No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
Unbiddable Pasts
Review products
GuyBeiner, Forgetful Remembrance: Social Forgetting and Vernacular Historiography of a Rebellion in Ulster (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2018), pp. 707. ISBN 978-0198749356.
JonathanEvershed, Ghosts of the Somme: Commemoration and Culture War in Northern Ireland (Notre Dame, IND: University of Notre Dame Press, 2018), pp. 294. ISBN 978-0268103859.
Richard S.Grayson and FearghalMcGarry, eds., Remembering 1916: The Easter Rising, the Somme and the Politics of Memory in Ireland (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2016), pp. 274. ISBN 978-1316509272.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 27 September 2022
Extract
At the Ulster Museum in Belfast two artefacts connect the momentous events of 1916 with the thirty years of conflict in Northern Ireland brought to an end by the Good Friday Agreement in 1998. One piece is the work of republican prisoners interned aboard HMS Maidstone in the Belfast docks in the early 1970s: a plaque, signed by its creators, bearing a portrait of the only socialist among the leaders of the Easter Rising in Dublin, James Connolly. The other is a painting by Gusty Spence, the founder of the modern loyalist paramilitary group, the Ulster Volunteer Force. It commemorates the Battle of the Somme: two soldiers in silhouette, bugles to their lips, on either side of a standard bearing the words ‘In Immortal Memory’, a reference to the 5,000 troops from the 36th Ulster Division who were killed or injured going over the top on 1 July 1916. These two objects not only bring home the importance of history and memory to the paramilitaries who fought each other during the Troubles but also point to how the story of the modern conflict is already being crafted for current political debates and future generations. As William Blair writes, the greatest challenge for the Ulster Museum in the near future will not be remembrance of the battles of a century ago but ‘dealing with the difficult and divisive legacy of “the Troubles”’.1 This is also an issue which historians have already begun to confront, often through their contributions to the debates surrounding the so-called ‘Decade of Centenaries’, stretching from the Home Rule crisis of 1912 to the end of the Irish revolution in 1923. These five books deal with the politics of memory in Ireland generally, and Northern Ireland in particular, and how memorialisation of traumatic events – official, unofficial and private – has shaped both the public sphere and the hidden recesses of everyday life. Two almost simultaneous events from 1916 – the Easter Rising in Dublin and the Battle of the Somme – have acquired extraordinary resonance in the contemporary politics of memory in Northern Ireland.
- Type
- Review Article
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © The Author(s), 2022. Published by Cambridge University Press
References
1 Blair, William, ‘Myth, Memory and Material Culture: Remembering 1916 at the Ulster Museum’, in Grayson, Richard and McGarry, Fearghal, eds., Remembering 1916: The Easter Rising, the Somme and the Politics of Memory in Ireland (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2016), 181–2CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
2 Roisin Higgins, ‘“The Irish Republic Was Proclaimed by Poster”: The Politics of Commemorating the Easter Rising’, in Grayson and McGarry, eds., Remembering 1916, 43.
3 Evershed, Jonathan, Ghosts of the Somme: Commemoration and Culture War in Northern Ireland (Notre Dame IND: University of Notre Dame Press, 2018), 10CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
4 Beiner, Guy, ‘Between Trauma and Triumphalism: The Easter Rising, the Somme, and the Crux of Deep Memory in Modern Ireland’, Journal of British Studies, 46, 2 (2007), 382CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
5 McBride, Ian, ‘The Truth About the Troubles’, in Smyth, Jim, ed., Remembering the Troubles: Contesting the Recent Past in Northern Ireland (Notre Dame IND: University of Notre Dame Press, 2017), 13Google Scholar.
6 Viggiani, Elizabeth, Talking Stones: The Politics of Memorialization in Post-Conflict Northern Ireland (New York; Oxford: Berghahn Books, 2016), 75Google Scholar.
7 Ibid., 145.
8 Ibid., 6.
9 Ibid., 195.
10 Ibid., 83.
11 Ibid., 181.
12 Ibid., 94.
13 Ibid., 201.
14 Robinson, Joseph S., Transitional Justice and the Politics of Inscription: Memory, Space and Narrative in Northern Ireland (Abingdon and New York: Routledge, 2018), 199Google Scholar.
15 Ibid., 23.
16 Ibid., 25.
17 Ibid., 63.
18 Ibid., 88.
19 Ibid., 127.
20 Ibid., 89.
21 Ibid., 169.
22 Ibid., 204.
23 Ibid., 170.
24 Ibid., 188.
25 Evershed, Ghosts of the Somme, 11.
26 Ibid., 139–43.
27 Ibid., 96.
28 Ibid., 89.
29 Ibid., 55.
30 Ibid., 212–4.
31 Ibid., 108.
32 Ibid., 205.
33 Ibid., 214.
34 Ibid., 83.
35 Ibid., 24.
36 Quoted in Kevin Bean, ‘New Roads to the Rising: the Irish Politics of Commemoration Since 1994’, in Grayson and McGarry, eds., Remembering 1916, 234.
37 Grayson, Richard, ‘The Place of the First World War in Contemporary Irish Republicanism in Northern Ireland’, Irish Political Studies, 25, 3 (2010), 342CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
38 Ibid., 234.
39 Evershed, Ghosts of the Somme, 79.
40 Ibid., 13.
41 Ibid., 12.
42 The Irish Times, 28 June and 2 July 1966.
43 Margaret O'Callaghan, ‘The Past Never Stands Still: Commemorating the Easter Rising ibn 1966 and 1976’, in Smyth, ed., Remembering the Troubles, 124–7.
44 Roisin Higgins, ‘“The Irish Republic was Proclaimed by Poster”: the Politics of Commemorating the Easter Rising’, in Grayson and McGarry, eds., Remembering 1916, 57.
45 Conor Cruise O'Brien, States of Ireland (London: Hutchinson, 1972), 150–1.
46 Moody, T.W. ‘Irish History and Irish Mythology’, in Brady, Ciaran, ed., Interpreting Irish History: The Debate on Historical Revisionism 1938–1994 (Dublin: Irish Academic Press, 1994), 86Google Scholar.
47 Rosenfeld, Gavriel D., ‘A Looming Crash or a Soft Landing? Forecasting the Future of the Memory “Industry”’, The Journal of Modern History, 81 (2009), 122–58CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
48 Guy Beiner, ‘Making Sense of Memory: Coming to Terms with Conceptualisations of Historical Remembrance’, in Grayson and McGarry, eds., Remembering 1916, 13.
49 Beiner, Guy, Forgetful Remembrance: Social Forgetting and Vernacular Historiography of a Rebellion in Ulster (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2018), 145CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
50 Ibid., 247.
51 Ibid., 357.
52 Ibid., 452.
53 Ibid., 503.
54 Ibid., 544–5.
55 Ibid., 27.
56 Ibid., 28–9.
57 Ibid., 291.
58 Ibid., 238.
59 Ibid., 496.
60 Ibid., 14.
61 Ibid., 282.
62 Ibid., 512–4.
63 Ibid., 226–38.
64 Ibid., 494.
65 Ibid., 16.
66 Ibid., 13.
67 Ibid., 30.
68 Moody, ‘Irish History and Irish Mythology’, 86.
69 Beiner, Forgetful Remembrance, 24–5.
70 Evershed, Ghosts of the Somme, 77–83.
71 Ibid., 72.
72 Dominic Bryan, ‘Ritual, Identity and Nation: When the Historian Becomes the High Priest of Commemoration’, in Grayson and McGarry, eds., Remembering 1916, 39.
73 Ibid., 40.
74 Beiner, ‘Between Trauma and Triumphalism’, 377.
75 Robinson, Transitional Justice, 204.
76 Viggiani, Talking Stones, 10.
77 Beiner, Forgetful Remembrance, 605.