Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home

Diversifying Methodologies: A Haudenosaunee/Settler Approach for Measuring Indigenous-Local Intergovernmental Success

  • Christopher Alcantara (a1) and Ian Kalman (a2)

Abstract

Intergovernmental agreements between municipal and Indigenous governments are rapidly expanding in number and importance in Canada and the United States, yet they remain underexamined in the literature. This article considers how to measure the success of these agreements. It takes as a case study the port divestiture agreement between the City of Cornwall (Ontario, Canada), and a neighbouring Indigenous government, the Mohawk Council of Akwesasne. While the agreement represents a partial success and partial failure by conventional public policy and public administration metrics, these evaluations are different when measured against the Haudenosaunee (Iroquois) principle of “one-mindedness.” Findings, which were generated using anthropological and qualitative political science methods, suggest that the use of both Indigenous and non-Indigenous frameworks are required to produce accurate and comprehensive evaluations of these agreements and the outcomes that are produced by them.

Le nombre et l'importance des ententes conclues entre les gouvernements municipaux et autochtones augmentent rapidement au Canada et aux États-Unis, mais elles n'ont pas fait l'objet d'un examen suffisamment étayé dans la littérature. Le présent article examine comment mesurer le succès de telles ententes. Il prend comme étude de cas l'accord de dessaisissement du Port entre la ville de Cornwall (Ontario, Canada) et un gouvernement autochtone voisin, le Conseil des Mohawks d'Akwesasne. Bien que l'accord représente un succès et un échec partiels de la politique publique conventionnelle et des dispositions de l'administration publique, ces évaluations diffèrent lorsqu'elles sont mesurées à l'aune du principe de la tradition haudenosaunee (iroquoise) de « l'unicité d'esprit ». Les résultats obtenus à l'aide de méthodes anthropologiques et qualitatives en science politique suggèrent que l'utilisation de cadres autochtones et non autochtones est nécessaire pour produire des évaluations précises et complètes de ces accords et des résultats qu'ils produisent.

Copyright

Corresponding author

*Corresponding author. Email: calcanta@uwo.ca

References

Hide All
Absolon, Kathleen E. 2011. Kaandossiwin. Halifax and Winnipeg: Fernwood Press.
Akwesasne Harbour Development Corporation. 2016. Resolution of the Directors of Akwesasne Harbour Development Corporation. June 30. Confidential document.
Alcantara, Christopher. 2007. “Reduce Transaction Costs? Yes. Strengthen Property Rights? Maybe.” Public Choice 132 (3–4): 421–32.
Alcantara, Christopher. 2008. “To Treaty or Not to Treaty?Publius: Journal of Federalism 38 (2): 343–69.
Alcantara, Christopher and Morden, Michael. 2017. “Indigenous Multilevel Governance and Power Relations: Lessons from Impact and Benefit Agreements.” Territory, Politics, Governance. Online at: https://doi.org/10.1080/21622671.2017.1360197.
Alcantara, Christopher and Nelles, Jen. 2016. A Quiet Evolution. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
Alcantara, Christopher and Whitfield, Greg. 2010. “Aboriginal Self-Government through Constitutional Design: A Survey of Fourteen Aboriginal Constitutions in Canada.” Journal of Canadian Studies 44 (2): 122–45.
Alcantara, Christopher, Broschek, Jorg and Nelles, Jen. 2016. “Rethinking Multilevel Governance as an Instance of Multilevel Politics.” Territory, Politics, Governance 4 (1): 3351.
Alcantara, Christopher, Lalonde, Dianne and Wilson, Gary. 2017. “Indigenous Research and Academic Freedom: A View from Political Scientists.” International Indigenous Policy Journal 8 (2): 119.
Alfred, Taiaiake. 2008. Peace, Power, Righteousness. Toronto: Oxford University Press.
Alfred, Taiaiake. 2005. Wasase. Toronto: Broadview Press.
Ansell, Christopher and Di Palma, Giuseppe. 2004. Restructuring Territoriality. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Bache, Ian. 2008. Europeanization and Multilevel Governance. Toronto: Rowman & Littlefield.
Baker, Lois Ann. 2016. “Group wants harbour process stopped.” Cornwall Standard-Freeholder. April 14. (July 5, 2018).
Barreiro, José. 2010. Thinking in Indian. Golden: Fulcrum Publishing.
Borrows, John. 2010. Canada's Indigenous Constitution. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
Bovens, MM. 2010. “A comment on Marsh and Mcconnell: Towards a framework for establish-ing policy success.” Public Administration 88 (2): 584–85.
Bovens, M., Hart, P. ‘t and Peters, B.G.. 2001. “Analysing Governance Success and Failure in Six European States.” In Success and Failure in Public Governance, ed. Bovens, M., Hart, P ’t and Peters, B.G.. Northhampton: Edward Elgar.
Caporaso, James. 2000. “Changes in the Westphalian Order.” International Studies Review 2 (2): 128.
Cole, Peter. 2002. “aboriginalizing methodology.” International Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education 15 (4): 447–59.
Evans, Laura. 2014. “Tribal-State Relations in the Anglosphere.” Annual Review of Political Science 17: 273–89.
Evans, Laura. 2011. “Expertise and Scale of Conflict: Governments as Advocates in American Indian Politics.” American Political Science Review 105 (4): 663–82.
Feiock, Richard. 2007. “Rational Choice and Regional Governance.” Journal of Urban Affairs 29 (1): 4763.
Foster, Michael K. 1974. From the Earth to Beyond the Sky. Ottawa: National Museums of Canada.
Foster, Michael, Campisi, Jack and Mithun, Marianne. 1984. Extending the Rafters: Interdisciplinary Approaches to Iroquoian Studies. Albany: State University of New York Press.
Gaudry, Adam. 2015. “Researching the Resurgence.” In Research as Resistance, ed. Strega, S. and Brown, L.. Toronto: Canadian Scholars’ Press.
George-Kanentiio, Doug. 2000. Iroquois Culture & Commentary. Santa Fe NM: Clear Light Publishers.
Goffman, Erving. 1974. Frame Analysis. Cambridge MA: Harvard University Press.
Haan, Richard L. 2003. “Covenant and Consensus: Iroquois and English 1676–1760.” In Beyond the Covenant Chain: The Iroquois and their Neighbors in the Indian North, ed. Richter, D. and Merrell, J.. Syracuse: Syracuse University Press.
Hale, Alan S. 2017a. “A year after Cornwall port divestiture, there's little to celebrate.” The Cornwall Standard Freeholder, June 29. (July 5, 2018).
Hale, Alan S. 2017b. “Seven Nations of Canada Prepared to Head Straight to the Crown.” The Cornwall Standard Freeholder, June 28. (July 5, 2018).
Hooghe, Liesbet and Marks, Gary. 2016. Community, Scale, and Regional Governance. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Imperial, Mark T. 1998. “Intergovernmental Policy Implementation.” Paper presented at the meeting of the Academy of Management, August 7–12, San Diego, CA.
Johansen, Bruce Elliott. 1993. Life and Death in Mohawk Country. Streamwood IL: North American Press.
Kalman, Ian. 2016. “Framing Borders.” Doctoral dissertation, McGill University, Montreal QP.
Kerr, D. 1976. “The logic of ‘policy’ and successful policies.” Policy Sciences 7 (3): 351–63.
Kovach, Margaret. 2009. Indigenous Methodologies. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
Marsh, D. and McConnell, A.. 2010. “Towards a Framework for Establishing Policy Success.” Public Administration 88 (2): 564–83.
MCA and Cornwall. 2016. Co-Owners’ Agreement. April 15. Confidential document.
Muller, Kathryn. 2008. “Holding Hands with Wampum: Haudenosaunee Council Fires from the Great Law of Peace to Contemporary Relationships with the Canadian State.” Doctoral dissertation, Queen's University, Kingston ON.
Nelles, Jennifer. 2012. Comparative Metropolitan Policy. New York: Routledge.
Newman, Joshua. 2014. “Measuring Policy Success.” Australian Journal of Public Administration 73 (2): 192205.
Parmenter, John. 2013. “The Meaning of Kaswentha and the Two Row Wampum Belt in Haudenosaunee (Iroquois) History: Can Indigenous Oral Tradition Be Reconciled with the Documentary Record?Journal of Early American History 3 (1): 82109.
Papillon, Martin. 2012. “Adapting Federalism.” Publius: Journal of Federalism 42 (2): 289312.
Piattoni, Simona. 2010. The Theory of Multi-Level Governance. New York: Oxford University Press.
Queen's University. 2017. “Yakwanastahentéha, Aankenjigemi. Extending the Rafters: Truth and Reconciliation Commission Task Force Final Report.” (July 5, 2018).
Rodrigues, Hugo. 2016. “Were they consulted: the Akwesasne edition.” Cornwall Standard-Freeholder. July 15. (July 5, 2018).
Simpson, Audra. 2014. Mohawk Interruptus. Durham: Duke University Press.
Song, Minsun and Jun Park, Hyung and Jung, Kyujin. 2018. “Do Political Similarities Facilitate Interlocal Collaboration?Public Administration Review 78 (2): 261–69.
Spicer, Zachary. 2015. “Cooperation, Coordination and Competition.” Canadian Public Administration 58 (4): 549–73.
Venables. 2008. “Polishing the Covenant Chain: A Brief History of Some of the Symbols and Metaphors in Haudenosaunee Treaty Negotiations.” Prepared for the Onondaga Nation at the request of Chief Irving Powless, Jr. (July 5, 2018).
Venables. 2010. “The Clearings and the Woods.” In Archaeology and Preservation of Gendered Landscapes, ed. Baugher, Sherene and Spencer-Wood, Suzanne M.. London: Springer.
Wallace, Anthony F. C. 2012. Tuscarora: A History. SUNY Press.
Webster, Rebecca M. 2016. “Tribal and Local Governments.” Wisconsin Lawyer 89. (July 5, 2018).
Webster, Rebecca M. 2015. “Service Agreements.” The American Indian Quarterly 39 (4): 347–63.
Wilson, Gary. 2008. “Nested Federalism in Arctic Quebec.” Canadian Journal of Political Science 41 (1): 7192.
Young, Robert. 2012. “Introduction.” In Sites of Governance, ed. Horak, Martin and Young, Robert. Montreal-Kingston: McGill-Queen's University Press.

Keywords

Diversifying Methodologies: A Haudenosaunee/Settler Approach for Measuring Indigenous-Local Intergovernmental Success

  • Christopher Alcantara (a1) and Ian Kalman (a2)

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed