Skip to main content
×
×
Home

Enhancing Democracy Through Legislative Redistricting

  • Andrew Gelman (a1) and Gary King (a2)
Abstract

We demonstrate the surprising benefits of legislative redistricting (including partisan gerrymandering) for American representative democracy. In so doing, our analysis resolves two long-standing controversies in American politics. First, whereas some scholars believe that redistricting reduces electoral responsiveness by protecting incumbents, others, that the relationship is spurious, we demonstrate that both sides are wrong: redistricting increases responsiveness. Second, while some researchers believe that gerrymandering dramatically increases partisan bias and others deny this effect, we show both sides are in a sense correct. Gerrymandering biases electoral systems in favor of the party that controls the redistricting as compared to what would have happened if the other party controlled it, but any type of redistricting reduces partisan bias as compared to an electoral system without redistricting. Incorrect conclusions in both literatures resulted from misjudging the enormous uncertainties present during redistricting periods, making simplified assumptions about the redistricters' goals, and using inferior statistical methods.

Copyright
References
Hide All
Abramowitz, Alan. 1984. “Partisan Redistricting and the 1982 Congressional Elections.” Journal of Politics 45:767–70.
Ansolabehere, Stephen, Brady, David, and Fiorina, Morris. 1988. “Turnout and the Calculation of Swing Ratios.” Research Paper No. 990. Stanford University Graduate School of Business.
Born, Richard. 1985. “Partisan Intentions and Election Day Realities in the Congressional Redistricting Process.” American Political Science Review 79:305–19.
Bullock, Charles. 1975. “Redistricting and Congressional Stability, 1962–1972.” Journal of Politics 37:569–75.
Burnham, Walter Dean. 1974. “Communication.” American Political Science Review 68:207–13.
Butler, David E. 1951. Appendix to The British General Election of 1950. Ed. Nichols, H. G.. London: Macmillan.
Cain, Bruce. 1984. The Reapportionment Puzzle. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Cain, Bruce. 1985. “Assessing the Partisan Effects of Redistricting.” American Political Science Review 79:320–33.
Campagna, Janet, and Grofman, Bernard. 1990. “Party Control and Partisan Bias in 1980s Congressional Redistricting.” Journal of Politics 52:1242–58.
Canon, David, Schousen, Matthew, and Sellers, Patrick. 1993. “The Supply Side of Congressional Redistricting: Race and Strategic Politicians, 1972–1992.” Presented at the annual meeting of the Midwest Political Science Association, Chicago.
Cortner, Richard C. 1970. The Apportionment Cases. New York: Norton.
Cranor, John D., Crawley, Gary L., and Sheele, Raymond H.. 1989. “The Anatomy of a Gerrymander.” American Journal of Political Science 33:222–39.
Davis v. Bandemer 1986. 106 S.Ct. 2797.
Dempster, A. P., Rubin, D. B., and Tsutakawa, R. K.. 1981. “Estimation in Covariance Components Models.” Journal of the American Statistical Association 76:341–53.
Dixon, Robert G. Jr., 1968. Democratic Representation. New York: Oxford University Press.
Erikson, Robert S. 1972. “Malapportionment, Gerrymandering, and Party Fortunes in Congressional Elections.” American Political Science Review 66:1234–45.
Ferejohn, John A. 1977. “On the Decline of Competition in Congressional Elections.” American Political Science Review 71:166–76.
Gelman, Andrew, and King, Gary. 1990. “Estimating the Electoral Consequences of Legislative Redistricting.” Journal of the American Statistical Association 85:274–82.
Gelman, Andrew, and King, Gary. 1993. “Judgeit: A Program for Evaluating Electoral Systems and Redistricting Plans.” Technical report and computer program. Harvard University.
Gelman, Andrew, and King, Gary. 1994. “A Unified Method of Evaluating Electoral Systems and Redistricting Plans.” American Journal of Political Science 38:514554.
Glazer, Amihai, Grofman, Bernard, and Robbins, Marc. 1987. “Partisan and Incumbency Effects in the 1970s Congressional Redistricting.” American Journal of Political Science 30:680701.
Gopoian, J. David, and West, Darrell M.. 1984. “Trading Security for Seats: Strategic Considerations in the Redistricting Process.” Journal of Politics 46:1080–96.
Green, Paul M. 1982. “Legislative Redistricting in Illinois 1871–1982: A Study of Geo-Political Survival.” In Redistricting: An Exercise in Prophecy, ed. Merritt, Anna J.. Chicago: University of Illinois Institute of Government and Public Affairs.
Hacker, Andrew. 1963. Congressional Districting: The Issue of Equal Representation. Washington: Brookings.
Hardy, Leroy, Heslop, Alan, and Anderson, Stuart, eds. 1981. Reapportionment Politics: The History of Redistricting in the Fifty States. Beverly Hills: Sage.
Hsiao, Cheng. 1986. The Analysis of Panel Data. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Kendall, M. G., and Stuart, A.. 1950. “The Law of the Cubic Proportion in Election Results.” British Journal of Sociology 1:193–96.
King, Gary. 1989. “Representation through Legislative Redistricting: A Stochastic Model,” American Journal of Political Science 33:787824.
King, Gary. 1991. “Constituency Service and Incumbency Advantage.” British Journal of Political Science 21:119–28.
King, Gary, and Browning, Robert. 1987. “Democratic Representation and Partisan Bias in Congressional Elections.” American Political Science Review 81:1251–76.
King, Gary, and Gelman, Andrew. 1991. “Systemic Consequences of Incumbency Advantage in the U.S. House.” American Journal of Political Science 35:110–38.
Mayhew, David R. 1971. “Congressional Representation: Theory and Practice in Drawing the Districts.” In Reapportionment in the 1970s, ed. Polsby, Nelson W.. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Monili, Richard. 1990. “A Geographer's Perspective.” In Political Gerrymandering and the Courts, ed. Grofman, Bernard. New York: Agathon.
Niemi, Richard, and Jackman, Simon. 1991. “Bias and Responsiveness in State Legislative Districting.” Legislative Studies Quarterly 16:183202.
Niemi, Richard, and Winsky, Laura R.. 1992. “The Persistence of Partisan Redistricting Effects in Congressional Elections, in the 1970s and 1980s.” Journal of Politics 54:565–72.
Owen, Guillermo, and Grofman, Bernard. 1988. “Optimal Partisan Gerrymandering.” Political Geography Quarterly 7:522.
Scarrow, Howard. 1982. “Partisan Gerrymandering—Invidious or Benevolent? Gaffney v. Cummings and Its Aftermath.” Journal of Politics 44:810–21.
Stimson, James. 1985. “Regression in Space and Time: A Statistical Essay.” American Journal of Political Science 29:914–47.
Tufte, Edward. 1973. “The Relationship between Seats and Votes in Two-Party Systems.” American Political Science Review 67:540–54.
Voinovich v. Quilter. 1993. 113 S.Ct. 1149.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

American Political Science Review
  • ISSN: 0003-0554
  • EISSN: 1537-5943
  • URL: /core/journals/american-political-science-review
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Metrics

Altmetric attention score