‘Commerce and Christianity’: The Rise and Fall of a Nineteenth-Century Missionary Slogan*
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 11 February 2009
‘“What,” some simple-minded man might say, “is the connection between the Gospel and commerce?”’ Speaking in Leeds in May 1860 on behalf of the Universities' Mission to Central Africa, Bishop Samuel Wilberforce was characteristically robust with his rhetorical question and no less direct in furnishing the answer. ‘There is a great connection between them. In the first place, there is little hope of promoting commerce in Africa, unless Christianity is planted in it; and, in the next place, there is very little ground for hoping that Christianity will be able to make its proper way unless we can establish a lawful commerce in the country’. Britain's part in forging the connexion was abundantly clear. It was effect of training the human race to a degree of excellence which it could never attain in non-Christian countries', giving ‘value to life’, ‘dignity to labour’ and ‘security to possession’, with the result that a Christian people would tend to be ‘a wealth-producing people, an exporting people and so a commercial people’.
- The Historical Journal , Volume 28 , Issue 3 , September 1985 , pp. 597 - 621
- Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1985
1 Wilberforce, Samuel, Speeches on missions, ed. RevRowley, Henry (London, 1874), p. 213Google Scholar.
4 Stanley, B., ‘“Commerce and Christianity”: providence theory, the missionary movement, and the imperialism of free trade, 1842–1860’, Historical Journal, 26 (1983), 72CrossRefGoogle Scholar, 93.
5 RevMonk, William (ed.), Dr Livingstone's Cambridge lectures (Cambridge, 1858), pp. 19–21Google Scholar ; Stanley, p. 93.
6 Porter, Andrew, ‘Cambridge, Keswick, and late nineteenth century attitudes to Africa’, Journal of Imperial and Commonwealth History, v (1976–1977), 5–34CrossRefGoogle Scholar ; idem, ‘Evangelical enthusiasm, missionary motivation, and West Africa in the late nineteenth century: the career of G. W. Brooke’, ibid, VI (1977–8), 23–46.
7 Marshall, P. J. and Williams, G., The great map of mankind: British perceptions of the world in the age of enlightenment (London, 1982), pp. 147, 149Google Scholar.
8 Edinburgh Review, XII (04 1808), 151–81Google Scholar, ‘Publications respecting Indian Missions’, p. 170.
9 Eclectic Review, I (10 1805), 762Google Scholar, in reviewing Indian recreations by the Rev. William Tennant.
11 Eclectic Review, I (12 1805), 884Google Scholar, in reviewing African memoranda by Capt. P. Beaver.
14 Edinburgh Review, XXI (02 1813), 64–6Google Scholar, in reviewing Travels into Southern Africa by Henry Lich tenstein; RevHanna, W., Memoirs of the life and writings of Thomas Chalmers (4 vols., Edinburgh, 1849–1852), I, 390–2Google Scholar.
15 Roxborough, W. J., ‘Thomas Chalmers and the mission of the Church with special reference to the rise of the missionary movement in Scotland’ (Aberdeen, Ph.D. thesis, 1978), pp. 307, 359Google Scholar.
16 Carey, William, An enquiry into the obligations of Christians, to use means for the conversion of the heathens (Leicester, 1792), p. 68Google Scholar. The biblical reference is to Isaiah, ch. lx, verse 9.
18 Bogue, David, ‘Objections against a mission to the heathen, stated and considered’, Sermons preached in London at the formation of the missionary society (London, 1795), pp. 132–3Google Scholar; the published Instructions of the committee of the Church Missionary Society and Proceedings of the Church Missionary Society, when missionaries left for the field are full of warnings on these questions.
19 Grant, Charles, Observations on the state of society among the Asiatic subjects of Great Britain, written in 1792, printed in P.P. 1831–2, VIII (734)Google Scholar, Report from the select committee on the affairs of the East India Company, General Appendix I.
20 Embree, A. T., Charles Grant and British rule in India (London, 1963), pp. 47Google Scholar, 118, 142–4, and passim; Grant, , Observations, p. 88Google Scholar.
21 Cf. the argument in Anstey, R. T., The Atlantic slave trade and British abolition, 1760–1810 (London, 1975), ch. 14CrossRefGoogle Scholar; and Chalmers, Thomas, The utility of missions ascertained by experience (2nd edn, Edinburgh, 1816), p. 19Google Scholar.
22 See the petitions from supporters of missionaries in 1813, Parliamentary Debates, XXV and XXVI.
24 Ibid, XXV, 1092–3, 28 April 1813, Petition of elders and ministers of the provincial synod of Glasgow.
27 Edinburgh Review, XII (04 1808), 179–80Google Scholar; cf. Parliamentary Register, XVIII, 685, 11 06 1802Google Scholar , speech by General Gascoyne on Sierra Leone.
28 Claudius Buchanan at the C.M.S. Anniversary Meeting, 1810, quoted in Bearce, G., British attitudes towards India, 1784–1858 (Oxford, 1961), p. 82Google Scholar; Grant, in his Observations, talking of the diffusion of ‘our religion and knowledge’ as ‘the noblest species of conquest’, added ‘and wherever, we may venture to say, our principles and language are introduced, our commerce will follow.’, P.P. 1831–2Google Scholar , VIII (734), General Appendix I, p. 88.
29 Wilberforce, R. I. and Wilberforce, S., The life of William Wilberforce (5 vols., London, 1838), IV, 14Google Scholar, diary entry, 14 February 1812.
30 P.P. 1812–13, VII 18. Lord Teignmouth, previously Sir John Shore, governor-general in India, 1793–8, servant of the East India Company 1769–89, and member of the Board of Control 1807–28.
31 Parliamentary Debates, XXV, 493–500, 527–32, 648–56, April 1813, evidence of Thomas Graham, and Major-Gen. Alexander Kyd; ibid, XXVI, 436, May 1813, evidence of Mr Bruce.
33 Potts, E. D., British Baptist missionaries in India, 1793–1837 (Cambridge, 1967), pp. 70–4Google Scholar; Ingham, K., Reformers in India, 1793–1833: an account of the work of Christian missionaries on behalf trol of social reform (Cambridge, 1956)Google Scholar.
35 As examples of this commonly held view, Wilberforce, , Life, IV, III, Wilberforce, William to Wellesley, Lord, 6 04 1813Google Scholar; and Martyn, Henry, Sermons (Calcutta, 1822), no. XX, on the British and Foreign Bible SocietyGoogle Scholar.
36 Curtin, P. D., The image of Africa: British ideas and action, 1780–1850 (London, 1965), chs. 4–5Google Scholar; Fyfe, Christopher, A history of Sierra Leone (Oxford, 1962), p. 94Google Scholar; Peterson, J., Province of freedom: a history of Sierra Leone, 1787–1870 (London, 1969), ch. 1Google Scholar.
37 , P.P. 1801–1802, II (339), Report from the committee on the petition of the court of directors of the Sierra Leone Company, p. 7Google Scholar.
39 Ibid., and pp. 105–7; Austen, R. A. and Smith, W. D., ‘Images of Africa and British slave trade abolition: the transition to an imperialist ideology’, African Historical Studies, II (1969)Google Scholar.
44 P.P. 1801–2, II (339), 30–1, evidence of William Greaves.
45 James, J. A., Missionary prospects: a sermon the substance of which was delivered in Hoxton Chapel…1826, at the opening of Hoxton College as a missionary academy (Birmingham, 1826), p. 24Google Scholar.
47 For criticisms of a ‘wandering’ existence as inimical to Christianity, , The journals of the Rev. T. L. Hodgson, missionary to the Seleka-Rolong and the Griquas, 1821–31, ed. Cope, R. L. (Johannesburg, 1977), pp. 66, 76Google Scholar; notes by DrPhilip, John, ?1840, Philip papers, Rhodes House Library, Oxford, MSS Afr. s. 219C, fo. 591Google Scholar; Read, James (L.M.S. missionary) to SirCradock, John (governor, Cape of Good Hope), 23 09 1812, Council for World Mission Archive, School of Oriental and African Studies, London (hereafter L.M.S.) 5/1/B/12Google Scholar.
48 The Kitchingman papers: missionary letters and journals, 1817 to 1848, from the Brenthurst collection, Johannesburg, ed. Le Cordeur, Basil and Saunders, Christopher (Johannesburg, 1976), pp. 129–34, 138–45, 156–9Google Scholar.
49 Gunson, Niel, Messengers of grace: evangelical missionaries in the South Seas, 1797–1860 (Melbourne, 1978), PP. 115–21, 136Google Scholar; Williams, John, A narrative of missionary enterprises in the South Sea Islands (London, 1837)Google Scholar.
51 , L.M.S. directors to Philip, John, 9 04 1819, Philip papers, MSS Afr. s.216, fo. 70Google Scholar.
52 P.P. 1836, VII (538), and P.P. 1837, VII (425), contain the reports and proceedings of the select ican committee.
53 See Coates, D., Beecham, John and Ellis, William, Christianity the means of civilization (London, 1837), in which the missionary evidence was also published for a wider audienceGoogle Scholar.
54 , P.P. 1836, VII (538), Aborigines (British settlements): report from the select committee, qq. 4329–43Google Scholar; , P.P. 1837, VII (425), Report from the select committee on aborigines (British settlements), p. 74Google Scholar.
55 P.P. 1836, VII (538), qq. 4376, 4385–6.
56 T. F. Buxton papers, Rhodes House Library, Oxford; Mellor, G. R., British imperial trusteeship, 1783–1850 (London, 1951), ch. 7Google Scholar; Macmillan, W. M., The Cape colour question: a historical survey (London, 1927), chs. 10–13Google Scholar; idem, Bantu, Boer, and Briton: the making of the South African native problem (Oxford, 1963, rev. edn), pp. 187–90.
57 P.P. 1836, VII (538), qq. 4350, 4375, and passim.
58 Philip, J., Researches in South Africa (2 vols., London, 1828), especially I, ch. X, and II, 355–61Google Scholar; Macmillan, Cape coloured question. For evidence of Philip's own change of views under the impact of experience in the field, compare RevPhilip, John, Necessity of divine influence: a sermon preached before the Missionary Society…May 12, 1813 (London, 1813), with views of 1820–2, Philip papers, MSS Afr. s.216, fos. 91, 143Google Scholar.
60 P.P. 1836, VII (538), qq. 4345–7.
62 Kitchingman papers, p. 272; Philip, to MissBuxton, , 15 03 1832, Philip papers, MSS Afr. S.219B, fo. 328Google Scholar.
63 P.P. 1836, VII (538), q. 4383.
67 Ibid. q. 4367. In later years, commercial language and analogies were still more consciously developed by commentators: RevJohnston, James (ed.), Report of the centenary conference on the protestant missions of the world (2 vols., London, 1888), pp. 111–12Google Scholar.
70 Gallagher, J., ‘Fowell Buxton and the new African policy, 1838–42’, Cambridge Historical Journal, X (1950), 40Google Scholar; Curtin, p. 299; Macmillan, , Bantu, Boer, and Briton, pp. 186–7Google Scholar ; Pugh, P. M., Calendar of the papers of Sir T. F. Buxton, 1786–1845: List and Index Society: special series, Vol. 13 (London, 1979)Google Scholar.
71 Buxton, C. (ed.), Memoirs of Sir Thomas Fowell Buxton, Bart. (London, 1882), pp. 184–5Google Scholar.
72 Curtin, p. 300.
74 Buxton, T. F., The African slave trade and its remedy (London, 1840, 2nd edn), ch. 6 ‘The elevation of native minds’, pp. 502ffGoogle Scholar.
75 Gallagher, p. 49.
76 , P.P. 1842, XI (551), Report from the select committee on the West Coast of Africa, qq. 3586–722, 6471–539 7688–725Google Scholar.
78 Ibid. pp. xi-xii; Knight, W., Memoir of the Rev. H. Venn: the missionary secretariat of Henry Venn, B.D. (London, 1880), p. 277Google Scholar.
79 Webster, J. B., ‘The Bible and the plough’, Journal of the Historical Society of Nigeria, II (1963), 418–34Google Scholar; J. F. A. Ajayi, ‘Henry Venn and the policy of development’, ibid. I (1959), 331–42; idem, Christian missions in Nigeria, 1841–1891 (London, 1965), chs. 3–6.
80 Schapera, I. (ed.), Livingstone's missionary correspondence, 1841–1856 (London, 1961), p. 301Google Scholar, 12 October 1855.
82 Stanley, p. 93.
83 Stanley also points out that Christianity and commerce were not linked in the context of South America, ibid. p. 94.
86 Cambridge lectures, p. 24.
87 Chadwick, O., Mackenzie's grave (London, 1959)Google Scholar; Neave, D. R., ‘Aspects of the Universities' Mission to central Africa, 1858–1900’ (York, M.Phil, thesis, 1975)Google Scholar.
88 Report of the centenary conference, I, 111–37.
89 Porter, ‘Evangelical enthusiasm’.
90 Porter, ‘Cambridge, Keswick, and late nineteenth century attitudes’; Stanley, B., ‘Home support for overseas missions in early Victorian England, c.1838–1873’ (Cambridge, Ph.D. thesis, 1979)Google Scholar, ch.7, ‘The origins of “faith” missions’.
91 Cohen, P. A., China and Christianity: the missionary movement and the growth of Chouse anti-foreignism, 1860–1870 (Cambridge, Mass. 1963)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; idem, ‘Christian missions and their impact to 1900’, The Cambridge history of China, X. Late Ch'ing, 1800–1911, ed. Fairbank, J. K. and Twitchett, D. (Cambridge, 1976), pp. 543–90Google Scholar.
92 Missionary correspondence, p. 301.
93 Maples, E., Chauncy Maples (London, 1897), p. 350Google Scholar, 31 August 1893, and p. 354; Smith, H. M., Frank Bishop of Zanzibar: life of Frank Weston, D.D., 1871–1924 (London, 1926), pp. 24, 41, 96–7, 242Google Scholar.
95 Lorimer, A., Colour, class and the Victorians: English attitudes to the negro in the mid-nineteenth century (Leicester U.P., 1978)Google Scholar.
96 Piggin, S., ‘The social background, motivation, and training of British protestant missionaries to India, 1789–1858’ (London, Ph.D. thesis, 1974)Google Scholar, ch. 1.
97 Williams, C.P., ‘“Not quite gendemen”: an examination of “middling class” protestant missionaries from Britain, c. 1850–1900’, Journal of Ecclesiastical History, XXXI (1980), 301–15CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
98 Marsden, Rev. J. B., Memoirs of the life and letters of the Rev. Samuel Marsden (London, 1858)Google Scholar; The letters and journals of Samuel Marsden, 1765–1838, ed. Elder, J. R. (Dunedin, 1932)Google Scholar; Macmillan, H. W., ‘The origins and development of the African Lakes Company, 1878–1908’ (Edinburgh, Ph.D. thesis, 1970)Google Scholar; McCracken, J., Politics and Christianity in Malawi, 1875–1940 (Cambridge, 1977)Google Scholar.