Skip to main content
    • Aa
    • Aa

Cultural legacies and political preferences: the failure of separatism in the Swiss Jura

  • David S. Siroky (a1), Sean Mueller (a2) and Michael Hechter (a3) (a4)

The study of secession generally stresses the causal influence of cultural identities, political preferences, or ecological factors. Whereas these different views are often considered to be mutually exclusive, this paper proposes a two-stage model in which they are complementary. We posit that cultural identities matter for explaining secessionism, but not because of primordial attachments. Rather, religious and linguistic groups matter because their members are imbued with cultural legacies that lead to distinct political preferences – in this case preferences over welfare statism. Further, ecological constraints such as geography and topography affect social interaction with like-minded individuals. On the basis of both these political preferences and ecological constraints, individuals then make rational choices about the desirability of secession. Instrumental considerations are therefore crucial in explaining the decision to secede, but not in a conventional pocketbook manner. To examine this theory, we analyze the 2013 referendum on the secession of the Jura Bernois region from the Canton of Berne in Switzerland, using municipal level census and referendum data. The results lend support to the theory and suggest one way in which the politics of identity, based on factors like language and religion, can be fused with the politics of interest (preferences for more or less state intervention into the polity and economy) to better understand group behavior.

Corresponding author
Linked references
Hide All

This list contains references from the content that can be linked to their source. For a full set of references and notes please see the PDF or HTML where available.

T. Amemiya (1985), Advanced Econometrics, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

K. Armingeon , F. Bertozzi and G. Bonoli (2004), ‘Swiss worlds of welfare’, West European Politics 27(1): 2044.

R.W. Ayres (2000), ‘Is separatism as contagious as the common cold or as cancer? Testing international and domestic explanations’, Nationalism and Ethnic Politics 6(3): 91113.

F. Bieber (2006), Post-War Bosnia: Ethnicity, Inequality and Public Sector Governance, New York, NY: Palgrave Macmillan.

P. Bolton and G. Roland (1997), ‘The breakup of nations: a political economy analysis’, The Quarterly Journal of Economics 112(4): 10571090.

M. Bookman (1992), ‘Economic issues underlying secession: the cases of Slovenia and Slovakia’, Communist Economies and Economic Transformation 4(1): 111134.

P. Bourdieu (1977), Outline of a Theory of Practice, Cambridge, NY: Cambridge University Press.

R. Brubaker (2013), ‘Language, religion and the politics of difference’, Nations and Nationalism 19(1): 120.

F.G. Castles (1994), ‘On religion and public policy: does Catholicism make a difference?’, European Journal of Political Research 25(1): 1940.

L.-E. Cederman , K.S. Gleditsch and H. Buhaug (2013), Inequality, Grievances, and Civil War, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

N. Charron and V. Lapunte (2013), ‘Why do some regions in Europe have a higher quality of government’, The Journal of Politics 75(3): 567582.

K.R. Cox (2002), Political Geography: Territory, State, and Society, Oxford: Blackwell Publishers.

K. Darden and A. Gryzmala-Busse (2006), ‘The great divide: literacy, nationalism, and the communist collapse’, World Politics 59(1): 83115.

S. Dion (1996), ‘Why is secession difficult in well-established democracies? Lessons from Quebec’, British Journal of Political Science 26(2): 269283.

F. Fossati and S. Häusermann (2014), ‘Social policy preferences and party choice in the 2011 Swiss elections’, Swiss Political Science Review 20(4): 590611.

A. Goldberg (2014), ‘The impact of religion on voting behaviour – a multilevel approach for Switzerland’, Swiss Political Science Review 20(2): 305329.

M. Hechter (1978), ‘Group formation and the cultural division of labor’, American Journal of Sociology 84(2): 293318.

M. Hechter (2013), Alien Rule, New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.

D. Horowitz (1981), ‘Patterns of ethnic separatism’, Comparative Studies in Society and History 23(2): 165195.

D. Horowitz (1985), Ethnic Groups in Conflict, Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.

I. Katznelson and B. Weingast (2005), Preferences and Institutions: Points of Intersection Between Historical and Rational Choice Institutionalism, New York, NY: Russell Sage Foundation.

J.S. Kopstein and J. Wittenberg (2011), ‘Deadly communities: local political milieus and the persecution of Jews in occupied Poland’, Comparative Political Studies 44(3): 259283.

J. Laponce (2012), ‘Language and sovereignty referendums: the convergence effect’, Nationalism and Ethnic Politics 18(1): 113128.

A. Lijphart (1971), ‘Comparative politics and the comparative method’, American Political Science Review 65(3): 682693.

W. Linder , R. Zürcher and C. Bolliger (2008), Gespaltene Schweiz – geeinte Schweiz. Gesellschaftliche Spaltungen und Konkordanz bei den Volksabstimmungen seit 1874, Baden: hier+jetzt.

K.-J. Lundquist and M. Trippl (2013), ‘Distance, proximity and types of cross-border innovation systems: a conceptual analysis’, Regional Studies 47(3): 450460.

M. McPherson , L. Smith-Lovin and J.M. Cook (2001), ‘Birds of a feather: homophily in social networks’, Annual review of sociology 27: 415444.

T. Mitchell (1991), ‘The limits of the state: beyond statist approaches and their critics’, American Political Science Review 85(1): 7596.

S. Mueller (2013), ‘Conflicting cantonalisms’, L'Europe en Formation 369: 86102.

J. Muñoz and M. Guinjoan (2013), ‘Accounting for internal variation in nationalist mobilization: unofficial referendums for independence in Catalonia (2009–11)’, Nations and Nationalism 19(1): 4467.

J. Muñoz and R. Tormos (2014), ‘Economic expectations and support for secession in Catalonia: between causality and rationalization’, European Political Science Review 7(2): 315341.

R. Nadeau , P. Martin and A. Blais (1999), ‘Attitude towards risk-taking and individual choice in the Quebec referendum on sovereignty’, British Journal of Political Science 29(3): 523539.

R.E. Nisbett and D. Cohen (1996), Culture of Honor : The Psychology of Violence in the South, Boulder, CO: Westview Press.

D. Oesch and L. Rennwald (2010), ‘The class basis of Switzerland’s cleavage between the New Left and the Populist Right’, Swiss Political Science Review 16(3): 343371.

L. Peisakhin (2015), ‘Long shadow of the past: identity, norms, and political behavior’. PhD Dissertation, Yale University, 2012.

A. Pichard (2004), La question jurassienne: Avant et après la naissance du 23 e canton Suisse , Lausanne: Presses polytechniques et universitaires romandes.

G. Pop-Eleches and J. Tucker (2011), ‘Communism’s shadow: historical legacies, and political values and behavior’. Unpublished manuscript.

M. Qvortrup (2014), Referendums and Ethnic Conflict, Philadelphia, PA: University of Pennsylvania Press.

J.-C. Rennwald (1995), Nord-Sud, le Partage: Ce qui pourrait être un Canton de Jura à 6 districts, Courrendlin: Communication Jurassienne et Européenne.

S. Roccas and B. Brewer Marilynn (2002), ‘Social identity complexity’, Personality and Social Psychology Review 6(29): 88106.

S. Rokkan and D. Urwin (1983), Economy, Territory, Identity. Politics of West European Peripheries, London, Beverly Hills, CA, New Delhi: Sage Publications.

J.-J. Schumacher (2005), L’assemblée interjurassien: Histoire et perspectives, Porrentruy: Société jurassienne d’Emulation.

M. Shefter (1977), ‘Party and patronage: Germany, England, and Italy’, Politics and Society 7(4): 403451.

G. Simmel (1955), Conflict and the Web of Group Affiliations, New York, NY: Free Press.

A. Smith (1986), The Ethnic Origins of Nations, Oxford: Basil Blackwell.

M. Sobel (1982), ‘Asymptotic confidence intervals for indirect effects in structural equations models’, in S. Leinhardt (ed.) Sociological Methodology, San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass, pp. 290312.

J. Sorens (2012), Secessionism: Identity, Interest, Strategy, Montréal, Kingston, London, Ithaca, NY: McGill-Queen’s University Press.

S. Steinmo , K. Thelen and F. Longstreth (eds) (1992), Structuring Politics: Historical Institutionalism in Comparative Politics., Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

T. Talhelm , X. Zhang , S. Oishi , C. Shimin , D. Duan , X. Lan and S. Kitayama (2014), ‘Large-scale psychological differences within China explained by rice versus wheat agriculture’, Science 344(6184): 603608.

A. Vatter (2014), ‘Kantone’, in P. Knoepfel, Y. Papadopoulos, P. Sciarini, A. Vatter and S. Häusermann (eds), Handbuch der Schweizer Politik/Manuel de la politique suisse, Zürich: Verlag NZZ, pp. 245274.

A. Wimmer (2002), Nationalist Exclusion and Ethnic Conflict: Shadows of Modernity, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

J. Wittenberg (2006), Crucibles of Political Loyalty: Church Institutions and Electoral Continuity in Hungary, New York: Cambridge University Press.

J. Wittenberg (2015), ‘Conceptualizing historical legacies’, East European Politics & Societies 29(2): 366378.

A. Zellner (1962), ‘An efficient method of estimating seemingly unrelated regression equations and tests for aggregation bias’, Journal of the American Statistical Association 57: 348368.

A. Zellner and T. Ando (2010), ‘A direct Monte Carlo approach for Bayesian analysis of the seemingly unrelated regression model’, Journal of Econometrics 159(1): 3345.

M. Hechter (2000), Containing Nationalism, Oxford University Press.

R. Simeon (2009), ‘Constitutional design and change in federal systems’, The Journal of Federalism 39(2): 241261.

A. Zellner and T. Ando (2010), ‘A direct Monte Carlo approach for Bayesian analysis of the seemingly unrelated regression model’, Journal of Econometrics 159(1): 3345.

Y. Slezkin (1994), ‘The USSR as a communal apartment, or how a socialist state promoted ethnic particularism’, Slavic Review 53(2): 414452.

Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

European Political Science Review
  • ISSN: 1755-7739
  • EISSN: 1755-7747
  • URL: /core/journals/european-political-science-review
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *



Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 3
Total number of PDF views: 58 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 346 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 21st September 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.