Skip to main content
×
×
Home

The Deliberative Sublime: Edmund Burke on Disruptive Speech and Imaginative Judgment

  • ROB GOODMAN (a1)
Abstract

Is there a case to be made for the value, amidst relatively settled institutions, of unsettling speech—speech characterized by excess, impropriety, and even the uncanny? Much of contemporary deliberative theory would answer in the negative. This article, however, proposes that we can derive a defense of the deliberative value of immoderate speech from an unlikely source: Edmund Burke's theory and practice of the rhetorical sublime. Burke's account of the sublime was developed in response to an eighteenth-century discourse of civility that anticipated the anti-rhetorical strand of contemporary deliberative theory. By reconstructing Burke's response, we can recover a forceful defense of rhetoric in the present. For Burke, the disruptive practice of sublime speech can provoke circumstantial judgment, overcoming deliberators’ aversions to judging. Drawing on Burke's rhetorical practice alongside his aesthetic and linguistic theory, this article upholds a central role in deliberation for rhetoric, even in its unruly and excessive aspects.

Copyright
Corresponding author
Rob Goodman is a Ph.D. candidate, Department of Political Science, Columbia University, 420 W. 118th St., 710 International Affairs Building, Mail Code 3320, New York, NY 10027 (rg2803@columbia.edu).
Footnotes
Hide All

The author would like to thank Ashraf Ahmed, Christopher Berry, Philip Hamburger, Turkuler Isiksel, David Johnston, Carl Knight, Jennifer London, Alison McQueen, Melissa Schwartzberg, Nadia Urbinati, and several anonymous reviewers for their helpful comments on this article.The author would also like to thank attendees of the 2017 American Political Science Association Annual Meeting, and of the 2016 Princeton University Graduate Conference in Political Theory, Midwest Political Science Association Annual Conference, and Braga Colloquium in the History of Moral and Political Philosophy.

Footnotes
References
Hide All
Abizadeh Arash. 2007. “On the Philosophy/Rhetoric Binaries: Or, Is Habermasian Discourse Motivationally Impotent?Philosophy and Social Criticism 33 (4): 445–72.
Achen Christopher H., and Bartels Larry M.. 2016. Democracy for Realists: Why Elections Do Not Produce Responsive Government. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Allen Danielle. 2004. Talking to Strangers: Anxieties of Citizenship since Brown v. Board of Education. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Arendt Hannah. 1992. Lectures on Kant's Political Philosophy, eds. Beiner Ronald. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Ashfield Andrew, and de Bolla Peter, eds. 1996. The Sublime: A Reader in British Eighteenth-Century Aesthetic Theory. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Beiner Ronald. 1983. Political Judgment. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Bejan Teresa M. 2017. Mere Civility: Disagreement and the Limits of Toleration. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Benhabib Seyla. 1996a. “Introduction: The Democratic Moment and the Problem of Difference.” In Democracy and Difference: Contesting the Boundaries of the Political. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 318.
Benhabib Seyla. 1996b. “Toward a Deliberative Model of Democratic Legitimacy.” In Democracy and Difference: Contesting the Boundaries of the Political. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 6794.
Bessette Joseph M. 1994. The Mild Voice of Reason: Deliberative Democracy and American National Government. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Blair Hugh. 2005. Lectures on Rhetoric and Belles Lettres, eds. Ferreira-Buckley Linda and Halloran S. Michael. Carbondale, IL: Southern Illinois University Press.
Bourke Richard. 2015. Empire and Revolution: The Political Life of Edmund Burke. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Bromwich David. 2014. The Intellectual Life of Edmund Burke: From the Sublime and Beautiful to American Independence. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Bullard Paddy. 2011. Edmund Burke and the Art of Rhetoric. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Burke Edmund. 1887a. A Philosophical Enquiry into the Origin of Our Ideas Concerning the Sublime and Beautiful . In The Works of the Right Honorable Edmund Burke. Vol. 1. London: John C. Nimmo, 67262.
Burke Edmund. 1887b. A Representation to His Majesty. In Works. Vol. 2. 537–76.
Burke Edmund. 1887c. An Appeal from the New to the Old Whigs. In Works. Vol. 4. 57–216.
Burke Edmund. 1887d. “Letter to a Noble Lord.” In Works. Vol. 5. 171–232.
Burke Edmund. 1887e. “Speech in General Reply: Ninth Day.” In Works. Vol. 12. 335–400.
Burke Edmund. 1887f. “Speech in Opening the Impeachment: First Day.” In Works. Vol. 9. 329–95.
Burke Edmund. 1887g. “Speech on American Taxation.” In Works. Vol. 2. 1–80.
Burke Edmund. 1887h. “Speech on Conciliation with the Colonies.” In Works. Vol. 2. 99–186.
Burke Edmund. 1887i. “Speech on Mr. Fox's East India Bill.” In Works. Vol. 2. 431–536.
Burke Edmund. 1887j. “Speech on the Nabob of Arcot's Private Debts.” In Works. Vol. 3. 1–210.
Burke Edmund. 1887k. “Speech to the Electors of Bristol.” In Works. Vol. 2. 89–98.
Burke Edmund. 1887l. Reflections on the Revolution in France. In Works. Vol. 3. 231–563.
Burke Edmund. 1960. The Correspondence of Edmund Burke. Vol. 2, ed. Sutherland Lucy S.. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Carroll Ross. 2014. “Revisiting Burke's Critique of Enthusiasm.” History of Political Thought 35 (2): 317–44.
Chambers Simone. 1996. Reasonable Democracy: Jürgen Habermas and the Politics of Discourse. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
Chambers Simone. 2009. “Rhetoric and the Public Sphere.” Political Theory 37 (9): 323–50.
Cohen Joshua. 1997. “Deliberation and Democratic Legitimacy.” In Deliberative Democracy: Essays on Reason and Politics, eds, Bohman James and Rehg William. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 6792.
Craiutu Aurelian. 2016. Faces of Moderation: The Art of Balance in an Age of Extremes. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
De Bruyn Frans. 2012. “‘Expressive Uncertainty’: Edmund Burke's Theory of the Sublime and Eighteenth Century Conceptions of Metaphor.” In The Science of Sensibility: Reading Burke's Philosophical Enquiry, eds. Vermeir Koen and Deckard Michael Funk. New York: Springer, 265–82.
Doran Robert. 2015. The Theory of the Sublime from Longinus to Kant. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Dowe William. 1857. Junius, Lord Chatham. New York: Miller, Orton.
Dryzek John S. 2010. “Rhetoric in Democracy: A Systemic Appreciation.” Political Theory 38 (3): 319–39.
Eco Umberto. 1994. “Political Language: The Use and Abuse of Rhetoric.” In Apocalypse Postponed. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
Fearon James D. 1998. “Deliberation as Discussion.” In Deliberative Democracy, ed. Elster Jon. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 4468.
Frank Jason. 2014. “‘Delightful Horror’: Edmund Burke and the Aesthetics of Democratic Revolution.” In The Aesthetic Turn in Political Thought, ed. Kompridis Nikolas. New York: Bloomsbury Academic, 328.
Garsten Bryan. 2006. Saving Persuasion: A Defense of Rhetoric and Judgment. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Garsten Bryan. 2011. “The Rhetoric Revival in Political Theory.” Annual Review of Political Science 14: 159–80.
Gastil John. 2008. Political Communication and Deliberation. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Gutmann Amy, and Thompson Dennis. 1996. Democracy and Disagreement. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Habermas Jürgen. 2001. Moral Consciousness and Communicative Action. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Hamilton Alexander. 1987. “Federalist No. 70.” In The Federalist Papers, ed. Kramnick Isaac. New York: Penguin, 402–8.
Hampsher-Monk Iain. 1988. “Rhetoric and Opinion in the Politics of Edmund Burke.” History of Political Thought 9 (3): 455–84.
Hume David. 1985a. “Of Eloquence.” In Essays Moral, Political, and Literary, ed. Miller Eugene F.. Indianapolis: Liberty Fund, 97110.
Hume David. 1985b. “Of the Standard of Taste.” In Essays Moral, Political, and Literary, ed. Miller Eugene F.. Indianapolis: Liberty Fund, 226–52.
Jetñil-Kijiner Kathy. 2014. “A Poem to My Daughter.” Accessed July 6, 2017. www.kathyjetnilkijiner.com/united-nations-climate-summit-opening-ceremony-my-poem-to-my-daughter/.
Kapust Daniel, and Schwarze Michelle A.. 2016. “The Rhetoric of Sincerity: Cicero and Smith on Propriety and Political Context.” American Political Science Review 110 (1): 100–11.
Landemore Hélène. 2013. “On Minimal Deliberation, Partisan Activism, and Teaching People how to Disagree.” Critical Review 25 (3): 210–25.
Landwehr Claudia. 2015. “Democratic Meta-Deliberation: Towards Reflective Institutional Design.” Political Studies 63 (S1): 3854.
Leach Jim. 2010. “Civility in a Fractured Society.” Accessed July 6, 2017. www.neh.gov/about/chairman/speeches/civility-in-fractured-society-excerpts.
Lock F. P. 1998. Edmund Burke. Vol. 1. Oxford: Clarendon.
Madison James. 1987. “Federalist No. 58.” In The Federalist Papers, ed. Kramnick Isaac. New York: Penguin, 347–51.
Manin Bernard. 1987. “On Legitimacy and Political Deliberation.” Political Theory 15 (3): 338–68.
Mansbridge Jane, Bohman James, Chambers Simone, Christiano Thomas, Fung Archon, Parkinson John, Thompson Dennis F., and Warren Mark E.. 2012. “A Systemic Approach to Deliberative Democracy.” In Deliberative Systems: Deliberative Democracy at the Large Scale, eds. John Parkinson and Mansbridge. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 126.
Obama Barack. 2011. “Obama's Remarks in Tucson.” Accessed July 6, 2017. www.nytimes.com/2011/01/13/us/politics/13obama-text.html.
Pocock J. G. A. 1985. “The Varieties of Whiggism from Exclusion to Reform.” In Virtue, Commerce, and History: Essays on Political Thought and History, Chiefly in the Eighteenth Century, ed. Pocock. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 215310.
Potkay Adam S. 1994. The Fate of Eloquence in the Age of Hume. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
Prior James. 1878. Life of the Right Honourable Edmund Burke. London: Bell & Sons.
Rawls John. 2005. Political Liberalism: Expanded Edition. New York: Columbia University Press.
Reid Christopher. 2012. “Burke as Rhetorician and Orator.” In The Cambridge Companion to Edmund Burke, eds. Dwan David and Insole Christopher. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 4152.
Remer Gary. 1999. “Political Oratory and Conversation: Cicero Versus Deliberative Democracy.” Political Theory 27 (1): 3964.
Remer Gary. 2000. “Two Models of Deliberation: Oratory and Conversation in Ratifying the Constitution.” Journal of Political Philosophy 8 (1): 6890.
Roberts-Miller Patricia. 2005. “Democracy, Demagoguery, and Critical Rhetoric.” Rhetoric & Public Affairs 8 (3): 459–76.
Ryan Cressida. 2012. “Burke's Classical Heritage: Playing Games with Longinus.” In The Science of Sensibility: Reading Burke's Philosophical Enquiry, eds. Vermeir Koen and Deckard Michael Funk. New York: Springer, 225–46.
Sainsbury John. 2006. John Wilkes: The Lives of a Libertine. Burlington, VT: Ashgate.
Smith Adam. 1985. Lectures on Rhetoric and Belles-Lettres, ed. Bryce J.C.. Indianapolis: Liberty Classics.
Spragens Thomas A. 1990. Reason and Democracy. Durham: Duke University Press.
Strachan J. Cherie, and Wolf Michael R.. 2012. “Introduction to Political Civility.” PS: Political Science and Politics 45 (3): 401– 4.
Sunstein Cass. 2002. “The Law of Group Polarization.” Journal of Political Philosophy 10 (2): 175–95.
Supporting the Designation of a National Day of Civility. 2017. H.Res.400. 115th Congress.
Trenchard John. 1995. “Of Eloquence, Considered Politically.” In Trenchard and Thomas Gordon, Cato's Letters. Vol. 2, ed. Hamowy Ronald. Indianapolis: Liberty Fund, 727–33.
Yack Bernard. 2006. “Rhetoric and Public Reasoning: An Aristotelian Understanding of Political Deliberation.” Political Theory 34 (4): 417–38.
Young Iris Marion. 2000. Inclusion and Democracy. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

American Political Science Review
  • ISSN: 0003-0554
  • EISSN: 1537-5943
  • URL: /core/journals/american-political-science-review
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 10
Total number of PDF views: 97 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 833 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between 20th December 2017 - 20th February 2018. This data will be updated every 24 hours.