Skip to main content Accessibility help

A second-person neuroscience in interaction 1

  • Leonhard Schilbach (a1), Bert Timmermans (a2), Vasudevi Reddy (a3), Alan Costall (a3), Gary Bente (a4), Tobias Schlicht (a5) and Kai Vogeley (a1) (a6)...


In this response we address additions to as well as criticisms and possible misinterpretations of our proposal for a second-person neuroscience. We map out the most crucial aspects of our approach by (1) acknowledging that second-person engaged interaction is not the only way to understand others, although we claim that it is ontogenetically prior; (2) claiming that spectatorial paradigms need to be complemented in order to enable a full understanding of social interactions; and (3) restating that our theoretical proposal not only questions the mechanism by which a cognitive process comes into being, but asks whether it is at all meaningful to speak of a mechanism and a cognitive process when it is confined to intra-agent space. We address theoretical criticisms of our approach by pointing out that while a second-person social understanding may not be the only mechanism, alternative approaches cannot hold their ground without resorting to second-person concepts, if not in the expression, certainly in the development of social understanding. In this context, we also address issues of agency and intentionality, theoretical alternatives, and clinical implications of our approach.



Hide All

Authors Leonhard Schilbach and Bert Timmermans have contributed equally to this Response article.



Hide All
Adams, F. & Aizawa, K. (2008) The bounds of cognition. Wiley Blackwell.
Bargh, J. A. & Earp, B. D. (2009) The will is caused, not free. Dialogue – Newsletter of the Society of Personality and Social Psychology 24(1):1315.
Barisic, I, Timmermans, B, Pfeiffer, UJ, Bente, G, Vogeley, K & Schilbach, L (2013). In it together: Using dual eyetracking to investigate real-time social interactions. In: Proceedings of the SIGCHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems, April 27 through May 2, 2013, Paris, France. Association for Computing Machinery. Available at:
Becchio, C., Cavallo, A., Begliomini, C., Sartori, L., Feltrin, G. & Castiello, U. (2012) Social grasping: From mirroring to mentalizing. Neuroimage 61(1):240–48.
Bente, G., Eschenburg, F. & Krämer, N. C. (2007b) Virtual gaze: A pilot study on the effects of computer simulated gaze in avatar-based conversations. Lecture Notes in Computer Science 4563:185–94. Available at:
Bente, G., Rüggenberg, S., Krämer, N. C. & Eschenburg, F. (2008b) Avatar-mediated networking: Increasing social presence and interpersonal trust in net-based collaborations. Human Communication Research 34(2):287318. Available at:
Brentano, F. (1874/1973) Psychology from an empirical standpoint, trans. Rancurello, A. C., Terrell, D. B. & McAlister, L. L.. Routledge. (Original work published in 1874).
Bruner, J. (1964) The course of cognitive growth. American Psychologist 19(1):115.
Buccino, G., Lui, F., Canessa, N., Patteri, I., Lagravinese, G., Benuzzi, F., Porro, C. A. & Rizzolatti, G. (2004) Neural circuits involved in the recognition of actions performed by non-conspecifics: An fMRI study. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 16:114–26.
Chakrabarti, B. & Baron-Cohen, S. (2011) Variation in the human Cannabinoid Receptor (CNR1) gene modulates gaze duration for happy faces. Molecular Autism 2(1):10. Available at:
Chemero, A. (2009) Radical embodied cognitive science. MIT Press.
Clark, A. (2001) Mindware. Oxford University Press.
Clark, A. (2013) Whatever next? Predictive brains, situated agents, and the future of cognitive science. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 36(3):181253.
Clark, A. & Chalmers, D. J. (1998) The extended mind. Analysis 58(1):719.
Conty, L., Dezecache, G., Hugueville, L. & Grèzes, J. (2012) Early binding of gaze, gesture, and emotion: Neural time course and correlates. The Journal of Neuroscience 32(13):4531–39. doi:10.1523/JNEUROSCI.5636-11.2012.
Custers, R. & Aarts, H. (2010) The unconscious will: How the pursuit of goals operates outside of conscious awareness. Science 329:4750.
De Bruin, L. C. & Gallagher, S. (2012) Embodied simulation: An unproductive explanation. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 16:9899.
De Jaegher, H., Di Paolo, E. & Gallagher, S. (2010) Can social interaction constitute social cognition? Trends in Cognitive Sciences 14(10):441–47. Available at:
Doyen, S., Klein, O., Pichon, C.-L. & Cleeremans, A. (2012) Behavioral priming: It's all in the mind, but whose mind? PLoS ONE 7(1):e29081. Available at:
Engemann, D. A., Bzdok, D., Eickhoff, S. B., Vogeley, K. & Schilbach, L. (2012) Games people play – toward an enactive view of cooperation in social neuroscience. Frontiers in Human Neuroscience 6:148. Epub June 1, 2012.
Friston, K. (2010) The free energy principle: A unified brain theory? Nature Reviews Neuroscience 11:127–38.
Frith, C. D. (2007) Making up the mind. Blackwell.
Frith, C. D. (2012b) The role of metacognition in human social interactions. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, B: Biological Sciences 367(1599):2213–-23.
Gallagher, S. (2001) The practice of mind: Theory, simulation, or interaction? Journal of Consciousness Studies 8(5–7):83108. Available at:
Gallagher, S. (2007) Simulation trouble. Social Neuroscience 2(3–4):353–65. Available at:
Gallagher, S. (2008) Direct perception in the intersubjective context. Consciousness and Cognition 17(2):535–43. Available at:
Gallese, V. & Sinigaglia, C. (2011) What is so special about embodied simulation? Trends in Cognitive Sciences 15(11):512–19 Available at:
Gazzola, V., van, der Worp, H., Mulder, T., Wicker, B., Rizzolatti, G. & Keysers, C. (2007) Aplasics born without hands mirror the goal of hand actions with their feet. Current Biology 17:1235–40.
Gintis, H. (2009) The bounds of reason: Game theory and the unification of the behavioral sciences. Princeton University Press.
Goldman, A. (2006) Simulating minds. The philosophy, psychology, and neuroscience of mindreading. Oxford University Press.
Haggard, P. (2008) Human volition: Towards a neuroscience of will. Nature Reviews Neuroscience 9:934–46.
Hein, G., Silani, G., Preuschoff, K., Batson, C. D. & Singer, T. (2010) Neural responses to ingroup and outgroup members' suffering predict individual differences in costly helping. Neuron 68:149–60.
Hohwy, J. (2012) Attention and conscious perception in the hypothesis testing brain. Frontiers in Psychology 3:96. Available at:
Hutto, D. D. (2008) Folk-psychological narratives. The sociocultural basis of understanding reasons. MIT Press.
Hutto, D. D. & Myin, E. (2013) Radicalizing enactivism: Basic minds without content. MIT Press.
Kitayama, S., Snibbe, A. C., Markus, H. R. & Suzuki, T. (2004) Is there any “free” choice? Self and dissonance in two cultures. Psychological Science 15:527–33.
Kuzmanovic, B., Georgescu, A., Eickhoff, S., Shah, N., Bente, G., Fink, G. R. & Vogeley, K. (2009) Duration matters. Dissociating neural correlates of detection and evaluation of social gaze. NeuroImage 46:1154–63.
Libet, B. (1985) Unconscious cerebral initiative and the role of conscious will in voluntary action. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 8:529–66.
Marsh, L. E. & Hamilton, A. F. (2011) Dissociation of mirroring and mentalising systems in autism. NeuroImage 56(3):1511–19.
McGeer, V. (2001) Psycho-practice, psycho-theory and the contrastive case of autism. How practices of mind become second-nature. Journal of Consciousness Studies 8(5–7):109–32.
Menary, R. (2010) The extended mind. MIT Press.
Merleau-Ponty, M. (1958) Phenomenology of perception. Routledge and Kegan Paul.
Nation, K. & Penny, S. (2008) Sensitivity to eye gaze in autism: Is it normal? Is it automatic? Is it social? Development and Psychopathology 20(1):7997.
Newen, A. & Schlicht, T. (2009) Understanding other minds: A criticism of Goldman's Simulation Theory and an outline of the Person Model Theory. Grazer Philosophische Studien 79(1):209–42.
Niedenthal, P. M., Mermillod, M., Maringer, M. & Hess, U. (2010) The Simulation of Smiles (SIMS) model: Embodied simulation and the meaning of facial expression. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 33(6):417–33; discussion 433–80. Available at:
Olsson, A., Ebert, J. P., Banaji, M. R. & Phelps, E. A. (2005) The role of social groups in the persistence of learned fear. Science 309:785–87.
Pfeiffer, U. J., Timmermans, B., Bente, G., Vogeley, K. & Schilbach, L. (2011) The non-verbal Turing test: Differentiating mind from machine in gaze-based social interaction. PLoS ONE 6(11):e27591. Available at:
Redcay, E., Dodell-Feder, D., Mavros, P. L., Kleiner, M., Pearrow, M. J., Triantafyllou, C., Gabrieli, J. D. & Saxe, R. (2012) Atypical brain activation patterns during a face-to-face joint attention game in adults with autism spectrum disorder. Human Brain Mapping. doi:10.1002/hbm.22086. [Epub ahead of print].
Santos, N. S., Kuzmanovic, B., David, N., Rotarska-Jagiela, A., Eickhoff, S. B., Shah, J. N., Fink, G. R., Bente, G. & Vogeley, K. (2010) Animated brain: A functional neuroimaging study on the parametric induction of animacy experience. NeuroImage 53(1):291302. Available at:
Schilbach, L. (2010) A second-person approach to other minds. Nature Reviews Neuroscience 11(6):449.
Schilbach, L., Wilms, M., Eickhoff, S. B., Romanzetti, S., Tepest, R., Bente, G., Shah, N. J., Fink, G. R. & Vogeley, K. (2010b) Minds made for sharing: Initiating joint attention recruits reward-related neurocircuitry. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 22(12):2702–15. Available at:
Schlicht, T. (forthcoming) Mittendrin statt nur dabei. In: Grenzen der Empathie, ed. Breyer, T.. Alber.
Searle, J. (1990) Collective intentions and actions. In: Intentions in communication, ed. Cohen, P., Morgan, J. & Pollack, M. E., pp. 401–15. Bradford Books/MIT Press.
Sinigaglia, C. (2008) Enactive understanding and motor intentionality. In: Enacting intersubjectivity: A cognitive and social perspective to the study of interactions, ed. Morganti, F., Carassa, A. & Riva, G., pp. 1732. IOS Press.
Soon, C. S., Brass, M., Heinze, H. & Haynes, J. (2008) Unconscious determinants of free decisions in the human brain. Nature Neuroscience 11(5):543–45.
Thompson, E. (2007) Mind in life: Biology, phenomenology, and the sciences of mind. Harvard University Press.
Varela, F., Thompson, E. & Rosch, E. (1991) The embodied mind: Cognitive science and human experience. MIT Press.
Vogeley, K. & Bartels, A. (2011) The explanatory value of representations in cognitive neuroscience. In: Knowledge and representation, ed. Newen, A., Bartels, A. & Jung, E. M., pp. 163–84. Stanford & Mentis Verlag
Vogeley, K. & Newen, A. (2009) Consciousness of oneself and others in relation to mental disorders. In: The neuropsychology of mental illness, ed. Wood, S., Allen, N. & Pantelis, C. (Hrsg.). Cambridge University Press.
Wang, Y., Ramsey, R. & Hamilton, A. F. de C. (2011) The control of mimicry by eye contact is mediated by medial prefrontal cortex. The Journal of Neuroscience 31(33):12001–10. Available at:
Wheeler, M. (2005) Reconstructing the cognitive world: The next step. MIT Press.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Behavioral and Brain Sciences
  • ISSN: 0140-525X
  • EISSN: 1469-1825
  • URL: /core/journals/behavioral-and-brain-sciences
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *


Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed