Skip to main content
    • Aa
    • Aa
  • Get access
    Check if you have access via personal or institutional login
  • Cited by 91
  • Cited by
    This article has been cited by the following publications. This list is generated based on data provided by CrossRef.

    Shrestha, K.K. and Ojha, H.R. 2017. Redefining Diversity and Dynamics of Natural Resources Management in Asia, Volume 1.

    Addison, Jane 2016. The Predictive Value of Resource Defence Theory in Understanding Resource User Responses to Climatic Variability: Implications for the Viability of Institutions in a Resource Dependent Context. Human Ecology, Vol. 44, Issue. 2, p. 137.

    Benham, Claudia 2016. Change, opportunity and grief: Understanding the complex social-ecological impacts of Liquefied Natural Gas development in the Australian coastal zone. Energy Research & Social Science, Vol. 14, p. 61.

    Budiharta, Sugeng Meijaard, Erik Wells, Jessie A. Abram, Nicola K. and Wilson, Kerrie A. 2016. Enhancing feasibility: Incorporating a socio-ecological systems framework into restoration planning. Environmental Science & Policy, Vol. 64, p. 83.

    Cumming, Graeme S. 2016. Heterarchies: Reconciling Networks and Hierarchies. Trends in Ecology & Evolution, Vol. 31, Issue. 8, p. 622.

    Deepananda, K.H.M. Ashoka Amarasinghe, Upali S. and Jayasinghe-Mudalige, Udith K. 2016. Neither bust nor boom: Institutional robustness in the beach seine fishery of southern Sri Lanka. Ocean & Coastal Management, Vol. 128, p. 61.

    Dyckman, Caitlin S. 2016. Sustaining the Commons: The Coercive to Cooperative, Resilient, and Adaptive Nature of State Comprehensive Water Planning Legislation. Journal of the American Planning Association, Vol. 82, Issue. 4, p. 327.

    Foster, Tim and Hope, Rob 2016. A multi-decadal and social-ecological systems analysis of community waterpoint payment behaviours in rural Kenya. Journal of Rural Studies, Vol. 47, p. 85.

    Gillet, Pauline Llavina, Elisabet Codina Yambene, Henri and Vermeulen, Cédric 2016. Comment les villageois nomment-ils et s’approprient-ils leurs espaces ressources ? Description d’un socio-écosystème en pays Yambassa, Cameroun. Cahiers Agricultures, Vol. 25, Issue. 4, p. 45006.

    Jones, L. Norton, L. Austin, Z. Browne, A.L. Donovan, D. Emmett, B.A. Grabowski, Z.J Howard, D.C. Jones, J.P.G. Kenter, J.O Manley, W. Morris, C. Robinson, D.A. Short, C. Siriwardena, G.M. Stevens, C.J. Storkey, J. Waters, R.D. and Willis, G.F. 2016. Stocks and flows of natural and human-derived capital in ecosystem services. Land Use Policy, Vol. 52, p. 151.

    Khan, Tehmina 2016. Handbook of Environmental and Sustainable Finance.

    KimDung, Nguyen Bush, Simon and Mol, Arthur 2016. The Vietnamese State and Administrative Co-Management of Nature Reserves. Sustainability, Vol. 8, Issue. 3, p. 292.

    Loring, Philip A. 2016. Toward a Theory of Coexistence in Shared Social-Ecological Systems: The Case of Cook Inlet Salmon Fisheries. Human Ecology, Vol. 44, Issue. 2, p. 153.

    Luederitz, Christopher Schäpke, Niko Wiek, Arnim Lang, Daniel J. Bergmann, Matthias Bos, Joannette J. Burch, Sarah Davies, Anna Evans, James König, Ariane Farrelly, Megan A. Forrest, Nigel Frantzeskaki, Niki Gibson, Robert B. Kay, Braden Loorbach, Derk McCormick, Kes Parodi, Oliver Rauschmayer, Felix Schneidewind, Uwe Stauffacher, Michael Stelzer, Franziska Trencher, Gregory Venjakob, Johannes Vergragt, Philip J. von Wehrden, Henrik and Westley, Frances R. 2016. Learning through evaluation – A tentative evaluative scheme for sustainability transition experiments. Journal of Cleaner Production,

    McClanahan, T.R. and Rankin, P.S. 2016. Geography of conservation spending, biodiversity, and culture. Conservation Biology, Vol. 30, Issue. 5, p. 1089.

    McCord, Paul Dell'Angelo, Jampel Baldwin, Elizabeth and Evans, Tom 2016. Polycentric Transformation in Kenyan Water Governance: A Dynamic Analysis of Institutional and Social-Ecological Change. Policy Studies Journal,

    Mogende, Emmanuel and Kolawole, Oluwatoyin 2016. Dynamics of local governance in natural resource conservation in the Okavango Delta, Botswana. Natural Resources Forum, Vol. 40, Issue. 3, p. 93.

    Nkemnyi, Mbunya Francis De Herdt, Tom Chuyong, George B. and Vanwing, Tom 2016. The influence of institutions on access to forest resources in Cameroon: The case of Tofala Hill Wildlife Sanctuary. Journal for Nature Conservation, Vol. 34, p. 42.

    Orach, Kirill and Schlüter, Maja 2016. Uncovering the political dimension of social-ecological systems: Contributions from policy process frameworks. Global Environmental Change, Vol. 40, p. 13.

    Partelow, Stefan 2016. Coevolving Ostrom’s social–ecological systems (SES) framework and sustainability science: four key co-benefits. Sustainability Science, Vol. 11, Issue. 3, p. 399.


Moving beyond panaceas: a multi-tiered diagnostic approach for social-ecological analysis

  • DOI:
  • Published online: 25 November 2010

Disturbances to key aspects of ecological systems, including biodiversity loss, climate change, pollution and natural resource degradation, have become a major concern to many policy analysts. Instead of learning from the study of biological complexity however, social scientists tend to recommend simple panaceas, particularly government or private ownership, as ‘the’ way to solve these problems. This paper reviews and assesses potential solutions for such overly simplified institutional prescriptions, referred to here as the ‘panacea problem’. In contrast to these simple prescriptions, recent research efforts are now illustrating the diversity of institutions around the world related to environmental conservation. The complexity of working institutions, however, presents a challenge to scholars who equate scientific knowledge with relatively simple models that predict optimal performance if specific institutional arrangements are in place. Dealing with this complexity has led to the development of frameworks as meta-theoretical tools. The institutional analysis and development (IAD) framework has been used over the last three decades as a foundation for a focused analysis of how institutions affect human incentives, actions and outcomes. Building on this foundation, the social-ecological systems (SES) framework has recently enabled researchers to begin the development of a common language that crosses social and ecological disciplines to analyse how interactions among a variety of factors affect outcomes. Such a framework may be able to facilitate a diagnostic approach that will help future analysts overcome the panacea problem. Using a common framework to diagnose the source, and possible amelioration, of poor outcomes for ecological and human systems enables a much finer understanding of these complex systems than has so far been obtained, and provides a basis for comparisons among many systems and ultimately more responsible policy prescriptions.

Corresponding author
*Correspondence: Dr Elinor Ostrom Tel: +1 812 855 0441 Fax: +1 812 855 3150 assistant's e-mail:
Linked references
Hide All

This list contains references from the content that can be linked to their source. For a full set of references and notes please see the PDF or HTML where available.

A. Agrawal (2003) Sustainable governance of common-pool resources: context, methods, and politics. Annual Review of Anthropology 32: 234262.

A. Agrawal , A. Chhatre & R. Hardin (2008) Changing governance of the world's forests. Science 320: 14601462.

K. Andersson , C. Gibson & F. Lehoucq (2006) Municipal politics and forest governance: comparative analysis of decentralization in Bolivia and Guatemala. World Development 34 (3): 576595.

D. Armitage , F. Berkes & N. Doubleday , eds (2007) Adaptive Co-Management: Collaboration, Learning and Multi-Level Governance. Vancouver, Canada: University of British Columbia Press.

A.Y. Banana , N. Vogt , J. Bahati & W. Gombya-Ssembajjwe (2007) Decentralized governance and ecological health: why local institutions fail to moderate deforestation in Mpigi District of Uganda. Scientific Research and Essays 2 (10): 434445.

C.B. Barrett , K. Brandon , C. Gibson & H. Gjertsen (2001) Conserving tropical biodiversity amid weak institutions. Bioscience 51: 497502.

M. Batistella , S. Robeson & E.F. Moran (2003) Settlement design, forest fragmentation, and landscape change in Rondônia, Amazônia. Photogrammetric Engineering and Remote Sensing 69 (7): 805812.

F. Berkes (2007) Community-based conservation in a globalized world. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 104 (39): 1518815193.

F. Berkes & C. Folke (1998) Linking Social and Ecological Systems: Management Practices and Social Mechanisms for Building Resilience. Cambridge, MA, USA: Cambridge University Press.

F. Berkes & N.J. Turner (2006) Knowledge, learning and the evolution of conservation practice for social-ecological system resilience. Human Ecology 34 (4): 479494.

P. Blaikie (2006) Is small really beautiful? Community-based natural resource management in Malawi and Botswana. World Development 34 (11): 19421957.

J.A. Brander & M. Scott Taylor (1998) Open access renewable resources: trade and trade policy in a two-country model. Journal of International Economics 44: 181209.

W.A. Brock & S.R. Carpenter (2007) Panaceas and diversification of environmental policy. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 104 (39): 1520615211.

D. Brunckhorst , I. Reeve , P. Morley & K. Bock (2008) Strategic spatial governance: deriving social–ecological frameworks for managing landscapes and regions. In: Landscape Analysis and Visualisation: Spatial Models for Natural Resource Management and Planning, ed. C. Pettit , W. Cartwright , I. Bishop , K. Lowell , D. Pullar & D. Duncan , pp. 253276. Berlin, Germany: Springer.

M.W. Brunson & L. Huntsinger (2008) Ranching as a conservation strategy: can old ranchers save the new west? Rangeland Ecology and Management 61 (2): 137147.

B.M. Campbell , I.J. Gordon , M.K. Luckert , L. Petheram & S. Vetter (2006) In search of optimal stocking regimes in semi-arid grazing lands: one size does not fit all. Ecological Economics 60 (1): 7585.

J.G. Canadell & M.R. Raupach (2008) Managing forests for climate change mitigation. Science 320: 14561457.

L. Carlsson & F. Berkes (2005) Co-management: concepts and methodological implications. Journal of Environmental Management 75: 6576.

D.W Cash , W.C. Clark , F. Alcock , N.M. Dickson , N. Eckley , D.H. Guston , J. Jager & R.B. Mitchell (2003) Knowledge systems for sustainable development. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 100 (14): 80868091.

A. Chhatre & A. Agrawal (2008) Forest commons and local enforcement. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 105 (36): 1328613291.

F. Cleaver (1999) Paradoxes of participation: questioning participatory approaches to development. Journal of International Development 11: 597612.

F. Cleaver (2000) Moral ecological rationality, institutions and the management of common property resources. Development and Change 31 (2): 361383.

E. Coleman (2009) Institutional factors affecting ecological outcomes in forest management. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management 28 (1): 122146.

E. Coleman & B. Steed (2009) Monitoring and sanctioning in the commons: an application to forestry. Ecological Economics 68 (7): 21062113.

M. Cox (2010) Exploring the dynamics of social-ecological systems: the case of the Taos valley acequias. Ph.D. dissertation, Indiana University, Indiana, USA.

M. Cox , B. Arnold & S. Villamayor-Tomas (2010) A review of design principles for community-based natural resource management. Ecology and Society (in press).

P. Dasgupta & G.M. Heal (1979) Economic Theory and Exhaustible Resources. Cambridge, MA, USA: Cambridge University Press.

P. Degnbol , H. Gislason , S. Hanna , S. Jentoft , J. Raakjær , Sverdrup-Jensen S. Nielsen & D. Clyde Wilson (2006) Painting the floor with a hammer: technical fixes in fisheries management. Marine Policy 30: 534543.

T. Dietz , E. Ostrom & P.C. Stern (2003) The struggle to govern the commons. Science 302 (5652): 19071912.

W. Dressler , B. Büscher , M. Schoon , D. Brockington , T. Hayes , C.A. Kull , J. McCarthy & K. Shrestha (2010) From hope to crisis and back again? A critical history of the global CBNRM narrative. Environmental Conservation 37 (1): 515.

P. Evans (2004) Development as institutional change: the pitfalls of monocropping and the potentials of deliberation. Studies in Comparative International Development 38 (4): 3052.

D. Feeny , F. Berkes , B.J. McCay & J.M. Acheson (1990) The tragedy of the commons: twenty-two years later. Human Ecology 18 (1): 119.

A.L. George & A. Bennett (2005) Case Studies and Theory Development in the Social Sciences. Cambridge, MA, USA: MIT Press.

R. Ghate & H. Nagendra (2005) Role of monitoring in institutional performance: forest management in Maharashtra, India. Conservation and Society 3 (2): 509532.

C.C. Gibson , J.T. Williams & E. Ostrom (2005) Local enforcement and better forests. World Development 33 (2): 273284.

J.D. Hackel (1999) Community conservation and the future of Africa's wildlife. Conservation Biology 13 (4): 726734.

S. Hanna & M. Munasinghe (1995) Property Rights in a Social and Ecological Context; Case Studies and Design Principles. Washington, DC, USA: The Beijer International Institute of Ecological Economics and The World Bank.

T. Hayes (2006) Parks, people, and forest protection: an institutional assessment of the effectiveness of protected areas. World Development 34 (12): 20642075.

K. Johnson , F. Swanson , M. Herring & S. Greene (1999) Bioregional Assessments: Science at the Crossroads of Management and Policy. Washington, DC, USA: Island Press.

D.C. Korten (1980) Community organization and rural development: a learning process approach. Public Administration Review 40 (5): 480511.

S.A. Levin (1992) The problem of pattern and scale in ecology. Ecology 73: 19431967.

T.E. Lovejoy (2006) Protected areas: a prism for a changing world. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 21: 329333.

M. McGinnis (1999) Polycentricity and Local Public Economies: Readings from the Workshop in Political Theory and Policy Analysis. Ann Arbor, MI, USA: University of Michigan Press.

R. Meinzen-Dick (2007) Beyond panaceas in water institutions. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 104 (39): 1520015206.

H. Moller , F. Berkes , P.O. Lyver & M. Kislalioglu (2004) Combining science and traditional ecological knowledge: monitoring populations for co-management. Ecology and Society 9 (3): 2.

M.W. Murphree (2002) Protected areas and the commons. Common Property Resource Digest 60: 13.

R.M. Netting (1972) Of men and meadows: strategies of alpine land use. Anthropological Quarterly 45: 132144.

NRC (1986) Proceedings of the Conference on Common Property Resource Management. Washington, DC, USA: National Academies Press.

NRC (2002) The Drama of the Commons. Washington, DC, USA: National Academies Press.

E. Ostrom (1986) An agenda for the study of institutions. Public Choice 48 (1): 325.

E. Ostrom , M. Janssen & M.A. Anderies (2007) Going beyond panaceas. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 104 (39): 1517615178.

E. Ostrom (2009) A general framework for analyzing sustainability of social-ecological systems. Science 325: 419422.

E. Ostrom & H. Nagendra (2006) Insights on linking forests, trees, and people from the air, on the ground, and in the laboratory. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 103 (51): 1922419231.

E. Ostrom & R.B. Parks (1999) Neither gargantua nor the land of lilliputs: conjectures on mixed systems of metropolitan organization. In: Polycentricity and Local Public Economies: Readings from the Workshop in Political Theory and Policy Analysis, ed. M. McGinnis , pp. 284305. Ann Arbor, MI, USA: University of Michigan Press.

E. Ostrom , R. Gardner & J. Walker (1994) Rules, Games, and Common-Pool Resources. Ann Arbor, MI, USA: University of Michigan Press.

E. Ostrom , M. Janssen & M.A. Anderies (2007) Going beyond panaceas. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 104 (39): 1517615178.

A. Pagdee , Y. Kim & P.J. Daugherty (2006) What makes community forest management successful: a meta-study from community forests throughout the world. Society and Natural Resources 19 (1): 3352.

A.R. Poteete & E. Ostrom (2004) Heterogeneity, group size and collective action: the role of institutions in forest management. Development and Change 35 (3): 437461.

C.C. Ragin (1987) The Comparative Method: Moving Beyond Qualitative and Quantitative Strategies. Berkeley and Los Angeles, CA, USA: University of California Press.

C.C. Ragin (2008) Redesigning Social Inquiry: Fuzzy Sets and Beyond. Chicago, IL, USA: University of Chicago Press.

T.K. Rudel (2008) Meta-analysis of case studies: a method for studying regional and global climate change. Global Environmental Change 18 (1): 1825.

C. Sandström (2009) Institutional dimensions of comanagement: Participation, power and process. Society and Natural Resources 22: 230244

A. Satria , Y. Matsuda & M. Sano (2006) Questioning community based coral reef management systems: case study of Awig-Awig in Gili Indah, Indonesia. Environment, Development and Sustainability 8: 99118.

E. Schlager & E. Ostrom (1992) Property-regimes and natural resources: a conceptual analysis. Land Economics 68 (3): 249262.

J.T. Scholz & C-L. Wang (2006) Cooptation or transformation? Local policy networks and federal regulatory enforcement. American Journal of Political Science 50 (1): 8197.

C. Shackleton & S. Shackleton (2004) The importance of non-timber forest products in rural livelihood security and as safety nets: a review of evidence from South Africa. South African Journal of Science 100: 658664.

N. Shanmugaratnam (1996) Nationalisation, privatisation, and the dilemmas of common property management in western Rajasthan. Journal of Development Studies 33: 163187.

K. St Martin , B.J. McCay , G. Murray , T. Johnson & B. Oles (2007) Communities, knowledge and fisheries of the future. International Journal of Global Environmental Issues 7 (2/3): 221239.

R.N. Stavins (2008) Addressing climate change with a comprehensive U.S. cap-and-trade system. Oxford Review of Economic Policy 24 (2): 298321.

P.B. Trawick (2001) Successfully governing the commons: principles of social organization in an Andean irrigation system. Human Ecology 29 (1): 125.

C.M. Tucker (2008) Changing Forests: Collective Action, Common Property, and Coffee in Honduras. New York, NY, USA: Springer.

E. Webb & G.P. Shivakoti , eds. (2008) Decentralization, Forests and Rural Communities: Policy Outcomes in South and Southeast Asia. New Delhi, India: Sage India.

D. Western & R.M. Wright (1994) The background to community-based conservation. In: Natural Connections: Perspectives in Community-Based Conservation, ed. D. Western & R.M. Wright , pp. 114. Washington, DC, USA: Island Press.

E. Wollenberg , L. Merino , A. Agrawal & E. Ostrom (2007) Fourteen years of monitoring community-managed forests: learning from IFRI's experience. International Forestry Review 9 (2): 670684.

O. Young (2002) The Institutional Dimensions of Environmental Change: Fit, Interplay, and Scale. Cambridge, MA, USA: MIT Press.

Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Environmental Conservation
  • ISSN: 0376-8929
  • EISSN: 1469-4387
  • URL: /core/journals/environmental-conservation
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *