Skip to main content

The Retreat of the Interventionist State in Advanced Democracies

  • Reimut Zohlnhöfer, Fabian Engler and Kathrin Dümig

Why have advanced democracies experienced a retreat of the interventionist state since 1980? This article provides evidence that in all relevant policy indicators (spending, subsidies, state-owned enterprises, regulation, capital taxation) government intervention has been scaled back across the OECD. An overview of the results of 130 quantitative studies analysing at least one of these indicators is provided. Focusing on five main explanatory variables – globalization, Europeanization, learning and emulation, socio-economic problems, and political parties – only limited agreement in the literature is found. The reasons for this disagreement are discussed. Ways forward are suggested for the theoretical models on which studies are based, how the dependent variable is chosen, the empirical approaches that may be applied, and how quantitative research and comparative case studies may be combined.

Hide All

Institute of Political Science, Heidelberg University, Germany (email:; Institute of Political Science, Heidelberg University, Germany (email:; Ministry of Economic Affairs, Lower Saxony, Germany (email: Online appendices are available at 10.1017/S0007123416000454.

Hide All
Adam, Antonis, and Kammas, Pantelis. 2007. Tax Policies in a Globalized World: Is It Politics after All? Public Choice 133:321341.
Adam, Antonis, Kammas, Pantelis, and Lagou, Athina. 2013. The Effect of Globalization on Capital Taxation: What Have We Learned after 20 Years of Empirical Studies. Journal of Macroeconomics 35:199209.
Adams, James, Haupt, Andrea B., and Stoll, Heather. 2009. What Moves Parties? The Role of Public Opinion and Global Economic Conditions in Western Europe. Comparative Political Studies 42:611639.
Allan, James, and Scruggs, Lyle. 2004. Political Partisanship and Welfare State Reform in Advanced Industrial Societies. American Journal of Political Science 48:496512.
Alvarez, Michael R., Garrett, Geoffrey, and Lange, Peter. 1991. Government Partisanship, Labor Organization, and Macroeconomic Performance. American Political Science Review 98:261276.
Basinger, Scott, and Hallerberg, Mark. 2004. Remodeling the Competition for Capital: How Domestic Politics Erases the Race-to-the-Bottom. American Political Science Review 98:539556.
Belloc, Filippo, Nicita, Antonio, and Sepe, Simone M.. 2014. Disentangling Liberalization and Privatization Policies: Is There a Political Trade-Off? Journal of Comparative Economics 42:10331051.
Bennett, Andrew, and Checkel, Jeffrey T.. 2015. Process Tracing: From Philosophical Roots to Best Practice. Pp. 337 in Process Tracing. From Metaphor to Analytic Tool, edited by Andrew Bennett and Jeffrey T. Checkel. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Bortolotti, Bernardo, Fantini, Marcella, and Siniscalco, Domenico. 2003. Privatisation around the World: Evidence from Panel Data. Journal of Public Economics 88:305332.
Bortolotti, Bernardo, and Pinotti, Paolo. 2008. Delayed Privatization. Public Choice 136:331351.
Botero, Juan C., Djankov, Simeon, La Porta, Rafael, Lopez-de-Silanes, Florencio, and Shleifer, Andrei. 2004. The Regulation of Labor. Quarterly Journal of Economics 119:13391382.
Bradbury, John C., and Crain, W. Mark. 2001. Legislative Organization and Government Spending: Cross-Country Evidence. Journal of Public Economics 82:309325.
Brady, David, and Lee, Hang Young. 2014. The Rise and Fall of Government Spending in Affluent Democracies, 1971–2008. Journal of European Social Policy 24:5679.
Brady, David, Seeleib-Kaiser, Martin, and Beckfield, Jason. 2005. Economic Globalization and the Welfare State in Affluent Democracies, 1975–2001. American Sociological Review 70:921948.
Braun, Dietmar, and Gilardi, Fabrizio. 2006. Taking ‘Galton’s Problem’ Seriously: Towards a Theory of Policy Diffusion. Journal of Theoretical Politics 18:298322.
Bretschger, Lucas, and Hettich, Frank. 2002. Globalisation, Capital Mobility and Tax Competition: Theory and Evidence for OECD Countries. European Journal of Political Economy 18:695716.
Bretschger, Lucas, and Hettich, Frank. 2005. Globalisation and International Tax Competition: Empirical Evidence Based on Effective Tax Rates. Journal of Economic Integration 20:530542.
Burgoon, Brian. 2001. Globalization and Welfare Compensation: Disentangling the Ties that Bind. International Organization 55:509551.
Burgoon, Brian. 2012. Partisan Embedding of Liberalism: How Trade, Investment, and Immigration Affect Party Support for the Welfare State. Comparative Political Studies 45:606635.
Busemeyer, Marius. 2009. From Myth to Reality: Globalisation and Public Spending in OECD Countries Revisited. European Journal of Political Research 48:455482.
Cao, Xun. 2010. Networks as Channels of Policy Diffusion: Explaining Worldwide Changes in Capital Taxation, 1998–2006. International Studies Quarterly 54:823854.
Castles, Francis G. 2007. Testing the Retrenchment Hypothesis: An Aggregate Overview. Pp. 1943 in The Disappearing State? Retrenchment Realities in an Age of Globalisation, edited by Francis G. Castles. Cheltenham: Elgar.
Castles, Francis G. 2009. What Welfare States Do: A Disaggregated Expenditure Approach. Journal of Social Policy 38:4562.
Clasen, Jochen, and Siegel, Nico A., eds. 2007. Investigating Welfare State Change. The ‘Dependent Variable Problem’ in Comparative Analysis. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.
Clausing, Kimberly A. 2008. Closer Economic Integration and Corporate Tax Systems. Global Economy Journal 8:122.
Clifton, Judith, Comín, Francisco, and Fuentes, Danial Días. 2006. Privatizing Public Enterprises in the European Union 1960–2002: Ideological, Pragmatic, Inevitable? Journal of European Public Policy 13:736756.
Conway, Paul, and Nicoletti, Giuseppe. 2006. Product Market Regulation in the Non-Manufacturing Sectors of OECD Countries: Measurement and Highlights, Working Paper No. 530, Paris, OECD Economics Department.
Dahl, Casper Hunnerup. 2014. Parties and Institutions: Empirical Evidence on Veto Players and the Growth of Government. Public Choice 159:415433.
Devereux, Michael P., Lockwood, Ben, and Redoano, Michaela. 2008. Do Countries Compete Over Corporate Taxes? Journal of Public Economics 92:12101235.
Dreher, Axel. 2006a. Does Globalization Affect Growth? Evidence from a New Index of Globalization. Applied Economics 38:10911110.
Dreher, Axel. 2006b. The Influence of Globalization on Taxes and Social Policy: An Empirical Analysis of OECD Countries. European Journal of Political Economy 22:179201.
Dreher, Axel, Sturm, Jan-Egbert, and Ursprung, Heinrich W.. 2008. The Impact of Globalization on the Composition of Government Expenditures: Evidence from Panel Data. Public Choice 134:263292.
Emmenegger, Patrick. 2007. Parteien und Opportunitätsstrukturen. Die parteipolitischen Determinanten der Staats- und Sozialausgaben. Zeitschrift für Sozialreform 53:79102.
Fink, Simon. 2011a. A Contagious Concept: Explaining the Spread of Privatization in the Telecommunications Sector. Governance 24:111139.
Fink, Simon. 2011b. Der Einfluss von Spielarten des Kapitalismus auf Privatisierungspolitik. Ein quantitativer Test. Zeitschrift für Vergleichende Politikwissenschaft 5:277301.
Franchino, Fabio, and Mainenti, Marco. 2013. Electoral Institutions and Distributive Policies in Parliamentary Systems: An Application to State Aid Measures in EU Countries. West European Politics 36:498520.
Franzese, Robert J., and Hays, Jude C.. 2006. Strategic Interaction among EU Governments in Active Labor Market Policy-Making. Subsidiarity and Policy Coordination under the European Employment Strategy. European Union Politics 7:167189.
Ganghof, Steffen. 2000. Adjusting National Tax Policy to Economic Internationalization. Strategies and Outcomes. Pp. 597645 in Welfare and Work in the Open Economy. Volume 2: Diverse Responses to Common Challenges, edited by Fritz W. Scharpf and Vivien A. Schmidt. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Garrett, Geoffrey. 1998. Partisan Politics in the Global Economy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Garrett, Geoffrey, and Mitchell, Deborah. 2001. Globalization, Government Spending and Taxation in the OECD. European Journal of Political Research 39:145177.
Genschel, Philipp, and Schwarz, Peter. 2011. Tax Competition: A Literature Review. Socio-Economic Review 9:339370.
Ghinamo, Mauro, Panteghini, Paolo M., and Revelli, Federico. 2010. FDI Determination and Corporate Tax Competition in a Volatile World. International Tax and Public Finance 17:532555.
Gilardi, Fabrizio. 2010. Who Learns from What in Policy Diffusion Processes? American Journal of Political Science 54:650666.
Ha, Eunyoung. 2008. Globalization, Veto Players, and Welfare Spending. Comparative Political Studies 41:783813.
Haupt, Andrea B. 2010. Parties’ Responses to Economic Globalization: What is Left for the Left and Right for the Right? Party Politics 16:527.
Hays, Jude C. 2003. Globalization and Capital Taxation in Consensus and Majoritarian Democracies. World Politics 56:79113.
Hays, Jude C., Ehrlich, Sean D., and Peinhardt, Clint. 2005. Government Spending and Public Support for Trade in the OECD: An Empirical Test of Embedded Liberalism Thesis. International Organization 59:473494.
Heinemann, Friedrich, Overesch, Michael, and Rincke, Johannes. 2010. Rate-Cutting Tax Reforms and Corporate Tax Competition in Europe. Economics & Politics 22:498518.
Henisz, Witold J., Zelner, Bennet A., and Guillén, Mauro F.. 2005. The Worldwide Diffusion of Market-Oriented Infrastructure Reform, 1977–1999. American Sociological Review 70:871897.
Herwartz, Helmut, and Theilen, Bernd. 2014. Partisan Influence on Social Spending Under Market Integration, Fiscal Pressure and Institutional Change. European Journal of Political Economy 34:409424.
Hicks, Alexander, and Zorn, Christopher. 2005. Economic Globalization, the Macro Economy, and Reversals of Welfare: Expansion in Affluent Democracies, 1978–94. International Organization 59:631662.
Höpner, Martin, Petring, Alexander, Seikel, Daniel, and Werner, Benjamin. 2011. Liberalisierungspolitik. Eine Bestandsaufnahme des Rückbaus wirtschafts- und sozialpolitischer Interventionen in entwickelten Industrieländern. Kölner Zeitschrift für Soziologie und Sozialpsychologie 63:132.
Iversen, Torben, and Cusack, Thomas R.. 2000. The Causes of Welfare State Expansion: Deindustrialization or Globalization? World Politics 52:313349.
Jensen, Carsten. 2011. Conditional Contraction: Globalisation and Capitalist Systems. European Journal of Political Research 50:168189.
Jensen, Carsten. 2012. Labour Market- vs. Life Course-Related Social Policies: Understanding Cross-Programme Differences. Journal of European Public Policy 19:275291.
Jensen, Carsten, and Seeberg, Henrik B.. 2015. The Power of Talk and the Welfare State: Evidence from 23 Countries on an Asymmetric Opposition–Government Response Mechanism. Socio-Economic Review 13:215233.
Jensen, Nathan M., and Lindstädt, René. 2012. Leaning Right and Learning from the Left: Diffusion of Corporate Tax Policy across Borders. Comparative Political Studies 19:275291.
Jordana, Jacint, Levi-Faur, David, and Fernández i Marín, Xavier. 2011. The Global Diffusion of Regulatory Agencies: Channels of Transfer and Stages of Diffusion. Comparative Political Studies 44:13431369.
Kammas, Pantelis. 2011. Strategic Fiscal Interaction among OECD Countries. Public Choice 147:459480.
Keman, Hans. 2011. Third Ways and Social Democracy: The Right Way to Go? British Journal of Political Science 41:671680.
Kim, Tae Kuen, and Zurlo, Karen. 2009. How Does Economic Globalisation Affect the Welfare State? Focusing on the Mediating Effect of Welfare Regimes. International Journal of Social Welfare 18:130141.
Kittel, Bernhard. 1999. Sense and Sensitivity in Pooled Analysis of Political Data. European Journal of Political Research 35:225253.
Kittel, Bernhard, and Obinger, Herbert. 2003. Political Parties, Institutions, and the Dynamics of Social Expenditure in Times of Austerity. Journal of European Public Policy 10:2045.
Kogut, Bruce, and Macpherson, J. Muir. 2008. The Decision to Privatize: Economists and the Construction of Ideas and Policies. Pp. 104140 in The Global Diffusion of Markets and Democracy, edited by Beth Simmons, Frank Dobbin and Geoffrey Garrett. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Kulessa, Alexander von, and Wenzelburger, Georg. 2015. Starker Steuerwettbewerb – starke Reformen? Ein neuer Blick auf Unternehmenssteuerreformen in 15 EU-Staaten (1998–2011). Swiss Political Science Review 21:302332.
Kwon, Hyeok Yong, and Pontusson, Jonas. 2010. Globalization, Labour Power and Partisan Politics Revisited. Socio-Economic Review 8:251281.
Leibrecht, Markus, and Hochgatterer, Claudia. 2012. Tax Competition as a Cause of Falling Corporate Income Tax Rates: A Survey of Empirical Literature. Journal of Economic Surveys 26:616648.
Leibrecht, Markus, Klien, Michael, and Onaran, Özlem. 2011. Globalization, Welfare Regimes and Social Protection Expenditures in Western and Eastern European Countries. Public Choice 148:569594.
Levi-Faur, David. 2003. The Politics of Liberalisation: Privatisation and Regulation-for-Competition in Europe’s and Latin America’s Telecoms and Electricity Industries. European Journal of Political Research 42:705740.
Liberati, Paolo. 2007. Trade Openness, Capital Openness and Government Size. Journal of Public Policy 27:215247.
Maggetti, Martino, and Gilardi, Fabrizio. 2016. Problems (and Solutions) in the Measurement of Policy Diffusion Mechanisms. Journal of Public Policy 36:87107.
Martin, Lanny W., and Vanberg, Georg. 2013. Multiparty Government, Fiscal Institutions, and Public Spending. The Journal of Politics 75:953967.
Merkel, Wolfgang, Petring, Alexander, Henkes, Christian, and Egle, Christoph. 2008. Social Democracy in Power: The Capacity to Reform. London/New York: Routledge.
Meseguer, Covadonga. 2004. What Role for Learning? The Diffusion of Privatization in OECD and Latin American Countries. Journal of Public Policy 24:299325.
Obinger, Herbert, Schmitt, Carina, and Zohlnhöfer, Reimut. 2014. Partisan Politics and Privatization in OECD Countries. Comparative Political Studies 47:12941323.
Onaran, Özlem, Boesch, Valerie, and Leibrecht, Markus. 2012. How Does Globalization Affect the Implicit Tax Rates on Labor Income, Capital Income, and Consumption in the European Union? Economic Inquiry 50:880904.
Osterloh, Steffen, and Debus, Marc. 2012. Partisan Politics in Corporate Taxation. European Journal of Political Economy 28:192207.
Pitlik, Hans. 2007. A Race to Liberalization? Diffusion of Economic Policy Reform among OECD-Economies. Public Choice 132:159178.
Plümper, Thomas, Troeger, Vera E., and Winter, Hannes. 2009. Why Is There No Race to the Bottom in Capital Taxation? International Studies Quarterly 53:761786.
Potrafke, Niklas. 2009. Did Globalization Restrict Partisan Politics? An Empirical Evaluation of Social Expenditures in a Panel of OECD Countries. Public Choice 140:105124.
Razin, Assaf, Sadka, Efraim, and Swagel, Philip. 2002. The Aging Population and the Size of Welfare State. Journal of Political Economy 110:900918.
Rickard, Stephanie. 2012. A Non-Tariff Protectionist Bias in Majoritarian Politics: Government Subsidies and Electoral Institutions. International Studies Quarterly 56:777785.
Roberts, Barbara M., and Saeed, Muhammad A.. 2012. Privatizations around the World: Economic or Political Determinants? Economics & Politics 24:4771.
Rodden, Jonathan. 2003. Reviving Leviathan: Fiscal Federalism and the Growth of Government. International Organization 57:695729.
Scharpf, Fritz W. 1999. Governing in Europe: Effective and Democratic? Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Schmidt, Susanne K. 1998. Liberalisierung in Europa: Die Rolle der Europäischen Kommission. Frankfurt/New York: Campus.
Schmitt, Carina. 2013a. Culture, Closeness, or Commerce? Policy Diffusion in Social Spending Dynamics. Swiss Political Science Review 19:123138.
Schmitt, Carina. 2013b. The Janus Face of Europeanisation: Explaining Cross-Sectoral Differences in Public Utilities. West European Politics 36:547563.
Schmitt, Carina. 2014. The Diffusion of Privatization in Europe: Political Affinity or Economic Competition? Public Administration 92:615635.
Schmitt, Carina. 2016. Panel Data Analysis and Partisan Variables: How Periodization Does Influence Partisan Effects. Journal of European Public Policy 23:14421459.
Schneider, Volker, and Häge, Frank M.. 2008. Europeanization and the Retreat of the State. Journal of European Public Policy 15:119.
Schneider, Volker, Fink, Simon, and Tenbrücken, Marc. 2005. Buying Out the State: A Comparative Perspective on the Privatization of Infrastructures. Comparative Political Studies 38:704727.
Schuster, Philipp, Schmitt, Carina, and Traub, Stefan. 2013. The Retreat of the State from Entrepreneurial Activities: A Convergence Analysis for the OECD Countries, 1980–2007. European Journal of Political Economy 32:95112.
Simmons, Beth, Dobbin, Frank, and Garrett, Geoffrey. 2006. Introduction: The International Diffusion of Liberalism. International Organization 60:781810.
Starke, Peter. 2006. The Politics of Welfare State Retrenchment: A Literature Review. Social Policy & Administration 40:104120.
Strøm, Kaare. 1990. A Behavioral Theory of Competitive Political Parties. American Journal of Political Science 34:565598.
Swank, Duane. 2006. Tax Policy in an Era of Internationalization: Explaining the Spread of Neoliberalism. International Organization 60:847882.
Swank, Duane. 2016. Taxing Choices: International Competition, Domestic Institutions and the Transformation of Corporate Tax Policy. Journal of European Public Policy 23:571603.
Swank, Duane, and Steinmo, Sven. 2002. The New Political Economy of Taxation in Advanced Capitalist Democracies. American Journal of Political Science 46:642655.
Tsebelis, George. 2002. Veto Players: How Political Institutions Work. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press.
Vis, Barbara, and van Kersbergen, Kees. 2007. Why and How Do Political Actors Pursue Risky Reforms? Journal of Theoretical Politics 19:153172.
Ward, Hugh, Ezrow, Lawrence, and Dorussen, Han. 2011. Globalization, Party Positions, and the Median Voter. World Politics 63:509547.
Winner, Hannes. 2005. Has Tax Competition Emerged in OECD Countries? Evidence from Panel Data. International Tax and Public Finance 12:667687.
Wolf, Frieder. 2010. Enlightened Eclecticism or Hazardous Hodgepodge? Mixed Methods and Triangulation Strategies in Comparative Public Policy Research. Journal of Mixed Methods Research 4:144167.
Zahariadis, Nikolaos. 2010a. Discretion by the Rules: European State Aid Policy and the 1999 Procedural Regulation. Journal of European Public Policy 17:954970.
Zahariadis, Nikolaos. 2010b. State Aid and Partisan Government in the European Union. Social Science Quarterly 91:436454.
Zohlnhöfer, Reimut. 2009. How Politics Matter when Policies Change: Understanding Policy Change as a Political Problem. Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis 11:97115.
Zohlnhöfer, Reimut, Wenzelburger, Georg, and Wolf, Frieder. 2013. Political Parties and Pension Generosity in Times of Permanent Austerity. World Political Science Review 9:291318.
Zohlnhöfer, Reimut, Obinger, Herbert, and Wolf, Frieder. 2008. Partisan Politics, Globalization, and the Determinants of Privatization Proceeds in Advanced Democracies (1990–2000). Governance 21:95121.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

British Journal of Political Science
  • ISSN: 0007-1234
  • EISSN: 1469-2112
  • URL: /core/journals/british-journal-of-political-science
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *


Type Description Title
Supplementary materials

Zohlnhöfer supplementary material

 PDF (302 KB)
302 KB


Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 18
Total number of PDF views: 284 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 1280 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between 20th March 2017 - 19th July 2018. This data will be updated every 24 hours.