Skip to main content Accessibility help

We use cookies to distinguish you from other users and to provide you with a better experience on our websites. Close this message to accept cookies or find out how to manage your cookie settings.

Close cookie message
×
Home
  • Home
Article
  • Cited by 2

  • Get access
    Add to cart €23.00
    Check if you have access via personal or institutional login
    Log in Register

Accountability for the Local Economy at All Levels of Government in United States Elections

  • JUSTIN DE BENEDICTIS-KESSNER (a1) and CHRISTOPHER WARSHAW (a2)

Abstract

Retrospective voting is a crucial component of democratic accountability. A large literature on retrospective voting in the United States finds that the president’s party is rewarded in presidential elections for strong economic performance and punished for weak performance. By contrast, there is no clear consensus about whether politicians are held accountable for the local economy at other levels of government, nor how voters react to the economy in a complex system of multilevel responsibility. In this study, we use administrative data on county-level economic conditions from 1969 to 2018 and election results across multiple levels of government to examine the effect of the local economy on elections for local, state, and federal offices in the United States. We find that the president’s party is held accountable for economic performance across nearly all levels of government. We also find that incumbents are held accountable for the economy in U.S. House and gubernatorial elections. Our findings have broad implications for literatures on representation, accountability, and elections.

Copyright

© American Political Science Association 2020

Corresponding author

Justin de Benedictis-Kessner, Assistant Professor, Department of Political Science, Boston University, jdbk@bu.edu.
Christopher Warshaw, Assistant Professor, Department of Political Science, George Washington University, warshaw@gwu.edu.

Footnotes

Hide All

We wish to thank the editors and three anonymous reviewers for their feedback. We are also grateful to Eric Guntermann, Martin Vinæs Larsen, Mike Sances, and seminar participants at UCLA, Stanford, the Harvard Kennedy School, and Brown University for their feedback on previous versions of this manuscript. Replication files are available at the American Political Science Review Dataverse: https://doi.org/10.7910/DVN/YDBMNI.

Footnotes

References

Hide All
Abramowitz, Alan I., and Segal, Jeffrey A.. 1986. “Determinants of the Outcomes of US Senate Elections.” The Journal of Politics 48 (2): 433–9.
Abramowitz, Alan I., and Webster, Steven. 2016. “The Rise of Negative Partisanship and the Nationalization of US Elections in the 21st Century.” Electoral Studies 41: 12–22.
Achen, Christopher H., and Bartels, Larry M.. 2017. Democracy for Realists: Why Elections Do Not Produce Responsive Government. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Aldrich, John H. 1995. Why Parties? The Origin and Transformation of Party Politics in America. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Angrist, Joshua David, and Pischke, Jörn-Steffen. 2009. Mostly Harmless Econometrics: An Empiricist’s Companion. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Ansolabehere, Stephen, Meredith, Marc, and Snowberg, Erik. 2014. “Mecro-Economic Voting: Local Information and Micro-Perceptions of the Macro-Economy.” Economics & Politics 26 (3): 380–410.
Arnold, R. Douglas, and Carnes, Nicholas. 2012. “Holding Mayors Accountable: New York’s Executives from Koch to Bloomberg.” American Journal of Political Science 56 (4): 949–63.
Ashworth, Scott. 2012. “Electoral Accountability: Recent Theoretical and Empirical Work.” Annual Review of Political Science 15: 183–201.
Ashworth, Scott, and de Mesquita, Ethan Bueno. 2014. “Is Voter Competence Good for Voters? Information, Rationality, and Democratic Performance.” American Political Science Review 108 (3): 565–87.
Atkeson, Lonna Rae, and Partin, Randall W.. 1995. “Economic and Referendum Voting: A Comparison of Gubernatorial and Senatorial Elections.” American Political Science Review 89 (1): 99–107.
Bartels, Larry M. 2008. Unequal Democracy: The Political Economy of the New Gilded Age. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Berry, Christopher R., Burden, Barry C., and Howell, William G.. 2010. “The President and the Distribution of Federal Spending.” American Political Science Review 104 (4): 783–99.
Besley, Timothy, and Case, Anne. 1995. “Incumbent Behavior: Vote-Seeking, Tax-Setting, and Yardstick Competition.” The American Economic Review 85 (1): 25–45.
Bisgaard, Martin. 2015. “Bias Will Find a Way: Economic Perceptions, Attributions of Blame, and Partisan-Motivated Reasoning during Crisis.” The Journal of Politics 77 (3): 849–60.
Bisgaard, Martin, and Slothuus, Rune. 2018. “Partisan Elites as Culprits? How Party Cues Shape Partisan Perceptual Gaps.” American Journal of Political Science 62 (2): 456–69.
Bisgaard, Martin, Dinesen, Peter Thisted, and Sønderskov, Kim Mannemar. 2016. “Reconsidering the Neighborhood Effect: Does Exposure to Residential Unemployment Influence Voters’ Perceptions of the National Economy?” The Journal of Politics 78 (3): 719–32.
Brambor, Thomas, Clark, William Roberts, and Golder, Matt. 2006. “Understanding Interaction Models: Improving Empirical Analyses.” Political Analysis 14 (1): 63–82.
Brown, Adam R. 2010. “Are Governors Responsible for the State Economy? Partisanship, Blame, and Divided Federalism.” The Journal of Politics 72 (3): 605–15.
Carsey, Thomas M., and Wright, Gerald C.. 1998. “State and National Factors in Gubernatorial and Senatorial Elections.” American Journal of Political Science 42 (3): 994–1002.
Caughey, Devin, Warshaw, Christopher, and Xu, Yiqing. 2017. “Incremental Democracy: The Policy Effects of Partisan Control of State Government.” The Journal of Politics 79 (4): 1342–58.
Chen, Jowei. 2013. “Voter Partisanship and the Effect of Distributive Spending on Political Participation.” American Journal of Political Science 57 (1): 200–17.
Cho, Wendy K. Tam, and Gimpel, James G.. 2009. “Presidential Voting and the Local Variability of Economic Hardship.” The Forum 7 (1): Article 1.
Chubb, John E. 1988. “Institutions, the Economy, and the Dynamics of State Elections.” American Political Science Review 82 (1): 133–54.
Cohen, Jeffrey E., and King, James D.. 2004. “Relative Unemployment and Gubernatorial Popularity.” The Journal of Politics 66 (4): 1267–82.
Cottrell, David, Herron, Michael C., and Westwood, Sean J.. 2018. “An Exploration of Donald Trump’s Allegations of Massive Voter Fraud in the 2016 General Election.” Electoral Studies 51 (1): 123–42.
Darr, Joshua P., Hitt, Matthew P., and Dunaway, Johanna L.. 2018. “Newspaper Closures Polarize Voting Behavior.” Journal of Communication 68 (6): 1007–28.
de Benedictis-Kessner, Justin, and Warshaw, Christopher. 2016. “Mayoral Partisanship and Municipal Fiscal Policy.” The Journal of Politics 78 (4): 1124–38.
de Benedictis-Kessner, Justin, and Warshaw, Christopher. 2020. “Politics in Forgotten Governments: The Partisan Composition of County Legislatures and County Fiscal Policies.” The Journal of Politics 82 (2).
Donovan, Kathleen, Kellstedt, Paul M., Key, Ellen M., and Lebo, Matthew J.. 2019. “Motivated Reasoning, Public Opinion, and Presidential Approval.” Political Behavior, 1–21. Published online 23 February 2019.
Dynes, Adam M., and Huber, Gregory A.. 2015. “Partisanship and the Allocation of Federal Spending: Do Same-Party Legislators or Voters Benefit from Shared Party Affiliation with the President and House Majority?” American Political Science Review 109 (1): 172–86.
Dynes, Adam M., and Holbein, John B.. 2020. “Noisy Retrospection: The Effect of Party Control on Policy Outcomes.” American Political Science Review 114 (1): 237–57.
Ebeid, Michael, and Rodden, Jonathan. 2006. “Economic Geography and Economic Voting: Evidence from the US States.” British Journal of Political Science 36 (3): 527–47.
Eisenberg, Daniel, and Ketcham, Jonathan. 2004. “Economic Voting in US Presidential Elections: Who Blames Whom for What.” Topics in Economic Analysis and Policy 4 (1): 497–521.
Elinder, Mikael. 2010. “Local Economies and General Elections: The Influence of Municipal and Regional Economic Conditions on Voting in Sweden 1985–2002.” European Journal of Political Economy 26 (2): 279–92.
Erikson, Robert S. 1989. “Economic Conditions and the Presidential Vote.” American Political Science Review 83 (2): 567–73.
Fair, Ray C. 1978. “The Effect of Economic Events on Votes for President.” The Review of Economics and Statistics 60 (2): 159–73.
Fearon, James D. 1999. “Electoral Accountability and the Control of Politicians: Selecting Good Types versus Sanctioning Poor Performance.” In Democracy, Accountability, and Representation, eds. Przeworski, Adam, Stokes, Susan C., and Manin, Bernard. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 55–97.
Ferejohn, John. 1986. “Incumbent Performance and Electoral Control.” Public Choice 50 (1/3): 5–25.
Fiorina, Morris P. 1978. “Economic Retrospective Voting in American National Elections: A Micro-Analysis.” American Journal of Political Science 22 (2): 426–43.
Fiorina, Morris P. 1981. Retrospective Voting in American National Elections. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
Fowler, Anthony, and Hall, Andrew B.. 2018. “Do Shark Attacks Influence Presidential Elections? Reassessing a Prominent Finding on Voter Competence.” The Journal of Politics 80 (4): 1423–37.
Gelman, Andrew, and Hill, Jennifer. 2007. Data Analysis Using Regression and Multilevel/Hierarchical Models. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Gosnell, Harold F., and Colman, William G.. 1940. “Political Trends in Industrial America: Pennsylvania an Example.” Public Opinion Quarterly 4 (3): 473–86.
Hall, Andrew B., Yoder, Jesse, and Karandikar, Nishant. 2019. “Economic Distress and Voting: Evidence from the Subprime Mortgage Crisis.” Working Paper. Online: https://www.dropbox.com/s/dl/2dm4s901gdkj9t0/foreclosure.pdf.
Hansen, Susan B.. 1999. “‘Life Is Not Fair’: Governors’ Job Performance Ratings and State Economies.” Political Research Quarterly 52 (1): 167–88.
Hayes, Danny, and Lawless, Jennifer L.. 2015. “As Local News Goes, So Goes Citizen Engagement: Media, Knowledge, and Participation in US House Elections.” The Journal of Politics 77 (2): 447–62.
Healy, Andrew, and Lenz, Gabriel S.. 2014. “Substituting the End for the Whole: Why Voters Respond Primarily to the Election-Year Economy.” American Journal of Political Science 58 (1): 31–47.
Healy, Andrew, and Lenz, Gabriel S.. 2017. “Presidential Voting and the Local Economy: Evidence from Two Population-Based Data Sets.” The Journal of Politics 79 (4): 1419–32.
Healy, Andrew, and Malhotra, Neil. 2013. “Retrospective Voting Reconsidered.” Annual Review of Political Science 16: 285–306.
Hibbs, Douglas A. Jr 1982. “President Reagan’s Mandate from the 1980 Elections: A Shift to the Right?” American Politics Quarterly 10 (4): 387–420.
Hill, Seth J., Herron, Michael C., and Lewis, Jeffrey B.. 2010. “Economic Crisis, Iraq, and Race: A Study of the 2008 Presidential Election.” Election Law Journal 9 (1): 41–62.
Holbrook-Provow, Thomas M. 1987. “National Factors in Gubernatorial Elections.” American Politics Quarterly 15 (4): 471–83.
Holbrook, Thomas M., and Weinschenk, Aaron C.. 2014. “Money, Candidates, and Mayoral Elections.” Electoral Studies 35: 292–302.
Holman, Mirya R. 2016. “Gender, Political Rhetoric, and Moral Metaphors in State of the City Addresses.” Urban Affairs Review 52 (4): 501–30.
Hopkins, Daniel J. 2018. The Increasingly United States: How and Why American Political Behavior Nationalized. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
Hopkins, Daniel J., and Pettingill, Lindsay M.. 2018. “Retrospective Voting in Big-City US Mayoral Elections.” Political Science Research and Methods 6 (4): 697–714.
Howell, Susan E., and Perry, Huey L.. 2004. “Black Mayors/White Mayors: Explaining Their Approval.” Public Opinion Quarterly 68 (1): 32–56.
Howell, Susan E., and Vanderleeuw, James M.. 1990. “Economic Effects on State Governors.” American Politics Quarterly 18 (2): 158–68.
Howell, Susan E., and McLean, William P.. 2001. “Performance and Race in Evaluating Minority Mayors.” Public Opinion Quarterly 65 (3): 321–43.
ICPSR. 2006. “State Legislative Election Returns in the United States, 1968–1989.” https://doi.org/10.3886/ICPSR08907.v5.
ICPSR. 2013. “General Election Data for the United States, 1950–1990.” http://doi.org/10.3886/ICPSR00013.v2.
Kaufmann, Karen M. 2004. The Urban Voter: Group Conflict and Mayoral Voting Behavior in American Cities. Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press.
Kenney, Patrick J. 1983. “The Effect of State Economic Conditions on the Vote for Governor.” Social Science Quarterly 64 (1): 154.
KeyV. O., Jr. V. O., Jr. 1966. The Responsible Electorate. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Kiewiet, D. Roderick, and Udell, Michael. 1998. “Twenty-Five Years after Kramer: An Assessment of Economic Retrospective Voting Based upon Improved Estimates of Income and Unemployment.” Economics & Politics 10 (3): 219–48.
Kinder, Donald R., and Kiewiet, D. Roderick. 1979. “Economic Discontent and Political Behavior: The Role of Personal Grievances and Collective Economic Judgments in Congressional Voting.” American Journal of Political Science 23 (3): 495–527.
Klarner, Carl. 2015. “Governors Dataset.” Harvard Dataverse, https://doi.org/1902.1/20408.
Klarner, Carl. 2018. “State Legislative Election Returns, 1967–2016.” Harvard Dataverse, https://doi.org/10.7910/DVN/3WZFK9.
Kramer, Gerald H. 1971. “Short-Term Fluctuations in US Voting Behavior, 1896–1964.” American Political Science Review 65 (1): 131–43.
Kriner, Douglas L., and Reeves, Andrew. 2012. “The Influence of Federal Spending on Presidential Elections.” American Political Science Review 106 (2): 348–66.
Kriner, Douglas L., and Reeves, Andrew. 2015. “Presidential Particularism and Divide-the-Dollar Politics.” American Political Science Review 109 (1): 155–71.
Larsen, Martin Vinæs, Hjorth, Frederik, Dinesen, Peter Thisted, and Sønderskov, Kim Mannemar. 2019. “When Do Citizens Respond Politically to the Local Economy? Evidence from Registry Data on Local Housing Markets.” American Political Science Review 113 (2): 499–516.
Leip, Dave. 2016. “Dave Leip U.S. House General County Election Results.”
Lewis-Beck, Michael S., and Stegmaier, Mary. 2000. “Economic Determinants of Electoral Outcomes.” Annual Review of Political Science 3 (1): 183–219.
Lewis-Beck, Michael S., and Rice, Tom W.. 1992. Forecasting Elections. Washington, DC: CQ Press.
Lewis, Jeffrey B., DeVine, Brandon, Pitcher, Lincoln, and Martis, Kenneth C.. 2013. Digital Boundary Definitions of United States Congressional Districts, 1789–2012. [Data file and code book]. Technical report UCLA.
Leyden, Kevin M., and Borrelli, Stephen A.. 1995. “The Effect of State Economic Conditions on Gubernatorial Elections: Does Unified Government Make a Difference?” Political Research Quarterly 48 (2): 275–90.
Logan, John R., and Molotch, Harvey. 1987. Urban Fortunes: The Political Economy of Place. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
Lowry, Robert C., Alt, James E., and Ferree, Karen E.. 1998. “Fiscal Policy Outcomes and Electoral Accountability in American States.” American Political Science Review 92 (4): 759–74.
Manson, Steven, Schroeder, Jonathan, Van Riper, David, and Ruggles, Steven. 2018. IPUMS National Historical Geographic Information System: Version 13.0 [Database]. Technical report, University of Minnesota Minneapolis.
Markus, Gregory B. 1988. “The Impact of Personal and National Economic Conditions on the Presidential Vote: A Pooled Cross-Sectional Analysis.” American Journal of Political Science 32 (1): 137–54.
Martin, Gregory J., and McCrain, Josh. 2019. “Local News and National Politics.” American Political Science Review 113 (2): 372–84.
Morgenstern, Scott, Smith, Noah, and Trelles, Alejandro. 2017. “How Party Nationalization Conditions Economic Voting.” Electoral Studies 47: 136–45.
Mummolo, Jonathan, and Peterson, Erik. 2018. “Improving the Interpretation of Fixed Effects Regression Results.” Political Science Research and Methods 6 (4): 829–35.
Nickell, Stephen. 1981. “Biases in Dynamic Models with Fixed Effects.” Econometrica 49: 1417–26.
Niemi, Richard G., Stanley, Harold W., and Vogel, Ronald J.. 1995. “State Economies and State Taxes: Do Voters Hold Governors Accountable?” American Journal of Political Science 39 (4): 936–57.
Oliver, J. Eric, and Ha, Shang E.. 2007. “Vote Choice in Suburban Elections.” American Political Science Review 101 (3): 393–408.
Partin, Randall W. 1995. “Economic Conditions and Gubernatorial Elections Is the State Executive Held Accountable?” American Politics Quarterly 23 (1): 81–95.
Peltzman, Sam. 1987. “Economic Conditions and Gubernatorial Elections.” The American Economic Review 77 (2): 293–7.
Peterson, Erik. 2019. “Paper Cuts: How Reporting Resources Affect Political News Coverage.” Presented at the Annual Meeting of the Southern Political Science Association. Online: https://files.osf.io/v1/resources/md7ts/providers/osfstorage/5c55173ee16f550019872a13?action=download&version=1&direct&format=pdf.
Pettigrew, Stephen. 2017. “November 2016 General Election Results (County-Level).”
Rogers, Steven. 2016. “National Forces in State Legislative Elections.” The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 667 (1): 207–25.
Rogers, Steven Michael. 2013. “Accountability in a Federal System.” Ph.D. dissertation, Princeton University.
Sances, Michael W. 2017. “Attribution Errors in Federalist Systems: When Voters Punish the President for Local Tax Increases.” The Journal of Politics 79 (4): 1286–1301.
Simonovits, Gabor, Kates, Sean, and Szeitl, Blanka. 2019. “Local Economic Shocks and National Election Outcomes: Evidence from Hungarian Administrative Data.” Political Behavior 41 (2): 337–48.
Snyder, James M., and Strömberg, David. 2010. “Press Coverage and Political Accountability.” Journal of Political Economy 118 (2): 355–408.
Stein, Robert M.. 1990. “Economic Voting for Governor and US Senator: The Electoral Consequences of Federalism.” The Journal of Politics 52 (1): 29–53.
Stone, Clarence N. 1989. Regime Politics: Governing Atlanta. Lawrence, KS: University of Kansas Press.
Svoboda, Craig J. 1995. “Retrospective Voting in Gubernatorial Elections: 1982 and 1986.” Political Research Quarterly 48 (1): 135–50.
Trounstine, Jessica. 2010. “Representation and Accountability in Cities.” Annual Review of Political Science 13: 407–23.
Tufte, Edward R. 1978. Political Control of the Economy. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Warshaw, Christopher. 2019. “Local Elections and Representation in the United States.” Annual Review of Political Science 22 (1): 461–79.
Wright, John R. 2012. “Unemployment and the Democratic Electoral Advantage.” American Political Science Review 106 (4): 685–702.
Type Description Title
PDF
Supplementary materials

de Benedictis-Kessner and Warshaw supplementary material
de Benedictis-Kessner and Warshaw supplementary material

 PDF (319 KB)
319 KB
UNKNOWN
Supplementary materials

de Benedictis-Kessner and Warshaw Dataset
Dataset

 Unknown
  • Cited by 2

  • Get access
    Add to cart €23.00
    Check if you have access via personal or institutional login
    Log in Register

Accountability for the Local Economy at All Levels of Government in United States Elections

  • JUSTIN DE BENEDICTIS-KESSNER (a1) and CHRISTOPHER WARSHAW (a2)

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed.