashi H. (eds) 1993. Shimin-sanka to koreisha-kea [Citizen Participation and Elder Care]. Daiichihoki-Shuppan, Tokyo.
Yamashita J. 2011. Exploring the impact of the Japanese Long-term Care Insurance Act on the gendered stratification of the care labour market through an analysis of the domiciliary care provided by welfare non-profit organisations. Social Policy and Society, 10, 4, 433–43.
Yamauchi N. (ed.) 1999. NPO De-ta Bukku [NPO Data Book]. Yuhikaku, Tokyo.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Ageing & Society
  • ISSN: 0144-686X
  • EISSN: 1469-1779
  • URL: /core/journals/ageing-and-society
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Keywords:

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 11
Total number of PDF views: 50 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 375 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 19th November 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.