Skip to main content Accessibility help

Influence of provider mix and regulation on primary care services supplied to US patients

  • Michael R. Richards (a1) and Daniel Polsky (a2) (a3)

Access to medical care and how it differs for various patients remain key policy issues. While existing work has examined clinic structure’s influence on productivity, less research has explored the link between provider mix and access for different patient types – which also correspond to different service prices. We exploit experimental data from a large field study spanning 10 US states where trained audit callers were randomly assigned an insurance status and then contacted primary care physician practices seeking new patient appointments. We find clinics with more non-physician clinicians are associated with better access for Medicaid patients and lower prices for office visits; however, these relationships are only found in states granting full practice autonomy to these providers. Substituting more non-physician labor in primary care settings may facilitate greater appointment availability for Medicaid patients, but this likely rests on a favorable policy environment. Relaxing regulations for non-physicians may be an important initiative as US health reforms continue and also relevant to other countries coping with greater demands for medical care and related financial strain.

Corresponding author
*Correspondence to: Assistant Professor Michael R. Richards, Department of Health Policy, Vanderbilt University, 2525 West End Ave, Suite 1206, Nashville, TN 37203, USA. Email:
Hide All
Allison, P. D. (1999), ‘Comparing logit and probit coefficients across groups’, Sociological Methods & Research, 28(2): 186208.
Baker, L. C. and Royalty, A. B. (2000), ‘Medicaid policy, physician behavior, and health care for the low-income population’, Journal of Human Resources, 35(3): 480502.
Boardman, A. E., Dowd, B., Eisenberg, J. M. and Williams, S. V. (1983), ‘A model of physicians’ practice attributes determination’, Journal of Health Economics, 2: 259268.
Bodenheimer, T. and Pham, H. H. (2010), ‘Primary care: current problems and proposed solutions’, Health Affairs, 29(5): 799805.
Bodenheimer, T., Berenson, R. A. and Rudolf, P. (2007), ‘The primary care – specialty income gap: why it matters’, Annals of Internal Medicine, 146: 301306.
Bodenheimer, T., Chen, E. and Bennett, H. D. (2009), ‘Confronting the growing burden of chronic disease: can the US health care workforce do the job?’, Health Affairs, 28(1): 6474.
Brown, D. A. (1988), ‘Do physicians underutilize aides?’, Journal of Human Resources, 23(3): 342355.
Buchmueller, T. C., Orzol, S. and Shore-Sheppard, L. D. (2013), ‘The Effect of Medicaid Payment Rates on Access to Dental Care Among Children’, NBER Working Paper Series (w19218): 1–50.
Buchmueller, T. C., Miller, S. and Vujicic, M. (2014), ‘How Do Providers Respond to Public Health Insurance Expansions? Evidence from Adult Medicaid Dental Benefits’, NBER Working Paper Series (No. 20053): 1–58.
Cassidy, A. (2013), ‘Health Policy Brief: Nurse Practitioners and Primary Care’, Health Affairs, RWJ Foundation.
Cooper, R. A. (2001), ‘Health care workforce for the twenty-first century: the impact of nonphysician clinicians’, Annual Review of Medicine, 52: 5161.
Cooper, R. A. and Aiken, L. H. (2001), ‘Human imputs: the health care workforce and medical markets’, Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law, 26(5): 925938.
Cromwell, J. and Mitchell, J. B. (1984), ‘An economic model of large Medicaid practices’, Health Services Research, 19(2): 197218.
Cunningham, J. and Cunningham, P. J. (2005), ‘The effects of Medicaid reimbursement on the access to care of Medicaid enrollees: a community perspective’, Medical Care Research and Review, 62(6): 676696.
Decker, S. L. (2007), ‘Medicaid physician fees and the quality of medical care of Medicaid patients in the USA’, Review of Economics of the Household, 5: 95112.
Decker, S. L. (2009), ‘Changes in Medicaid physician fees and patterns of ambulatory care’, Inquiry, 46: 291304.
Dobson, G., Pinker, E. and Van Horn, L. (2009), ‘Division of labor in medical office practices’, Manufacturing & Service Operations Management, 11(3): 525537.
Fairman, J. A., Rowe, J. W., Hassmiller, S. and Shalala, D. E. (2011), ‘Broadening the scope of nursing practice’, New England Journal of Medicine, 364: 193196.
Glied, S., Prabhu, A. G. and Edelman, N. (2009), ‘The cost of primary care doctors’, Forum for Health Economics & Policy, 12(1): 126.
Hofer, A. N., Abraham, J. M. and Moscovice, I. (2011), ‘Expansion of coverage under the patient protection and affordable care act and primary care utilization’, Milbank Quarterly, 89(1): 6989.
Hogg, W., Rowan, M., Russell, G., Geneau, R. and Muldoon, L. (2008), ‘Framework for primary care organizations: the importance of a structural domain’, International Journal for Quality in Health Care, 20(5): 308313.
Hooker, R. and Berlin, L. E. (2002), ‘Trends in the supply of physician assistants and nurse practitioners in the United States’, Health Affairs, 21(5): 174181.
Huang, E. S. and Finegold, K. (2013), ‘Seven million Americans live in areas where demand for primary care may exceed supply by more than 10 percent’, Health Affairs, 32(3): 614621.
IOM (2010), The Future of Nursing: Leading Change, Advancing Health, Washington, DC: N. A. Press and Institute of Medicine.
Jacobson, P. D., Parker, L. E. and Coulter, I. D. (1998), ‘Nurse practitioners and physician assistants as primary care providers in institutional settings’, Inquiry, 35(4): 432446.
Kehrer, B. H. and Intriligator, M. D. (1974), ‘Task delegation in physician office practice’, Inquiry, 11(4): 292299.
Kirch, D. G., Henderson, M. K. and Dill, M. J. (2012), ‘Physician workforce projections in an era of health care reform’, Annual Review of Medicine, 63: 435445.
Kleiner, M. M., Marier, A., Won Park, K. and Wing, C. (2014), Relaxing Occupational Licensing Requirements: Analyzing Wages and Prices for a Medical Service’, NBER Working Paper Series Working Paper 19906: 1–54.
Laurant, M. G., Akkermans, R. P., Sibbald, B. and Grol, R. P. (2008), ‘An overview of patients’ preferences for, and satisfaction with, care provided by general practitioners and nurse practitioners’, Journal of Clinical Nursing, 17(20): 26902698.
Lenz, E. R., Mundinger, M. O., Kane, R. L., Hopkins, S. C. and Lin, S. X. (2004), ‘Primary care outcomes in patients treated by nurse practitioners or physicians: two-year follow-up’, Medical Care Research and Review, 61(3): 332351.
Marsh, G. N. (1991), ‘The future of general practice: caring for larger lists’, British Medical Journal, 303: 13121316.
McGuire, T. G. and Pauly, M. V. (1991), ‘Physician response to fee changes with multiple payers’, Journal of Health Economics, 10: 385410.
Mood, C. (2010), ‘Logistic regression: why we cannot do what we think we can do, and what we can do about it’, European Sociological Review, 26(1): 6782.
Mundinger, M. O., Kane, R. L., Lenz, E. R., Totten, A. M., Tsai, W.-Y., Cleary, P. D., Friedewald, W. T., Siu, A. L. and Shelanski, M. L. (2000), ‘Primary care outcomes in patients treated by nurse practitioners or physicians’, Journal of the American Medical Association, 238(1): 5968.
Naylor, M. D. and Kurtzman, E. T. (2010), ‘The role of nurse practitioners in reinventing primary care’, Health Affairs, 29(5): 893899.
Newhouse, J. P. (1973), ‘The economics of group practice’, Journal of Human Resources, 8(1): 3756.
Ohman-Strickland, P. A., Orzano, A. J., Hudson, S. V., Solberg, L. I., DiCiccio-Bloom, B., O’Malley, D., Tallia, A. F., Balasubramanian, B. A. and Crabtree, B. F. (2008), ‘Quality of diabetes care in family medicine practices: influence of nurse-practitioners and physician’s assistants’, Annals of Family Medicine, 6(1): 1422.
Pohl, J. M., Hanson, C., Newland, J. A. and Cronenwett, L. (2010), ‘Unleashing nurse practitioners’ potential to deliver primary care and lead teams’, Health Affairs, 29(5): 900905.
Reid, R. J., Coleman, K., Johnson, E. A., Fishman, P. A., Hsu, C., Soman, M. P., Trescott, C. E., Erickson, M. and Larson, E. B. (2010), ‘The group health medical home at year two: cost savings, higher patient satisfaction, and less burnout for providers’, Health Affairs, 29(5): 835843.
Reinhardt, U. (1972), ‘A production function for physician services’, Review of Economics and Statistics, 54(1): 5566.
Rhodes, K. V., Kenney, G. M., Friedman, A. B., Saloner, B., Lawson, C. C., Chearo, D., Wissoker, D. and Polsky, D. (2014), ‘Primary care access for new patients on the eve of health care reform’, JAMA Internal Medicine, 174(6): 861869.
Richards, A., Carley, J., Jenkins-Clarke, S. and Richards, D. A. (2000), ‘Skill mix between nurses and doctors working in primary care-delegation or allocation: a review of the literature’, International Journal of Nursing Studies, 37: 185197.
Richards, M. R., Saloner, B., Kenney, G. M., Rhodes, K. V. and Polsky, D. (2014), ‘Access points for the underserved: primary care appointment availability at federally qualified health centers in ten states’, Medical Care, 52(9): 818825.
Richards, M. R., Saloner, B., Kenney, G. M., Rhodes, K. V. and Polsky, D. (2015), ‘Availability of new Medicaid patient appointments and the role of rural health clinics’, Health Services Research, E-pub ahead of print.
Richardson, G., Maynord, A., Cullum, N. and Kindig, D. (1998), ‘Skill mix changes: substitution or service development?’, Health Policy, 45: 119132.
Rittenhouse, D. R. and Shortell, S. M. (2009), ‘The patient-centered medical home: will it stand the test of health reform’, Journal of American Medical Association, 301(19): 20382040.
Roblin, D., Howard, D. H., Becker, E. R., Adams, E. K. and Roberts, M. H. (2004), ‘Use of midlevel practitioners to achieve labor cost savings in the primary care practice of an MCO’, Health Services Research, 39(3): 607625.
Rosenthal, T. C. (2008), ‘The medical home: growing evidence to support a new approach to primary care’, Journal of the American Board of Family Medicine, 24(5): 427440.
Schiff, M. (2012), The Role of Nurse Practitioners in Meeting Increasing Demand for Primary Care’. NGA Paper, National Governors Association, Washington, DC.
Sloan, F. A., Mitchell, J. B. and Cromwell, J. (1978), ‘Physician participation in state Medicaid programs’, Journal of Human Resources, 13(NBER Supplemental): 211245.
Sommers, B., Gordon, S., Somers, S., Ingram, C. and Epstein, A. (2013), ‘Medicaid on the Eve of Expansion: A Survey of State Medicaid Officials about the ACA’, Health Affairs Blog (Blog Post: December 30).
Spetz, J., Parente, S. T., Town, R. J. and Bazarko, D. (2013), ‘Scope-of-practice laws for nurse practitioners limit cost savings that can be achieved in retail clinics’, Health Affairs, 32(11): 19771984.
Stange, K. (2014), ‘How does provider supply and regulation influence health care markets? Evidence from nurse practitioners and physician assistants’, Journal of Health Economics, 33: 127.
Steinbrook, R. (2009), ‘Easing the shortage in adult primary care – is it all about money?’, New England Journal of Medicine, 360: 26962699.
Stimson, D. H. and Charles, G. (1975), ‘The study of physician extenders in primary care’, Health Services Research, Spring: 613.
Thurston, N. K. and Libby, A. M. (2002), ‘A production function for physician services revisited’, Review of Economics and Statistics, 84(1): 184191.
Whitcomb, M. E. and Cohen, J. J. (2004), ‘The future of primary care medicine’, New England Journal of Medicine, 351(7): 710712.
Wing, C. and Marier, A. (2014), ‘Effects of occupational regulations on the cost of dental services: evidence from dental insurance claims’, Journal of Health Economics, 34: 131143.
Wright, W. L., Romboli, J. E., DiTulio, M. A., Wogen, J. and Belletti, D. A. (2011), ‘Hypertension treatment and control within an independent nurse practitioner setting’, American Journal of Managed Care, 17(1): 5865.
Zeckhauser, R. and Eliastam, M. (1974), ‘The productivity potential of the physician assistant’, Journal of Human Resources, 9(1): 95116.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Health Economics, Policy and Law
  • ISSN: 1744-1331
  • EISSN: 1744-134X
  • URL: /core/journals/health-economics-policy-and-law
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *


Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed