Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-cfpbc Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-18T04:53:36.030Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Black Ecumenicism: Efforts to Establish a United Methodist Episcopal Church, 1918–1932

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 July 2009

Dennis C. Dickerson
Dennis C. Dickerson
Affiliation:
Mr. Dickerson is associate professor of history in Williams College, Williamstown, Massachusetts.
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Between 1918 and 1932 representatives from three black denominations— African Methodist Episcopal, African Methodist Episcopal Zion, and Colored Methodist Episcopal—devised plans to merge into one religious body which they hoped to name the United Methodist Episcopal church. During this period the clergy and laity of these three black denominations debated the advantages and shortcomings of the Birmingham Plan of 1918 and the Pittsburgh proposals of 1927 which sought to create a single black Methodist organization. Opponents of the Birmingham and Pittsburgh agreements feared that organic union would work against their particular denominational interests and destroy their historical identity. Advocates of merger stressed the common religious and racial background of the three churches and argued that black Methodist unity would benefit the nation's black population. By 1932, however, the deep denominational divisions among black Methodists slowed the movement toward merger and undermined efforts to end the religious rivalry among these three important black institutions.

Type
Research Article
Information
Church History , Volume 52 , Issue 4 , December 1983 , pp. 479 - 491
Copyright
Copyright © American Society of Church History 1983

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1. Trueblood, Roy W. has traced the general history of merger talks among black Methodists in “Union Negotiations between Black Methodists in America,” Methodist History 8 (1970): 18–20.Google Scholar Although he discusses the Birmingham Plan of 1918, he does not mention the Pittsburgh proposals of 1927.

2. Woodson, Carter G., History of the Negro Church (1921; reprint ed., Washington, D.C., 1972), pp. 63–73, 171–174;Google Scholar Richardson, Harry V., Dark Salvation: The Story of Methodism as it Developed among Blacks in America (Garden City, N.Y., 1976), p. 130;Google Scholar U.S. Bureau of the Census, Religious Bodies: 1926, vol. 2, Separate Denominations (Washington, D.C., 1929), pp. 997–1009, 1030;Google Scholar Lakey, Othal H., The Rise of “Colored Methodism” (Dallas, 1972), p. 58.Google Scholar

3. Religious Bodies: 1926, 2:996, 1006, 1028.Google Scholar

4. Wright, Richard R. Jr, ed., Encyclopedia of African Methodism (Philadelphia, 1947), p. 450;Google Scholar George, Carol V. R., Segregated Sabbaths (New York, 1973), p. 98;Google Scholar Walls, William J., The African Methodist Episcopal Zion Church: Reality of the Black Church (Charlotte, 1974), p. 74.Google Scholar

5. Walls, p. 188. See also Walker, Clarence E., A Rock in a Weary Land (Baton Rouge, 1982), pp. 101–102.Google Scholar

6. Lakey, pp. 98–102.

7. Smith, Charles S., A History of the African Methodist Episcopal Church (Philadelphia, 1922), pp. 383–387;Google Scholar Walls, pp. 468–471; The Christian Recorder, 16 March 1893.

8. Walls, pp. 471–473; Logan, Frenise A., The Negro in North Carolina, 1876–1894 (Chapel Hill, 1964), p. 171Google Scholar n. 27.

9. New York Age, 20 April 1928.

10. The Christian Index, 30 May 1918.

11. Proceedings of the Fifth Ecumenical Methodist Conference [London, 6–16 09 1921], (New York, 1921), pp. 125–126.Google Scholar

12. The Christian Index, 21 November 1918, 29 July 1920,8 July 1920.

13. Walls, p. 474; Proceedings of the Fourth Ecumenical Methodist Conference [Toronto, Canada, 4–17 10 1911], (New York, 1911), p. 738;Google Scholar The Christian Index, 21 March 1918; The Star of Zion, 22 April 1920; The Christian Index, 1 July 1920.

14. The Christian Index, 1 July 1920, 27 May 1920.

15. Proceedings of the Fifth Ecumenical Methodist Conference, p. 126.

16. The Christian Index, 23 March 1922.

17. The Christian Recorder, 20 July 1922; The Christian Index, 9 August 1923.

18. The Christian Index, 20 July 1922.

19. Smith, pp. 391–392; The Christian Index, 20 July 1922.

20. Walls, p. 474; Wright, Richard R. Jr, The Bishops of the A.M.E. Church (Nashville, 1963), p. 133.Google Scholar

21. Pittsburgh Courier, 25 June 1927; The Star of Zion, 30 June 1927.

22. The Star of Zion, 30 June 1927.

23. Judge Archibald J. Carey Jr., to author, 30 May 1979; The Star of Zion, 21 January 1926, 14 March 1929.

24. The Star of Zion, 26 July 1928, 17 March 1927, 5 December 1927, 12 December 1929; The Christian Recorder, 16 September 1920.

25. Pittsburgh Courier, 2 July 1927; Star of Zion, 18 October 1928, 28 April 1927.

26. The Star of Zion, 5 July 1928, 21 April 1927, 3 November 1927.

27. The Star of Zion, 22 September 1927, 7 April 1927, 15 December 1927.

28. The Star of Zion, 27 October 1927, 27 June 1929.

29. Wright, , Bishops, pp. 234–235;Google Scholar Wright, , ed., Encyclopedia, pp. 342–343;Google Scholar The Star of Zion, 31 October 1929.

30. Bradley, David H. Sr, A History of the A.M.E. Zion Church, vol. 2, 1872–1968 (Nashville, 1970), p. 360;Google Scholar The Star of Zion, 6 September 1928.

31. Religious Bodies: 1926, 2:998; The Star of Zion, 25 November 1920, 14 March 1929; Ransom, Reverdy C., The Pilgrimage of Harriet Ransom's Son (Nashville, n.d.), p. 262;Google Scholar Wright, , Bishops, pp. 165, 169.Google Scholar

32. Bradley, p. 359; Walls, p. 475.

33. The Christian Index, 23 September 1920; Butler, Jon, “Communities and Congregations: The Black Church in St. Paul, 1860–1900,” Journal of Negro History 56 (1971): 122.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

34. Wright, , ed., Encyclopedia, pp. 376–377.Google Scholar The members of Murphy AME Church in Chester raised money “to compensate Bishop Caldwell for what equity he had in the… building” (ibid., p. 377).

35. Souvenir Program, Mortgage Burning Celebration, 1–9 July 1946, Holliday Memorial AME Zion Church, Braddock, Pa. (Courtesy of Rev. T. B. Thornhill).