Skip to main content
×
Home
    • Aa
    • Aa

Poverty as Capability Deprivation: Conceptualising and Measuring Poverty in Contemporary Europe

  • Rod Hick (a1)
Abstract
Abstract

Poverty analysis is in the midst of a multidimensional “turn” due, in part, to the growing awareness of the limitations of relative income measures of poverty. In this paper, we argue that the conceptualisation of poverty remains a neglected aspect of this multidimensional turn to date, and demonstrate that the counter-intuitive results which flow from relative income analyses are not problems of measurement, but are entirely consistent with the conceptualisation of poverty under Peter Townsend’s dominant Poverty as Relative Deprivation framework. In response to these problems we articulate an alternative framework, Poverty as Capability Deprivation, drawing on Amartya Sen’s capability approach, and argue that this provides more persuasive explanations as to why some nations have greater poverty than others and why poverty remains a problem even in the richest nations.

Résumé

L’analyse de la pauvreté est au beau milieu d’un « tournant » multidimensionnel dû, en partie, à la prise de conscience croissante des limites des mesures de pauvreté en termes de revenus relatifs. Dans cet article, nous affirmons non seulement que la conceptualisation de la pauvreté reste un aspect négligé de ce tournant multidimensionnel, mais nous démontrons que les résultats contre-intuitifs qui découlent des analyses en termes de revenus relatifs ne sont pas des problèmes de mesure, mais sont avant tout congruents avec le cadre dominant de la pauvreté défini par Peter Townsend dans son ouvrage intitulé La Pauvreté comme Privation Relative. Pour résoudre ces problèmes, nous élaborons un cadre alternatif qui s’appuie sur l’approche des « capacités » d’Amartya Sen, La Pauvreté comme privation de capacité, et qui permet d’expliquer pourquoi certaines nations conservent un niveau de pauvreté plus élevé que d’autres et pourquoi la pauvreté demeure un problème même dans les nations les plus riches.

Zusammenfassung

Die Armutsdiagnose befindet sich inmitten einer multidimensionalen Wende, die zum Teil auf das wachsende Zugeständnis zurückzuführen ist, dass Einkommensmaßnahmen nur begrenzte Auswirkungen auf die Armut haben. In diesem Beitrag behaupten wir, dass die Konzeptualisierung der Armut im Rahmen dieser multidimensionalen Wende vernachlässigt wird und zeigen auf, dass die gegenintuitiven Ergebnisse, die auf relativen Einkommensuntersuchungen fußen, keine Messfehler sind, sondern sich durch Peter Townsends Konzeptualisierung der Armut, wie in seinem Werk „Poverty as Relative Deprivation“ beschrieben, erklären lassen. Zur Problemlösung tragen wir mit einem alternativen Raster bei, „Poverty as Capability Deprivation“ – Armut als Fähigkeitsentzug, aufbauend auf Amartya Sens Fähigkeitsansatz und argumentieren, dass dieser Ansatz besser erklärt, warum manche Nationen eine größere Armut als andere kennen und warum Armut selbst in reichsten Ländern ein Problem bleibt.

Copyright
References
Hide All
Alkire Sabina, 2007. “The Missing Dimensions of Poverty Data: Introduction to the Special Issue”, Oxford Development Studies, 35 (4): 347-359.
Alkire Sabina and Foster James, 2011. “Counting and Multidimensional Poverty Measurement”, Journal of Public Economics, 95 (7), 476-487.
Alkire Sabina and Santos Maria Emma, 2010. “Acute Multidimensional Poverty: A New Index for Developing Countries”, ophi Working Paper N° 38, Oxford.
Atkinson Tony, Cantillon Bea, et al. ., 2002. Social indicators: The EU and Social Inclusion (Oxford, Oxford University Press).
Atkinson Tony, Cantillon Bea, Marlier Eric and Nolan Brian, 2005. “Taking forward the EU Social Inclusion Process: An Independent Report Commissioned by the Luxembourg Presidency of the Council of the European Union”.
Anand Sudhir and Sen Amartya, 1997. “Concepts of Human Development and Poverty: A Multidimensional Perspective”, Human Development Papers (New York, undp: 19).
Berthoud Richard, 2012). “Calibrating a Cross-European Poverty Line”, iser Working Paper Series, n° 2012-02, Institute for Social and Economic Research (iser), University of Essex.
Berthoud Richard and Bryan Mark, 2011). “Income, Deprivation and Poverty: A Longitudinal Analysis”, Journal of Social Policy, 40 (1): 135-156.
Bradshaw Jonathan and Finch Naomi, 2003. “Overlaps in Dimensions of Poverty”, Journal of Social Policy, 32 (4): 513-525.
Bradshaw Jonathan, Hoelscher Petra, et al. ., 2007. “An index of child well-being in the European Union”, Social Indicators Research, 80 (1): 133-177.
Bradshaw Jonathan and Mayhew Emese, 2011. The Measurement of Extreme Poverty in the European Union, European Commission.
Brandolini Andrea and D’Alessio Giovanni, 1998. Measuring well-being in the functioning space. Rome, Banco d’Italia Research Department.
Coates Ken and Silburn Richard, 1973. Poverty: The Forgotten Englishmen (London, Penguin).
Coromaldi Manuela and Zoli Mariengela, 2012). “Deriving Multidimensional Poverty Indicators: Methodological Issues and an Empirical Analysis for ItalySocial indicators research, 107 (1): 37-54.
Doyal Len and Gough Ian, 1991). A Theory of Human Need (Basingstoke, Macmillan Education Ltd).
Drydyk Jay, 2011. “Responsible Pluralism, Capabilities, and Human Rights”, Journal of Human Development and Capabilities, 12 (1): 39-61.
Eurostat n. d. “People at Risk of Poverty after Social Transfers”, Tables, Graphs and Maps Interface, Retrieved 3 August 2012.
Fahey Tony, 2007. “The Case for an EU-Wide Measure of Poverty”, European Sociological Review, 23 (1): 35-47.
Fahmy Eldin, Pemberton Simon, et al. ., 2011. “Public Perceptions of Poverty, Social Exclusion and Living Standards: Preliminary Report on Focus Group Findings”, Poverty and Social Exclusion in the UK: The 2011 Survey, Working Paper Series, N° 12, Bristol, pse).
Ferreira Fransisco and Lugo Maria Ana, 2013. “Multidimensional Poverty Analysis: Looking for a Middle Ground”, The World Bank Research Observer, lks013.
Gordon David and Pantazis Christina, (eds.), 1997. Breadline Britain in the 1990s (Aldershot, Ashgate).
Gordon David, Pantazis Christina, et al. ., 2000. “Absolute and Overall Poverty: A European History and Proposal for Measurement”, in Gordon David and Peter, Breadline Europe: The measurement of poverty (Townsend, Bristol Policy Press).
Gordon David, Mack Joanna, Lansley Stewart, Main Gill, Nandy Shailen, Patsios Demi and Pomati Marco, 2013. The Impoverishment of the UK: PSE UK first results: living standards, http://www.poverty.ac.uk/, last accessed 25 June 2013.
Guio Anne-Catherine, Gordon David and Marlier Eric, 2012. Measuring Material Deprivation in the EU: Indicators for the Whole Population and Child-Specific Indicators, (Luxembourg, Eurostat).
Hick Rod, 2012. “The Capability Approach: Insights for a New Poverty Focus”, Journal of Social Policy, 41 (2): 291-208.
Hick Rod, 2013. “Poverty, Preference or Pensioners? Measuring Material Deprivation in the UK”, Fiscal Studies, 34 (1): 31-54.
Hick Rod, (forthcoming a). “Material Poverty and Multiple Deprivation: The Distinctiveness of Multidimensional Assessment”, Journal of Public Policy.
Hick Rod, (forthcoming b). “Three Perspectives on the Mismatch Between Measures of Material Poverty”, British Journal of Sociology.
Hick Rod and Burchardt Tania (forthcoming). “Capability Deprivation”, in David Brady and Burton L. M. (eds.), The Oxford Handbook of the Social Science of Poverty (Oxford, Oxford University Press).
Kangas Olli and Ritakallio Velli-Matti, 2004. “Relative to What? Cross-National Picture of European Poverty Measured by Regional, National and European Standards”, Luxembourg Income Study Working Paper Series.
Kennedy Steven, 2014. “Child Poverty Act 2010: a Short Guide”, House of Commons Library Standard, Note N° 5585.
Kennett Patricia, 2006. “Constructing Categories and Data Collection”, in Patricia Kennett (ed.), A Handbook of Comparative Social Policy (Cheltenham, Edward Elgar).
Kremakova Milena (2013). “Too Soft for Economics, Too Rigid for Sociology, or Just Right? The Productive Ambiguities of Sen’s Capability Approach.” European Journal of Sociology, 53 (3): 393-419.
Legard Robin, Gray Michelle and Margaret Blake, 2008. “Cognitive Testing: Older People and the FRS Material Deprivation Questions”, Department for Work and Pensions, Working paper N° 55.
Le Grand Julian, 1991. Equity and choice: An essay in economics and applied philosophy (London, Harper Collins Academic).
Lister Ruth, 2004. Poverty (Cambridge, Polity Press).
MacCàrthaigh Seosamh, 2014. “Need and Poverty”, Policy and Politics, 42 (3): 459-473.
Mack Joanna and Lansley Stewart,1985. Poor Britain (London: George Allen & Unwin).
McKay Stephen, 2004. “Poverty or Preference: What Do ‘Consensual Deprivation Indicators’ Really Measure?”, Fiscal Studies, 25 (2): 201-223.
Niemietz Kristian, 2011. A New Understanding of Poverty: Poverty Measurement and Policy Implications (London, Institute of Economic Affairs).
Nolan Brian and Whelan Christopher T., 1996. Resources, Deprivation and Poverty (Oxford, Oxford University Press).
Nolan Brian and Whelan Christopher T., 2007. “On the Multidimensionality of Poverty and Social Exclusion”, in Stephen Jenkins and Micklewright John, Inequality and Poverty Re-examined (Oxford, Oxford University Press).
Nolan Brian and Whelan Christopher T., 2011. Poverty and Deprivation in Europe (Oxford, Oxford University Press).
Piachaud David, 1981. “Peter Townsend and the Holy Grail”, New Society, 10 September 1981: 418-420.
Ravallion Martin, 2011. “On Multidimensional Indices of Poverty”, Journal of Economic Inequality, 9 (2): 235-248.
Ravallion Martin and Chen Shaohua, 2009. “Weakly Relative Poverty”, World Bank Policy Research Working Paper (Washington,World Bank).
Rawls John, 1971. A Theory of Justice (Cambridge, Harvard University Press).
Rawls John, 1988. “The Priority of Right and Ideas of the Good”, Philosophy and public affairs, 17 (4): 251-276.
Robeyns Ingrid, 2003. “Sen’s Capability Approach and Gender Equality: Selecting Relevant Capabilities”, Feminist Economic, 9 (2/3): 61-92.
Robeyns Ingrid, 2005). “Assessing Global Poverty and Inequality: Income, Resources and Capabilities”, Metaphilosophy, 36 (1/2): 30-49.
Rowntree Benjamin S., 1901. Poverty: A Study of Town Life (York, Macmillan and Co).
Rowntree Benjamin S., 1941. Poverty and progress: A second social survey of York (London, Longmans, Green and Co).
Rowntree Benjamin S. and Lavers George R., 1951). Poverty and the Welfare State: A Third Social Survey of York Dealing Only With Economic Questions (London, Longmans, Green and Co).
Saunders Peter and Abe Aya, 2010. “Poverty and Deprivation in Young and Old: A Comparative Study of Australia And Japan”, Poverty and Public Policy, 2 (1): 67-97.
Sen Amartya, 1983. “Poor, Relatively Speaking”, Oxford Economic Papers, 35 (2): 153-169.
Sen Amartya, 1985. “A Sociological Approach to the Measurement of Poverty: A Reply to Professor Peter Townsend”, Oxford Economic Papers, 37: 669-676.
Sen Amartya, 1992. Inequality Reexamined (New York, Russell Sage Foundation).
Sen Amartya, 1995. “The Political Economy of Targetingin Dominic Van de Walle and Nead Kimberly, Public Spending and the Poor (Washington, World Bank).
Sen Amartya, 1999. Development as Freedom (Oxford, Oxford University Press).
Sen Amartya, 2000. “Social Exclusion: Concept, Application and Scrutiny”, Social Development Papers, Manila Asian Development Bank: 54.
Sen Amartya, 2009. The Idea of Justice (London, Allen Lane).
Stiglitz Joseph, Sen Armatya, et al. ., 2009. Commission on the Measurement of Economic and Social Progresshttp://www.stiglitz-sen-fitoussi.fr/en/index.htm.
Sugden Robert, 1993. “Welfare, resource and capabilities: A review of Inequality Re-examined by Amartya Sen”, Journal of Economic Literature, 31 (4): 1947-1962.
Townsend Peter, 1954. “Measuring poverty”, The British Journal of Sociology, 5 (2): 130-137.
Townsend Peter, 1962. “The meaning of poverty”, The British Journal of Sociology, 13 (3): 210-227.
Townsend Peter, 1970. “Measures and Explanations of Poverty in High Income and Low income Countries: The Problems of Operationalising the Concepts of Development, Class and Poverty”, in Townsend Peter The concept of poverty (London, Heinemann Educational Books).
Townsend Peter, 1979. Poverty in the United Kingdom: A Survey of Household Resources and Standards of Living (Middlesex, Penguin).
Townsend Peter, 1985. “A Sociological Approach to the Measurement of Poverty: A Rejoinder to Professor Amartya Sen”, Oxford Economic Papers, 37: 659-668.
Townsend Peter, 1987. “Deprivation”, Journal of Social Policy, 16 (2): 125-146.
Unicef, 2012. Measuring Child Poverty: New League Table of Child Poverty in the World’s Rich Nations, U.I.R. Centre (Florence, Unicef Innocenti Research Centre).
Waglé Udaya R., 2008. “Multidimensional Poverty: An Alternative Measurement Approach for the United States?”, Social Science Research, 37 (2): 559-580.
Whelan Christopher T. and Maître Bertrand, 2009a. “Poverty and Deprivation in Ireland in a Comparative Perspective”, ESRI Research Series (Dublin, Economic and Social Research Institute, 11: 80).
Whelan Christopher T. and Maître Bertrand, 2009b. “Comparing Poverty Indicators in an Enlarged European Union”, European Sociological Review, 26 (5): 1-18.
Whelan Christopher T. and Maître Bertrand, 2014. “Multidimensional Poverty Measurement in Europe: An Application of the Adjusted Headcount Approach”, Journal of European Social Policy, 24 (2): 183-197.
Whelan Christopher T., Nolan Brian, et al. ., 2007). Consistent poverty and economic vulnerability (Dublin, Institute of Public Administration).
Wolff Jonathan and Avner de-Shalit, 2007. Disadvantage (Oxford, Oxford University Press).
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

European Journal of Sociology / Archives Européennes de Sociologie
  • ISSN: 0003-9756
  • EISSN: 1474-0583
  • URL: /core/journals/european-journal-of-sociology-archives-europeennes-de-sociologie
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Keywords:

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 7
Total number of PDF views: 99 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 390 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 22nd October 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.