Skip to main content
×
×
Home

The Construction of Meanings in Museums

  • Elizabeth Crooke
Extract

The museum is a construct; the collections and the physical building are enclosed by a structure, invisible to the eye, which is created by the context in which the museum is being viewed. The nature of that structure will depend on the viewer; he or she will make his or her own meanings. Reinhard Bernbeck, in his paper The exhibition of architecture and the architecture of an exhibition, has investigated how the Pergamon Museum can simultaneously mean different things to different people, according to their cultural perspective. What is at the core of this is the political and social nature of museums, and one of the most dominant aspects of this is the demonstration of power. This determines how the museum collects, interprets and displays both the objects and itself, and is related to both Bernbeck's colonial and postmodern readings of the museum, as well has his discussion of ‘pragmatist’ and ‘purist’ approaches to museums in general. Though his paper is based on a case study of the Pergamon Museum in Berlin, the issues he raised are applicable to museums elsewhere. In this response to his paper, I am going to look at what this demonstration of power reflects about what museums mean and how they function and relate Bernbeck's evaluation to museum development I am most familiar with, that in Ireland.

Copyright
References
Hide All
Agger, B., 1992: The discourse of domination. From the Frankfurt school to postmodernism, Evanston.
Anderson, P., 1998: The origins of postmodernity, London.
Andrae, W., 1934: Die neuen Säle für altorientalische Kunst im Vorderasiatischen Museum, Berliner Museen. Berichte aus den Preussischen Kunstsammlungen 55(31), 4656.
Andrae, E.W. and Boehmer, R.M., 1992: Walter Andrae, 18.2.1875 – 28.7.1956, in Andrae, E.W. and Boehmer, R.M. (eds), Bilder eines Ausgräbers. Sketches by an excavator. Walter Andrae im Orient 1898 – 1919, Berlin, 109148.
Apel, K.-O., 1995: Anderssein, ein Menschenrecht? Über die Vereinbarkeit universaler Normen mit kultureller und ethnischer Vielfalt, in Hoffmann, H. and Kramer, D. (eds), Anderssein, ein Menschenrecht, Weinheim, 920.
Appadurai, A. and Breckenridge, C.A., 1992: Museums are good to think: heritage on view in India, in Karp, I., Kreamer, C.M. and Lavine, S.D. (eds), Museums and communities. The politics of public culture, Washington D.C., 3455.
Arnold, B. and Hassmann, H., 1995: Archaeology in Nazi Germany: the legacy of the Faustian bargain, in Kohl, P.L. and Fawcett, C. (eds), Nationalism, politics, and the practice of archaeology, Cambridge, 7081.
Babich, B.E., 1994: On malls, museums, and the art world: postmodernism and the vicissitudes of consumer culture, Art criticism 9(1), 93109.
Bal, M., 1992: Telling, showing, showing off, Critical inquiry 18, 556594.
Barringer, T., 1998: The South Kensington Museum and the colonial project, in Barringer, T. and Flynn, T. (eds), Colonialism and the object. Empire, material culture and the museum, London, 1127.
Barthes, R., 1977: Image/music/text, London.
Baudrillard, J., 1983: Simulations, New York.
Beard, M. and Henderson, J., 1994: ‘Please don't touch the ceiling’. The culture of appropriation, in Pearce, S. (ed.), Museums and the appropriation of culture, London, 542.
Becker, P. von, 2000: ‘Leitkultur’, ‘Fremde’, ‘Zuwanderer’: wenn die Politik Phantasmen spinnt, Tagesspiegel November 11, 2000.
Benjamin, W., 1968: The work of art in the age of mechanical reproduction, in Arendt, H. (ed.), Illuminations. Essays and reflections, New York, 217252.
Bernau, N., 2000: Kein Pop auf der Insel. Die Ergebnisse des Wettbewerbs für das Pergamonmuseum, Berliner Zeitung 26.5.2000.
Bernau, N., n.d.: Das Pergamonmuseum in Berlin. Der Gründungsbau des wilhelminischen Neuklassizimus in der Debatte um Nationalstil und Nationalmuseum. Dissertation in progress, Technische Universität Berlin.
Bernbeck, R. and Lamprichs, R., 1992: Museen, Besitz und Macht: wohin mit den Altertümern?, Das Altertum 38(2), 109124.
Best, S. and Kellner, D., 1991: Postmodern theory: critical interrogations, New York.
Bhatt, C., 2000: Primordial being. Enlightenment, Schopenhauer and the Indian subject in postcolonial theory, Radical philosophy 100, 2841.
Blattberg, R.C. and Broderick, C.J., 1991: Marketing of art museums, in Feldstein, M. (ed.), The economics of art museums, Chicago, 327346.
Bode, W. von, 1997: Mein Leben (edited by Gaehtgens, T.W. and Paul, B.), Berlin.
Boswell, D. and Evans, J.(eds), 1999: Representing the nation: a reader. Histories, heritage and museums, London.
Bourdieu, P., 1984: Distinction. A social critique of the judgement of taste, Cambridge (Mass.).
Bourdieu, P. and Darbel, A., 1990: The love of art. European art museums and their public, Stanford.
Brands, G., 1990: Zwischen Island und Athen. Griechische Kunst im Spiegel des Nationalsozialismus, in Brock, B. and Preiß, A. (eds), Kunst auf Befehl? Dreiunddreiβig bis Fünfundvierzig, München, 103136.
Brecht, B., 1971: Über Realismus, Frankfurt am Main (first edition 1939).
Buhr, M. and Kosing, A., 1974: Kleines Wörterbuch der marxistisch-leninistischen Philosophie, Berlin.
Bunch, L.G., 1995: Fighting the good fight. Museums in an age of uncertainty, Museum news March/April 1995, 32–35; 58–61.
Butler, E.M., 1958: The tyranny of Greece over Germany, Boston.
Caspar, H. and Krähe, H., 1995: Museumsinsel – ein ernster Pflegefall, Berliner Zeitung 12.5.1995.
Clifford, J., 1985: Objects and selves – an afterword, in Stocking, G.W., Objects and others. Essays on museums and material culture, Madison, 236246.
Cohn, B.S., 1996: Colonialism and its forms of knowledge. The British in India, Princeton.
Corrin, L.G. (ed.), 1994: Mining the museum: an installation, New York.
Crooke, E.M., 2000: Politics, archaeology and the creation of the National Museum in Ireland. An expression of national life, Dublin.
Crüsemann, N., 2000: Vom Zweistromland zum Kupfergraben. Vorgeschichte und Entstehungsjahre (1899–1918) der Vorderasiatischen Abteilung der Berliner Museen vor fach- und kulturpolitischen Hintergründen, Berlin.
Daniels, S. and Cosgrove, D., 1988: Introduction: iconography and landscape, in Cosgrove, D. and Daniels, S. (eds), The iconography of landscape, Cambridge, 110.
Davies, M. and Vergo, P., 1989: Musing anew. Interview with Peter Vergo, Museums journal 89, 2022.
Davis, W.M., 1979: Plato on Egyptian art, Journal of Egyptian archaeology 65, 121127.
Derrida, J., 1983: Margins of philosophy, London.
Duncan, C., 1991: Art museums and the ritual of citizenship, in Karp, I. and Lavine, S.D. (eds), Exhibiting cultures. The poetics and politics of museum display, Washington, 88103.
Duncan, C., 1995: Civilizing rituals. Inside public art museums, London.
Durrans, B., 1988: The future of the other: changing cultures on display in ethnographic museums, in Lumley, R. (ed.), The museum time machine, London, 144169.
Eco, U., 1986: Travels in hyperreality, San Diego.
Elsner, J., 1996: The ‘New Museology’ and Classical art, American journal of archaeology 100, 769773.
Engelhardt, T., 1997: Plugging culture, The nation September 8/15, 2729.
Ernst, W., 1988: Entstellung der Historie? Museale Spuren(t)sicherung zwischen déja vu und Wahrnehmungsschock, in Rüsen, J., Ernst, W. and Grüttner, H.T. (eds), Geschichte sehen. Beiträge zur Ästhetik historischer Museen, Pfaffenweiler, 2134.
Ernst, W., 1992/1993: Museale Räume im nachliberalistischen Zeitalter: Nationalsozialismus, Klassizismus, Antike(n), Hephaistos 11/12, 187205.
Evans, H.C. and Wixon, W.D. (eds), 1997: The glory of Byzantium. Art and culture of the Middle Byzantine era, AD 843–1261. Catalog of the exhibition, New York.
Fehr, M., 1988: Aufklärung oder Verklärung, in Rüsen, J., Ernst, W. and Grüttner, H.T. (eds), Geschichte sehen. Beiträge zur Ästhetik historischer Museen, Pfaffenweiler, 110123.
Fischer, F., 1961: Griff nach der Weltmacht. Die Kriegszielpolitik des Kaiserlichen Deutschland 1914 – 1918, Düsseldorf.
Foucault, M., 1966: Les mots et les choses, Paris.
Foucault, M., 1974: The archaeology of knowledge, London.
Gable, E. and Handler, R., 1996: After authenticity at an American heritage site, American anthropologist 98, 568596.
Gaehtgens, T.W., 1992: Die Berliner Museumsinsel im Deutschen Kaiserreich, München.
Gaehtgens, T.W., 1996: The museum island in Berlin, in Wright, G. (ed.), The formation of national collections of art and archaeology, Washington D.C., 5377
Gaillemin, J.-L. and Gaehtgens, T.W., 1997: Les musées de Berlin, Connaissance des arts 535, 96109.
George, A.S., Hayward, J., Quinn, S., Rice, D., Sims, J.E. and Spock, M., 1990: Context and commitment. A round table discussion, Museum news September/October, 6670.
Glasmeier, M., 1992: Vorwort, in Glasmeier, M. (ed.), Periphere Museen in Berlin, Berlin, 712.
Gordon, J., 1996: Museum fiction, Art history 19, 150155.
Greenhalgh, P., 1989: Education, entertainment and politics: lessons from the great international exhibitions, in Vergo, P. (ed.), The new museology, London, 7498.
Haraway, D., 1984: Teddy Bear patriarchy: taxidermy in the garden of Eden, New York City, 1908–1936, Social text 11, 19–64. (Revised version in Haraway, D., Primate visions, 1989, London, 2658).
Harris, N., 1990: Polling for opinions, Museum news September/October, 4653.
Harvey, D., 1989: The condition of postmodernity, Cambridge (Mass).
Heilmeyer, W.-D., 1997: Aufstellungsgeschichte im 20. Jahrhundert. Die Aufstellungen von 1901, 1930 und 1959, in Heilmeyer, W.-D. (ed.), Der Pergamonaltar. Die neue Präsentation nach Restaurierung des Telephosfrieses, Berlin, 1723.
Hein, G.E., 1998: Learning in the museum, London.
Hobsbawm, E., 1964: The age of revolution, 1789–1848, New York.
Hobsbawm, E., 1992: Nations and nationalism since 1780. Program, myth, reality, Cambridge.
Hoepfner, W., 1997: Modell des Pergamonaltars im Maßstab 1:20, in Heilmeyer, W.D. (ed.) Der Pergamonaltar. Die neue Präsentation nach Restaurierung des Telephosfrieses, Berlin, 171176.
Hoffmann, D., 1988: Künstler und Wissenschaftler als Produzenten kulturhistorischer Ausstellungen? in Rüsen, J., Ernst, W. and Grüttner, H.T. (eds), Geschichte sehen. Beiträge zur Ästhetik historischer Museen, Pfaffenweiler, 137144.
Holtorf, C., 1995: ‘Problem oriented’ and ‘object oriented’ approaches to archaeological research – reconsidered, Hephaistos 13, 718.
Hooper-Greenhill, E., 1988: Counting visitors or visitors who count? in Lumley, R. (ed.), The museum time machine. Putting cultures on display, London, 213232.
Horkheimer, M. and Adorno, T.W., 1969: Dialektik der Aufklärung, Frankfurt a.M.
Hudson, K., 1998: The museum refuses to stand still, Museum international 197, 4350.
Jakob-Rost, L., Klengel-Brandt, E., Marzahn, J. and Wartke, R.-B., 1990: Vorderasiatisches Museum, Antike Welt 1990, special issue, 4069.
Jakob-Rost, L., Klengel-Brandt, E., Marzahn, J. and Wartke, R.-B., 1992: Das Vorderasiatische Museum Berlin, Mainz.
Jameson, F., 1991: Postmodernism, or the cultural logic of late capitalism, London.
Jencks, C., 1997: The contemporary museum, Architectural design 67, 913.
Jordanova, L., 1989: Objects of knowledge: A historical perspective on museums, in Vergo, P. (ed.), The new museology, London, 2240.
Kästner, U., 1997: Ausgrabung und Zusammensetzung, in Heilmeyer, W.-D. (ed.), Der Pergamonaltar. Die neue Präsentation nach Restaurierung des Telephosfrieses, Berlin, 916.
Karp, I., 1992: On civil society and social identity, in Karp, I., Kreamer, C.M. and Lavine, S.D. (eds), Museums and communities. The politics of public culture, Washington D.C., 1933.
Karp, I., Kreamer, C.M. and Lavine, S.D. (eds), 1992: Museums and communities. The politics of public culture, Washington D.C.
Kearney, R., 1988: The wake of imagination, Minneapolis.
King, M.J., 1990: Theme park thesis, Museum news September/October, 6062.
Klemm, G., 1963 [1843]: Fantasie über ein Museum für die Kulturgeschichte der Menschheit, in Schmitz, C.A. (ed.), Kultur, Frankfurt a.M., 516.
Koldewey, R., 1990: Das wiedererstehende Babylon, new enlarged edition, Hrouda, B., München.
Kopytoff, I., 1986: The cultural biography of things: commoditization as process, in Appadurai, A. (ed.), The social life of things. Commodities in cultural perspective, Cambridge, 6491.
Koshar, R., 2000: From monuments to traces. Artifacts of German memory, 1870–1990, Berkeley.
Kunze, M., 1990: Antikensammlung, Antike Welt 1990, special issue, 70105.
Kunze, M., 1992: Die Antikensammlung im Pergamonmuseum – Geschichte der Ausstellungen, Erwerbungen und Ausgrabungen, in Kunze, M. (ed.), Die Antikensammlung, Mainz, 920.
Larsen, M.T., 1994: The conquest of Assyria, London.
Landfester, M., 1996: Griechen und Deutsche: der Mythos einer ‘Wahlverwandtschaft’, in Berding, H. (ed.), Mythos und Nation. Studien zur Entwicklung des kollektiven Bewuβtseins in der Neuzeit, Frankfuurt a.M., 198219.
Le Roy Ladurie, E., 1975: Montaillou, village occitan de 1294 à 1324, Paris.
Leon, W., 1989: The Margaret Woodbury Strong museum: a review, American quarterly 41, 526542.
Lubar, S., 1997: Exhibiting memories, in Henderson, A. and Kaeppler, A. (eds), Exhibiting dilemmas. Issues of representation at the Smithsonian, Washington D.C., 1527.
Lovatt, J.R., 1997: The people's show festival 1994: a survey, in Pearce, S.M. (ed.), Experiencing material culture in the western world, London, 196221.
Lyotard, F., 1984: The postmodern condition. A report on knowledge, Manchester.
MacCannell, D., 1999: The tourist. A new theory of the leisure class, Berkeley.
Macdonald, S., 1998a: Exhibitions of power and powers of exhibition: an introduction to the politics of display, in Macdonald, S. (ed.), The politics of display. Museums, science, culture, London, 124.
Macdonald, S., 1998b: Supermarket science? Consumers and ‘the public understanding of science’, in Macdonald, S. (ed.), The politics of display. Museums, science, culture, London, 118138.
Maleuvre, D., 1999: Museum memories. History, technology, art, Stanford.
Malraux, A., 1967: Museum without walls, Garden City (NY) (first edition 1947).
Marchand, S.L., 1996: Down from Olympus. Archaeology and philhellenism in Germany, 1750 – 1970, Princeton.
Marchand, S. and Grafton, A., 1997: Martin Bernal and his critics, Arion 5.2, 135.
Marcuse, H., 1937: Über den affirmativen Charakter der Kultur, Zeitschrift für Sozialforschung 6, 5494.
Martin, J.-H., 1995: The ‘Musée Sentimental’ of Daniel Spoerri, in Cooke, L. and Wollen, P. (eds), Visual display. Culture beyond appearances, New York, 5467.
Marx, K., 1974: Einleitung zur Kritik der politischen Ökonomie, Marx-Engels-Werke, 13, 613644, Berlin.
Marx, K. and F., Engels, 1965: The German ideology, London.
Marzahn, J., 1992a: Geschichte des Vorderasiatischen Museums und kurzer Überblick über die Ausgrabungstätigkeit, in Staatliche Museen zu Berlin (ed.), Das Vorderasiatische Museum Berlin, Mainz, 1118.
Marzahn, J., 1992b: Babylonien, in Staatliche Museen zu Berlin (ed.), Das Vorderasiatische Museum Berlin, Mainz, 95141.
Marzahn, J., 1992c: Assyrien, in Staatliche Museen zu Berlin (ed.), Das Vorderasiatische Museum Berlin, Mainz, 142194.
Massow, W. von, 1936: Führer durch das Pergamonmuseum, Berlin.
Mayrand, P., 1985: The new museology proclaimed, Museum 37, 200201.
McTavish, L., 1998: Shopping in the museum? Consumer spaces and the redefinition of the Louvre, Cultural studies 12, 168192.
Melhuish, C., 1997: The museum as a mirror of society, Architectural design 67 (11/12), 2225.
Merriman, N., 1989: Museum visiting as a cultural phenomenon, in Vergo, P. (ed.), The new museology, London, 149171.
Meyer, G.R., 1956: Durch vier Jahrtausende altvorderasiatischer Kultur. Vorderasiatisches Museum, Berlin.
Meyer, G.R., 1958: Schätze der Weltkultur von der Sowjetunion gerettet, Berlin.
Mohr, R., 2000: Operation Sauerbraten, Der Spiegel 45/2000, November 6.
Morris, M., 1988: Banality in cultural studies, Discourse 10 (2), 329.
Mönninger, M., 1999: Museums-Mall, Berliner Zeitung 7.6.1999.
Mönninger, M., 2000: Pergamon-Hof ohne Dach. Der letzte Wettbewerb auf der Museumsinsel ist entschieden, Berliner Zeitung 25.5.2000.
Mönninger, M. and Preuss, S., 1999: Ende eines Kulturkampfes. Und sie bewegt sich doch: die Preußen-Stiftung hat einen neuen Masterplan samt Generaldirektor, Berliner Zeitung 5.6.1999.
Monroe, D.L., 1995: Federal funding of museums: the reality, Museum news November/December, 5051.
Munslow, A., 1997: Deconstructing history, London.
Müller, M., 1992: Kunstgeschichte zwischen affirmativer Kultur und Kulturindustrie, in Berndt, A., Kaiser, P., Rosenberg, A. and Trinkner, D. (eds), Frankfurter Schule und Kunstgeschichte, Berlin, 141164.
Nipperdey, T., 1993: Deutsche Geschichte 1866–1918. Band I. Arbeitswelt und Bürgergeist, München.
Oberholtzer, C., 2000: Exhibit review essay. ‘First peoples, first contacts: tangible records’, American anthropologist 102(1), 139146.
Paolozzi, E., 1985: Lost magic kingdoms, London.
Pearce, S.M., 1986: Objects as signs and symbols, Museums journal 86, 131135.
Pearce, S.M., 1991: Objects in structures, in Pearce, S.M. (ed.), Museum studies in material culture, Washington D.C., 4760.
Pearce, S.M., 1994: Objects as meaning; or narrating the past, in Pearce, S.M. (ed.), Interpreting objects and collections, London, 1929.
Posner, R., 1991: Kultur als Zeichensystem. Zur semiotischen Explikation kulturwissenschaftlicher Grundbegriffe, in Assmann, A. and Harth, D. (eds), Kultur als Lebenswelt und Monument, Frankfurt a.M., 3774.
Prakash, G., 1999: Another reason. Science and the imagination of modern India, Princeton.
Putz, U., 1999: Schleichwege ins Wäschemuseum, Berliner Zeitung 30.8.1999.
Rabinow, P., 1984: Introduction, in Rabinow, P. (ed.), The Foucault reader, New York, 329.
Roberts, L.C., 1997: From knowledge to narrative. Educators and the changing museum, Washington D.C.
Rorty, R., 1989: Contingency, irony, and solidarity, Cambridge.
Rosenberg, P. and Galard, J., 2000: The irresistible rise of the museum. Onward and upward or the end of the road? Apollo January, 3034.
Rüsen, J., 1988: Für eine Didaktik historischer Museen, in Rüsen, J., Ernst, W. and Grüttner, H.T. (eds), Geschichte sehen. Beiträge zur Ästhetik historischer Museen, Pfaffenweiler, 920.
Schalles, H.J., 1986: Der Pergamonaltar zwischen Bewertung und Verwertbarkeit, Frankfurt a.M.
Scheffler, K., 1921: Berliner Museumskrieg, Berlin.
Schiering, W., 1969: Zur Geschichte der Archäologie, in Hausmann, U. (ed.), Allgemeine Grundlagen der Archäologie, München, 11162.
Schmidt, B., 1994: Postmoderne – Strategien des Vergessens, Frankfurt a.M.
Schudson, M., 1997: Paper tigers. A sociologist follows cultural studies into the wilderness, Lingua franca August 1997, 4956.
Shanks, M. and Tilley, C., 1987: Re-constructing archaeology. Theory and practice, London.
Shelton, A., 1992: The recontextualization of culture: in UK museums, Anthropology today 8(5), 1116.
Sherman, D.J., 1990: Museums and their discontents, Art history 13, 409414.
Silver, J., 1988: ‘Astonished and somewhat terrified’: the preservation and development of aural culture, in Lumley, R. (ed.), The museum time machine. Putting cultures on display, London, 170196.
Sorensen, C., 1989: Theme parks and time machines, in Vergo, P. (ed.), The new museology, London, 6073.
Terrell, J., 1991: Disneyland and the future of museum anthropology, American anthropologist 93, 149153.
Trouillot, M.-R., 1995: Silencing the past. Power and the production of history, Boston.
Truettner, W.H., 1997: For museum audiences: the ‘morning of a new day’?, in Henderson, A. and Kaeppler, A. (eds), Exhibiting dilemmas. Issues of representation at the Smithsonian, Washington D.C., 2846.
Vestner, H., 1989: Berlin. Insight city guides, Singapore.
Vogel, S., 1991: Always true to the object, in our fashion, in Karp, I. and Lavine, S.D. (eds), Exhibiting cultures. The poetics and politics of museum display, Washington D.C., 191204.
Walsh, K., 1992: The representation of the past. Museums and heritage in the post-modern world, London.
Weber, A., 1990: ‘Wir verkaufen den Leuten Träume’. Das Écomusée d'Alsace zwischen Kultur und Konsum, Geschichtswerkstatt 21, 914.
Wehler, H.U., 1988: Das deutsche Kaiserreich 1871–1918, Göttingen.
Weil, S.E., 1995: A cabinet of curiosities. Inquiries into museums and their prospects, Washington D.C.
Weiss, P., 1983: Die Ästhetik des Widerstands, Frankfurt a.M.
West, B., 1988: The making of the English working past: a critical view of the Ironbridge Gorge museum, in Lumley, R. (ed.), The museum time machine, London, 3662.
White, H., 1978: Tropics of discourse. Essays in cultural criticism, Baltimore.
Wittlin, A.S., 1970: Museums in search of a useable future,Cambridge (Mass.).
Wolf, E., 1982: Europe and the people without history, Berkeley.
Wright, P., 1989: The quality of visitor's experiences in art museums, in Vergo, P. (ed.), The new museology, London, 119148.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Archaeological Dialogues
  • ISSN: 1380-2038
  • EISSN: 1478-2294
  • URL: /core/journals/archaeological-dialogues
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Metrics

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 64 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 220 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 13th June 2018. This data will be updated every 24 hours.