Skip to main content
×
×
Home

Exclusion and Cooperation in Diverse Societies: Experimental Evidence from Israel

  • RYAN D. ENOS (a1) and NOAM GIDRON (a2)
Abstract

It is well-established that in diverse societies, certain groups prefer to exclude other groups from power and often from society entirely. Yet as many societies are diversifying at an increasingly rapid pace, the need for cross-group cooperation to solve collective action problems has intensified. Do preferences for exclusion inhibit the ability of individuals to cooperate and, therefore, diminish the ability for societies to collectively provide public goods? Turning to Israel, a society with multiple overlapping and politically salient cleavages, we use a large-scale lab-in-the-field design to investigate how preferences for exclusion among the Jewish majority predict discriminatory behavior toward Palestinian Citizens of Israel. We establish that preferences for exclusion are likely symbolic attitudes, and therefore stable and dominating of other attitudes; are held especially strongly by low-status majority group members; and powerfully predict costly non-cooperation. This preferences/behavior relationship appears unaffected by mitigating factors proposed in the intergroup relations literature. The demonstrated influence of symbolic attitudes on behavior calls for further examination of the social roots of exclusionary preferences.

Copyright
Corresponding author
Ryan D. Enos is a Professor of Government, Department of Government, Harvard University, 1737 Cambridge Street, Cambridge, MA 02138 (renos@gov.harvard.edu).
Noam Gidron is a Research Fellow at the Niehaus Center for Globalization and Governance at Princeton University and an Assistant Professor of Political Science, Hebrew University, Mount Scopus, Jerusalem (Noam.Gidron@mail.huji.ac.il).
Footnotes
Hide All

Both authors contributed equally. Support for this research was provided by the Harvard Center for Jewish Studies, the Harvard Academy for International and Area Studies, and the Multidisciplinary Program in Inequality and Social Policy at Harvard University. A previous version of this article was presented at the 2017 Midwest Political Science Association Annual Meeting and the 2017 Toronto Political Behaviour Workshop. We thank Stanley Feldman and Eric Arias for comments and Riley Carney and Alexander Sahn for additional assistance. Replication files are available at the American Political Science Review Dataverse: https://doi.org/10.7910/DVN/DAR56O.

Footnotes
References
Hide All
Achen, Christopher H. 1975. “Mass Political Attitudes and the Survey Response.” American Political Science Review 69 (04): 1218–31.
Alesina, Alberto, Baqir, Reza, and Easterly, William. 1999. “Public Goods and Ethnic Divisions.” The Quarterly Journal of Economics 114 (4): 1243–84.
Alexander, Marcus, and Christia, Fotini. 2011. “Context Modularity of Human Altruism.” Science 334 (6061): 1392–4.
Allport, Gordon W. 1954. The Nature of Prejudice. Cambridge, MA: Addison-Wesley.
Anderson, Benedict. 1983. Imagined Communities: Reflections on the Origin and Spread of Nationalism. New York: Verso Books.
Axelrod, Robert M. 2006. The Evolution of Cooperation. New York: Basic books.
Baldassarri, Delia. 2015. “Cooperative Networks: Altruism, Group Solidarity, Reciprocity, and Sanctioning in Ugandan Producer Organizations.” American Journal of Sociology 121 (2): 355–95.
Bar, Revital, and Zussman, Asaf. 2017. “Customer Discrimination: Evidence from Israel.” Journal of Labor Economics 35 (4): 1031–59.
Ben-Nun Bloom, Pazit, Arikan, Gizem, and Courtemanche, Marie. 2015. “Religious Social Identity, Religious Belief, and Anti-Immigration Sentiment.” American Political Science Review 109 (April): 203–21.
Bertrand, Marianne, and Mullainathan, Sendhil. 2004. “Are Emily and Greg More Employable than Lakisha and Jamal? A Field Experiment on Labor Market Discrimination.” American Economic Review 94 (4): 9911013.
Binder, Jens, Zagefka, Hanna, Brown, Rupert, Funke, Friedrich, Kessler, Thomas, Mummendey, Amelie, Maquil, Annemie, Demoulin, Stephanie, and Leyens, Jacques-Philippe. 2009. “Does Contact Reduce Prejudice or Does Prejudice Reduce Contact? A Longitudinal Test of the Contact Hypothesis among Majority and Minority Groups in Three European Countries.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 96 (4): 843.
Blumer, Herbert. 1958. “Race Prejudice as a Sense of Group Position.” Pacific Sociological Review 1 (1): 37.
Bobo, Lawrence, and Hutchings, Vincent. 1996. “Perceptions of Racial Group Competition: Extending Blumer’s Theory of Group Position to a Multiracial Social Context.” American Sociological Review 61 (6): 951–72.
Bogardus, Emory S. 1926. “Social Distance in the City.” Proceedings and Publications of the American Sociological Society 20: 40–6.
Bogardus, Emory Stephen. 1933. “A Social Distance Scale.” Sociology & Social Research 17: 265–71.
Brewer, Marilynn, and Miller, Norman. 1984. “Beyond the Contact Hypothesis: Theoretical Perspectives on Desegregation.” In Groups in Contact: The Psychology of Desegregation, eds. Brewer, Marilynn and Miller, Norman. San Diego, CA: Academic, 281302.
Browning, Rufus P., Marshall, Dale Rogers, and Tabb, David H.. 1984. Protest Is Not Enough: The Struggle of Blacks and Hispanics for Equality in Urban Politics. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
Canetti-Nisim, Daphna, Ariely, Guy, and Halperin, Eran. 2008. “Life, Pocketbook, or Culture: The Role of Perceived Security Threats in Promoting Exclusionist Political Attitudes toward Minorities in Israel.” Political Research Quarterly 61 (1): 90103.
Charles, Kerwin Kofi, and Guryan, Jonathan. 2011. “Studying Discrimination: Fundamental Challenges and Recent Progress.” Annual Review of Economics 3 (September): 479511.
Citrin, Jack, and Sides, John. 2008. “Immigration and the Imagined Community in Europe and the United States.” Political Studies 56: 3356.
Clark, Kenneth B., and Clark, Mamie P.. 1950. “Emotional Factors in Racial Identification and Preference in Negro Children.” The Journal of Negro Education 19 (3): 341–50.
Coopermanm, Alan, Sahgal, Neha, and Schiller, Anna. 2016. Israel’s Religiously Divided Society. Technical report, Pew Research Center.
Cuddy, Amy J. C., Fiske, Susan T., and Glick, Peter. 2007. “The BIAS Map: Behaviors from Intergroup Affect and Stereotypes.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 92 (4): 631–48.
Dinesen, Peter Thisted, and Sønderskov, Kim Mannemar. 2015. “Ethnic Diversity and Social Trust Evidence from the Micro-Context.” American Sociological Review 80 (3): 550–73.
Enos, Ryan D. 2014. “The Causal Effect of Intergroup Contact on Exclusionary Attitudes.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 111 (10): 3699–704.
Enos, Ryan D. 2017. The Space Between Us: Social Geography and Politics. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Enos, Ryan D., and Gidron, Noam. 2016. “Intergroup Behavioral Strategies as Contextually Determined: Experimental Evidence from Israel.” Journal of Politics 78 (3): 851–67.
Fershtman, Chaim, and Gneezy, Uri. 2001. “Discrimination in a Segmented Society: An Experimental Approach.” The Quarterly Journal of Economics 116 (1): 351–77.
Gidron, Noam, and Hall, Peter A.. 2017. “The Politics of Social Status: Economic and Cultural Roots of the Populist Right.” The British Journal of Sociology 68 (1): 5784.
Golder, Matt. 2003. “Explaining Variation in the Success of Extreme Right Parties in Western Europe.” Comparative Political Studies 36 (4): 432–66.
Greenwald, Anthony G., McGhee, Debbie E., and Schwartz, Jordan L. K.. 1998. “Measuring Individual Differences in Implicit Cognition: The Implicit Association Test.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 74 (6): 1464–80.
Grossman, Guy. 2011. “Lab-in-the-Field Experiments.” Newsletter of the APSA Experimental Section 2 (2): 13–9.
Grossman, Guy, and Baldassarri, Delia. 2012. “The Impact of Elections on Cooperation: Evidence from a Lab-in-the-Field Experiment in Uganda.” American Journal of Political Science 56 (4): 964–85.
Gubler, Joshua R., and Kalmoe, Nathan P.. 2015. “Violent Rhetoric in Protracted Group Conflicts: Experimental Evidence from Israel and India.” Political Research Quarterly 68 (November): 651–64.
Gubler, Joshua Ronald, Halperin, Eran, and Hirschberger, Gilad. 2015. “Humanizing the Outgroup in Contexts of Protracted Intergroup Conflict.” Journal of Experimental Political Science 2 (February): 3646.
Habyarimana, James, Humphreys, Macartan, Posner, Daniel N., and Weinstein, Jeremy M.. 2007. “Why Does Ethnic Diversity Undermine Public Goods Provision?American Political Science Review 101 (4): 709–25.
Habyarimana, James, Humphreys, Macartan, Posner, Daniel N., and Weinstein, Jeremy M.. 2009. Coethnicity: Diversity and the Dilemmas of Collective Action. New York: Russell Sage.
Hainmueller, Jens, and Hangartner, Dominik. 2013. “Who Gets a Swiss Passport? A Natural Experiment in Immigrant Discrimination.” American Political Science Review 107 (1): 159–87.
Hainmueller, Jens, and Hiscox, Michael. 2010. “Attitudes Towards Highly Skilled and Low Skilled Immigration: Evidence from a Survey Experiment.” American Political Science Review 104 (1): 61–84.
Halperin, Eran, Canetti-Nisim, Daphna, and Pedahzur, Ami. 2007. “Threatened by the Uncontrollable: Psychological and Socio-Economic Antecedents of Social Distance towards Labor Migrants in Israel.” International Journal of Intercultural Relations 31 (July): 459–78.
Hellwig, Timothy, and Sinno, Abdulkader. 2016. “Different Groups, Different Threats: Public Attitudes towards Immigrants.” Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies (July): 120.
Henrich, Joseph, McElreath, Richard, Barr, Abigail, Ensminger, Jean, Barrett, Clark, Bolyanatz, Alexander, Cardenas, Juan Camilo, Gurven, Michael, Gwako, Edwins, Henrich, Natalie et al. 2006. “Costly Punishment Across Human Societies.” Science 312 (5781): 1767–70.
Hewstone, Miles. 2015. “Consequences of Diversity for Social Cohesion and Prejudice: The Missing Dimension of Intergroup Contact.” Journal of Social Issues 71 (2): 417–38.
Hjort, Jonas. 2014. “Ethnic Divisions and Production in Firms.” The Quarterly Journal of Economics 129 (4): 1899–946.
Hochschild, Jennifer L. 2000. “Lumpers and Splitters, Individuals and Structures.” In Racialized Politics: The Debate About Racism in America. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 234343.
Hopkins, Daniel J., Sides, John, and Citrin, Jack. 2016. “The Muted Consequences of Correct Information About Immigration.” Working paper, University of Pennsylvania.
Inbar, Michael, and Yuchtman-Yaar, Ephraim. 1986. “Social Distance in the Israeli-Arab Conflict: A Resource-Dependency Analysis.” Comparative Political Studies 19 (October): 283316.
Islam, Mir Rabiul, and Hewstone, Miles. 1993. “Dimensions of Contact as Predictors of Intergroup Anxiety, Perceived Out-Group Variability, and Out-Group Attitude: An Integrative Model.” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 19 (6): 700–10.
Jennings, M. Kent, and Niemi, Richard G.. 2015. Political Character of Adolescence: The Influence of Families and Schools. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Johnson, Megan K., Rowatt, Wade C., and LaBouff, Jordan. 2010. “Priming Christian Religious Concepts Increases Racial Prejudice.” Social Psychological and Personality Science 1 (2): 119–26.
Jones, Dan. 2010. “A WEIRD View of Human Nature Skews Psychologists’ Studies.” Science 328 (5986): 16271627.
Jost, John T., Glaser, Jack, Kruglanski, Arie W., and Sulloway, Frank J.. 2003. “Political Conservatism as Motivated Social Cognition.” Psychological Bulletin 129 (3): 339–75.
Kahneman, Daniel. 2003. “A Perspective on Judgement and Choice: Mapping Bounded Rationality.” American Psychologist 58 (9): 697720.
Key, V. O. 1949. Southern Politics in State and Nation. New York: Knopf.
Kinder, Donald R., and Kam, Cindy D.. 2009. Us Against Them: Ethnocentric Foundations of American Opinion. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Kinder, Donald R., and Sears, David O.. 1981. “Prejudice and Politics: Symbolic Racism Versus Threats to the Good Life.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 40 (3): 414–31.
Knoll, Benjamin R. 2009. “And Who Is My Neighbor? Religion and Immigration Policy Attitudes.” Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 48 (2): 313–31.
Kramer, Gerald H. 1986. “Political Science as Science.” In Political Science: The Science of Politics, ed. Weisberg, Herbert F.. New York: Agathon, 1123.
Krochmal, Max. 2016. Blue Texas: The Making of a Multiracial Democratic Coalition in the Civil Rights Era. Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press.
Krosnick, Jon A. 1991. “Response Strategies for Coping with the Cognitive Demands of Attitude Measures in Surveys.” Applied Cognitive Psychology 5 (3): 213–36.
Kurzban, Robert, and Leary, Mark R.. 2001. “Evolutionary Origins of Stigmatization: The Functions of Social Exclusion.” Psychological Bulletin 127 (2): 187208.
LaPiere, Richard. 1934. “Attitudes vs. Actions.” Social Forces 13 (February): 230–7.
Lieberman, Evan S., and McClendon, Gwyneth H.. 2013. “The Ethnicity–Policy Preference Link in Sub-Saharan Africa.” Comparative Political Studies 46 (5): 574602.
Liviatan, Ido, Trope, Yaacov, and Liberman, Nira. 2008. “Interpersonal Similarity as a Social Distance Dimension: Implications for Perception of Others Actions.” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 44 (5): 1256–69.
Manekin, Devorah, Grossman, Guy, and Mitts, Tamar. 2016. “Contested Ground: Disentangling Material and Symbolic Attachment to Territory.” Working Paper: Arizona State University.
Marger, Martin. 2003. Race and Ethnic Relations: American and Global Perspectives. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth/Thomson Learning.
Massey, Douglas S., and Denton, Nancy A.. 1993. American Apartheid: Segregation and the Making of the Underclass. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Mendelberg, Tali, McCabe, Katherine T., and Thal, Adam. 2017. “College Socialization and the Economic Views of Affluent Americans.” American Journal of Political Science 61 (3): 606–23.
Mitchell, Gregory, and Tetlock, Philip E.. 2017. “Popularity as a Poor Proxy for Utility.” In Psychological Science under Scrutiny: Recent Challenges and Proposed Solutions. Hoboken: NJ: John Wiley & Sons, 164–95.
Okun, Barbara S., and Friedlander, Dov. 2005. “Educational Stratification Among Arabs and Jews in Israel: Historical Disadvantage, Discrimination, and Opportunity.” Population Studies 59 (July): 163–80.
Olson, Mancur. 1971. The Logic of Collective Action: Public Good and the Theory of Groups. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Oxley, Douglas R., Smith, Kevin B., Alford, John R., Hibbing, Matthew V., Miller, Jennifer L., Scalora, Mario, Hatemi, Peter K., and Hibbing, John R.. 2008. “Political Attitudes Vary with Physiological Traits.” Science 321 (5896): 1667–70.
Pager, D., and Quillian, L.. 2005. “Walking the Talk? What Employers Say versus What They Do.” American Sociological Review 70 (3): 355–80.
Pager, Devah, and Shepherd, Hana. 2008. “The Sociology of Discrimination: Racial Discrimination in Employment, Housing, Credit, and Consumer Markets.” Annual Review of Sociology 34 (August): 181209.
Paluck, Elizabeth Levy. 2009. “What’s in a Norm? Sources and Processes of Norm Change.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 96 (3): 594600.
Parrillo, Vincent N., and Donoghue, Christopher. 2005. “Updating the Bogardus Social Distance Studies: A New National Survey.” The Social Science Journal 42 (2): 257–71.
Pedahzur, Ami, and Yishai, Yael. 1999. “Hatred by Hated People: Xenophobia in Israel.” Studies in Conflict & Terrorism 22 (May): 101–17.
Pedahzur, Ami, Halperin, Eran, and Canetti, Daphna. 2007. “Psychoeconomic Approaches to the Study of Hostile Attitudes Toward Minority Groups: A Study Among Israeli Jews.” Social Science Quarterly 88 (March): 177–98.
Pettigrew, Thomas F., and Tropp, Linda. 2006. “A Meta-Analytic Test of Intergroup Contact Theory.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 90 (5): 751–83.
Putnam, Robert D. 2007. “E Pluribus Unum: Diversity and Community in the Twenty-First Century: The 2006 Johan Skytte Prize Lecture.” Scandinavian Political Studies 30 (2): 137–74.
Schroeder, Juliana, and Risen, Jane L.. 2015. “Befriending the Enemy: Outgroup Friendship Longitudinally Predicts Intergroup Attitudes in a Coexistence Program for Israelis and Palestinians.” Group Processes & Intergroup Relations 19 (December): 7293.
Sears, David O. 1986. “College Sophomores in the Laboratory: Influences of a Narrow Data Base on Social Psychology’s View of Human Nature.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 51 (3): 515–30.
Sears, David O. 1993. “Symbolic Politics: A Socio-Psychological Theory.” In Explorations in Political Psychology, eds. Iyengar, Shanto and McGuire, William James. Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 113–49.
Sears, David O., and Henry, P. J.. 2003. “The Origins of Symbolic Racism.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 85 (3): 259–75.
Sears, David O., van Laar, Colette, Carillo, Mary, and Kosterman, Richard. 1997. “Is It Really Racism? The Origins of White Americans’ Opposition to Race-Targeted Policies.” Public Opinion Quarterly 61 (1): 1653.
Semyonov, Moshe, Raijman, Rebeca, and Gorodzeisky, Anastasia. 2006. “The Rise of Anti-foreigner Sentiment in European Societies, 1988–2000.” American Sociological Review 71 (3): 426–49.
Sidanius, James, Levin, Shana, Van Laar, Colette, and Sears, David O.. 2008. The Diversity Challenge. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
Sidanius, Jim, and Pratto, Felicia. 2001. Social Dominance: An Intergroup Theory of Social Hierarchy and Oppression. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Simpson, George Eaton, and Yinger, J. Milton. 2013. Racial and Cultural Minorities: An Analysis of Prejudice and Discrimination. Medford, MA: Springer Science & Business Media.
Singh, Prerna. 2011. “We-ness and Welfare: A Longitudinal Analysis of Social Development in Kerala, India.” World Development 39 (February): 282–93.
Smooha, Sammy. 1987. “Jewish and Arab Ethnocentrism in Israel.” Ethnic and Racial Studies 10 (1): 126.
Smooha, Sammy. 1992. Arabs and Jews in Israel. Boulder: Westview Press.
Smooha, Sammy. 2002. “The Model of Ethnic Democracy: Israel as a Jewish and Democratic State.” Nations and Nationalism 8 (October): 475503.
Smooha, Sammy. 2004. Index of Arab–Jewish Relations in Israel. Haifa: The Jewish–Arab Center, University of Haifa.
Sniderman, Paul M., and Tetlock, Philip E.. 1986. “Symbolic Racism: Problems of Motive Attribution in Political Analysis.” Journal of Social Issues 42 (2): 129–50.
Storm, Ingrid, Sobolewska, Maria, and Ford, Robert. 2017. “Is Ethnic Prejudice Declining in Britain? Change in Social Distance Attitudes among Ethnic Majority and Minority Britons.” The British Journal of Sociology 68 (3): 410–34.
Stubager, Rune. 2008. “Education Effects on Authoritarian–Libertarian Values: A Question of Socialization.” The British Journal of Sociology 59 (June): 327–50.
Stubager, Rune. 2009. “Education-Based Group Identity and Consciousness in the Authoritarian-Libertarian Value Conflict.” European Journal of Political Research 48 (March): 204–33.
Tajfel, Henri, and Turner, John. 1979. “An Integrative Theory of Intergroup Conflict.” In The Social Psychology of Intergroup Relations, ed. Austin, W.G., and Worchel, S.. Monterey, CA: Brooks Cole, 3347.
Tajfel, Henri, Billig, M. G., Bundy, R. P., and Flament, Claude. 1971. “Social Categorization and Intergroup Behavior.” European Journal of Social Psychology 1 (2): 149–78.
Tarman, Christopher, and Sears, David O.. 2005. “The Conceptualization and Measurement of Symbolic Racism.” The Journal of Politics 67 (03): 731–61.
Tesler, Michael. 2012. “The Spillover of Racialization into Health Care: How President Obama Polarized Public Opinion by Racial Attitudes and Race.” American Journal of Political Science 56 (3): 690704.
Turner, John C., and Oakes, Penelope J.. 1986. “The Significance of the Social Identity Concept for Social Psychology with Reference to Individualism, Interactionism and Social Influence.” British Journal of Social Psychology 25 (3): 237–52.
Uslaner, Eric M. 2012. Segregation and Mistrust: Diversity, Isolation, and Social Cohesion. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Weaver, Charles N. 2008. “Social Distance as a Measure of Prejudice Among Ethnic Groups in the United States.” Journal of Applied Social Psychology 38 (3): 779–95.
Whitt, Sam, and Wilson, Rick K.. 2007. “The Dictator Game, Fairness and Ethnicity in Postwar Bosnia.” American Journal of Political Science 51 (3): 655–68.
Yamagishi, Toshio, and Cook, Karen S.. 1993. “Generalized Exchange and Social Dilemmas.” Social Psychology Quarterly 235–48.
Zaller, John R. 1992. The Nature and Origins of Mass Opinion. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Zeitzoff, Thomas. 2014. “Anger, Exposure to Violence, and Intragroup Conflict: A ‘Lab in the Field’ Experiment in Southern Israel.” Political Psychology 35 (3): 309–35.
Zeitzoff, Thomas. 2016. “Anger, Legacies of Violence, and Group Conflict: An Experiment in Post-Riot Acre, Israel.” Conflict Management and Peace Science (May): 122.
Zussman, Asaf. 2013. “Ethnic Discrimination: Lessons from the Israeli Online Market for Used Cars.” The Economic Journal 123 (572): F433–68.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

American Political Science Review
  • ISSN: 0003-0554
  • EISSN: 1537-5943
  • URL: /core/journals/american-political-science-review
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×
Type Description Title
PDF
Supplementary materials

Enos and Gidron supplementary material 1
Appendix

 PDF (161 KB)
161 KB

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed