Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home

Justifications and Citizen Competence in Direct Democracy: A Multilevel Analysis

  • Céline Colombo

Abstract

The criticism that ordinary voters lack the necessary competence to make policy decisions persists despite the growth, popularity and implementation of direct democratic instruments throughout the democratic world. This article presents a novel measure of voters’ levels of justification as a possible, policy-specific, conceptualization of citizen competence in direct democracy. Using a unique dataset based on thirty-four ballot decisions in Switzerland, the study analyses the levels and correlates of citizen competence. The main findings are, first, that most voters do understand arguments about policies. Secondly, the political context as well as individual resources are important in determining voters’ competence. Finally, with regard to individual resources, motivation is strongly associated with justification levels, while the effect of ability is smaller than expected.

Copyright

Footnotes

Hide All
*

Department of Political Science, University of Zurich (email: colombo@ipz.uzh.ch). I am grateful to Hanspeter Kriesi, Alexander Trechsel, Thomas Milic, Marco Steenbergen, Nan Zhang, Thomas Widmer, Hannes Kröger and Igor Skulkin for their valuable comments and support. In particular, I thank Mathias Birrer for his invaluable help with data coding and his many inputs. Supplementary materials available at http://dx.doi.org/doi: 10.1017/S0007123416000090 and replication data available at https://dataverse.harvard.edu/dataverse/BJPolS.

Footnotes

References

Hide All
Althaus, Scott L. 2003. Collective Preferences in Democratic Politics: Opinion Surveys and the Will of the People. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Altman, David. 2010. Direct Democracy Worldwide. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Bächtiger, André, and Wyss, Dominik. 2013. Empirische Deliberationsforschung–eine systematische Übersicht. Zeitschrift für Vergleichende Politikwissenschaft 7 (2):155181.
Barabas, Jason, Jerit, Jennifer, Pollock, William, and Rainey, Carlisle. 2014. The Question(s) of Political Knowledge: A Temporal-Topical Framework. American Political Science Review 108 (4):840854.
Bauer, Paul C., and Fatke, Matthias. 2014. Direct Democracy and Political Trust: Enhancing Trust, Initiating Distrust or Both? Swiss Political Science Review 20 (1):4969.
Bennett, Stephen Earl. 1988. Know-Nothings’ Revisited: The Meaning of Political Ignorance Today. Social Science Quarterly 69 (2):476490.
Benz, Matthias, and Stutzer, Alois. 2004. Are Voters Better Informed when They Have a Larger Say in Politics? Evidence for the European Union and Switzerland. Public Choice 119 (1–2):3159.
Bolsen, Toby, Druckman, James N., and Cook, Fay Lomax. 2014. The Influence of Partisan Motivated Reasoning on Public Opinion. Political Behavior 36 (2):235262.
Boudreau, Cheryl, and MacKenzie, Scott A.. 2014. Informing the Electorate? How Party Cues and Policy Information Affect Public Opinion about Initiatives. American Journal of Political Science 58 (1):4862.
Bowler, Shaun, and Donovan, Todd. 2002. Democracy, Institutions and Attitudes About Citizen Influence on Government. British Journal of Political Science 32 (2):371390.
Chambers, Simone. 2001. Constitutional Referendums and Democratic Deliberation. Pp. 231255 in Referendum Democracy: Citizens, Elites, and Deliberation in Referendum Campaigns, edited by M. Mendelson and A. Parkin. New York: Palgrave.
Converse, Phillip E. 1964. The Nature of Belief Systems in Mass Politics. Pp. 206261 in Ideology and Discontent, edited by David E. Apter. New York: Free Press.
Dahl, Robert A. 1989. Democracy and its Critics. New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press.
Delli Carpini, Michael X., and Keeter, Scott. 1996. What Americans Don’t Know about Politics and Why It Matters. New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press.
Donovan, Todd, Tolbert, Caroline J., and Smith, Daniel A.. 2009. Political Engagement, Mobilization, and Direct Democracy. Public Opinion Quarterly 73 (1):98118.
Druckman, James N., and Nelson, Kjersten R.. 2003. Framing and Deliberation: How Citizens’ Conversations Limit Elite Influence. American Journal of Political Science 47 (4):729745.
Dryzek, John S. 2009. Democratization as Deliberative Capacity Building. Comparative Political Studies 42 (11):13791402.
Elo, Kimmo, and Rapeli, Lauri. 2010. Determinants of Political Knowledge: The Effects of the Media on Knowledge and Information. Journal of Elections, Public Opinion and Parties 20 (1):133146.
Esterling, Kevin M., Neblo, Michael A., and Lazer, David M. J.. 2011. Means, Motive, and Opportunity in Becoming Informed About Politics: A Deliberative Field Experiment with Members of Congress and Their Constituents. Public Opinion Quarterly 75 (3):483503.
Fishkin, James. 2009. When the People Speak: Deliberative Democracy and Public Consultation. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Freitag, Markus, and Stadelmann-Steffen, Isabelle. 2010. Stumbling Block or Stepping Stone? The Influence of Direct Democracy on Individual Participation in Parliamentary Elections. Electoral Studies 29 (3):472483.
Gerber, Marlène, Bächtiger, André, Fiket, Irena, Steenbergen, Marco, and Steiner, Jürg. 2014. Deliberative and Non-Deliberative Persuasion: Mechanisms of Opinion Formation in EuroPolis. European Union Politics 15 (3):410429.
Gilens, Martin. 2001. Political Ignorance and Collective Policy Preferences. American Political Science Review 95 (June):379396.
Graber, Doris A. 2001. Processing Politics: Learning from Television in the Internet Age. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Gruner, Erich, and Hertig, Hans Peter. 1983. Der Stimmbürger und die neue Politik: Wie reagiert die Politik auf die Beschleunigung der Zeitgeschichte? Bern: Haupt.
Haidt, Jonathan. 2012. The Righteous Mind: Why Good People Are Divided by Politics and Religion. New York: Vintage.
Hirschman, Albert O. 1989. Having Opinions – One of the Elements of Well-Being? American Economic Review 79 (2):7579.
Jerit, Jennifer, Barabas, Jason, and Bolsen, Toby. 2006. Citizens, Knowledge, and the Information Environment. American Journal of Political Science 50 (2):266282.
Kriesi, Hanspeter. 2002. Individual Opinion Formation in a Direct Democratic Campaign. British Journal of Political Science 32 (1):171185.
Kriesi, Hanspeter. 2005. Direct Democratic Choice: The Swiss Experience. Lanham, Md.: Lexington Books.
Kriesi, Hanspeter. 2010. Manipulation or Deliberation, unpublished manuscript, University of Zurich.
Krosnick, Jon A. 1990. Government Policy and Citizen Passion: A Study of Issue Publics in Contemporary America. Political Behavior 12 (1):5992.
Kuklinski, James H., Quirk, Paul J., Schwieder, David W., and Rich, Robert F.. 1998. Just the Facts, Ma’am: Political Facts and Public Opinion. Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 560 (November):143154.
Kuklinski, James H., Quirk, Paul J., Jerit, Jennifer, and Rich, Robert F.. 2001. The Political Environment and Citizen Competence. American Journal of Political Science 45 (2):410424.
Lau, Richard R., and Heldman, Caroline. 2009. Self Interest, Symbolic Attitudes, and Support for Public Policy: A Multilevel Analysis. Political Psychology 30 (4):513537.
Lavine, Howard G., Johnston, Christopher D., and Steenbergen, Marco R.. 2012. The Ambivalent Partisan: How Critical Loyalty Promotes Democracy . Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Lodge, Milton, and Taber, Charles S.. 2013. The Rationalizing Voter. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Lupia, Arthur. 2006. How Elitism Undermines the Study of Voter Competence. Critical Review 18 (1–3):217232.
Lupia, Arthur, McCubbins, Mathew D., and Popkin, Samuel, eds. 2000. Elements of Reason: Cognition, Choice, and the Bounds of Rationality. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Magleby, David B. 1984. Direct Legislation: Voting on Ballot Propositions in the United States. Baltimore, Md.: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Matsusaka, John G. 2005. The Eclipse of Legislatures: Direct Democracy in the 21st Century. Public Choice 124 (1–2):157177.
Mendelsohn, Matthew, and Cutler, Fred. 2000. The Effect of Referendums on Democratic Citizens: Information, Politicization, Efficacy and Tolerance. British Journal of Political Science 30 (4):669698.
Milewicz, Karolina, and Goodin, Robert E.. 2012. Deliberative Capacity Building through International Organizations. American Political Science Association 2012 Annual Meeting Paper, available at http://ssrn.com/abstract=2106604.
Milic, Thomas. 2009. Von der Parteilichkeit der Argumente. Presented at the Jahreskongress der Schweizerischen Vereinigung für Politische Wissenschaft, St. Gallen, in 2009.
Mondak, Jeffery J. 2000. Reconsidering the Measurement of Political Knowledge. Political Analysis 8 (1):5782.
Nai, Alessandro. 2013. What Really Matters Is Which Camp Goes Dirty: Differential Effects of Negative Campaigning on Turnout During Swiss Federal Ballots. European Journal of Political Research 52 (1):4470.
Nai, Alessandro. 2015. The Maze and the Mirror: Voting Correctly in Direct Democracy. Social Science Quarterly 96 (2):465486.
Neblo, M. A., Siegel, D. A., and Minozzi, W.. 2012. A Theory of Deliberation as Interactive Reasoning. Presented at the 2012 Annual Meeting of the American Political Science Association.
Neijens, Peter, and de Vreese, Claes. 2009. Helping Citizens Decide in Referendums: The Moderating Effect of Political Sophistication on the Use of the Information and Choice Questionnaire as a Decision Aid. Public Opinion Quarterly 73 (3):521536.
Pedrini, Seraina. 2014. Deliberative Capacity in the Political and Civic Sphere. Swiss Political Science Review 20 (2):263286.
Price, Vincent, and Zaller, John. 1993. Who Gets the News? Alternative Measures of News Reception and Their Implications for Research. Public Opinion Quarterly 57 (2):133164.
Prior, Markus. 2007. Post-Broadcast Democracy: How Media Choice Increases Inequality in Political Involvement and Polarizes Elections. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Sanders, Lynn M. 1997. Against Deliberation. Political Theory 25 (3):347376.
Schiller, Theo. 2011. Local Direct Democracy in Europe: A Comparative Overview. Pp. 929 in Local Direct Democracy in Europe, edited by Theo Schiller. Wiesbaden: VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften.
Sciarini, Pascal, Nai, Alessandro, and Tresch, Anke. 2014. Analyse de la votation fédérale du 9 février 2014. Bern/Genève: gfs. bern et Université de Genève.
Shaker, Lee. 2012. Local Political Knowledge and Assessments of Citizen Competence. Public Opinion Quarterly 76:525537.
Smith, Daniel A., and Tolbert, Caroline. 2004. Educated by Initiative: The Effects of Direct Democracy On Citizens and Political Organizations in the American States. Michigan: University of Michigan Press.
Sniderman, Paul M., Tetlock, Phillip E., and Brody, Richard A.. 1991. Reasoning and Choice: Explorations in Political Psychology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Somin, Ilya. 2004. When Ignorance Isn’t Bliss. Policy Analysis 525:128.
Steiner, J. 2004. Deliberative Politics in Action: Analyzing Parliamentary Discourse. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Steiner, Jürg. 2012. The Foundations of Deliberative Democracy: Empirical Research and Normative Implications. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Steiner, Jürg, Bächtiger, André, Spörndli, Markus, and Steenbergen, Marco R.. 2004. Deliberative Politics in Action: Analyzing Parliamentary Discourse. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Taber, Charles S., and Lodge, Milton. 2006. Motivated Skepticism in the Evaluation of Political Beliefs. American Journal of Political Science 26 (3):755769.
Tetlock, Philip E. 1983. Accountability and Complexity of Thought. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 45 (1):74.
Thompson, Dennis F. 2008. Deliberative Democratic Theory and Empirical Political Science. Annual Review of Political Science 11:497520.
Young, Iris M. 2000. Inclusion and Democracy, Vol. 18. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Zajonc, Robert B. 1980. Feeling and Thinking: Preferences Need No Inferences. American Psychologist 35 (2):151157.
Zaller, John. 1992. The Nature and Origins of Mass Opinion. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Type Description Title
UNKNOWN
Supplementary materials

Colombo Dataset
Dataset

 Unknown
WORD
Supplementary materials

Colombo supplementary material
Colombo supplementary material 1

 Word (25 KB)
25 KB
WORD
Supplementary materials

Colombo supplementary material
Appendix

 Word (43 KB)
43 KB

Justifications and Citizen Competence in Direct Democracy: A Multilevel Analysis

  • Céline Colombo

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed