Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
×
Home

Paying for hospital care: the experience with implementing activity-based funding in five European countries

  • Jacqueline O'Reilly (a1), Reinhard Busse (a2), Unto Häkkinen (a3), Zeynep Or (a4), Andrew Street (a5) and Miriam Wiley (a6)...
Abstract

Following the US experience, activity-based funding has become the most common mechanism for reimbursing hospitals in Europe. Focusing on five European countries (England, Finland, France, Germany and Ireland), this paper reviews the motivation for introducing activity-based funding, together with the empirical evidence available to assess the impact of implementation. Despite differences in the prevailing approaches to reimbursement, the five countries shared several common objectives, albeit with different emphasis, in moving to activity-based funding during the 1990s and 2000s. These include increasing efficiency, improving quality of care and enhancing transparency. There is substantial cross-country variation in how activity-based funding has been implemented and developed. In Finland and Ireland, for instance, activity-based funding is principally used to determine hospital budgets, whereas the models adopted in the other three countries are more similar to the US approach. Assessing the impact of activity-based funding is complicated by a shortage of rigorous empirical evaluations. What evidence is currently available, though, suggests that the introduction of activity-based funding has been associated with an increase in activity, a decline in length of stay and/or a reduction in the rate of growth in hospital expenditure in most of the countries under consideration.

Copyright
Corresponding author
*Correspondence to: Jacqueline O'Reilly, Health Research and Information Division, Economic and Social Research Institute, Whitaker Square, Sir John Rogerson's Quay, Dublin 2, Ireland. E-mail: jacqueline.oreilly@esri.ie
References
Hide All
Aas, I. H. M. (1995), ‘Incentives and financing methods’, Health Policy, 34(3): 205220.
Audit Commission (2008a), PbR Data Assurance Framework 2007/08. Findings from the First Year of the National Clinical Coding Audit Programme, London: Audit Commission.
Audit Commission (2008b), The Right Result? Payment by Results 2003-07, London: Audit Commission.
Audit Commission (2009), PbR Data Assurance Framework 2008/09. Key Messages from Year 2 of the National Clinical Coding Audit Programme, London: Audit Commission.
Audit Commission (2010), Improving Data Quality in the NHS: Annual Report of the PbR Assurance Programme, London: Audit Commission.
Bellanger, M. M.Tardif, L. (2006), ‘Accounting and reimbursement schemes for inpatient care in France’, Health Care Management Science, 9(3): 295305.
Böcking, W., Ahrens, U., Kirch, W.Milakovic, M. (2005), ‘First results of the introduction of DRGs in Germany and overview of experience from other DRG countries’, Journal of Public Health, 13(3): 128137.
Boyle, S. (2005), ‘Payment by results in England’, Euro Observer, 7(4): 14.
Brick, A., Nolan, A., O'Reilly, J.Smith, S. (2010), Resource Allocation, Financing and Sustainability in Health Care: Evidence for the Expert Group on Resource Allocation and Financing in the Health Sector, Dublin: Department of Health and Children and Economic and Social Research Institute.
Busse, R., Geissler, A., Quentin, W.Wiley, M. (eds) (2011), Diagnosis Related Groups in Europe. Moving Towards Transparency, Efficiency and Quality in Hospitals, Maidenhead: Open University Press.
Busse, R.Riesberg, A. (2004), Health Care Systems in Transition: Germany, Copenhagen: WHO Regional Office for Europe on behalf of the European Observatory on Health Systems and Policies.
Busse, R., Schreyögg, J.Smith, P. C. (2006), ‘Editorial: Hospital case payment systems in Europe’, Health Care Management Science, 9(3): 211213.
Clarke, A. (1996), ‘Why are we trying to reduce length of stay? Evaluation of the costs and benefits of reducing time in hospital must start from the objectives that govern change’, Quality in Health Care, 5(3): 172179.
Commission on Health Funding (1989), Report of the Commission on Health Funding, Dublin: The Stationery Office.
Daidone, S.Street, A. (2011), Estimating the Costs of Specialised Care. CHE Research Paper 61, York: University of York.
Department of Health (2007), ‘Payment by Results Guidance 2008/09’, http://www.dh.gov.uk/prod_consum_dh/groups/dh_digitalassets/@dh/@en/documents/digitalasset/dh_081334.pdf [4 March 2011].
Department of Health (2009), ‘Patient-Level Information and Costing Systems (PLICS)’, http://www.dh.gov.uk/en/Managingyourorganisation/Financeandplanning/NHScostingmanual/DH_080056 [24 August 2010].
Department of Health (2010), ‘Payment by Results Guidance for 2010-11’, http://www.dh.gov.uk/prod_consum_dh/groups/dh_digitalassets/@dh/@en/@ps/documents/digitalasset/dh_112970.pdf [17 February 2011].
Department of Health (2011), ‘Payment by Results Guidance for 2011-12’, http://www.dh.gov.uk/prod_consum_dh/groups/dh_digitalassets/documents/digitalasset/dh_124522.pdf [28 February 2011].
Ellis, R. P. (1998), ‘Creaming, skimping and dumping: provider competition on the intensive and extensive margins’, Journal of Health Economics, 17(5): 537555.
Ellis, R. P.Vidal-Fernández, M. (2007), ‘Activity-based payments and reforms of the English hospital payment system’, Health Economics, Policy and Law, 2(4): 435444.
Epstein, D.Mason, A. (2006), ‘Costs and prices for inpatient care in England: mirror twins or distant cousins’?, Health Care Management Science, 9(3): 233242.
Ettelt, S., Nolte, E. (2010), ‘Funding intensive care – approaches in systems using diagnosis-related groups’, http://www.rand.org/pubs/technical_reports/2010/RAND_TR792.pdf [17 June 2010].
Ettelt, S., Thomson, S., Nolte, E.Mays, N. (2006), Reimbursing Highly Specialised Hospital Services: The Experience of Activity-Based Funding in Eight Countries, London: London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine.
Farrar, S., Sussex, J., Yi, D., Sutton, M., Chalkley, M., Scott, T.Ma, A. (2007), National Evaluation of Payment by Results, Aberdeen: Health Economics Research Unit, University of Aberdeen.
Farrar, S., Yi, D., Sutton, M., Chalkley, M., Sussex, J.Scott, A. (2009), ‘Has payment by results affected the way that English hospitals provide care? Difference-in-differences analysis’, British Medical Journal, 339: b3047doi:10.1136/bmj.b3047.
Friesner, D. L.Rosenman, R. (2004), ‘Inpatient-outpatient cost shifting in Washington hospitals’, Health Care Management Science, 7(1): 1726.
Geissler, A., Scheller-Kreinsen, D.Busse, R. (2011), ‘Germany: Understanding G-DRGs’, in R. Busse, A. Geissler, W. Quentin and M. Wiley (eds), Diagnosis Related Groups in Europe. Moving Towards Transparency, Efficiency and Quality in Hospitals, Maidenhead: Open University Press.
Goldfield, N. (2010), ‘The evolution of diagnosis-related groups (DRGs): from its beginnings in case-mix and resource use theory, to its implementation for payment and now for its current utilization for quality within and outside the hospital’, Quality Management in Health Care, 19(1): 316.
Greß, S., Focke, A., Hessel, F.Wasem, J. (2006), ‘Financial incentives for disease management programmes and integrated care in German social health insurance’, Health Policy, 78(2–3): 295305.
Häkkinen, U. (2005), ‘The impact of changes in Finland's health care system’, Health Economics, 14(Supplement 1): S101S118.
Häkkinen, U. (2010), ‘Financing of hospital care in Finland’, Euro Observer, 12(3): 1012.
Häkkinen, U.Linna, M. (2005), ‘DRGs in Finnish health care’, Euro Observer, 7(4): 78.
Health Service Executive (2008), ‘Consultant Contract 2008 – measurement of public:private mix’, http://www.hse.ie/eng/staff/HR/tandc/Consultant_Contract_2008_-_Measurement_of_Public_Private_Mix.pdf [4 August 2010].
Health Service Executive (2010a), ‘Casemix Budget Outturns for 2009’, http://www.hse.ie/eng/services/Publications/corporate/2009casemix.html [12 May 2010].
Health Service Executive (2010b), ‘HealthStat – Supporting High Performance’, http://www.hse.ie/eng/staff/Healthstat/about/ [4 August 2010].
Health Service Executive (2010c), HSE National Service Plan 2010, Dublin: Health Service Executive.
Health Service Executive (2010d), National Service Plan 2011, Dublin: Health Service Executive.
Henschke, C., Bäumler, M., Weid, S., Gaskins, M.Busse, R. (2010), ‘Extrabudgetary (“NUB”) payments: a gateway for introducing new medical devices into the German inpatient reimbursement system’? Journal of Management & Marketing in Healthcare, 3(2): 119133.
Hensen, P., Beissert, S., Bruckner-Tuderman, L., Luger, T. A., Roeder, N.Muller, M. L. (2008), ‘Introduction of diagnosis-related groups in Germany: evaluation of impact on in-patient care in a dermatological setting’, European Journal of Public Health, 18(1): 8591.
Jegers, M., Kesteloot, K., De Graeve, D.Gilles, W. (2002), ‘A typology for provider payment systems in health care’, Health Policy, 60(3): 255273.
Kahn, K. L., Rubenstein, L. V., Draper, D., Kosecoff, J., Rogers, W. H., Keeler, E. B.Brook, R. H. (1990), ‘The effects of the DRG-based prospective payment system on quality of care for hospitalized Medicare patients: an introduction to the series’, Journal of the American Medical Association, 264(15): 19531955.
Kautianen, K., Häkkinen, U.Lauharanta, J. (2011), ‘Finland: DRGs in a Decentralized Health Care System’, in R. Busse, A. Geissler, W. Quentin and M. Wiley (eds), Diagnosis Related Groups in Europe. Moving Towards Transparency, Efficiency and Quality in Hospitals, Maidenhead: Open University Press.
Kimberly, J. R.de Pouvourville, G. and Associates (1993), The Migration of Managerial Innovation: Diagnosis-Related Groups and Health Care Administration in Western Europe, San Francisco: Jossey-Bass Inc.
Kimberly, J. R., de Pouvourville, G.D'Aunno, T. (2008), The Globalization of Managerial Innovation in Health Care, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Kittelsen, S. A. C., Anthun, K. S., Kalseth, B., Kalseth, J., Halsteinli, V., Magnussen, J. (2009), ‘En komparativ analyse av spesialisthelsetjenesten i Finland, Sverige, Danmark og Norge: Aktivitet, ressursbruk og produktivitet 2005–2007’, http://www.sintef.no/upload/Helse/%C3%98KT/Pdf-filer/SINTEF_Rapport_A12200-Analyse_speshelsetjenesten_Finland-Sverige-Danmark-Norge.pdf [2 March 2011].
Kobel, C., Thuilliez, J., Bellanger, M.Pfeiffer, K.-P. (2011), ‘DRG Systems and Similar Patient Classification Systems in Europe’, in R. Busse, A. Geissler, W. Quentin and M. Wiley (eds), Diagnosis Related Groups in Europe. Moving Towards Transparency, Efficiency and Quality in Hospitals, Maidenhead: Open University Press.
Kosecoff, J., Kahn, K. L., Rogers, W. H., Reinisch, E. J., Sherwood, M. J., Rubenstein, L. V., Draper, D., Roth, C. P., Chew, C.Brook, R. H. (1990), ‘Prospective payment system and impairment at discharge: the “quicker-and-sicker” story revisited’, Journal of the American Medical Association, 264(15): 19801983.
Kutzin, J. (2001), ‘A descriptive framework for country-level analysis of health care financing arrangements’, Health Policy, 56(3): 171204.
Langenbrunner, J., Orosz, E., Kutzin, J.Wiley, M. M. (2005), ‘Purchasing and Paying Providers’, in J. Figueras, R. Robinson and E. Jakubowski (eds), Purchasing to Improve Health Systems Performance, Maidenhead: Open University Press.
Langenbrunner, J. C.Wiley, M. M. (2002), ‘Hospital Payment Mechanisms: Theory and Practice in Transition Countries’, in M. McKee and J. Healy (eds), Hospitals in a Changing Europe, Buckingham: Open University Press.
Leister, J. E.Stausberg, J. (2005), ‘Comparison of cost accounting methods from different DRG systems and their effect on health care quality’, Health Policy, 74(1): 4655.
Linna, M.Häkkinen, U. (2008), ‘Benchmarking Finnish Hospitals’, in J. Blank and V. Valdmanis (eds), Evaluating Hospital Policy and Performance: Contributions from Hospital Policy and Productivity Research, Oxford: JAI Press.
Linna, M., Häkkinen, U.Magnussen, J. (2006), ‘Comparing hospital cost efficiency between Norway and Finland’, Health Policy, 77(3): 268278.
Linna, M., Häkkinen, U., Peltola, M., Magnussen, J., Anthun, K., Kittelsen, S., Roed, A., Olsen, K., Medin, E.Rehnberg, C. (2010), ‘Measuring cost efficiency in the Nordic Hospitals – a cross-sectional comparison of public hospitals in 2002’, Health Care Management Science, 13(4): 346357.
Lungen, M., Dredge, B., Rose, A., Roebuck, C., Plamper, E., Lauterbach, K.The Working Group (2004), ‘Using diagnosis-related groups: the situation in the United Kingdom National Health Service and in Germany’, European Journal of Health Economics, 5(4): 287289.
Lungen, M.Lapsley, I. (2003), ‘The reform of hospital financing in Germany: an international solution’?, Journal of Health Organization and Management, 17(5): 360372.
Mannion, R., Marini, G.Street, A. (2008), ‘Implementing payment by results in the English NHS: changing incentives and the role of information’, Journal of Health Organization and Management, 22(1): 7988.
Mannion, R., Street, A. (2005), Payment by Results and Demand Management: Learning from the South Yorkshire laboratory. CHE Research Paper 14, York: University of York.
Mason, A., Goddard, M. (2009), Payment by Results in Mental Health: A Review of the International Literature and an Economic Assessment of the Approach in the English NHS. CHE Research Paper 50, York: University of York.
Mason, A., Street, A., Miraldo, M.Siciliani, L. (2009), ‘Should prospective payments be differentiated for public and private healthcare providers’?, Health Economics, Policy and Law, 4(Pt 4): 383403.
Mason, A., Ward, P.Street, A. (2011), ‘England: The Healthcare Resource Group System’, in R. Busse, A. Geissler, W. Quentin and M. Wiley (eds), Diagnosis Related Groups in Europe. Moving Towards Transparency, Efficiency and Quality in Hospitals, Maidenhead: Open University Press.
McDaid, D., Wiley, M., Maresso, A.Mossialos, E. (2009), ‘Ireland: health system review’, Health Systems in Transition, 11(4): 1268.
McNair, P., Luft, H.Bindman, A. (2009), ‘Medicare's policy not to pay for treating hospital-acquired conditions: the impact’, Health Affairs, 28(5): 14851493.
Michelot, X.Rodrigues, J.-M. (2008), ‘DRGs in France’, in J. Kimberly, G. de Pouvourville and T. D'Aunno (eds), The Globalization of Managerial Innovation in Health Care, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Mikkola, H. (2003), ‘Hospital pricing reform in the public health care system–an empirical case study from Finland’, International Journal of Health Care Finance and Economics, 3(4): 267286.
Mikkola, H.Häkkinen, U. (2002), ‘The effects of case-based pricing on length of stay for common surgical procedures’, Journal of Health Services Research and Policy, 7(2): 9097.
Ministry of Health (2009), ‘Rapport 2009 au Parlement sur la tarification à l'activité (T2A)’, http://www.sante.gouv.fr/IMG/pdf/Rapport_T2A_2009.pdf [1 March 2011].
Ministry of Health (2010), ‘Rapport 2010 au Parlement sur la tarification à l'activité (T2A)’, http://www.sante.gouv.fr/IMG/pdf/Rapport_T2A_2010.pdf [1 March 2011].
Miraldo, M., Goddard, M., Smith, P. C. (2006), The Incentive Effects of Payment by Results. CHE Research Paper 19, London: Dr Foster Intelligence.
Moreno-Serra, R.Wagstaff, A. (2010), ‘System-wide impacts of hospital payment reforms: evidence from Central and Eastern Europe and Central Asia’, Journal of Health Economics, 29(4): 585602.
Newhouse, J. P. (1996), ‘Reimbursing health plans and health providers: efficiency in production versus selection’, Journal of Economic Literature, 34(3): 12361263.
NHS Information Centre (2010), ‘Healthcare Resource Groups 4 (HRG4)’, www.ic.nhs.uk/services/the-casemix-service/new-to-this-service/healthcare-resource-groups-4-hrg4 [17 June 2010].
O'Reilly, J., McCarthy, B.Wiley, M. (2011), ‘Ireland: A Review of Casemix Applications Within the Acute Public Hospital System’, in R. Busse, A. Geissler, W. Quentin and M. Wiley (eds), Diagnosis Related Groups in Europe. Moving Towards Transparency, Efficiency and Quality in Hospitals, Maidenhead: Open University Press.
Oliver, A. (2005), ‘The English National Health Service: 1979–2005’, Health Economics, 14(Supplement 1): S75S99.
Or, Z. (2009), ‘Activity based payment in France’, Euro Observer, 11(4): 56.
Or, Z.Bellanger, M. (2011), ‘France: Implementing Homogeneous Patient Groups in a Mixed Market’, in R. Busse, A. Geissler, W. Quentin and M. Wiley (eds), Diagnosis Related Groups in Europe. Moving Towards Transparency, Efficiency and Quality in Hospitals, Maidenhead: Open University Press.
Or, Z.Häkkinen, U. (2011), ‘DRGs and Quality: For Better or Worse’?, in R. Busse, A. Geissler, W. Quentin and M. Wiley (eds), Diagnosis Related Groups in Europe. Moving Towards Transparency, Efficiency and Quality in Hospitals, Maidenhead: Open University Press.
Pronovost, P. J., Goeschel, C. A.Wachter, R. M. (2008), ‘The wisdom and justice of not paying for “preventable complications” ’, Journal of the American Medical Association, 299(18): 21972199.
Propper, C., Sutton, M., Whitnall, C., Windmeijer, F. (2007), Did ‘targets and terror’ reduce English waiting times for elective hospital care?, CMPO Working Paper no. 07/179, Bristol: Centre for Market and Public Organisation.
Rosenberg, M. A.Browne, M. J. (2001), ‘The impact of the inpatient prospective payment system and diagnosis-related groups: a survey of the literature’, North American Actuarial Journal, 5(4): 8494.
Scheller-Kreinsen, D., Geissler, A.Busse, R. (2009), ‘The ABC of DRGs’, Euro Observer, 11(4): 15.
Schreyögg, J., Stargardt, T., Tiemann, O.Busse, R. (2006a), ‘Methods to determine reimbursement rates for diagnosis related groups (DRG): a comparison of nine European countries’, Health Care Management Science, 9(3): 215223.
Schreyögg, J., Tiemann, O.Busse, R. (2005), ‘The DRG reimbursement system in Germany’, Euro Observer, 7(4): 46.
Schreyögg, J., Tiemann, O.Busse, R. (2006b), ‘Cost accounting to determine prices: how well do prices reflect costs in the German DRG-system’?, Health Care Management Science, 9(3): 269279.
Shleifer, A. (1985), ‘A theory of yardstick competition’, RAND Journal of Economics, 16(3): 319327.
Smith, P. C.Street, A. (2005), ‘Measuring the efficiency of public services: the limits of analysis’, Journal of the Royal Statistical Society. Series A (Statistics in Society), 168(2): 401417.
Steinbusch, P. J., Oostenbrink, J. B., Zuurbier, J. J.Schaepkens, F. J. (2007), ‘The risk of upcoding in casemix systems: a comparative study’, Health Policy, 81(2-3): 289299.
Street, A. (2006), ‘Reform of Hospital Funding and the Introduction of Patient Choice in England’, http://www.york.ac.uk/inst/che/pdf/REES%205-2%20English.pdf [24 August 2010].
Street, A.Maynard, A. (2007), ‘Activity based financing in England: the need for continual refinement of payment by results’, Health Economics, Policy and Law, 2(4): 419427.
Street, A., Miraldo, M. (2007), ‘The impact of the reform of hospital funding in England’, Paper presented at Evaluating Health Policy: New Evidence from Administrative Data, University of York, http://www.york.ac.uk/media/che/documents/papers/che-2007-impactreform.pdf [15 August 2011].
Street, A., O'Reilly, J., Ward, P.Mason, A. (2011), ‘DRG-Based Hospital Payment and Efficiency: Theory, Evidence, and Challenges’, in R. Busse, A. Geissler, W. Quentin and M. Wiley (eds), Diagnosis Related Groups in Europe. Moving Towards Transparency, Efficiency and Quality in Hospitals, Maidenhead: Open University Press.
Street, A., Scheller-Kreinsen, D., Geissler, A., Busse, R. (2010), Determinants of hospital costs and performance variation: methods, models and variables for the EuroDRG Project, Working Papers in Health Policy and Management Volume 3, Berlin: Berlin University of Technology.
Street, A., Vitikainen, K., Bjorvatn, A., Hvenegaard, A. (2007), Introducing activity-based financing: a review of experience in Australia, Denmark, Norway and Sweden, CHE Research Paper 30, York: University of York.
Sussex, J.Farrar, S. (2009), ‘Activity-based funding for National Health Service hospitals in England: managers’ experience and expectations’, European Journal of Health Economics, 10(2): 197206.
Tan, S. S., Serdén, L., Geissler, A., van Ineveld, M., Redekop, K., Heurgren, M.Hakkaart-van Roijen, L. (2011), ‘DRGs and Cost Accounting: Which is Driving Which’?, in R. Busse, A. Geissler, W. Quentin and M. Wiley (eds), Diagnosis Related Groups in Europe. Moving Towards Transparency, Efficiency and Quality in Hospitals, Maidenhead: Open University Press.
US Congress Office of Technology Assessment (1985), Medicare's Prospective Payment System: Strategies for Evaluating Cost, Quality, and Medical Technology, Washington, DC: US Government Printing Office.
Vuorenkoski, L., Mladovsky, P.Mossialos, E. (2008), ‘Finland: health system review’, Health Systems in Transition, 10(4): 1168.
Wiley, M. (2005a), ‘Diagnosis Related Groups (DRGs): Measuring Hospital Case Mix’, in P. Armitage and T. Colton (eds), Encyclopedia of Biostatistics, Chichester: John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
Wiley, M. M. (2005b), ‘The Irish health system: developments in strategy, structure, funding and delivery since 1980’, Health Economics, 14(Supplement 1): S169S186.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Health Economics, Policy and Law
  • ISSN: 1744-1331
  • EISSN: 1744-134X
  • URL: /core/journals/health-economics-policy-and-law
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed