Skip to main content
×
Home
    • Aa
    • Aa

What is this thing called “SAD”? A critique of the concept of seasonal affective disorder

  • Vidje Hansen (a1), Ingunn Skre (a2) and Eiliv Lund (a3)
Summary
Summary

Background – Seasonal Affective Disorder (SAD) is supposed to be caused by lack of daylight in winter. Yet the population of Northern Norway, living without sun for two winter months, does not spontaneously complain about depression during the dark period. Aims – To summarize research bearing upon the validity of the concept of SAD. Method – Review of relevant literature concerning the epidemiology of SAD and the questionnaire developed to measure it in general populations, the Seasonal Pattern Assessment Questionnaire (SPAQ). Results – Large population studies from northern Norway do not point to a higher prevalence of depression in winter than expected in any other general population. The psychometric properties of SPAQ are rather poor, and the diagnosis of SAD based on SPAQ bears little relationship to a meaningful concept of depression. Conclusions – Seasonal Affective Disorder is not a valid medical construct. Instead, “Recurrent depression with seasonal pattern” as defined in the DSM-IV and the ICD-10 should be used as terms. However, more research is needed to establish whether it is at all fruitful to single out such a subtype of recurrent depression.

Declaration of Interest: None.

Copyright
Corresponding author
Address for correspondence: Professor V. Hansen, Department of Clinical Psychiatry, Psychiatric Department UNN, p.o. 6124, N-9291 Tromsø, (Norway). E-mail: vidje.hansen@unn.no
References
Hide All
Allen J., Lam R. W., Remick R. & Sadovnick A. (1993). Depressive symptoms and family history in seasonal and nonseasonal mood disorders, American Journal of Psychiatry 150, 443448.
American Psychiatric Association (1987). Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (3. ed. revised). American Psychiatric Association: Washington DC.
American Psychiatric Association (2000). Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (A. ed., text revision). American Psychiatric Association: Washington DC.
Avasthi A., Sharma A., Gupta N., Kulhara P., Varma V. K., Malhotra S. & Mattoo S. K. (2001). Seasonality and affective disorders: a report from North India, Journal of Affective Disorders 64, 145154.
Axelsson J., Káradóttir R. & Karlsson M. (2002a). Differences in prevalence og seasonal affective disorder that are not explained by either genetic or lattitude differences. International Journal of Circumpolar Health 61, 1720.
Axelsson J., Stefansson C. G., Magnusson A., Sigvaldason H. & Karlsson H. (2002b). Seasonal affective disorders: relevance of Icelandic and Icelandic-Canadian evidence to etiological hypothesis. Canadian Journal of Psychiatry Al, 153158.
Axelsson J., Ragnarsdottir S., Pind J. & Sigbjørnsson R. (2004). Dailight availability: A poor predictor of depression in Iceland. International Journal of Circumpolar Health 63, 267277.
Bagby R.M., Schuller D.R., Levitt A.J., Joffe R.T. & Harkness K.L. (1996). Seasonal and non-seasonal depression and the five-factor model of personality. Journal of Affective Disorders 38, 8995.
Blazer D., Kessler R.C. & Swartz M. (1998). Epidemiology of recurrent major and minor depression with a seasonal pattern. British Journal of Psychiatry 172, 164167.
Brennen T. (2001). Seasonal cognitive rhythms within the arctic circle: An individual differences approach. Journal of Environmental Psychology 21, 191199.
Brennen T. & Martinussen M. (1999). Arctic cognition. A study of cognitive performance in summer and winter at 69 degrees North”. Applied Cognitive Psychology 13, 561580.
Christensen E. M., Larsen J. K. & Gjerris A. (2003). The stability of the Seasonal Pattern Assessment Questionnaire score index over time and the validity compared to classifiction according to DSM-III-R. Journal of Affective Disorders 1A, 167172.
de Graaf R., van Dorsselaer S., ten Have M., Schoemaker C. & Vollebergh W.A. (2005). Seasonal variations in mental disorders in the general population of a country with a maritime climate: findings from the Netherlands mental health survey and incidence study. American Journal of Epidemiology 162, 654661.
Devold O., Barlinghaug E. & Backer J.E. (1957). Sleep-disturbances in the dark period (in Norwegian). Journal of the Norwegian Medical Association 77, 836837.
Dollinger S. J. & Leong F. (1993). Volunteer bias and the five-factor model. Journal of Psychology 127, 2936.
Eagles J.M., Howie F.L., Cameron I.M., Wileman S.M., Andrew J., Robertsen C. & Naji S.A. (2002). Use of health care services in seasonal affective disorder”. British Journal of Psychiatry 180, 449454.
Eastwood M.R. & Peter A.M. (1988). Epidemiology and seasonal affective disorder. Psychlogical Medicine 18, 799806.
Grof P. (2002). Mood disorders – New definitions, treatment, directions, and understanding. Canadian Journal of Psychiatry Al, 123124.
Haggarty J., Cernovsky Z. & Husni M. (2001). The limited influence of latitude in rates of seasonal affective disorder. Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease 189, 482484.
Haggarty J., Cernovsky Z., Husni M., Minor K., Kermeen P. & Mersky H. (2005). Seasonal affective disorder in an Arctic community. Ada Psychiatrica Scandinavica 105, 378384.
Hansen V., Jacobsen B. K. & Husby R. (1991). Mental distress during winter. An epidemiological study of 7759 adults north of Arctic Circle. Ada Psychiatrica Scandinavica 84, 137141.
Hansen V., Lund E. & Smith-Sivertsen T. (1998). Self-reported mental distress under the shifting daylight in the high north. Psychological Medicine 28, 447452.
Hardin T.A., Wehr T.A., Brewerton T., Kasper S., Berretini W., Rabkin J. & Rosenthal N.E. (1991). Evaluation of seasonality in six clinical populations and two normal populations. Journal of Psychiatric Research 25, 7587.
Hellekson C.J., Kline J.A. & Rosenthal N.E. (1986). Phototherapy for seasonal affective disorder in Alaska. American Journal of Psychiatry 143, 10351037.
Husby R. & Lingjaerde O. (1990). Prevalence of reported sleeplessness in northern Norway, in relation to sex, age and season. Ada Psychiatrica Scandinavica 81, 542547.
Jain U., Blais M.A., Otto M.W., Hirschfeld D. & Sachs G.S. (1999). Five-factor personality traits in patients with seasonal depression: Treatment effects and comparisons wity bipolar patients. Journal of Affective Disorders 55, 5154.
James S.P., Wehr T.A., Sack D.A., Parry B.L. & Rosenthal N.E. (1985). Treatment of seasonal affective disorder with light in the evening. British Journal of Psychiatry 147, 424428.
Kasper S., Wehr T.A., Bartko J.J., Gaist P.A. & Rosenthal N.E. (1989). Epidemiological findings of seasonal changes in mood and behaviour. Archives of General Psychiatry 46, 823833.
Kringlen E., Torgersen S. & Cramer V. (2001). A Norwegian Psychiatric Epidemiological study. American Journal of Psychiatry 158, 10911098.
Levitt A.J. & Boyle M.H. (2002). The impact of latitude on the prevalence of seasonal depression. Canadian Journal of Psychiatry 47, 361367
Levitt A.J., Boyle M.H., Joffe R.T. & Baumal Z. (2000). Estimated prevalence of the Seasonal Subtype of Major Depression in a Canadian Community Sample. Canadian Journal of Psychiatry 45, 650654.
Lewy A.J., Wehr T.A. & Goodwin F.K. (1980). Light suppresses melatonin secretion in humans. Science 210, 12671268.
Lewy A.J., Kern H.A., Rosenthal N E. & Wehr T.A. (1982). Bright artificial light treatment of a manic-depressive patient with a seasonal mood cycle. American Journal of Psychiatry 139, 14961498.
Lingjaerde O. & Reichborn-Kjennerud T. (1993). Characteristics of winter depression in the Oslo area (60 degrees N). Ada Psychiatrica ScandinavicaSS, 111120.
Lingjaerde O., Bratlid T., Hansen T. & Gøtestam K.G. (1986). Seasonal affective disorder and midwinter insomnia in the far north. Studies on two related chronobiological disorders in Norway. Proceedings of the Collegium Internationale Neuro-Psychopharmacologicum 9, 187189.
Lund E. & Hansen V. (2001). Responses to the Seasonal Pattern Assessment Questionnaire in different seasons. American Journal of Psychiatry 158, 316318.
Magnusson A. (1996). Validation of the Seasonal Pattern Assessment Questionnaire (SPAQ). Journal of Affective Disorders 40, 121129.
Mersch P., Middendorp H., Bouhuys A.L., Beersma D. & van den Hoofdakker R.H. (1999). Seasonal affective disorder and latitude: a review of the literature. Journal of Affective Disorders 53, 3548.
Mersch P.P., Vastenburg N.C., Meesters Y., Bouhuys A.L., Beersma D., van den Hoofdakker R.H. & den Boer J.A. (2004). The reliability and validity of the Seasonal Pattern Assessment Questionnaire: a comparison between patient groups. Journal of Affective Disorders 80, 209219.
Morrissey S.A., Raggatt P.T., James B. & Rogers J. (1996). Seasonal affective disorder: some epidemiological findings from a tropical climate. Australia and New Zeeland Journal of Psychiatry 30, 579586.
Murray G. (2003). The Seasonal Pattern Assessment Questionnaire as a measure of mood seasonality: a prospective validation study. Psychiatry Research 120, 5359.
Näyhä S., Väisänen E. & Hassi J. (1994). Season and mental illness in an Arctic area of northern Finland. Ada Psychiatrica Scandinavica, Suppl. 377, 4649.
Nilssen O., Brenn T., Høyer G., Lipton R.I., Boiko J. & Tkatchev A. (1999). Self-reported seasonal variation in depression at 78 degree north. The Svalbard Study. International Journal of Circumpolar Health 58, 1423.
Potkin S.G., Zetin M., Stamnekovic V., Kripke D. & Bunney W.E. (1986). Seasonal Affective Disorder: Prevalence varies with latitude and climate. Journal of Clinical Neuropharmacology 9, 181183.
Raheja S.K., King E.A. & Thompson C. (1996). The seasonal pattern assessment questionnaire for identifying seasonal affective disorders. Journal of Affective Disorders 41, 193199.
Robins L.N., Wing J.K., Wittchen H.U., Helzer J.E., Babor T., Burke J., Farmer A., Jablensky A., Pickens R., Regier D.A., Sartorius N. & Towle L. (1988). The Composite International Diagnostic Interview. Archives of General Psychiatry 45, 10691077.
Rosen L.N., Targum S.D., Terman M., Bryant M.J., Hoffmann H., Kasper S., Hamovit J.R., Docherty J., Welch B. & Rosenthal N.E. (1990). Prevalence of seasonal affective disorder at four latitudes. Psychiatry Research 31, 131144.
Rosenthal N.E. (1993). Winter Blues. Seasonal Affective Disorder. What It Is and How to Overcome It. Guilford Press: New York.
Rosenthal N.E., Sack D.A., Gillin J.C., Lewy A.J., Goodwin F.K., Davenport Y., Mueller P.S., Newsome D.A. & Wehr T.A. (1984a). Seasonal Affective Disorder. A description of the syndrome and preliminary findings with light therapy. Archives of General Psychiatry 41, 7280
Rosenthal N.E., Bradt G.H. & Wehr T.A. (1984b). Seasonal Pattern Assessment Questionnaire. National Institute of Mental Health: Bethesda MD.
Rosenthal N.E., Sack D.A., Carpenter C.J., Parry B.L., Mendelson W.B. & Wehr T.A. (1985). Antidepressant effects of light in seasonal affective disorder. American Journal of Psychiatry 142, 163170.
Rosenthal N.E., Carpenter C.J., James S.P., Parry B.L., Rogers S. L. & Wehr T.A. (1986). Seasonal affective disorder in children and adolescents. American Journal of Psychiatry 143, 356358.
Rosenthal R. & Rubin D. (1978). Interpersonal expectancy effects:The first 345 studies. Behavioural and Brain Sciences 1, 377415.
Saarijärvi S., Lauerma H., Helenius H. & Saarilehto S. (1999). Seasonal affective disorders among rural Finns and Lapps. Ada Psychiatrica Scandinavica 99, 95101.
Sandanger I., Nygård J.F., Ingebrigtsen G., Sørensen T. & Dalgard O.S. (1999). Prevalence, incidence and age at onset of psychiatric disorders in Norway. Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology 34, 570579.
Sherer M.A., Weingartner H., James S.P. & Rosenthal N.E. (1985). Effects of melatonin on performance testing in patients with seasonal affective disorder. Neuroscience Letters 58, 277282.
Skou Nilsen L., Hansen V. & Olstad R. (2004). Improvement in mental health over time in Northern Norway. A prospective study of a general population followed for 9 years, with special emphasis on the influence of darkness in winter. Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology 39, 273279.
Srisurapanont M. & Intaprasert S. (1999). Seasonal variations in mood and behaviour: epidemiological findings in the north tropics. Journal of Affective Disorders 54, 9799.
Swedish Council on Technology in Health Care (2007). Light Therapy for Depression (in Swedish). Statens beredning for medicinsk utvardering: Stockholm. Retrieved December 11, 2007 from http://www.sbu.se/sv/Publicerat/Gul/Ljusterapi-vid-depression-samt-ovrig-behandling-av-arstidsbunden-depression/
Tam E., Lam R. W., Robertsen H., Stewart J., Yatham L. & Zis A. (1997). Atypical depressive symptoms in seasonal and non-seasonal mood disorders. Journal of Affective Disorders 44, 3944.
Tansella M. (2006). Recent advances in depression. Where are we going? Epidemiologia e Psichiatria Sociale 15, 13.
Thompson C. & Cowan A. (2001). The seasonal health questionnaire: a preliminary validation of a new instrument to screen for Seasonal Affective Disorder. Journal of Affective Disorders 64, 8998.
Thompson C. & Isaacs G. (1988). Seasonal affective disorder- a British sample. Symptomatology in relation to mode of referral and diagnostic subtype. Journal of Affective Disorders 14, 111.
Thompson C, Stinson D., Fernandez M., Fine J. & Isaacs G. (1988). A comparison of normal, bipolar and seasonal affective disorder subjects using the Seasonal Pattern Assessment Questionnaire. Journal of Affective Disorders 14, 257264.
Thompson C, Thompson S. & Smith R. (2005). Prevalence of seasonal affective disorder in primary care; a comparison of the seasonal health questionnaire and seasonal pattern assessment questionnaire. Journal of Affective Disorders 78, 219226.
van Praag H. (1993). Seasonal Affective Disorder (winter depression). In “Make-believes” in Psychiatry or the Perils of Progress, pp. 176188. Brunner/Mazel: New York.
Williams R. J. & Schmidt G.G. (1993). Frequency of seasonal affective disorder among individuals seeking treatment at a northern Canadian mental health center. Psychiatry Research 46, 4145.
World Health Organisation (1992). The ICD-10 Classification of Mental and Behavioral Disorders: Clinical Description and Diagnostic Guidelines. World Health Organisation: Geneva.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Epidemiology and Psychiatric Sciences
  • ISSN: 2045-7960
  • EISSN: 2045-7979
  • URL: /core/journals/epidemiology-and-psychiatric-sciences
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Keywords:

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 20 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 217 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 22nd October 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.