Skip to main content
×
Home
    • Aa
    • Aa

Allies, not aliens: increasing the role of local communities in marine protected area implementation

  • SEBASTIAN C.A. FERSE (a1), MARÍA MÁÑEZ COSTA (a2), KATHLEEN SCHWERDTNER MÁÑEZ (a1), DEDI S. ADHURI (a3) and MARION GLASER (a1)...
Abstract
SUMMARY

Various management approaches have been proposed to address the alarming depletion of marine coastal resources. Prominent among them are community-based management and the establishment of marine protected areas (MPAs). The overall poor performance of MPAs can be traced to a failure to effectively include local communities in the design and implementation of relevant measures. Recent efforts have incorporated aspects of community-based management into a hybrid form of management, which ideally builds upon existing local management practices. A key challenge lies in the development of appropriate frameworks that allow for the successful participation of local communities in management. A review of studies on MPA design and community-based marine resource management and fieldwork observations provides suggestions on how to address current socioeconomic shortcomings in MPA design and implementation, successfully involving local communities in order to provide a better local basis for effective larger MPA networks. A combination of MPA tools as the formal frame and community-based natural resource management as the adaptive core that recognizes local communities as allies, not aliens, is needed to develop successful conservation approaches.

Copyright
Corresponding author
*Correspondence: Dr Sebastian Ferse Tel: +49 421 2380028 Fax: +49 421 2380030 e-mail: sebastian.ferse@zmt-bremen.de
Linked references
Hide All

This list contains references from the content that can be linked to their source. For a full set of references and notes please see the PDF or HTML where available.

D. Adhuri (2004) The incident in west monsoon. Marine tenure and the politics of village leadership in Maluku, Eastern Indonesia. Maritime Anthropological Studies (MAST) 3: 523.

T. Agardy , P. Bridgewater , M.P. Crosby , J. Day , P.K. Dayton , R. Kenchington , D. Laffoley , P. McConney , P.A. Murray , J.E. Parks & L. Peau (2003) Dangerous targets? Unresolved issues and ideological clashes around marine protected areas. Aquatic Conservation: Marine and Freshwater Ecosystems 13: 353367.

A. Agrawal & C.C. Gibson (1999) Enchantment and disenchantment: the role of community in natural resource conservation. World Development 27: 629649.

A.C. Alcala & G.R. Russ (2006) No-take marine reserves and reef fisheries management in the Philippines: a new people power revolution. Ambio 35: 245254.

G.R. Almany , S.R. Connolly , D.D. Heath , J.D. Hogan , G.P. Jones , L.J. McCook , M. Mills , R.L. Pressey & D.H. Williamson (2009) Connectivity, biodiversity conservation and the design of marine reserve networks for coral reefs. Coral Reefs 28: 339351.

E.C. Amar , R.M.T. Cheong & M.V.T. Cheong (1996) Small-scale fisheries of coral reefs and the need for community-based resource management in Malalison Island, Philippines. Fisheries Research 25: 265277.

D. Armitage (2005) Adaptive capacity and community-based natural resource management. Environmental Management 35: 703715.

S. Aswani & M. Lauer (2006) Incorporating fishermen's local knowledge and behaviour into Geographical Information Systems (GIS) for designing marine protected areas in Oceania. Human Organization 65: 81102.

O. Barreteau , P. Garin , A. Dumontier , G. Abrami & F. Cernesson (2003) Agent-based facilitation of water allocation: case study in the Drome River Valley. Group Decision and Negotiation 12: 441461.

C.Y. Bartlett & C. Manua (2009) Community sea tenure and the establishment of marine reserve networks in the Pacific islands. Proceedings of the 11th International Coral Reef Symposium, Ft. Lauderdale, Florida, 7–11 July 2008: 1069–1073 [www document]. URL http://www.nova.edu/ncri/11icrs/proceedings/files/m23-02.pdf#zoom=100

C.Y. Bartlett , C. Manua , J. Cinner , S. Sutton , R. Jimmy , R. South , J. Nilsson & J. Raina (2010) Comparison of outcomes of permanently closed and periodically harvested coral reef reserves. Conservation Biology DOI 10.1111/j.1523-1739.2009.01293.x (in press).

G. Bennett , J. Fry , A.M. González & S. Zilberman (2006) Understanding and acceptance of conservation: analyzing perceptions of local communities in the Berau Marine Protected Area, Indonesia. Final Capstone Report. International Development Studies, Elliott School of International Affairs, George Washington University, Washington, DC, USA.

F. Berkes (2004) Rethinking community-based conservation. Conservation Biology 18: 621630.

F. Berkes (2007) Community-based conservation in a globalized world. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA 104: 1518815193.

F. Berkes (2009) Community conserved areas: policy issues in historic and contemporary context. Conservation Letters 2: 1924.

F. Berkes & N.J. Turner (2006) Knowledge, learning and the evolution of conservation practice for social-ecological system resilience. Human Ecology 34: 479494.

F. Berkes , J. Colding & C. Folke (2000) Rediscovery of traditional ecological knowledge as adaptive management. Ecological Applications 10: 12511262.

F. Berkes , T.P. Hughes , R.S. Steneck , J.A. Wilson , D.R. Bellwood , B. Crona , C. Folke , I.H. Gunderson , H.M. Leslie , J. Norberg , M. Nyström , P. Olsson , H. Österblom , M. Scheffer & B. Worm (2006) Globalization, roving bandits, and marine resources. Science 311: 15571558.

P. Blaikie (2006) Is small really beautiful? Community-based natural resource management in Malawi and Botswana. World Development 34: 19421957.

L. Burke , E. Selig & M. Spalding , eds (2002) Reefs at Risk in Southeast Asia. Washington, DC, USA: World Resources Institute (WRI).

P. Christie (2004) MPAs as biological successes and social failures in southeast Asia. In: Aquatic Protected Areas as Fisheries Management Tools: Design, Use, and Evaluation of These Fully Protected Areas, ed. J.B. Shipley , pp. 155164. Bethesda, MD, USA: American Fisheries Society.

P. Christie & A.T. White (1997) Trends in development of coastal area management in tropical countries: from central to community orientation. Coastal Management 25: 155181.

P. Christie , D.L. Fluharty , A.T. White , L. Eisma-Osorio & W. Jatulan (2007) Assessing the feasibility of ecosystem-based fisheries management in tropical contexts. Marine Policy 31: 239250.

P. Christie , R.B. Pollnac , E.G. Oracion , A. Sabonsolin , R. Diaz & D. Pietri (2009) Back to basics: an empirical study demonstrating the importance of local-level dynamics for the success of tropical marine ecosystem-based management. Coastal Management 37: 349373.

J.E. Cinner (2005) Socioeconomic factors influencing customary marine tenure in the Indo-Pacific. Ecology and Society 10 (1): 36.

J.E. Cinner (2007) Designing marine reserves to reflect local socioeconomic conditions: lessons from long-enduring customary management systems. Coral Reefs 26: 10351045.

J.E. Cinner & S. Aswani (2007) Integrating customary management into marine conservation. Biological Conservation 140: 201216.

J.E. Cinner , A. Wamukota , H. Randriamahazo & A. Rabearisoa (2009 a) Toward institutions for community-based management of inshore marine resources in the Western Indian Ocean. Marine Policy 33: 489496.

J.E. Cinner , T. Daw & T.R. McClanahan (2009 b) Socioeconomic factors that affect artisanal fishers’ readiness to exit a declining fishery. Conservation Biology 23: 124130.

F. Cleaver (1999) Paradoxes of participation: questioning participatory approaches to development. Journal of International Development 11: 597612.

J. Clifton (2003) Prospects for co-management in Indonesia's marine protected areas. Marine Policy 27: 389395.

B.R. Crawford , A. Siahainenia , C. Rotinsulu & A. Sukmara (2004) Compliance and enforcement of community-based coastal resource management regulations in North Sulawesi, Indonesia. Coastal Management 32: 3950.

K. Daniell (2008) Co-ingénierie des processus de modélisation participative pour la planification et la gestion de l'eau. Ph.D. thesis, Cemagref UMR G-EAU, AgroParistech, Montpellier, France.

D.M. De Freitas & P.R.A. Tagliani (2009) The use of GIS for the integration of traditional and scientific knowledge in supporting artisanal fisheries management in southern Brazil. Journal of Environmental Management 90: 20712080.

J.A. Drew (2005) Use of traditional ecological knowledge in marine conservation. Conservation Biology 19: 12861293.

N. Dudley , ed (2008) Guidelines for Applying Protected Area Management Categories. Gland, Switzerland: IUCN.

R. Few (2000) Conservation, participation, and power: protected-area planning in the coastal zone of Belize. Journal of Planning Education and Research 19: 401408.

S. Foale (1998) Assessment and management of the Trochus Fishery at West Nggela, Solomon Islands: an interdisciplinary approach. Ocean and Coastal Management 40: 187205.

S. Foale (2002) Commensurability of scientific and indigenous ecological knowledge in coastal Melanesia: implications for contemporary marine resource management strategies. Resource Management in Asia-Pacific Working Paper 38, Resource Management in Asia-Pacific Program, Research School for Pacific and Asian Studies, The Australian National University, Canberra, Australia.

S. Foale & B. Manele (2004) Social and political barriers to the use of Marine Protected Areas for conservation and fishery management in Melanesia. Asia Pacific Viewpoint 45. 373386.

C. Folke , T. Hahn , P. Olsson & J. Norberg (2005) Adaptive governance of social-ecological systems. Annual Review of Environment and Resources 30: 441473.

J. Fraga & A. Jesus (2008) Coastal and Marine Protected Areas in Mexico. SAMUDRA Monograph. Chennai, India: International Collective in Support of Fishworkers (ICSF).

J. Francis , A. Nilsson & D. Waruinge (2002) Marine protected areas in the eastern African region: how successful are they? Ambio 31: 503511.

M. Gadgil , P.R. Seshagiri Rao , G. Utkarsh , P. Pramod , A. Chhatre & Members of the People's Biodiversity Initiative (2000) New meanings for old knowledge: the people's biodiversity registers program. Ecological Applications 10: 13071317.

S. Gelcich , G. Edwards-Jones , M.J. Kaiser & J.C. Castilla (2006) Co-management policy can reduce resilience in traditionally managed ecosystems. Ecosystems 9: 951966.

M. Glaser & R. da Silva Oliveira (2004) The prospects for co-management of mangrove ecosystems on the North Brazilian coast: whose rights, whose duties and whose priorities? Natural Resources Forum 28: 224233.

H. Govan , W. Aalbersberg , A. Tawake & J. Parks (2008) Locally-Managed Marine Areas: A Guide for Practicioners. The Locally-Managed Marine Area Network [www document]. URL http://lmmanetwork.org/Site_Documents/Grouped/LMMAGuide.pdf

S.J. Hall (2009) Area and time restrictions. In: A Fishery Manager's Guidebook. Second edition, ed. K.L. Cochrane & S.M. Garcia , pp. 196219. Oxford, UK: Wiley-Blackwell and Rome, Italy: FAO.

B.S. Halpern (2003) The impact of marine reserves: do reserves work and does reserve size matter? Ecological Applications 13 (Suppl.): 117137.

D. Henley (2008) Natural resource management: historical lessons from Indonesia. Human Ecology 36: 273290.

A.H. Himes (2007) Performance indicators in MPA management: using questionnaires to analyze stakeholder preferences. Ocean and Coastal Management 50: 329351.

ICEM (2003) Lessons Learned From Global Experience. Review of Protected Areas and Development in the Lower Mekong River Region. Indooroopilly, Queensland, Australia: International Centre for Environmental Management (ICEM).

ISRS (2004) Marine protected areas (MPAs) in management of coral reefs. Briefing Paper 1. International Society for Reef Studies. [www document]. URL http://research2.fit.edu/isrs/Press%20releases/ISRS%20Briefing%20Paper%201%20-%20MPAs.pdf

IUCN-WCPA (2008) Establishing Marine Protected Area Networks. Making It Happen. Washington, DC, USA: IUCN-WCPA, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration and The Nature Conservancy.

R.E. Johannes (1978) Traditional marine conservation methods in Oceania and their demise. Annual Review of Ecological Systems 9: 349364.

R.E. Johannes (1998) The case for data-less marine resource management: examples from tropical nearshore finfisheries. TRENDS in Evolution and Ecology 13: 243246.

R.E. Johannes (2002) The renaissance of community-based marine resource management in Oceania. Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics 33: 317–40.

G. Kelleher (1999) Guidelines for Marine Protected Areas. Gland, Switzerland and Cambridge, UK: IUCN.

G. Krause & M. Glaser (2003) Co-evolving geomorphic and socio-economic dynamics in a coastal fishing village of the Bragança region (Pará, North Brazil). Ocean and Coastal Management 46: 850874.

M. Leach , R. Mearns & I. Scoones (1999) Environmental entitlements: dynamics and institutions in community-based natural resource management. World Development 27: 225247.

G.K. Lowry , A.T. White & P. Christie (2009) Scaling up to networks of marine protected areas in the Philippines: biophysical, legal, institutional, and social considerations. Coastal Management 37: 274290.

R.J. Maliao , R.S. Pomeroy & R.G. Turingan (2009) Performance of community-based coastal resource management (CBCRM) programs in the Philippines: a meta-analysis. Marine Policy 33: 818825.

M.B. Mascia (2003) The human dimension of coral reef marine protected areas: recent social science research and its policy implications. Conservation Biology 17: 630632.

T.R. McClanahan (1999) Is there a future for coral reef parks in poor tropical countries? Coral Reefs 18: 321325.

T.R. McClanahan & J.E. Cinner (2008) A framework for adaptive gear and ecosystem-based management in the artisanal coral reef fishery of Papua New Guinea. Aquatic Conservation: Marine and Freshwater Ecosystems 18: 493507.


T.R. McClanahan , M.J. Marnane , J.E. Cinner & W.E. Kiene (2006) A comparison of marine protected areas and alternative approaches to coral-reef management. Current Biology 16: 14081413.

C. Mora , S. Andréfouët , M.J. Costello , C. Kranenburg , A. Rollo , J.E.N. Veron , K.J. Gaston & R.A. Myers (2006) Coral reefs and the global network of marine protected areas. Science 312: 17501751.

R.N. Mwaipopo (2008) The Social Dimensions of Marine Protected Areas: a Case Study of the Mafia Island Marine Park in Tanzania. SAMUDRA Monograph. Chennai, India: International Collective in Support of Fishworkers (ICSF).

P. Olsson , C. Folke & F. Berkes (2004) Adaptive comanagement for building resilience in social-ecological systems. Environmental Management 34: 7590.

E.G. Oracion , M.L. Miller & P. Christie (2005) Marine protected areas for whom? Fisheries, tourism, and solidarity in a Philippine community. Ocean and Coastal Management 48: 393410.


D. Pietri , P. Christie , R.B. Pollnac , R. Diaz & A. Sabonsolin (2009) Information diffusion in two marine protected area networks in the Central Visayas Region, Philippines. Coastal Management 37: 331348.

R.B. Pollnac , B.R. Crawford & M.L.G. Gorospe (2001 a) Discovering factors that influence the success of community-based marine protected areas in the Visayas, Philippines. Ocean and Coastal Management 44: 683710.

R.B. Pollnac , R.S. Pomeroy & I.H.T. Harkes (2001b) Fishery policy and job satisfaction in three southeast Asian fisheries. Ocean & Coastal Management 44: 531544.

R.S. Pomeroy (1995) Community-based and co-management institutions for sustainable coastal fisheries management in southeast Asia. Ocean and Coastal Management 27: 143162.

R.S. Pomeroy & K.K. Viswanathan (2003) Experiences with fisheries co-management in Southeast Asia and Bangladesh. In: The Fisheries Co-management Eexperience, eds. D.C. Wilson , J.R. Nielsen & P. Degnbol , pp. 99117. Dordrecht, the Netherlands.

R.S. Pomeroy , B.M. Katon & I.H.T. Harkes (2001) Conditions affecting the success of fisheries co-management: lessons from Asia. Marine Policy 25: 197208.

R.S. Pomeroy , J.E. Parks & L.M. Watson , eds (2004) How is your MPA doing? A Guidebook of Natural and Social Indicators for Evaluating Marine Protected Area Management Effectiveness. Gland, Switzerland and Cambridge, UK: IUCN.

C. Reichel , U.U. Frömming & M. Glaser (2009) Conflicts between stakeholder groups affecting the ecology and economy of the Segara Anakan region. Regional Environmental Change 9: 335343.

J.C. Ribot & N.L. Peluso (2003) A theory of access. Rural Sociology 68: 153181.

K. Ruddle (1994) A Guide to the Literature on Traditional Community-based Fishery Management in the Asia-Pacific Tropics. FAO Fisheries Circular 869. Rome, Italy: FAO.

G.R. Russ & A.C. Alcala (2004) Marine reserves: long-term protection is required for full recovery of predatory fish populations. Oecologia 138: 622627.

G.R. Russ , A.C. Alcala , A.P. Maypa , H.P. Calumpong & A.T. White (2004) Marine reserve benefits local fisheries. Ecological Applications 14: 597606.

L.M. Ruttan (1998) Closing the commons: cooperation for gain or restraint? Human Ecology 26: 4366.

P.F. Sale (2008) Management of coral reefs: where we have gone wrong and what we can do about it. Marine Pollution Bulletin 56: 805809.

P.F. Sale , R.K. Cowen , B.S. Danilowicz , G.P. Jones , J.P. Kritzer , K.C. Lindeman , S. Planes , N.V.C. Polunin , G.R. Russ , Y.J. Sadovy & R.S. Steneck (2005) Critical science gaps impede use of no-take fishery reserves. TRENDS in Ecology and Evolution 20: 7480.

H.T. Sandersen & S. Koester (2000) Co-management of tropical coastal zones: the case of the Soufriere Marine Management Area, St. Lucia, WI. Coastal Management 28: 8797.

H. Scales , A. Balmford , M. Liu , Y.J. Sadovy & A. Manica (2006) Keeping bandits at bay? Science 313: 612613.

S.V. Siar , R.F. Agbayani & J.B. Valera (1992) Acceptability of territorial use rights in fisheries: towards community-based management of small-scale fisheries in the Philippines. Fisheries Research 14: 295304.

L. Sievanen , B. Crawford , C. Pollnac & C. Lowe (2005) Weeding through assumptions of livelihood approaches in ICM: seaweed farming in the Philippines and Indonesia. Ocean and Coastal Management 48: 297313.

L.T.L. Simonian & M. Glaser (2002) Extractive reserves and the question of sustainability: recent experiences in north of Brazil. In: Neotropical Ecosystems. Proceedings of the German-Brazilian Workshop, Hamburg 2000, ed. R. Lieberei , H.K. Bianchi , V. Boehm & C. Reisdorff , pp. 767776. Geesthacht, Germany: GKSS.

S. Singleton (2009) Native people and planning for marine protected areas: how ‘stakeholder’ processes fail to address conflicts in complex, real-world environments. Coastal Management 37: 421440.

J. Sunde & M. Isaacs (2008) Marine Conservation and Coastal Communities: Who Carries the Costs? A Study of Marine Protected Areas and Their Impact on Traditional Small-scale Fishing Communities in South Africa. SAMUDRA Monograph. Chennai, India: International Collective in Support of Fishworkers (ICSF).

C.-L. Tam (2007) Harmony hurts: participation and silent conflict at an Indonesian fish pond. Environmental Management 38: 115.

UNEP (2004) People and Reefs: Successes and Challenges in the Management of Coral Reef Marine Protected Areas. UNEP Regional Seas Reports and Studies 176. Nairobi, Kenya: UNEP.

E.L. Venstra (2007) Consequences of fisheries catch and effort allocation for the design of a marine protected area in Berau, East-Kalimantan, Indonesia. M.Sc. thesis, Wageningen University and Research Center, Wageningen, the Netherlands.

P. West , J. Igoe & D. Brockington (2006) Parks and peoples: the social impact of protected areas. Annual Review of Anthropology 35: 251277.

A.T. White , C.A. Courtney , & A. Salamanca (2002) Experience with marine protected area planning and management in the Philippines. Coastal Management 30: 126.


P.R. Wilshusen , S.R. Brechin , C.L. Fortwangler & P.C. West (2002) Reinventing a square wheel: critique of a resurgent ‘protection paradigm’ in international biodiversity conservation. Society and Natural Resources 15: 1740.

World Bank (1996) Participation Sourcebook. Washington, DC, USA: World Bank.

Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Environmental Conservation
  • ISSN: 0376-8929
  • EISSN: 1469-4387
  • URL: /core/journals/environmental-conservation
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Keywords: