Skip to main content

A redefinition of the syndrome of Broca's aphasia: Implications for a neuropsychological model of language

  • Rita Sloan Berndt (a1) and Alfonso Caramazza (a1)

A neuropsychological theory is offered to account for the syndrome of Broca's aphasia. A critical review of the literature, with emphasis on recent research, provides the basis for a redefinition of the syndrome that considerably broadens its classical description. The argument is advanced that the focus of neuropsychological explanation should be on theoretically separable psychological mechanisms that might be disrupted in relative isolation from other components in conditions of focal brain damage, rather than on isolated units of aphasic performance. The symptoms that characterize Broca's aphasia are explained as predictable behavioral manifestations of a central disruption of the syntactic parsing component of the language System, coupled with a (theoretically independent) articulatory deficit that affects only the speech output System. The neuroanatomical implications of this argument are considered within the framework of the classical “strong localizationist” hypothesis.

Corresponding author
Rita Sloan Berndt, Department of Psychology, The Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD 21218
Hide All
Andreewsky E., & Seron X.Implicit processing of grammatical rules in a classical case of agrammatism. Cortex, 1975, 11, 379–90.
Benson D. F.The third alexia. Archives of Neurology, 1977, 34, 327–31.
Benson D. F., Brown J., & Tomlinson E. B.Varieties of alexia: Word and letter blindness. Neurology, 1971, 21, 951–57.
Benson D. F., & Geschwind N. The alexias. In Vinken P. J. and Bruyn G. W. (Eds.), Handbook of Clinical Nuerology, Vol. 4. Amsterdam: North Hoiland Publishing, 1969.
Benson D. F., & Geschwind N. The aphasias and related disturbances. In Baker A. B. and Baker L. H. (Eds.), Clinical Neurology. Vol. 1. Hagerstown: Harper & Row, 1977.
Berndt R. & Caramazza A. Semantic operations deficits in sentence comprehension. Psychological Research, in press.
Bever T. G. The cognitive basis for linguistic structures. In Hayes T. R. (Ed.), Cognition and the development of language. New York: John Wiley & Sons, 1970.
Bliss L. S., Tikofsky R. S., & Guilford A. M.Aphasies' sentence repetition behavior as a function of grammaticality. Cortex, 1976, 12, 113–21.
Blumstein S., Baker E., & Goodglass H.Phonological factors in auditory comprehension in aphasia. Neuropsychologia, 1977, 15, 1930.
Blumstein S., Cooper W., Zurif E. B., & Caramazza A.The perception and production of VOT in aphasia. Neuropsychologia. 1976, 15, 371–83.
Blumstein S., & Goodglass H.The perception of stress as a semantic cue in aphasia. Journal of Speech and Hearing Research, 1972, 15, 800806.
Boller F., Kim Y., & Mack J. Auditory comprehension in aphasia. In Whitaker H. and Whitaker H. A. (Eds.), Studies in Neurolinguistics. Vol. 3. New York: Academic Press, 1977.
Bradley D. C. Computational distinctions of verbal types. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, 1978.
Bradley C., Garrett M. E., & Zurif E. B. Syntactic deficits in Broca's aphasia. In Caplan D. (Ed.), Biological studies of mental processes. Cambridge, Massachusetts: MIT Press, 1980.
Brown J. W.Mind, brain and consciousness. New York: Academic Press, 1977.
Brown R.A first language: The early stages. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press, 1973.
Caramazza A., & Berndt R. S.Semantic and syntactic processes in aphasia: A review of the literature. Psychological Bulletin, 1978, 85(4), 898918.
Caramazza A., & Zurif E. B.Dissociation of algorithmic and heuristic processes in language comprehension: Evidence from aphasia. Brain and Language, 1976, 3, 572–82.
Caramazza A., Zurif E. B., & Gardner H.Sentence memory in aphasia. Neuropsychologia, 1978, 16, 661–69.
Chomsky N.Aspects of the theory of syntax. Cambridge, Massachusetts: MIT Press, 1965.
Clark H. H., & Clark E. V.Psychology and language. New York: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, 1977.
Dennis M., & Kohn B.Comprehension of syntax in infantile hemiplegies after cerebral hemidecortication: Left-hemisphere superiority. Brain and Language, 1975, 2, 472–82.
Dennis M., & Whitaker H. H.Language acquisition following hemidecortication. Brain and Language, 1976, 3, 404–33.
DeRenzi E., & Vignolo L. A.The Token Test: A sensitive test to detect receptive disturbances in aphasics. Brain, 1962, 85, 665–78.
de Villiers J. G.Quantitative aspects of agrammatism in aphasia. Cortex, 1974, 10, 3654.
Fodor J. A., & Garrett M. F.Some syntactic determinants of sentential complexity. Perception and Psychophysics, 1967, 2, 289–96.
Frazier L.On comprehending sentences: Syntactic parsing strategies. Bloomington, Indiana: Indiana University Linguistics Club, 1979.
Gardner H., Denes G., & Zurif E.Critical reading at the sentence level in aphasia. Cortex, 1975, 11, 6072.
Gardner H., & Zurif E.“Bee” but not “be”: Oral reading of single words in aphasia and alexia. Neuropsychologia, 1975, 13, 181–90.
Gardner H., & Zurif E.Critical reading of words and phrases in aphasia. Brain and Language, 1976, 3, 173–90.
Gleason J. B., Goodglass H., Green E., Ackerman N., & Hyde M. R.The retrieval of syntax in Broca's aphasia. Brain and Language, 1975, 2, 451–71.
Goldstein K.Language and language disturbances. New York: Grune & Stratton, 1948.
Goodenough C., Zurif E., & Weintraub S.Aphasies' attention to grammatical morphemes. Language and Speech. 1977, 20, 1119.
Goodglass H. Redefining the concept of agrammatism in aphasia. In Croatto L. and Croatto-Martinolli C. (Eds.), Proceedings of the XIIth International Speech and Voice Therapy Conference. Padua, Italy, 1962.
Goodglass H. Studies on the grammar of aphasies. In Rosenberg S. and Koplin J. H. (Eds.), Developments in applied psycholinguistics research. New York: Macmillan, 1968.
Goodglass H. Agrammatism. In Whitaker H. and Whitaker H. A. (Eds.), Studies in neurolinguistics, Vol. 1. New York: Academic Press, 1976.
Goodglass H., & Berko J.Agrammatism and inflectional morphology in English. Journal of Speech and Hearing Research, 1960, 3, 257–67.
Goodglass H., Blumstein S. E., Gleason J. B., Hyde M. R., Green E., & Statlender S.The effect of syntactic encoding on sentence comprehension in aphasia. Brain and Language, 1979, 7, 201–9.
Goodglass H., Fodor I. G., & Schulhoff C.Prosodic factors in grammar – Evidence from aphasia. Journal of Speech and Hearing Research, 1967, 10, (1), 520.
Goodglass H., & Geschwind N. Language disorders (aphasia). In Carterette E. C. and Friedman M. P. (Eds.), Handbook of perception. Vol. 7, Speech and language. New York: Academic Press, 1976.
Goodglass H., Gleason J. B., Bernholtz N. A., & Hyde M. R.Some linguistic structures in the speech of a Broca's aphasic. Cortex, 1972, 8, 191212.
Goodglass H., Gleason J. B., & Hyde M. R.Some dimensions of auditory language comprehension in aphasia. Journal of Speech and Hearing Research, 1970, 13, 595606.
Goodglass H., & Hunt J.Grammatical complexity and aphasic speech. Word, 1958, 14, 197207.
Goodglass H., & Hunter M.A linguistic comparison of speech and writ ing in two types of aphasia. Journal of Communication Disorders, 1970, 3, 2835.
Goodglass M., & Kaplan E.The assessment of aphasia and related disorders. Philadelphia: Lea & Febiger, 1972.
Goodglass H., Quadfasel F. A., & Timberlake W. H.Phrase length and the type and severity of aphasia. Cortex, 1964, 1, 133–53.
Heilman K. M., & Scholes R. J.The nature of comprehension errors in Broca's, conduction, and Wernicke's aphasics. Cortex, 1976, 12(3), 258–65.
Howes D. Application of the word frequency concept to aphasia. In DcReuck A.V.S. and O'Connor M. (Eds.), Ciba foundation symposium on disorders of language. London: Churchill, 1964.
Howes D. Hypotheses concerning the functions of the language mechanism. In Salzinger S. and Salzinger K. (Eds.) Research in verbal behavior and some neurophysiological implications. New York: Academic Press: 1967.
Howes D., & Geschwind N. Statistical properties of aphasic speech. Unpublished progress report, USPHS Grant M-1802, Boston, 1962.
Isserlin M.Uber Agrammatismus. Zeitschrift für die Gesante Neurologie and Psychiatrie, 1922, 75, 332416.
Jakobson R. Two aspects of language and two types of aphasic disturbances. In Jakobson R. and Halle M. (Eds.), Fundamentals of language. The Hague: Mouton, 1956.
Jakobson R. Towards a linguistic typology of aphasic impairments. In deReuck A.V.S. and O'Connor M. (Eds.) Ciba foundation symposium on disorders of language. London: Churchill, 1964.
Johnson S. C.Hierarchical clustering schemes. Psychometrika, 1967, 32, 241–54.
Jones L. V., & Wepman J. M.Grammatical indicants of speaking styles in normal and aphasie speakers. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Psychometric Laboratory, Publication No. 46, 1965.
Kean M. L.The linguistic interpretation of aphasic syndromes: Agrammatism in Broca's aphasia, an example. Cognition, 1977, 5, 946.
Kean M. L. The linguistic interpretation of aphasic syndromes. In Walker E. (Ed.), Explorations in the biology of language. Montgomery, Vermont: Bradford Books, 1978.
Kellar L.Stress and syntax in aphasia. Paper presented at the meeting of the Academy of Aphasia, Chicago, 1978.
Kertesz A., Lesk D., & McCabe P.Isotope localization of infarcts in aphasia. Archives of Neurology, 1977, 34, 590601.
Kimball J.Seven principles of surface structure parsing in natural language. Cognition, 1973, 2, 1547.
Kimball J. Predictive analysis and over-the-top parsing. In Kimball J. (Ed.), Syntax and semantics, Vol. 4. New York, Academic Press, 1975.
Kleist K.Gehirnpathologie. Leipzig: Barth, 1934.
Kolk H. H. J.The linguistic interpretation of Broca's aphasia: A reply to M. L. Kean. Cognition, 1978, 6, 353–61. (a)
Kolk H. H. J.Judgment of sentence structure in Broca's aphasia. Neuropsychologia. 1978, 16, 617–25. (b)
Lenneberg E. H.The neurology of language. Daedalus, 1973, 102, 115–33.
Lesser R.Verbal comprehension in aphasia: An English version of three Italian tests. Cortex, 1974, 10, 247–63.
Lesser R.Linguistic investigations of aphasia. New York: Elsevier North-Holland, 1978.
Levelt W. J. N. A scaling approach to the study of syntactic relations. In d'Arcais G. B. Flores and Levelt W. J. M. (Eds.), Advances in psycholinguistics. Amsterdam: North Holland, 1970.
Luria A. R. Factors and forms of aphasia. In DeReuck A.V.S. and O'Connor M. (Eds.), Ciba foundation symposium on disorders of language. London: Churchill, 1964.
Luria A. R.Traumatic aphasia. The Hague: Mouton, 1970.
Luria A. R.Two kinds of disorders in the comprehension of grammatical constructions. Linguistics, 1975, 154/155. 4756.
Luria A. R.Basic problems of neurolinguistics. The Hague: Mouton, 1976.
Luria A. R.Disturbances of grammatical operations in semantic aphasia. Neurolinguistics, 1977, 6, 169–76.
Maratsos M. P.The use of definite and indefinite reference in young children. London: Cambridge University Press, 1976.
Marin O. S. M., Saffran E. M., & Schwartz M. F.Dissociations of language in aphasia: Implications for normal functions. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 1976, 280, 868–84.
Marshall J. C. Disorders in the expression of language. In Morton J. and Marshall J. (Eds.), Psycholingustics: Developmental and pathological. Ithaca, New York: Cornell University Press, 1977.
Marshall J. C. & Newcombe F.Syntactic and semantic errors in paralexia. Neuropsychologia, 1966, 4, 169–76.
Marshall J. C. & Newcombe F.Patterns of paralexia: A psycholinguistic approach, Journal of Psycholinguistic Research, 1973, 2, 175–99.
Martin E.Toward an analysis of subjective phrase structure. Psychological Bulletin, 1970, 74, 153–66.
Martin R., & Caramazza A. Classification in well-defined and ill-defined categories: Evidence for common processing strategies. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, in press.
Mohr T. R. Broca's area and Brocay's aphasia. In Whitaker H. and Whitaker H. A. (Eds.), Studies in neurolinguislics. Vol. 1. New York: Academic Press, 1976.
Olson D.Language and thought: Aspects of a cognitive theory of semantics. Psychological Review, 1970, 77, 257.
Parisi D., & Pizzamiglio L.Syntactic comprehension in aphasia. Cortex, 1970, 6, 204–15.
Patterson K. E., & Marcel A. J.Aphasia, dyslexia, and the phonological coding of written words. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology. 1977, 29, 307–18.
Perlmutter D. M. On the article in English. In Bierwisch M. and Heidolph K. E. (Eds.), Progress in Linguistics. The Hague: Mouton, 1970.
Pick A.Die Agrammatischer Sprachstonngen. Berlin: Springer-Verlag, 1913.
Poeck K., Kerschensteiner M., & Hartje W.A quantitative study of language understanding in fluent and nonfluent aphasia. Cortex, 1972, 8, 299304.
Richardson J. T. E.The effect of word imageability in acquired dyslexia. Neuropsychologia, 1975, 13, 281–88.
Saffran E. M., & Marin O. S. M.Reading without phonology: Evidence from aphasia. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology, 1977, 29, 515525.
Saffran E. M., & Marin O. S. M.Reading without phonology, Evidence from aphasia. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology, 1977, 29, 515–25.
Samuels J. A., & Benson D. F.Some aspects of language comprehension in anterior aphasia. Brain and Language, 1979, 8, 275–86.
Schnitzer M. L.Aphasiological evidence for five linguistic hypotheses. Language, 1974, 50, 300–15.
Scholes R. Syntactic and lexical components of sentence comprehension. In Caramazza A. and Zurif E. (Eds.), Language acquisition and language breakdown. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins Press, 1977.
Schwartz M. F., Saffran E. M., & Marin O. S. M.An analysis of agrammatic reading in aphasia. Paper presented at the meeting of the International Neuropsychological Society, Santa Fe, New Mexico, February, 1977.
Schwartz M. F., Saffran E. M., & Marin O. S. M. The word order problem in agrammatism: I. Comprehension. Brain and Language, in press.
Shallice T., & Warrington E. K.Word recognition in a phonemic dyslexie patient. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology, 1975, 27, 187–99.
Shewan C. M.Error pattern in auditory comprehension of adult aphasics. Cortex, 1976, 12, 325–36.
Shewan C. M., & Canter C. J.Effects of vocabulary, syntax, and sentence length on auditory comprehension in aphasic patients. Cortex, 1971, 7, 209–26.
Smith M. D.On the understanding of some relational words in aphasia. Neuropsychologia, 1974, 12, 377–84.
vonStockert T. R.Recognition of syntactic structure in aphasic patients. Cortex, 1972, 8, 323–34.
vonStockert T. R., & Bader L.Some relations of grammar and lexicon in aphasia. Cortex, 1976, 12, 4960.
Weigl E., & Bierwisch M.Neuropsychology and linguistics: Topics of common research. Foundations of Language, 1970, 6, 130.
Weisenberg T., & McBride K.Aphasia. New York: Commonwealth Fund, 1935.
Wepman J. M., & Jones L. V. Five aphasias. In Disorders of Communication, Research Publications of the Association for Research on Nervous and Mental Diseases, 1964.
Wernicke C.Der aphasische symptomencomplex. Breslau: Cohn and Weigert, 1874. Reprinted and translated in Boston studies in the philosophy of science, Vol 4. Dordrecht, Holland: D. Reidel.
Whitaker H. A.Unsolicited nominalizations by aphasics: The plausibility of the Lexicalist model. Linguislics, 1972, 78, 6271.
Whitaker H. A.Linguistic competence: Evidence from aphasia. Glossa, 1970, 4(1), 4654.
Whitaker H. A., & Selnes O. A.Broca's area: A problem in language-brain relationships. Linguistics, 1975, 154/155, 91103.
Zurif E., & Blumstein S. Language and the brain. In Halle M., Bresnan J., and Miller G. (Eds.), Linguistic theory and psychological reality. Cambridge, Massachusetts: MIT Press, 1978.
Zurif E. B., & Caramazza A. Psycholinguistic structures in aphasia: Studies in syntax and semantics. In Whitaker H. and Whitaker H. A. (Eds.), Studies in neurolinguistics. Vol. 1. New York: Academic Press, 1976.
Zurif E. B., Caramazza A., & Myerson R.Grammatical judgments of agrammatic aphasics. Neuropsychologia, 1972, 10, 405–17.
Zurif E. B., Green E., Caramazza A., & Goodenough C.Grammatical intuitions of aphasic patients: Sensitivity to functors. Cortex, 1976, 12, 183–6.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Applied Psycholinguistics
  • ISSN: 0142-7164
  • EISSN: 1469-1817
  • URL: /core/journals/applied-psycholinguistics
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *


Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 267 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 1753 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 18th November 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.