Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home

To Trust an Adversary: Integrating Rational and Psychological Models of Collaborative Policymaking

  • WILLIAM D. LEACH (a1) and PAUL A. SABATIER (a2)

Abstract

This study explores how trust arises among policy elites engaged in prolonged face-to-face negotiations. Mirroring recent evidence that citizens' procedural preferences (as opposed to policy preferences) drive trust in government, we find that interpersonal trust among stakeholders in consensus-seeking partnerships is explained by the perceived legitimacy and fairness of the negotiation process more so than by the partnership's track record of producing mutually agreeable policies. Overall, hypotheses derived from social psychology do as well or better than those based on rational-choice assumptions. Important predictors of trust include small and stable groups, generalized social trust, clear decision rules, political stalemate, congruence on policy-related beliefs, and absence of devil-shift (the belief that one's opponents wield more power than one's allies). Surprisingly, null or negative correlations exist between trust and network density, measured by membership in voluntary associations. The study illustrates the value of behavioral models that integrate institutional, rational, and psychological explanations.

Copyright

Corresponding author

William D. Leach is Research Director, Center for Collaborative Policy, California State University, Sacramento, 1303 J Street, Suite 250, Sacramento, CA 95814 (bleach@ccp.csus.edu).
Paul A. Sabatier is Professor, Department of Environmental Science & Policy, University of California, One Shields Avenue, Davis, CA 95616-8576 (pasabatier@ucdavis.edu).

References

Hide All
Allison Graham T. 1969. “Conceptual Models and the Cuban Missile Crisis.” American Political Science Review 63 (September): 689718.
American Association for Public Opinion Research. 2000. Standard Definitions: Final Dispositions of Case Codes and Outcome Rates for Surveys. Lenexa, Kansas: AAPOR.
Baumgartner Frank R., and Bryan D. Jones. 1993. Agendas and Instability in American Politics. Chicago: University of Chicago. Press.
Bohnet Iris, Bruno S. Frey, and Steffen Huck. 2001. “More Order with Less Law: On Contract Enforcement, Trust and Crowding.” American Political Science Review 95 (March): 13144.
Braithwaite Valerie. 1998. “Communal and Exchange Trust Norms: Their Value Base and Relevance to Institutional Trust.” In Trust and Governance, ed. Valerie Braithwaite and Margaret Levi. New York: Russell Sage, 4674.
Brehm John, and Wendy Rahn. 1997. “Individual-Level Evidence for the Causes and Consequences of Social Capital.” American Journal of Political Science 41 (July): 9991023.
Chong Dennis, Jack Citrin, and Patricia Conley. 2001. “When Self-Interest Matters.” Political Psychology 22 (September): 54170.
Converse Phillip. 1964. “The Nature of Belief Systems in Mass Publics.” In Ideology and Discontent, ed. David Apter. New York: The Free Press, 20661.
Cook Karen S., Russell Hardin, and Margaret Levi. 2005. Cooperation Without Trust? New York: Russell Sage.
Eliasoph Nina. 1998. Avoiding Politics. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press.
EPA (U.S. Environmental Protection Agency). 2002. Adopt Your Watershed. Accessed 29 August 2002. http://www.epa.gov/adopt.
Evans John H. 2003. “Have Americans' Attitudes Become More Polarized?—An Update.” Social Science Quarterly 84 (March): 7190.
Festinger Leon. 1957. A Theory of Cognitive Dissonance. Evanston, IL: Row Peterson.
Fisher Ronald J. 1997. Interactive Conflict Resolution. Syracuse, NY: Syracuse University Press.
Fisher Roger, and William Ury. 1981. Getting to Yes: Negotiating Agreement without Giving In. Markham, Ontario: Penguin Books.
Green Donald Philip, and Ann Elizabeth Gerken. 1989. “Self-Interest and Public Opinion Toward Smoking Restrictions and Cigarette Taxes.” The Public Opinion Quarterly 53 (Spring): 116.
Green Donald P., and Ian Shapiro. 1994. Pathologies of Rational Choice Theory: A Critique of Applications in Political Science. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
Hardin Russell. 2002. Trust and Trustworthiness. New York: Russell Sage.
Hetherington Marc J. 1998. “The Political Relevance of Political Trust.” The American Political Science Review 92 (December): 791808.
Hetherington Marc J. 2001. “Resurgent Mass Partisanship: The Role of Elite Polarization.” American Political Science Review 95 (September): 61931.
Hibbing John R., and Elizabeth Theiss-Morse. 2001. “Process Preferences and American Politics: What the People Want Government to Be.” American Political Science Review 95 (March): 14553.
Hibbing John R., and Elizabeth Theiss-Morse. 2002. Stealth Democracy: Americans' Beliefs about How Government Should Work. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press.
Kenney Doug S. 1999. “Historical and Sociopolitical Context of the Western Watersheds Movement.” Journal of the American Water Resources Association 35 (June): 493503.
Kriesberg Louis. 1998. Constructive Conflicts: From Escalation to Resolution. Lanham, MD: Rowman and Littlefield.
Lakatose Imre. 1971. “History of Science and Its Rational Reconstruction.” In In Memory of Rudolf Carnap. Vol. 8 of Boston Studies in the Philosophy of Science, ed. R. C. Buck and Robert S. Cohen. Dordrecht, Holland: D. Reidel, 42134.
Leach William D, and Neil W. Pelkey. 2001. “Making Watershed Partnerships Work: A Review of The Empirical Literature.” Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management 127 (November/December): 37885.
Leach William D., Neil W. Pelkey, and Paul A. Sabatier. 2002. “Stakeholder Partnerships as Collaborative Policymaking: Evaluation Criteria Applied to Watershed Management in California and Washington.” Journal of Policy Analysis and Management 21 (Fall): 64570.
Levi Margaret. 1996. “Social and Unsocial Capital: A Review Essay of Robert Putnam's ‘Making Democracy Work’.” Politics and Society 24 (March): 4455.
Loehle Craig. 1987. “Hypothesis Testing in Ecology: Psychological Aspects and the Importance of Theory Maturation.” Quarterly Review of Biology 62 (December): 397409.
Lord Charles G., Lee Ross, and Mark R. Lepper. 1979. “Biased Assimilation and Attitude Polarization: The Effects of Prior Theories on Subsequently Considered Evidence.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 37: 20982109.
Lubell Mark, and John T. Scholz. 2001. “Cooperation, Reciprocity, and the Collective-Action Heuristic.” American Journal of Political Science 45 (January): 16078.
McKnight D. Harrison, and Norman L. Chervany. 1996. “The Meaning of Trust.” Working Paper: Carlson School of Management, University of Minnesota.
Moulton Brent R. 1986. “Random Group Effects and the Precision of Regression Estimates.” Journal of Econometrics, 32 (August): 38597.
Munro Geoffrey, and Peter Ditto. 1997. “Biased Assimilation, Attitude Polarization, and Affect in Reactions to Stereotype-Relevant Scientific Information.” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 23 (June): 63653.
National Commission on Civic Renewal 1998. “Associations and Democracy.” In A Nation of Spectators: How Civic Disengagement Weakens America and What We Can Do About It. http://www.puaf.umd.edu/Affiliates/CivicRenewal/finalreport/associations_and_ democracy.htm (June 22 2004).
Olson Mancur. 1965. The Logic of Collective Action. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Orbell John, and Robyn M. Dawes. 1991. “A ‘Cognitive Miser’ Theory of Cooperators' Advantage.” American Political Science Review 85 (June): 51528.
Ostrom Elinor. 1990. Governing the Commons: The Evolution of Institutions for Collective Action. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press.
Ostrom Elinor. 1992. “The Rudiments of a Theory of the Origins, Survival, and Performance of Common-Property Institutions.” In Making the Commons Work: Theory, Practice, and Policy, ed. Daniel W. Bromley. San Francisco: Institute for Contemporary Studies Press.
Ostrom Elinor A. 1998. “Behavioral Approach to the Rational Choice Theory of Collective Action: Presidential Address, American Political Science Association, 1997.” American Political Science Review 92 (March): 122.
Ostrom Elinor. 1999. “Institutional Rational Choice: An Assessment of the Institutional Analysis and Development Framework.” In Theories of the Policy Process, ed. Paul Sabatier. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
Ostrom Elinor, Roy Gardner, and James Walker. 1994. Rules, Games, and Common-Pool Resources. Ann Arbor, MI: The University of Michigan Press.
Peel Mark. 1998. “Trusting Disadvantaged Citizens.” In Trust in Governance, ed. Valerie Braithwaite and Margaret Levi. New York: Russell Sage.
Platt John R. 1964. “Strong Inference.” Science 146: 34753.
Popper Karl. 1959. The Logic of Scientific Discovery. New York: Harper and Row.
Price David E. 2004. The Congressional Experience. Third Edition. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
Putnam Robert D. 2000. Bowling Alone: The Collapse and Revival of American Community. New York: Simon & Schuster.
Putnam Robert D., with Robert Leonardi and Raffaella Y. Nanetti. 1993. Making Democracy Work: Civic Traditions in Modern Italy. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Quattrone George, and Amos Tversky. 1988. “Contrasting Rational and Psychological Analyses of Political Choice.” American Political Science Review 82 (September): 71936.
Reingold Beth. 1996. Conflict and Cooperation: Legislative Strategies and Concepts of Power among Female and Male State Legislators. The Journal of Politics 58 (2, May): 46485.
Rieke Betsy, and Douglas Kenney. 1997. Resource Management at the Watershed Level: An Assessment of the Changing Federal Role in the Emerging Era of Community-Based Watershed Management. Boulder, CO: Natural Resources Law Center, University of Colorado School of Law.
Rothstein Bo. 2000. “Trust, Social Dilemmas and Collective Memories.” Journal of Theoretical Politics 12 (October): 477501.
Ruscio Kenneth P. 1999. “Jay's Pirouette, or Why Political Trust Is Not the Same as Personal Trust.” Administration & Society 31 (November): 63957.
Sabatier Paul, Susan Hunter, and Susan McLaughlin. 1987. “The Devil Shift: Perceptions and Misperceptions of Opponents.” Western Political Quarterly 40 (September): 5173.
Sabatier Paul, and Hank Jenkins-Smith. 1993. Policy Change and Learning: An Advocacy Coalition Approach. Boulder: Westview Press.
Sabatier Paul, and Hank Jenkins-Smith. 1999. “The Advocacy Coalition Framework: An Assessment.” In Theories of the Policy Process, ed. Paul Sabatier. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
Sabatier Paul A., and Matthew A. Zafonte. 2001. “Policy Knowledge: Advocacy Organizations.” In International Encyclopedia of the Social & Behavioral Sciences, ed. Paul B. Baltes and Neil J. Smelser. New York: Elsevier Science Ltd., 11,56311,568.
Simon Herbert. 1985. “Human Nature in Politics: The Dialogue of Psychology with Political Science.” American Political Science Review 79 (June): 293304.
Stinchcombe Arthur L. 1968. Constructing Social Theories. University of Chicago Press.
Sullivan John L. and John E. Transue. 1999. “The Psychological Underpinnings of Democracy: A Selective Review of Research on Political Tolerance, Interpersonal Trust, and Social Capital.” Annual Review of Psychology 50 (February): 62550.
Tonkiss Fran, and Andrew Passey. 1999. “Trust, Confidence and Voluntary Organizations: Between Values and Institutions.” Sociology 33 (May): 25774.
Tversky Amos, and Kahneman Daniel. 1981. “The Framing of Decisions and the Psychology of Choice.” Science 211: 45358.
Tyler Tom R. 2000. “Social Justice: Outcome and Procedure.” International Journal of Psychology 35 (April): 11725.
Tyler Tom R., and Steven Blader. 2000. Cooperation in Groups: Procedural Justice, Social Identity, and Behavioral Engagement. Philadelphia: Psychology Press.
Tyler Tom R., and Kathleen M. McGraw. 1986. “Ideology and the Interpretation of Personal Experience: Procedural Justice and Political Quiescence.” Journal of Social Issues 42 (Summer): 11528.
Weber Edward P. 1998. “Successful Collaboration: Negotiating Effective Regulations.” Environment 40 (November): 1021.
Williamson Oliver E. 1993. “Calculativeness, Trust, and Economic Organization.” Journal of Law and Economics 36 (April): 45386.
Young Jason, Cynthia J. Thomsen, Eugene Borgida, John L. Sullivan, and John H. Aldrich. 1991. “When Self-Interest Makes a Difference: The Role of Construct Accessibility in Political Reasoning.” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 27 (May): 27196.
Zafonte Matthew, and Paul Sabatier. 1998. “Shared Beliefs and Imposed Interdependencies as Determinants of Ally Networks in Overlapping Subsystems.” Journal of Theoretical Politics 10 (October): 473505.

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed