Skip to main content
    • Aa
    • Aa
  • Get access
    Check if you have access via personal or institutional login
  • Cited by 15
  • Cited by
    This article has been cited by the following publications. This list is generated based on data provided by CrossRef.

    Boonen, Lieke H. H. M. Laske-Aldershof, Trea and Schut, Frederik T. 2016. Switching health insurers: the role of price, quality and consumer information search. The European Journal of Health Economics, Vol. 17, Issue. 3, p. 339.

    Duijmelinck, Daniëlle and van de Ven, Wynand 2016. What can Europe learn from the managed care backlash in the United States?. Health Policy, Vol. 120, Issue. 5, p. 509.

    Maarse, Hans Jeurissen, Patrick and Ruwaard, Dirk 2016. Results of the market-oriented reform in the Netherlands: a review. Health Economics, Policy and Law, Vol. 11, Issue. 02, p. 161.

    van der Geest, Stéphanie A. and Varkevisser, Marco 2016. Using the deductible for patient channeling: did preferred providers gain patient volume?. The European Journal of Health Economics, Vol. 17, Issue. 5, p. 645.

    Boncz, Imre Evetovits, Tamás Dózsa, Csaba Sebestyén, Andor Gulácsi, László Ágoston, István Endrei, Dóra Csákvári, Tímea and Getzen, Thomas E. 2015. The Hungarian Care Managing Organization Pilot Program. Value in Health Regional Issues, Vol. 7, p. 27.

    Kerpershoek, Emiel F.P. Bes, Romy E. Curfs, Emile C. and de Jong, Judith D. 2015. Herkomst en aanwending van de winst van zorgverzekeraars vanuit verzekerdenperspectief. Tijdschrift voor gezondheidswetenschappen, Vol. 93, Issue. 4, p. 133.

    Shmueli, Amir Stam, Piet Wasem, Jürgen and Trottmann, Maria 2015. Managed care in four managed competition OECD health systems. Health Policy, Vol. 119, Issue. 7, p. 860.

    Martinez-Giralt, X. 2014. Encyclopedia of Health Economics.

    Mikkers, Misja and Ryan, Padhraig 2014. “Managed competition” for Ireland? The single versus multiple payer debate. BMC Health Services Research, Vol. 14, Issue. 1,

    Bes, Romy E Wendel, Sonja Curfs, Emile C Groenewegen, Peter P and de Jong, Judith D 2013. Acceptance of selective contracting: the role of trust in the health insurer. BMC Health Services Research, Vol. 13, Issue. 1,

    Heinemann, Stephanie Leiber, Simone and Greß, Stefan 2013. Managed competition in the Netherlands—A qualitative study. Health Policy, Vol. 109, Issue. 2, p. 113.

    Thomson, Sarah Busse, Reinhard Crivelli, Luca van de Ven, Wynand and Van de Voorde, Carine 2013. Statutory health insurance competition in Europe: A four-country comparison. Health Policy, Vol. 109, Issue. 3, p. 209.

    van de Ven, Wynand P.M.M. Beck, Konstantin Buchner, Florian Schokkaert, Erik Schut, F.T. (Erik) Shmueli, Amir and Wasem, Juergen 2013. Preconditions for efficiency and affordability in competitive healthcare markets: Are they fulfilled in Belgium, Germany, Israel, the Netherlands and Switzerland?. Health Policy, Vol. 109, Issue. 3, p. 226.

    Petsoulas, Christina Allen, Pauline Hughes, David Vincent-Jones, Peter and Roberts, Jennifer 2011. The use of standard contracts in the English National Health Service: A case study analysis. Social Science & Medicine, Vol. 73, Issue. 2, p. 185.

    Wendel, Sonja de Jong, Judith D and Curfs, Emile C 2011. Consumer evaluation of complaint handling in the Dutch health insurance market. BMC Health Services Research, Vol. 11, Issue. 1,


Preferred providers and the credible commitment problem in health insurance: first experiences with the implementation of managed competition in the Dutch health care system

  • Lieke H. H. M. Boonen (a1) and Frederik T. Schut (a1)
  • DOI:
  • Published online: 02 December 2010

We investigate the impact of the transition towards managed competition in the Dutch health care system on health insurers’ contracting behaviour. Specifically, we examine whether insurers have been able to take up their role as prudent buyers of care and examine consumers’ attitudes towards insurers’ new role. Health insurers’ contracting behaviour is investigated by an extensive analysis of available information on purchasing practices by health insurers and by interviews with directors of health care purchasing of the four major health insurers, accounting for 90% of the market. Consumer attitudes towards insurers’ new role are investigated by surveys among a representative sample of enrollees over the period 2005–2009. During the first four years of the reform, health insurers were very reluctant to engage in selective contracting and preferred to use ‘soft’ positive incentives to encourage preferred provider choice rather than engaging in restrictive managed care activities. Consumer attitudes towards channelling vary considerably by type of provider but generally became more negative in the first two years after the reform. Insurers’ reluctance to use selective contracting can be at least partly explained by the presence of a credible-commitment problem. Consumers do not trust that insurers with restrictive networks are committed to provide good quality care. The credible-commitment problem seems to be particularly relevant to the Netherlands, since Dutch enrollees are not used to restrictions on provider choice. Since consumers are quite sensitive to differences in provider quality, more reliable information about provider quality is required to reduce the credible-commitment problem.

Corresponding author
*Correspondence to: Lieke Boonen, Institute of Health Policy and Management, Erasmus University Rotterdam, PO Box 1738, 3000 DR Rotterdam, The Netherlands. Email:
Linked references
Hide All

This list contains references from the content that can be linked to their source. For a full set of references and notes please see the PDF or HTML where available.

C. Capps , D. Dranove M. Satterthwaite (2003), ‘Competition and market power in option demand markets’, RAND Journal of Economics, 34(4): 737763.

G. Claxton , J. R. Gabel , B. Dijulio , J. Pickreign , H. Whitmore , B. Finder , M. Jarlenski S. Hawkins (2008), ‘Health benefits in 2008: premiums moderately higher, while enrollment in consumer-directed plans rises in small firms’, Health Affairs, 27(6): 492502.

D. Dranove , R. Lindrooth , W. D. White J. Zwanziger (2008), ‘Is the impact of managed care on hospital prices decreasing?’, Journal of Health Economics, 27(2): 362376.

A. C. Enthoven W. P. M. M. van de Ven (2007), ‘Going Dutch – Managed-Competition Health Insurance in the Netherlands’, The New England Journal of Medicine, 357(24): 24212423.

S. Glied (2000), ‘Managed care’, in A. J. and J. P. Newhouse (eds), Handbook of Health Economics, Volume 1. Amsterdam: Elsevier, 707753.

K. Ho (2009), ‘Barriers to entry of a vertically integrated health insurer: an analysis of welfare and entry costs’, Journal of Economics and Management Strategy, 18(2): 487545.

G. A. Melnick , J. Zwanziger , A. Bamezai R. Pattison (1992), ‘The effects of market structure and bargaining position on hospital prices’, Journal of Health Economics, 11(3): 217233.

N. H. Miller (2006), ‘Insurer–provider integration, credible commitment, and managed-care backlash’, Journal of Health Economics, 25(5): 861876.

M. V. Pauly (1987), ‘Monopsony power in health insurance: thinking straight while standing on your head’, Journal of Health Economics, 6(1): 7381.

A. T. Sorensen (2003), ‘Insurer–hospital bargaining: negotiated discounts in post-deregulation connecticut’, Journal of Industrial Economics, 51(4): 469490.

M. Staten , W. Dunkelberg J. Umbeck (1987), ‘Market share and the illusion of power. Can Blue Cross force hospitals to discount?’, Journal of Health Economics, 6(1): 4358.

R. Town G. Vistnes (2001), ‘Hospital competition in HMO networks’, Journal of Health Economics, 20(5): 733753.

A. Tversky D. Kahneman (1991), ‘Loss aversion in riskless choice: a reference-dependent model’, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 106(4): 10391061.

W. P. Van de Ven F. T. Schut (2009), ‘Managed competition in the Netherlands: still work-in-progress’, Health Economics, 18(3): 253255.

B. Van den Berg , P. Van Dommelen , P. Stam , T. Laske-Aldershof , T. Buchmueller F. T. Schut (2008), ‘Preferences and choices for care and health insurance’, Social Science and Medicine, 66(12): 24482459.

V. Y. Wu (2009), ‘Managed care’s price bargaining with hospitals’, Journal of Health Economics, 28(2): 350360.

Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Health Economics, Policy and Law
  • ISSN: 1744-1331
  • EISSN: 1744-134X
  • URL: /core/journals/health-economics-policy-and-law
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *