Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-c47g7 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-23T17:27:11.063Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

ABOLITIONISM AND EVANGELICALISM: ISAAC NELSON, THE EVANGELICAL ALLIANCE, AND THE TRANSATLANTIC DEBATE OVER CHRISTIAN FELLOWSHIP WITH SLAVEHOLDERS*

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  08 May 2014

DANIEL RITCHIE
DANIEL RITCHIE*
Affiliation:
Queen's University, Belfast
*
School of History and Anthropology, Queen's University, 15 University Square, Belfast, BT7 1NNdritchie05@qub.ac.uk
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This article seeks to illuminate significantly our understanding of the link between abolitionism and evangelicalism by considering the debate at the formation of the Evangelical Alliance in 1846 surrounding the propriety of Christian fellowship with slaveholders. The leading critic of the pro-slavery faction was the Revd Isaac Nelson, an orthodox Presbyterian minister from Belfast, Ireland. Nelson's importance to anti-slavery was recognized by abolitionists on both sides of the Atlantic at the time, but has not yet been adequately analysed by historians. Hence, this article will examine Nelson's role in the dispute with the defenders of the American slaveholders at the London meeting in 1846 and in further debates within the Alliance on the slavery question. The article will conclude by examining Nelson's claim that the Alliance was a failure owing to its alleged compromise on the slavery question.

Type
Articles
Information
The Historical Journal , Volume 57 , Issue 2 , June 2014 , pp. 421 - 446
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2014 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

*

The author would like to thank Dr Andrew Holmes, Professor David Bebbington, Professor Crawford Gribben, Stuart Irwin, and the anonymous peer-reviewers for their feedback on earlier versions of this article. All mistakes in fact or interpretation are the sole responsibility of the author. The research for this article was conducted while the author was an AHRC doctoral candidate at Queen's University, Belfast.

References

1 Nelson, Isaac, The American War in relation to slavery (Belfast, 1863), p. 23Google Scholar.

2 Noll, M. A., America's God: from Jonathan Edwards to Abraham Lincoln (New York, NY, 2001), p. 387Google Scholar.

3 Wolffe, John, ‘Unity in diversity? North Atlantic evangelical thought in the mid-nineteenth century’, in Swanson, R. N., ed., Studies in church history, xxxii: Unity and diversity in the church (Oxford, 1996), pp. 363–75Google Scholar.

4 Huzzey, Richard, Freedom burning: anti-slavery and empire in Victorian Britain (Ithaca, NY, 2012), p. 77CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

5 Whyte, Iain, ‘Send back the money!’: the Free Church of Scotland and American slavery (Cambridge, 2012), pp. 45–6, 120–1Google Scholar.

6 Staiger, C. B., ‘Abolitionism and the Presbyterian schism of 1837–1838’, Mississippi Valley Historical Review, 36 (Dec. 1949), pp. 391–414CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at p. 391; Smith, E. A., ‘The role of the South in the Presbyterian schism of 1837–38’, Church History, 29 (Mar. 1960), pp. 44–63CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Marsden, G. M., The evangelical mind and the New School Presbyterian experience: a case study of thought and theology in nineteenth-century America (1970; Eugene, OR, 2003), pp. 59–103Google Scholar.

7 McKivigan, J. R., The war against proslavery religion: abolitionism and the Northern churches, 1830–1865 (Ithaca, NY, 1984), p. 74Google Scholar.

8 Noll, M. A., God and race in American politics: a short history (Princeton, NJ, 2008), p. 36CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

9 McKivigan, Proslavery religion, p. 125.

10 MacLear, J. F., ‘Thomas Smyth, Frederick Douglass, and the Belfast antislavery campaign’, Southern Carolina Historical Magazine, 80 (Oct. 1979), pp. 286–97Google Scholar, at p. 296.

11 Fifteenth annual report, presented to the Massachusetts Anti-Slavery Society, by its board of managers, January 27, 1847 (Boston, MA, 1847), p. 51. The report mistakenly says ‘john nelson’ when it is referring to Isaac.

12 Rodgers, Nini, Ireland, slavery and anti-slavery: 1612–1865 (paperback edn, Houndmills, 2009)Google Scholar. It is mentioned briefly in Douglas Riach's doctoral thesis. See D. C. Riach, ‘Ireland and the campaign against American slavery’ (Ph.D. thesis, Edinburgh, 1975), pp. 309–11.

13 Daniel Ritchie, ‘Evangelism, abolitionism, and Parnellism: the public career of the Revd Isaac Nelson’ (Ph.D. thesis, Queen's University Belfast, 2014), ch. 2.

14 Carson, J. T., God's river in spate: the story of the religious awakening of Ulster in 1859 (Belfast, 1958), p. 102Google Scholar.

15 Bebbington, D. W., Evangelicalism in modern Britain: a history from the 1730s to the 1980s (1989; London, 2002), pp. 1–19Google Scholar.

16 Ritchie, ‘Evangelicalism, abolitionism, and Parnellism’, ch. 1.

17 Fox-Genovese, Elizabeth and Genovese, E. D., The mind of the master class: history and faith in the Southern slaveholder's worldview (New York, NY, 2005), p. 499CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

18 Oshatz, Molly, ‘The problem of moral progress: the slavery debates and the development of liberal Protestantism in the United States’, Modern Intellectual History, 5 (2008), pp. 225–50CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at p. 230.

19 Evangelical Alliance. Report of the proceedings of the conference, held at Freemasons' Hall, London, from August 19th to September 2nd inclusive, 1846 (London, 1847), p. 375.

20 Although there is reason to believe that Nelson was influenced by the Scottish Enlightenment's approach to slavery (especially since he was a common sense realist), this outlook was not inconsistent with Christianity or belief in the authority of the Bible. See Whyte, Iain, Scotland and the abolition of black slavery, 1756–1838 (Edinburgh, 2006), pp. 50–66CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Ritchie, Daniel, ‘Antislavery orthodoxy: Isaac Nelson and the Free Church of Scotland, c. 1843–65’, Scottish Historical Review (forthcoming)Google Scholar.

21 Even various Southern evangelicals realized the poverty of appealing to the Old Testament's permission to hold the heathen as bond-servants, especially after their slaves had converted to Christianity. Irons, C. F., The origins of proslavery Christianity: white and black evangelicals in colonial and antebellum Virginia (Chapel Hill, SC, 2008), p. 13CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

22 For an expanded discussion of these arguments, see Nelson, Isaac, Slavery supported by the American churches, and countenanced by recent proceedings in the Free Church of Scotland (Edinburgh, 1847)Google Scholar; Ritchie, ‘Antislavery orthodoxy’.

23 Nelson, Isaac, The year of delusion: a review of ‘The year of grace’ (Belfast, 1860–6), p. 122Google Scholar.

24 Nelson, Slavery supported, p. 14.

25 Carey, H. M., God's empire: religion and colonialism in the British world, c. 1801–1908 (Cambridge, 2011), pp. 62–4CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

26 See Ritchie, ‘Antislavery orthodoxy’.

27 Evangelical Alliance, p. 373.

28 Francis Calder to Louis Chamerovzow, 19 Oct. 1853, Oxford, Rhodes House, Bodleian Libraries, British and Foreign Anti-Slavery Society papers, MSS Brit.Emp.S.18.C29, fo. 21.

29 Nelson, Isaac, Person and work of the Holy Spirit (Belfast, 1859), p. 24Google Scholar; Daniel Ritchie, ‘Transatlantic delusions and pro-slavery religion: Isaac Nelson's evangelical abolitionist critique of revivalism in America and Ulster’, Journal of American Studies (first-view 2014), http://journals.cambridge.org/action/displayAbstract?fromPage=online&aid=9174982.

30 Nelson, Isaac, Evangelical Alliance: letter from the Rev. Isaac Nelson, of Belfast, member of the Alliance, to the ‘Belfast Newsletter’ in reply to a correspondent (Manchester, 1846), p. 3Google Scholar.

31 Hansard 3 (Commons), cclvii, col. 459 (9 Feb. 1881); Glasgow Herald, 10 Feb. 1881.

32 Banner of Ulster, 9 Dec. 1845, 10 Feb. 1846; Belfast News-Letter, 10 Apr. 1846; Calver, Clive, ‘The rise and fall of the Evangelical Alliance: 1835–1905’, in Brady, Steve and Rowdon, Harold, eds., For such a time as this: perspectives on evangelicalism, past, present and future (London, 1996), p. 153Google Scholar; Maclear, J. F., ‘The Evangelical Alliance and the antislavery crusade’, Huntington Library Quarterly, 42 (1979), pp. 141–64CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at pp. 143–4.

33 Wolffe, John, The Protestant crusade in Great Britain, 1829–1860 (Oxford, 1991)CrossRefGoogle Scholar, pp. 107, 137ff, 159, 219, 249, 318; Wolffe, John, ‘The Evangelical Alliance in the 1840s: an attempt to institutionalize Christian unity’, in Sheils, W. J. and Wood, Diana, eds., Studies in church history, xxiii: Voluntary religion (Oxford, 1986), pp. 340–1Google Scholar; Calver, ‘Evangelical Alliance’, p. 153.

34 Hilton, Boyd, A mad, bad, & dangerous people? England, 1783–1846 (Oxford, 2006), p. 238Google Scholar.

35 Doyle, Mark, Fighting like the devil for the sake of God: Protestants, Catholics and the origins of violence in Victorian Belfast (Manchester, 2009), p. 176Google Scholar; Hirst, Catherine, Religion, politics and violence in nineteenth-century Belfast: the Pound and Sandy Row (Dublin, 2002)Google Scholar, pp. 106, 109, 166.

36 Wolffe, John, The expansion of evangelicalism: the age of Wilberforce, More, Chalmers and Finney (Leicester, 2006), p. 230Google Scholar; Hempton, D. N., ‘The Methodist crusade in Ireland, 1795–1845’, Irish Historical Studies, 22 (Mar. 1980), pp. 33–48CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at p. 47.

37 Wolffe, John, ‘A transatlantic perspective: Protestantism and national identities in mid-nineteenth-century Britain and the United States’, in Claydon, Tony and McBride, Ian, eds., Protestantism and national identity: Britain and Ireland, c. 1650–1850 (Cambridge, 1998), pp. 293–4Google Scholar; Maclear, ‘Evangelical Alliance’, pp. 143–4.

38 Belfast Protestant Journal, 6 Dec. 1845.

39 Sandeen, E. R., ‘The distinctiveness of American denominationalism: a case study of the 1846 Evangelical Alliance’, Church History, 45 (June 1976), pp. 222–34CrossRefGoogle Scholar, at p. 232.

40 Rouse, Ruth, ‘Voluntary movements and the changing ecumenical climate’, in Rouse, Ruth and Neill, S. C., eds., A history of the ecumenical movement, 1517–1948 (2nd edn, London, 1967), pp. 318–19Google Scholar; Liverpool Mercury, 10 Oct. 1845; Sheffield & Rotherham Independent, 11 Oct. 1845; Belfast News-Letter, 10, 14 Oct. 1845.

41 Wolffe, ‘Unity in diversity’, pp. 373–4; Wolffe, Expansion of evangelicalism, pp. 230–1; Calver, ‘Evangelical Alliance’, p. 150; Maclear, ‘Evangelical Alliance’, pp. 144, 152–4; Sandeen, ‘American denominationalism’, pp. 223, 234; Witness, 8 Apr. 1846; Caledonian Mercury, 9 Apr. 1846; Morning Post, 16 Apr. 1846.

42 Hutchinson, Mark and Wolffe, John, A short history of global evangelicalism (Cambridge, 2012), p. 19CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

43 Vidler, A. R., The church in an age of revolution: 1789 to the present (1971; London, 1990), p. 257Google Scholar.

44 Wolffe, ‘Unity in diversity’, p. 372.

45 Maclear, ‘Evangelical Alliance’, p. 146; The Evangelical Alliance; will slaveholders be admitted to membership in it? And will its influence go to support and perpetuate slavery?: letter from the committee of the Glasgow Emancipation Society to the Rev. John Angell James, the Rev. Dr. King, the Rev. Dr. Candlish (Glasgow, 1845).

46 Witness, 8 Apr. 1846; Maclear, ‘Evangelical Alliance’, pp. 145–6.

47 Ibid., pp. 143–4.

48 Morning Post, 16 Apr. 1846. The term ‘schismatic confederacy’ reflects the Anglican bias of the writer.

49 Ibid.

50 Maclear, ‘Evangelical Alliance’, pp. 144–7.

51 Ibid., p. 149.

52 Ibid., p. 153; P. J. Wallace, ‘“The bond of union”: the Old School Presbyterian Church and the American nation, 1837–1861’ (3 vols., Ph.D. thesis, Notre Dame, 2004), ii, p. 398.

53 Oshatz, Molly, ‘No ordinary sin: antislavery Protestants and the discovery of the social nature of morality’, Church History, 79 (June 2010), pp. 334–58CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

54 Anti-Slavery Reporter, 15 July 1840, p. 174; Maclear, ‘Evangelical Alliance’, p. 145.

55 Blackett, R. J. M., Building an antislavery wall: black Americans in the Atlantic abolitionist movement, 1830–1860 (Baton Rouge, LA, 1983), p. 32Google Scholar.

56 Francis Calder to John Scoble, 24 Dec. 1845, Oxford, Rhodes House, Bodleian Libraries, British and Foreign Anti-Slavery Society papers, MSS Brit.Emp.S.18.C14, fo. 124.

57 W. L. Garrison to H. E. Garrison, 13 Aug. 1846 in The letters of William Lloyd Garrison, ed. W. M. Merrill (6 vols., Cambridge, MA, 1971–81), iii, p. 368.

58 W. L. Garrison to Edmund Quincy, 18 Sept. 1846 in Letters, iii, pp. 418–20.

59 Nelson, Slavery supported, p. 13; Eclectic Review, Dec. 1846, p. 762.

60 See J. H. Y. Briggs, ‘Hinton, John Howard (1791–1873)’, Oxford dictionary of national biography (ODNB), www.oxforddnb.com/view/article/13356.

61 Evangelical Alliance, p. 286.

62 Ibid., p. 290.

63 Ibid., p. 291.

64 Ibid., p. 292; Caledonian Mercury, 22 June 1840; Anti-Slavery Reporter, 1 July 1840, p. 153; Calver, ‘Evangelical Alliance’, p. 51.

65 Maclear, ‘Evangelical Alliance’, p. 157.

66 Evangelical Alliance, pp. 293–4.

67 W. L. Garrison to H. C. Wright, 18 Sept. 1846, Boston Public Library, Garrison papers, MS A.1.1.v.4.p. 35.

68 Evangelical Alliance, p. 294.

69 Ibid., p. 295.

70 Ibid.

71 Ibid., pp. 296, 328, 339.

72 For examples, see Evangelical Alliance, pp. 301 317, 325–7, 331.

73 Made by Dr William Patton. Ibid., p. 314.

74 Made by President Robert Emerory of the Methodist Episcopal Church. Ibid., p. 318.

75 Made by Thomas Smyth. Ibid., p. 305; Hart, D. G. and Muether, J. R., Seeking a better country: 300 years of American Presbyterianism (Phillipsburg, NJ, 2007), p. 142Google Scholar; Long, K. T., The revival of 1857–1858: interpreting an American religious awakening (New York, NY, 1998), p. 94Google Scholar.

76 Made by Smyth. Evangelical Alliance, p. 319.

77 Made by Dr Thomas Harvey Skinner, a New York Presbyterian. Ibid., p. 333.

78 Ibid., p. 325.

79 Ibid., pp. 336–8.

80 Ibid., p. 323.

81 Ibid., p. 316.

82 Ibid., pp. 338–40.

83 Ibid., p. 370.

84 Ibid., p. 371.

85 Maclear, ‘Evangelical Alliance’, p. 156.

86 Evangelical Alliance, p. 371.

87 C. D. Rice, ‘The Scottish factor in the fight against American slavery, 1830–1870’ (Ph.D. thesis, University of Edinburgh, 1969), p. 353.

88 Evangelical Alliance, p. 372.

89 Ibid.

90 Ibid., p. 373.

91 Ibid., p. 374. This argument had earlier been made by Frederick Douglass Arbroath Guide, 14 Feb. 1846. Nelson's specific point may also be found in the Liberator, 26 Mar. 1836. For more on Owen's religious infidelity, see Leopold, R. W., Robert Dale Owen: a biography (Cambridge, MA, 1940)Google Scholar, pp. 8, 58, 65ff, 387; Liberator, 20 Dec. 1834; Ian Donnachie, ‘Owen, Robert Dale (1801–1877)’, ODNB, www.oxforddnb.com/view/article/21028.

92 Evangelical Alliance, p. 375.

93 Ibid., pp. 376–8.

94 Ibid., p. 384.

95 Ibid., p. 385; Bradford & Wakefield Observer, 3 Sept. 1846; Rice, ‘Scottish factor’, p. 355.

96 Evangelical Alliance, p. 438.

97 Ibid., p. 441.

98 See a copy of the protest in the Liberator, 25 Sept. 1846; Anti-Slavery Reporter, 1 Oct. 1846, p. 165.

99 MacLear, ‘Evangelical Alliance’, p. 160.

100 Evangelical Alliance, p. 442.

101 Ibid.

102 Ibid., p. 443.

103 Ibid. Although it should be noted that other Irish Presbyterian ministers remained silent during the debate on slavery.

104 Ibid., p. 444.

105 Ibid., pp. 445–7.

106 Ibid., p. 454.

107 Ibid., p. 456. Himes later challenged this. Belfast Commercial Chronicle, 14 Sept. 1846.

108 Evangelical Alliance, p. 457; Maclear, ‘Evangelical Alliance’, p. 164.

109 For a similar conclusion about the American delegates in general, see Turley, David, The culture of English antislavery, 1780–1860 (London, 1991), pp. 210–11CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

110 Carwardine, R. J., Evangelicals and politics in antebellum America (New Haven, CT, 1993), pp. 139–41CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

111 McKivigan, Proslavery religion, pp. 53–4.

112 Howe, D. W., What hath God wrought: the transformation of America, 1815–1848 (paperback edn, Oxford, 2009)Google Scholar, p. 702ff; McPherson, J. M., Battle cry of freedom: the American Civil War (1988; London, 1990)Google Scholar, pp. 5, 42, 46–51.

113 Wolffe, Protestant crusade, pp. 315–16.

114 Evangelical Alliance, pp. 457–8. For Bunting, see Hempton, David, Methodism and politics in British society, 1750–1850 (Standford, CA, 1984), pp. 195–7Google Scholar; Vidler, Age of revolution, p. 41; D. W. Bebbington, The dominance of evangelicalism: the age of Spurgeon and Moody (Leicester, 2005), p. 55.

115 Evangelical Alliance, pp. 459–60.

116 Belfast Commercial Chronicle, 7 Sept. 1846.

117 Belfast Protestant Journal, 10 Oct. 1846.

118 Londonderry Standard, 9 Oct. 1846.

119 Ibid., 30 Oct. 1846.

120 Sixteenth annual report, presented to the Massachusetts Anti-Slavery Society, by its board of managers, January 26, 1848 (Boston, MA, 1848), p. 35.

121 Daily News, 15 Sept. 1846; Merrill, W. M., Against wind and tide: a biography of Wm. Lloyd Garrison (Cambridge, MA, 1965), p. 194Google Scholar.

122 See W. L. Garrison to Elizabeth Pease, 12 Oct. 1846, Boston Public Library, Garrison papers, MS A.1.1. v.4.no. 40; W. L. Garrison to the Liberator, 20 Oct. 1846, in Letters, iii, pp. 437–8; Northern Whig, 6 Oct. 1846; Banner of Ulster, 9 Oct. 1846; Witness, 24 Oct. 1846.

123 Minutes of the Glasgow Emancipation Society, 30 Sept. 1846, Glasgow, Mitchell Library, Smeal Collection, 324926.

124 Banner of Ulster, 16 Oct. 1846; Belfast Commercial Chronicle, 26 Oct. 1846; Londonderry Standard, 30 Oct. 1846.

125 Nelson, Evangelical Alliance, p. 4; Whyte, Scotland and the abolition of black slavery, p. 205.

126 James Standfield to W. L. Garrison, 22 Oct. 1846, Boston Public Library, Garrison papers, MS.A.1.2.v.16.p. 116.

127 Northern Whig, 6 Oct. 1846; Belfast News-Letter, 6 Oct. 1846.

128 Belfast News-Letter, 9 Oct. 1846.

129 Belfast Protestant Journal, 10 Oct. 1846.

130 Belfast Commercial Chronicle, 10 Oct. 1846.

131 Liberator, 11 Dec. 1846.

132 Nelson, American War, p. 33.

133 Belfast News-Letter, 16 Oct., 10 Nov. 1846; Wolffe, Expansion of evangelicalism, p. 199.

134 Manchester Times, 6 Nov. 1846; Maclear, ‘Evangelical Alliance’, p. 141.

135 Nelson, Slavery supported, pp. 16–17.

136 Free Church Magazine, Jan. 1847, pp. 3–5. The editor at this time was the Revd William M. Hetherington.

137 Minutes of the Glasgow Emancipation Society, 29 Jan. 1847, Glasgow, Mitchell Library, Smeal Collection, 324926.

138 Nelson, Slavery supported, p. 17; Liberator, 28 May 1847.

139 Nelson, Slavery supported, pp. 7–8.

140 Ibid., p. 8. For the resolutions, see Liberator, 12 Mar. 1836, 7 May 1841.

141 Nelson, Slavery supported, p. 10. Nelson's argument is substantially the same as that of the Liberator, 2 Oct. 1846; Oberlin Evangelist, 24 June 1846, p. 101; Daily News, 15 Sept. 1846.

142 Belfast News-Letter, 14 July 1843.

143 Nelson, Slavery supported, pp. 14–15.

144 Sandeen, ‘American denominationalism’, p. 226.

145 Liberator, 28 May 1847.

146 Daily News, 15 Sept. 1846.

147 Liberator, 21 Nov. 1845.

148 Noll, America's God, p. 387; Oshatz, ‘Problem of moral progress’, p. 229.

149 Liberator, 21 Nov. 1845.

150 Belfast Commercial Chronicle, 5 Oct. 1846.

151 McKivigan, Proslavery religion, pp. 58–61.

152 Turley, English antislavery, p. 204; McKivigan, Proslavery religion, p. 80.

153 Evangelical Alliance, p. 442.

154 Whyte, Send back the money!, p. 123.

155 W. L. Garrison to R. D. Webb, 5 Sept. 1846, Boston Public Library, Garrison papers, MS.A.1.1.v.4.

156 Rice, ‘Scottish factor’, p. 355.

157 Turley, English antislavery, p. 211.

158 American Freeman, 26 May 1847; Banner of Ulster, 29 June 1847.

159 Anti-Slavery Reporter, 1 July 1847, p. 107.

160 American Freeman, 26 May 1847.

161 Banner of Ulster, 29 June 1847.

162 National Era, 13 May 1847; American Freeman, 7 July 1847.

163 Anti-Slavery Reporter, 1 July 1847, p. 108.

164 Glasgow Argus, 17 May 1847.

165 Caledonian Mercury, 14 June 1847; Edinburgh Evening Post & Scottish Record, 16 June 1847; Evangelical Christendom, July 1847, p. 222.

166 Liberator, 9 July 1847. Watson was an Edinburgh Baptist minister. Robert Botsford, ‘Scotland and the American Civil War’ (Ph.D. thesis, Edinburgh, 1956), p. 90.

167 For example, see Hutchinson and Wolffe, Global evangelicalism, p. 3; Calver, ‘Evangelical Alliance’, p. 151; Sandeen, ‘American denominationalism’, p. 226; Maclear, ‘Evangelical Alliance’, p. 160; Rice, C. D., The Scots abolitionists, 1833–1861 (Baton Rouge, LA, 1981), p. 124Google Scholar.

168 Nelson, Slavery supported, p. 16; idem, Evangelical Alliance, p. 8.

169 Nelson, American War, p. 30.

170 Rouse, ‘Voluntary movements’, pp. 321–2.

171 Calver, ‘Evangelical Alliance’, p. 155; Thompson, Todd, ‘The Evangelical Alliance, religious liberty, and the evangelical conscience in nineteenth-century Britain’, Journal of Religious History, 33 (Mar. 2009), pp. 49–65CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

172 Wolffe, Protestant crusade, pp. 159–60; Wolffe, ‘Evangelical Alliance’, pp. 340–1. It was also not anti-Tractarian enough for some Anglicans. Wisenant, J. C., A fragile unity: anti-ritualism and the division of Anglican evangelicalism in the nineteenth century (Milton Keynes, 2003), p. 38Google Scholar.

173 Wolffe, ‘Evangelical Alliance’, p. 346; Chadwick, Owen, The Victorian church (2 vols., London, 1966)Google Scholar, i, p. 441.

174 Machin, G. I. T., ‘The Maynooth grant, the dissenters, and disestablishment’, English Historical Review, 82 (Jan. 1967), pp. 61–85CrossRefGoogle Scholar at p. 74.

175 Wolffe, ‘Evangelical Alliance’, pp. 345–6; Banner of Ulster, 8 Dec. 1848.

176 Anti-Slavery Reporter, 2 Nov. 1846, pp. 185–6.

177 Banner of Ulster, 4 Sept. 1846.

178 Ibid., 12 Dec. 1845; Belfast Commercial Chronicle, 13 Dec. 1845.

179 Belfast News-Letter, 15 Sept. 1852; Northern Whig, 16 Sept. 1852; Wolffe, Protestant crusade, pp. 267, 283; Thompson, ‘Evangelical Alliance’, pp. 53–4.

180 Belfast Commercial Chronicle, 15 Sept. 1852.

181 Belfast News-Letter, 7 Dec. 1859.

182 Nelson, Isaac, The present importance of Irish History (Belfast, 1874), p. 42Google Scholar; cf. Berkley, L. E., ‘Evangelization of Ireland’, in Schaff, Philip and Prime, S. I., eds., Evangelical Alliance conference, 1873: history, essays, and other documents of the Sixth General Conference of the Evangelical Alliance, held in New York, October 2–12, 1873 (New York, NY, 1874), pp. 508–16Google Scholar.

183 Freeman's Journal, 11 Oct. 1880.