Skip to main content
×
Home
    • Aa
    • Aa

The health effects of the global financial crisis: can we reconcile the differing views? A network analysis of literature across disciplines

  • David Stuckler (a1), Aaron Reeves (a2), Marina Karanikolos (a3) and Martin McKee (a4)
Abstract
Abstract

Why are researchers studying the health effects of economic change reaching markedly varying conclusions? To understand these differences, we first systematically searched Web of Science for the literature on recessions and health yielding 461 articles and 14,401 cited documents. We then undertook a network analysis of co-citation pattern by disciplines, journals and backgrounds of the authors, followed by a chronological review of the literature, to trace the evolution of ideas. We then examined the extent to which earlier literature predicted what has happened in the 2007–2012 crisis. Our analysis finds the literature is dominated by disciplinary silos, with economics studies predominantly citing each other and relative isolation of psychiatry and substance abuse journals. Different philosophical approaches to assessing causality appear to contribute to varying interpretations, a tendency that is unlikely to be resolved without a shift in research norms. We conclude by calling for more inter-disciplinary research that combines empirical findings with a search for plausible mechanisms. This approach would evaluate not only the effects of economic shocks but also the mechanisms that offer protection against them.

Copyright
Corresponding author
*Correspondence to: Martin McKee, Professor of European Public Health, European Observatory on Health Systems and Policies, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, 15-17 Tavistock Place, London WC1H 9SH, UK. Email: Martin.McKee@lshtm.ac.uk
References
Hide All
BartleyM. (1992), Authorities and Partisans, Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
BevanG. and SkellernM. (2011), ‘Does competition between hospitals improve clinical quality? A review of evidence from two eras of competition in the English NHS’, British Medical Journal, 343: d6470.
BonovasS. and NikolopoulosG. (2012), ‘High-burden epidemics in Greece in the era of economic crisis. Early signs of a public health tragedy’, Journal of Preventive Medicine and Hygiene, 53(3): 169171.
BorJ., BasuS., CouttsA., McKeeM. and StucklerD. (2013), ‘Alcohol use during the Great Recession of 2008–2009’, Alcohol and Alcoholism, 48(3): 343348.
BrennerM. H. (1971), ‘Economic changes and heart disease mortality’, American Journal of Public Health, 61(3): 606611.
BunnA. R. (1979), ‘Ischaemic heart disease mortality and the business cycle in Australia’, American Journal of Public Health, 69(8): 772781.
CarpenterL. (1987), ‘Some observations on the healthy worker effect’, British Journal of Industrial Medicine, 44(5): 289291.
CatalonoR. (1979), ‘Health costs of economic expansion: the case of manufacturing accident injuries’, American Journal of Public Health, 69: 789794.
CatalanoR., Goldman-MellorS., SaxtonK., Margerison-ZilkoC., SubbaramanM., LeWinnK. and AndersonE. (2011), ‘The health effects of economic decline’, Annual Review of Public Health, 32(1): 431450.
ChengP. W. (1997), ‘From covariation to causation: a causal power theory’, Psychological Review, 104: 367405.
CooperZ., GibbonsS., JonesS. and McGuireA. (2010), Does Hospital Competition Improve Efficiency? An Analysis of the Recent Market-Based Reforms to the English NHS. CEP Discussion Papers, No. 988, London: Centre for Economic Performance, London School of Economics and Political Science.
DurkheimE. (1997), Suicide, New York: Free Press.
EyerJ. (1977), ‘Prosperity as a cause of death’, International Journal of Health Services, 7(1): 125150.
EyerJ. and SterlingP. (1977), ‘Stress-related mortality and social organization’, Review of Radical Political Economics, 9(1): 144.
GarfieldR. and SantanaS. (1997), ‘The impact of the economic crisis and the US embargo on health in Cuba’, American Journal of Public Health, 87(1): 1520.
GaynorM. and PropperC. (2012), Healthcare Competition Saves Lives. http://www.voxeu.org/article/healthcare-competition-saves-lives [24 July 2013].
GerdthamU. and RuhmC. J. (2006), ‘Deaths rise in good economic times: evidence from the OECD’, Economics and Human Biology, 4(3): 298316.
GiliM., RocaM., BasuS., McKeeM. and StucklerD. (2013), ‘The mental health risks of economic crisis in Spain: evidence from primary care centres, 2006 and 2010’, European Journal of Public Health, 23(1): 103108.
GravelleH. S., HutchinsonG. and SternJ. (1981), ‘Mortality and unemployment: a critique of Brenner’s time-series analysis’, Lancet, 2(8248): 675679.
HarhayM. O., BorJ., BasuS., McKeeM., MindellJ. S., SheltonN. J. and StucklerD. (2014), ‘Differential impact of the economic recession on alcohol use among white British adults, 2004–2010’, European Journal of Public Health, 24: 410415.
HendryD. F. (1980), ‘Econometrics: alchemy or science?’, Economica, 47(188): 387406.
HeutelG. and RuhmC. J. (2013), ‘Air pollution and procyclical mortality’, Working Paper No. 18959, Cambridge, MA: NBER.
HillA. B. (1965), ‘The Environment and Disease Association or Causation?’, Proceedings of the Royal Society of Medicine, 58(5): 295300.
HopkinsS. (2006), ‘Economic stability and health status: evidence from east Asia before and after the 1990s economic crisis’, Health Policy, 75(3): 347357.
HumeD. (1896), A Treatise of Human Nature, Oxford: Clarendon Press.
JänttiM., MartikainenP. and ValkonenT. (2000), ‘When the welfare state works: unemployment and mortality in Finland’, in A. Cornia and R. Paniccia (eds), The mortality crisis in transitional economies, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 351369.
JinR., ShahC. P. and SvobodaT. P. (1995), ‘The impact of unemployment on health: a review of the evidence’, Canadian Medical Association Journal, 153(5): 529540.
KantI. (1963), Critique of Pure Reason (translated by N. K. Smith), London: Macmillan.
KaranikolosM., RechelB., StucklerD. and McKeeM. (2013a), ‘Financial crisis, austerity, and health in Europe – Authors’ reply’, Lancet, 382(9890): 392.
KaranikolosM., MladovskyP., CylusJ., ThomsonS., BasuS., StucklerD., MackenbachJ. P. and McKeeM. (2013b), ‘Financial crisis, austerity, and health in Europe’, Lancet, 381(9874): 13231331.
KaslS. V. (1979), ‘Mortality and the business cycle: some questions about research strategies when utilizing macro-social and ecological data’, American Journal of Public Health, 69(8): 784788.
KentikelenisA., KaranikolosM., PapanicolasI., BasuS., McKeeM. and StucklerD. (2011), ‘Health effects of financial crisis: omens of a Greek tragedy’, Lancet, 378(9801): 14571458.
KentikelenisA., KaranikolosM., ReevesA., McKeeM. and StucklerD. (2014), ‘Greece’s health crisis: from austerity to denialism’, Lancet, 383(9918): 748753.
LeamerE. E. (1983), ‘Let’s take the con out of econometrics’, The American Economic Review, 73(1): 3143.
LeinsaluM., StirbuI., VageroD., KaledieneR., KovacsK., WojtyniakB., WroblewskaW., MackenbachJ. P. and KunstA. E. (2009), ‘Educational inequalities in mortality in four Eastern European countries: divergence in trends during the post-communist transition from 1990 to 2000’, International Journal of Epidemiology, 38(2): 512525.
LeonD., SaburovaL., TomkinsS., AndreevE., KiryanovN., McKeeM. and ShkolnikovV. M. (2007), ‘Hazardous alcohol drinking and premature mortality in Russia: a population based case-control study’, Lancet, 369(9578): 20012009.
LeonD., ChenetL., ShkolnikovV. M., ZakharovS., ShapiroJ., RakhmanovaG., VassinS. and McKeeM. (1997), ‘Huge variation in Russian mortality rates 1984–94: artefact, alcohol, or what?Lancet, 350(9075): 383388.
LeRoyS. F. (2004), Causality in Economics: Causality: Metaphysics and Methods, Technical Report 20/04, London: Centre for Philosophy of Natural and Social Science, LSE.
Lopez-BernalJ. A., GasparriniA., ArtundoC. M. and McKeeM. (2013), ‘The effect of the late 2000s financial crisis on suicides in Spain: an interrupted time-series analysis’, European Journal of Public Health, 23: 732736.
McKee-RyanM., SongZ., WanbergC. R. and KinickiA. J. (2005), ‘Psychological and physical well-being during unemployment: a meta-analytic study’, Journal of Applied Psychology, 90(1): 5376.
MillJ. S. (1874), A System of Logic, 8th edition, New York: Harper and Brothers.
MillerD., PageM. E., StevensA. H. and FilipskiM. (2009), ‘Why are recessions good for your health?American Economic Review, 99(2): 122127.
ModrekS., StucklerD., McKeeM. and CullenM. R. (2013), ‘A review of health consequences of recessions internationally and a synthesis of the US response during the Great Recession’, Public Health Reviews, 35(1): 135.
MulliganC. (2013), Recessions save lives, New York Times, Economix, Available at http://economix.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/05/29/recessions-save-lives/?_php=true&_type=blogs&_r=0
OgburnW. and ThomasD. S. (1922), ‘The influence of the business cycle on certain social conditions’, Journal of the American Statistical Association, 18(139): 324340.
PearlR. (1928), The Rate of Living, Being an Account of Some Experimental Studies on the Biology of Life Duration, New York: Alfred A. Knopf.
PlattS. (1984), ‘Unemployment and suicidal behaviour: a review of the literature’, Social Science & Medicine, 19: 93115.
PollockA., MacfarlaneA., KirkwoodG., MajeedF. A., GreenerI., MorelliC., BoyleS., MellettH., GoddenS., PriceD. and BrhlikovaP. (2011), ‘No evidence that patient choice in the NHS saves lives’, Lancet, 378(9809): 20572060.
PropperC., BurgessS. and GreenK. (2004), ‘Does competition between hospitals improve the quality of care? Hospital death rates and the NHS internal market’, Journal of Public Economics, 88: 12471272.
ReevesA., McKeeM. and StucklerD. (2014), ‘Economic suicides: more than 10,000 preventable tragedies in Europe and North America’s Great Recessions’, British Journal of Psychiatry, doi: 10.1192/bjp.bp.114.144766.
ReisenW., TakahashiR. M., CarrollB. D. and QuiringR. (2008), ‘Delinquent mortgages, neglected swimming pools, and West Nile virus, California’, Emerging Infectious Diseases, 14(11): 17471749.
RuhmC. (2000), ‘Are recessions good for your health?Quarterly Journal of Economics, 115(2): 617650.
RuhmC. (2003), ‘Good times make you sick’, Journal of Health Economics, 22(3): 637658.
RuhmC. (2006), ‘Macroeconomic Conditions, Health and Mortality’, in A. Jones (ed.), Elgar Companion to Health Economics, Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar Publishing, 516.
RuhmC. (2008a), ‘A healthy economy can break your heart’, Demography, 44(4): 829848.
RuhmC. (2008b), ‘Macroeconomic Conditions, Health and Government Policy. Making Americans Healthier: Social and Economic Policy as Health Policy’, in R. Schoeni, J. S. House, G. A. Kaplan and H. Pollack (eds), New York: Russell Sage, 173200.
SimsC. A. (1980), ‘Macroeconomics and reality’, Econometrica, 48: 148.
SmithG. D. and PhillipsA. (1990), ‘Declaring independence: why we should be cautious’, Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health, 44(4): 257258.
SmithR. (1985), ‘“Bitterness, shame, emptiness, waste”: an introduction to unemployment and health’, British Medical Journal, 291: 10241027.
SmolinaK., WrightF. I., RaynerM. and GoldacreM. J. (2012), ‘Determinants of decline in mortality from acute myocardial infarction in England between 2002 and 2010: linked national database study’, British Medical Journal, 344: d8059.
SteinwaldB. and DummitL. A. (1989), ‘Hospital case-mix change: sicker patients or DRG creep?Health Affairs (Millwood), 8(2): 3547.
StucklerD. and BasuS. (2013), The Body Economic: Why Austerity Kills, London: Penguin.
StucklerD., BasuS., SuhrckeM., CouttsA. and McKeeM. (2009), ‘The public health impact of economic crises and alternative policy responses in Europe’, Lancet, 374(9686): 315323.
StucklerD., BasuS., SuhrckeM., CouttsA. and McKeeM. (2011), ‘Effects of the 2008 financial crisis on health: a first look at European data’, Lancet, 378(9876): 124125.
StucklerD., BasuS., MeissnerC., FishbackP. and McKeeM. (2012), ‘Banking crises and mortality during the Great Depression: evidence from U.S. urban populations, 1927–1939’, Journal of Epidemiology & Community Health, 66: 410419.
SugiharaG., MayR., YeH., HsiehC. H., DeyleE., FogartyM. and MunchS. (2012), ‘Detecting causality in complex ecosystems’, Science, 338(6106): 496500.
SuhrckeM., StucklerD., SukJ. E., DesaiM., SenekM., McKeeM., TsolovaS., BasuS., AbubakarI., HunterP., RechelB. and SemenzaJ. C. (2010), ‘The impact of economic crises on communicable disease transmission and control: a systematic review of the evidence’, PLoS One, 6(6): e20724.
SydenstrickerE. (1933), ‘Health and the depression’, Milbank Memorial Fund Quarterly Bulletin, 11: 273280.
Tapia-GranadosJ. (2005), ‘Increasing mortality during the expansions of the US economy, 1900–1996’, International Journal of Epidemiology, 34(6): 11941202.
Tapia-GranadosJ. (2005), ‘Recessions and mortality in Spain, 1980–1997’, European Journal of Population, 21(4): 393422.
Tapia-GranadosJ. (2008), ‘Macroeconomic fluctuations and mortality in postwar Japan’, Demography, 45(2): 323343.
TekinE., McClellanC. and MinyardK. J. (2013), ‘Health and health behaviors during the worst of times: evidence from the Great Recession’, Working Paper No. 19234, Cambridge, MA: NBER.
ThomsonH., PetticrewM. and MorrisonD. (2002), Housing Improvement and Health Gain: A Summary and Systematic Review, Glasgow: MRC Social & Public Health Sciences Unit.
WalbergP., McKeeM., ShkolnikovV., ChenetL. and LeonD. A. (1998), ‘Economic change, crime, and mortality crisis in Russia: a regional analysis’, British Medical Journal, 317: 312318.
WatersH., SaadahF. and PradhanM. (2003), ‘The impact of the 1997–98 East Asian economic crisis on health and healthcare in Indonesia’, Health Policy and Planning, 18(2): 172181.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Health Economics, Policy and Law
  • ISSN: 1744-1331
  • EISSN: 1744-134X
  • URL: /core/journals/health-economics-policy-and-law
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×
Type Description Title
WORD
Supplementary Materials

Stuckler Supplementary Material
Appendix

 Word (645 KB)
645 KB

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 22
Total number of PDF views: 73 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 494 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 23rd October 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.