Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-tj2md Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-24T12:17:06.070Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

NEGOTIATING FEMALE PROPERTY- AND SLAVE-OWNERSHIP IN THE ARISTOCRATIC WORLD

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  13 November 2019

HANNAH YOUNG Open the ORCID record for HANNAH YOUNG [Opens in a new window]
HANNAH YOUNG*
Affiliation:
University of Southampton
*
University of Southampton, Avenue Campus, Highfield Road, Southampton, SO17 1BFH.L.Young@soton.ac.uk
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This article uses Anna Eliza Grenville, first duchess of Buckingham and Chandos, as a lens through which to explore the gendering of aristocratic property- and slave-ownership in late eighteenth- and early nineteenth-century Britain. Alongside the extensive metropolitan property that Grenville brought to her marriage was Hope estate, a Jamaican plantation upon which worked 379 enslaved men, women, and children. Using legal records, family papers, and correspondence, the article examines the ways in which Grenville negotiated her position as a married woman and substantial property-owner, and considers what it meant for a married woman to ‘own’ property, landed and in the form of other human beings, in the late eighteenth- and early nineteenth-century aristocratic world. Examining her absentee slave-ownership alongside her metropolitan property-ownership highlights the complex intersections between race, class, and gender across both metropole and colony. In doing so, the article makes an important contribution to the rapidly expanding scholarship exploring female property-ownership in eighteenth- and nineteenth-century Britain, hitherto almost entirely metropolitan in focus. It demonstrates how seamlessly enslaved property could be integrated into aristocratic forms of property-ownership and transmission, and highlights the important role that women played in bringing slave-ownership ‘home’ to metropolitan Britain.

Type
Article
Information
The Historical Journal , Volume 63 , Issue 3 , June 2020 , pp. 581 - 602
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2019

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

Many thanks to Keith McClelland, Catherine Hall, Margot Finn, and the anonymous reviewers of the Historical Journal for their helpful comments, suggestions, and advice.

References

1 Anna Eliza Grenville to Richard Grenville, 2 May 1832, Huntington Library (HL), Stowe papers, Grenville family papers (STG), box 74 (40).

2 Bailey, Joanne, Unquiet lives: marriage and marriage breakdown in England, 1660–1800 (Cambridge, 2003), p. 109CrossRefGoogle Scholar. For the purposes of this article, ‘Grenville’ will refer to Anna Eliza Grenville. Her husband will be referred to as ‘Richard Grenville’ or ‘the duke’.

3 Grenville to Richard Grenville, 2 May 1832, HL, STG, box 74 (40).

4 Phillips, Nicola, Women in business, 1700–1850 (Woodbridge, 2006)Google Scholar; Barker, Hannah, The business of women: female enterprise and urban development in northern England, 1760–1830 (Oxford, 2006)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Kay, Allison C., The foundations of female entrepreneurship: enterprise, home and household in London, c. 1800–1870 (Abingdon, 2009)Google Scholar; Laurence, Anne, Maltby, Josephine, and Rutterford, Janette, eds., Women and their money, 1700–1950 (Abingdon, 2009)Google Scholar; Green, David R., Owens, Alistair, Maltby, Josephine, and Rutterford, Janette, eds., Men, women, and money: perspectives on gender, wealth, and investment, 1850–1930 (Oxford, 2011)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Gleadle, Kathryn, ‘“The riches and treasures of other countries”: women, empire and maritime expertise in early Victorian London’, Gender and History, 25 (2013), pp. 7–26CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Shepard, Alexandra, ‘Minding their own business: married women and credit in early eighteenth-century London’, Transactions of the Royal Historical Society, 25 (2015), pp. 53–74CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed; Aston, Jennifer, Female entrepreneurship in nineteenth-century England (London, 2016)CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

5 Alistair Owens, ‘A hidden investment? Women and business in England, c. 1750–1900’, pp. 1–39, at p. 34 (typescript English-language version of ‘Una inverió oculta? Dones i empresa a Anglaterra, 1750–1900’, Recerques: Historia, Economía y Cultura, 56 (2007), pp. 61–89Google Scholar).

6 Cannadine, David, The decline and fall of the British aristocracy (New Haven, CT, 1990), p. 7CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Casson, Janet, ‘Women's landownership in England in the nineteenth century’, in Casson, Mark and Hashimzade, Nigar, eds., Large databases in economic history: research methods and case studies (Abingdon, 2013), pp. 200–21, at p. 212CrossRefGoogle Scholar; McDonagh, Briony, Elite women and the agricultural landscape, 1700–1830 (Abingdon, 2018), p. 26CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

7 Reynolds, K. D., Aristocratic women and political society in Victorian Britain (Oxford, 1998), pp. 43–4CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

8 McDonagh, Elite women and the agricultural landscape, p. 161.

9 Erickson, Amy Louise, Women and property in early modern England (London, 1993)Google Scholar; Amy Erickson, ‘Rethinking the significance of inheritance and marriage in landholding’, keynote address presented at ‘Women, land and the making of the British landscape’ conference, University of Hull, 30 June 2015.

10 Carmichael, Mrs, Domestic manners and social condition of the white, coloured, and negro population of the West Indies (London, 1833), i, p. 16Google Scholar.

11 Walker, Christine, ‘Pursuing her profits: women in Jamaica, Atlantic slavery and a globalising market, 1700–60’, Gender and History, 26 (2014), pp. 478–501CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Walker, Christine, ‘Womanly masters: gendering slave ownership in colonial Jamaica’, in Foster, Thomas, ed., Women in early America: transnational histories, rethinking master narratives (New York, NY, 2015), pp. 160–81Google Scholar; Butler, Kathleen Mary, The economics of emancipation: Jamaica and Barbados, 1823–1843 (Chapel Hill, NC, 1995), pp. 92–108Google Scholar; Jones, Cecily, Engendering whiteness: white women and colonialism in Barbados and North Carolina, 1627–1865 (Manchester, 2007), p. 83Google Scholar; Mair, Lucille Mathurin, A historical study of women in Jamaica, 1655–1844 (Kingston, 2006)Google Scholar.

12 Draper, Nicholas, The price of emancipation: slave-ownership, compensation and British society at the end of slavery (Cambridge, 2010), p. 114Google Scholar.

13 Anon., Letters on the necessity of a prompt extinction of British colonial slavery; chiefly addressed to the more influential classes (London, 1826), p. 214Google Scholar.

14 Hall, Catherine, Draper, Nicholas, McClelland, Keith, Donington, Katie, and Lang, Rachel, Legacies of British slave-ownership: colonial slavery and the formation of Victorian Britain (Cambridge, 2014), pp. 255–6CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

15 Stretton, Tim and Kesselring, Krista J., ‘Introduction: coverture and continuity’, in Stretton, Tim and Kesselring, Krista J., eds., Married women and the law: coverture in England and the common law world (Montreal, 2013), pp. 7–8Google Scholar.

16 Erickson, Women and property, p. 26.

17 Mingay, G. E., English landed society in the eighteenth century (London, 1963), p. 32Google Scholar.

18 Habakkuk, John, Marriage, debt and the estates system: English landownership, 1650–1950 (Oxford, 1994), pp. 1–2CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

19 Trumbach, Randolph, The rise of the egalitarian family: aristocratic kinship and domestic relations in eighteenth-century England (New York, NY, 1978), p. 78Google Scholar.

20 Bonfield, Lloyd, ‘Affective families, open elites and strict family settlements in early modern England’, Economic History Review, 2nd ser., 39 (1986), pp. 341–54, at pp. 352–3CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

21 Spring, Eileen, ‘The strict settlement: its role in family history’, Economic History Review, 2nd ser., 41 (1988), pp. 454–60, at p. 459CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

22 Erickson, Women and property, p. 102.

23 Staves, Susan, Married women's separate property in England, 1660–1833 (Cambridge, MA, 1990), p. 203CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

24 Stobart, Jon and Owens, Alastair, ‘Introduction’, in Stobart, Jon and Owens, Alastair, eds., Urban fortunes: property and inheritance in the town, 1700–1900 (Aldershot, 2000), p. 2Google Scholar.

25 ‘Brief on petition’ in case of Brydges vs. Chandos, HL, STG legal, box 2 (12), p. 13.

26 Ibid., p. 18.

27 Miscellaneous papers concerning the fortune of Anna Eliza Brydges, HL, STG personal, box 11 (7).

28 Marriage settlement of Anna Eliza …, HL, STG personal, box 12 (4), p. 27.

29 ‘List of negroes on Hope plantation, 1 Jan. 1788’, HL, Stowe papers, West Indian estates (ST West Indies), box 3.

30 Staves, Married women's separate property, pp. 132–3.

31 Okin, Susan Moller, ‘Patriarchy and married women's property in England: questions on some current views’, Eighteenth-Century Women's Studies, 17 (1983–4), pp. 121–38, at p. 136CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Marriage settlement of Anna Eliza …, HL, STG personal, box 12 (4), p. 61; Anna Eliza Grenville to Messers Coutts, 17 Mar. 1834, HL, STG, box 264 (40).

32 Marriage settlement of Anna Eliza …, HL, STG personal, box 12 (4), pp. 63–7; ‘Brief on petition’, HL, STG legal, box 2 (12), p. 17.

33 Proposal by marquis of Buckingham …, HL, STG personal, box 12 (1).

34 ‘Brief on petition’, HL, STG legal, box 2 (12), p. 15.

35 Erickson, Women and property, p. 5.

36 Marriage settlement of Anna Eliza …, HL, STG personal, box 12 (4), pp. 58–60.

37 Ditz, Toby L., Property and kinship: inheritance in early Connecticut, 1750–1820 (Princeton, NJ, 1986), pp. 31–2CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

38 Henry French and Mark Rothery, ‘Male anxiety among younger sons of the English landed gentry, 1700–1900’, Historical Journal, published online 20 Nov. 2018, p. 2.

39 Thomas Grenville to Anna Eliza Grenville, 20 Dec. 1827, HL, STG, box 7 (48).

40 Ditz, Property and kinship, p. 31.

41 Marriage settlement of Anna Eliza …, HL, STG personal, box 12 (4), p. 62.

42 Stretton and Kesselring, ‘Introduction: coverture and continuity’, p. 9.

43 Capern, Amanda, ‘The landed woman in early modern England’, Parergon, 19 (2002), pp. 185–214, at p. 198CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

44 McDonagh, Elite women and the agricultural landscape, p. 24.

45 Beckett, John, The rise and fall of the Grenvilles: dukes of Buckingham and Chandos, 1710–1921 (Manchester, 1994), p. 147Google Scholar.

46 Ibid., pp. 146–7; The journal of the hon. Henry Edward Fox, 1818–1830 (London, 1923), p. 310Google Scholar.

47 Marriage settlement of Anna Eliza …, HL, STG personal, box 12 (4), p. 58. Male descendants of Grenville by another husband, however, were prioritized over any of the couple's female descendants.

48 Proposals for settlement previous to the marriage of Richard Grenville … with the Lady Mary Campbell, 11 May 1819, HL, STG personal, box 19 (3).

49 Edward Hyde East to Anna Eliza Grenville, 24 Dec. 1827, HL, STG, box 6 (19).

50 Edward Hyde East to Anna Eliza Grenville, 31 Dec. 1827, HL, STG, box 6 (19).

51 East to Grenville, 24 Dec. 1827, HL, STG, box 6 (19).

52 Beckett, Rise and fall of the Grenvilles, pp. 148–9.

53 Anna Eliza Grenville to Richard Grenville, 18 Sept. 1835, HL, STG, box 74 (44).

54 Edward Hyde East to Anna Eliza Grenville, 10 Dec. 1828, HL, STG, box 6 (20).

55 Ibid.

56 Richard Grenville to Edward Hyde East, 4 Feb. 1828, HL, STG, box 6 (20).

57 ‘An act for granting various powers to trustees of Chandos estates of Richard, duke of Buckingham and Chandos, 1850 (restating terms of 1828 legislation)’, HL, STG personal oversize, box 6.

58 Edward Hyde East to Anna Eliza Grenville, 26 Dec. 1827, HL, STG, box 6 (19).

59 Beckett, Rise and fall of the Grenvilles, p. 146.

60 Edward Hyde East to Anna Eliza Grenville, 21 Mar. 1828, HL, STG, box 6 (20).

61 Edward Hyde East to Anna Eliza Grenville, 12 Dec. 1828, HL, STG, box 6 (20).

62 Anna Eliza Grenville to Richard Plantagenet Grenville, 20 Sep. 1833, HL, STG, box 95 (63).

63 James Buller East to Anna Eliza Grenville, 30 May 1833, HL, STG, box 364 (7).

64 Anna Eliza Grenville to Richard Grenville [c. 6 May] 1832, HL, STG, box 74 (40).

65 Grenville to Richard Grenville, 2 May 1832, HL, STG, box 74 (40).

66 Anna Eliza Grenville to Mary Grenville, 12 Feb. 1834, HL, STG, box 50 (45).

67 Edward Hyde East to Anna Eliza Grenville, 15 Mar. 1828, HL, STG, box 6 (20).

68 Anna Eliza Grenville to Richard Plantagenet Grenville, 16 Oct. 1832, HL, STG, box 95 (62).

69 Anna Eliza Grenville to Richard Plantagenet Grenville, 27 Sept. 1833, HL, STG, box 95 (63).

70 Grenville to Richard Plantagenet Grenville, 16 Oct. 1832, HL, STG, box 95 (62).

71 East to Grenville, 31 Dec. 1827, HL, STG, box 6 (19).

72 McDonagh, Elite women and the agricultural landscape, pp. 52–3.

73 A. O. Baker to Anna Eliza Grenville, 8 July–17 Aug. 1828, HL, STG, box 363 (3–5); Thomas Crawfurd to Anna Eliza Grenville, 5–12 Oct. 1827, HL, STG, box 363 (29–32).

74 Mitson, Anne, ‘An exchange of letters: estate management and Lady Yarborough’, Women's History Review, 7 (1998), pp. 547–66CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Crawford, Patricia, ‘Women and property: women as property’, Parergon, 19 (2002), pp. 151–71, at p. 155CrossRefGoogle Scholar; McDonagh, Elite women and the agricultural landscape, particularly pp. 39–69.

75 Anna Eliza Grenville to Lord Goodrich, [c. 1828], HL, STG, box 364 (36).

76 Coutts & Co. to Anna Eliza Grenville, 10 Oct. 1835, HL, STG, box 363 (28).

77 Anna Eliza Grenville to Richard Grenville, [9 Oct.] 1835, HL, STG, box 74 (44).

78 Bailey, Joanne, ‘Favoured or oppressed? Married women, property and “coverture” in England, 1660–1800’, Continuity and Change, 17 (2002), pp. 351–72, at pp. 360–1CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

79 Callan, Hilary, ‘Introduction’, in Ardener, Shirley and Callan, Hilary, eds., The incorporated wife (Beckenham, 1984), pp. 1–24Google Scholar.

80 Grenville to Richard Grenville, 2 May 1832, HL, STG, box 74 (40).

81 Anna Eliza Grenville to Richard Grenville, 27 Sept. 1835, HL, STG, box 74 (44).

82 Anna Eliza Grenville to Richard Grenville, [after 1 June] 1832 and 2 May 1832, HL, STG, box 74 (40).

83 Mary Grenville to Anna Eliza Grenville, 10 Feb. 1834, HL, STG, box 7 (15).

84 Anna Eliza Grenville to Mary Grenville, 12 Feb. 1834, HL, STG, box 50 (45).

85 Ågren, Maria, ‘“His estate – or hers?” Three chapters in the history of married women's property rights in Sweden, 1350–1850’, Gender and History, 25 (2013), pp. 211–29, at p. 223CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

86 ‘A general list of negroes on Hope estate, 1 Jan. 1813’, HL, ST West Indies, box 1 (12).

87 Young, Hannah, ‘Forgotten women: gender and absentee slave-ownership’, in Donington, Katie, Hanley, Ryan, and Moody, Jessica, eds., Britain's history and memory of transatlantic slavery: local nuances of a ‘national sin’ (Liverpool, 2016), pp. 83–101Google Scholar. A Chancery inquisition declared Anna Eliza Brydges a ‘lunatic’ in 1791 and guardians adopted responsibility for her daughter's care, at least partly explaining why Anna Eliza Grenville did not share her mother's enthusiasm for the transatlantic management of Hope.

88 Satchell, Veront M., Hope transformed: a historical sketch of the Hope landscape, St Andrew, Jamaica, 1660–1960 (Kingston, 2010), p. 184Google Scholar.

89 Hope plantation, accounts of sugar sales, 1821–2, HL, ST West Indies, box 4 (1); Edward Hyde East to Anna Eliza Grenville, 11 Mar. 1828, HL, STG, box 6 (20).

90 Edward Tichbourne to Richard Grenville, 1 May 1822, HL, STG, box 433 (2); ‘Return of slaves on Hope estate, 28 June 1823’, HL, ST West Indies, box 1 (16).

91 Edward Tichbourne to Richard Grenville, 16 Dec. 1824, HL, STG, box 433 (4).

92 Richard Barrett to Richard Grenville, 12 Feb. 1832, HL, STG, box 433 (23).

93 Ibid.

94 Richard Barrett to Robson, 29 Mar. 1833, HL, STG, box 433 (36).

95 Richard Grenville to Robson, 2 Sept. 1831, HL, STG, box 433 (22).

96 Anna Eliza Grenville to Richard Plantagenet Grenville, 25 Oct. 1832, HL, STG, box 95 (62).

97 Anna Eliza Grenville to Mr Burge, n.d. [1832], HL, STG, box 364 (38–9).

98 Edward East to Anna Eliza Grenville, 11 and 12 Mar. 1828, HL, STG, box 6 (8).

99 Richard Barrett to Anna Eliza Grenville, 3 May 1836, HL, STG, box 434 (22).

100 Anna Eliza Grenville to Richard Grenville, 23 Aug. 1835, HL, STG, box 74 (44).

101 Barrett to Grenville, 3 May 1836, HL, STG, box 434 (22).

102 ‘Jamaica St Andrew 114 (Hope estate)’, 25 July 1836, Legacies of British slave-ownership, https://www.ucl.ac.uk/lbs/claim/view/19451.

103 Anna Eliza Grenville to Richard Grenville, 9 Sept. 1835, HL, STG, box 74 (44).

104 Anna Eliza Grenville to Richard Grenville, 15 Sept. 1835, HL, STG, box 74 (44).

105 Hall, Catherine, Civilising subjects: metropole and colony in the English imagination, 1830–1867 (Cambridge, 2002), p. 174Google Scholar.

106 Hall et al., Legacies of British slave-ownership, p. 17.

107 Gikandi, Simon, Slavery and the culture of taste (Princeton, NJ, 2011), p. 26Google Scholar.

108 Paton, Diana, No bond but the law: punishment, race, and gender in Jamaican state formation, 1780–1870 (Durham, NC, 2004), p. 54CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

109 Holt, Thomas C., The problem of freedom: race, labor and politics in Jamaica and Britain, 1832–1938 (Baltimore, MD, 1992), pp. 56–7Google Scholar.

110 Satchell, Hope transformed, p. 204. Satchell also suggests that most of these labourers were Irish. While it is certainly possible that there were Irish immigrants living in Avington, the duchess referred to the group as ‘the English party’. Anna Eliza Grenville to Richard Grenville, [after 15 Sept.] 1835, STG, box 74 (44).

111 Grenville to Richard Grenville, [after 15 Sept.] 1835, HL, STG, box 74 (44).

112 Lai, Walton Look, Indentured labor, Caribbean sugar: Chinese and Indian migrants to the British West Indies, 1838–1918 (Baltimore, MD, 1993), p. 19Google Scholar.

113 Higman, B. W., Plantation Jamaica: capital and control in a colonial economy (Kingston, 2005), p. 237Google Scholar.

114 Anna Eliza Grenville to Richard Grenville, 21 Sept. 1835, HL STG, box 74 (44).

115 Haines, Robin F., Emigration and the labouring poor: Australian recruitment in Britain and Ireland, 1831–60 (Basingstoke, 1997), pp. 79–80CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

116 Grenville to Richard Grenville, 21 Sept. 1835, HL, STG, box 74 (44).

117 Anna Eliza Grenville to Richard Grenville, 3 Sept. 1835, HL, STG, box 74 (44).

118 Grenville to Richard Grenville, 15 Sept. 1835, HL, STG, box 74 (44).

119 Richard Barrett to Anna Eliza Grenville, 23 Dec. 1834, HL, STG, box 433 (61).

120 Richard Barrett to Anna Eliza Grenville, 12 Mar. 1836, HL, STG, box 434 (21).

121 Roberts, David, Paternalism in early Victorian England (London, 1979), p. 5Google Scholar; Diaries of Anna Eliza Grenville, vol. 1: 1807, HL, ST 110; Anna Eliza Grenville to Percy Grace, 23 Dec. 1810, HL, STG, box 4 (5); Anna Eliza Grenville to Percy Grace, 7 May 1834, HL, STG, box 4 (27).

122 Lewis, Judith S., Sacred to female patriotism: gender, class and politics in late Georgian England (London, 2003), p. 5CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

123 Young, ‘Forgotten women’, pp. 98–9.

124 Delle, James A., The colonial Caribbean: landscapes of power in the plantation system (Cambridge, 2014), p. 182Google Scholar.

125 Anna Eliza Grenville to Richard Grenville, [after 3 Sept.] 1835, HL, STG, box 74 (44); Grenville to Richard Grenville, 3 Sept. 1835, HL, STG, box 74 (44).

126 Richard Barrett to Richard Grenville, 17 Oct. 1836, HL, STG, box 434 (24).

127 George Pigott to Richard Grenville, 10 Aug. 1836, HL, STG, box 434 (23).

128 McDonagh, Elite women and the agricultural landscape, pp. 1–9.

129 Davidoff, Leonore, Doolittle, Megan, Fink, Janet, and Holden, Katherine, The family story: blood, contract and intimacy, 1830–1960 (Harlow, 1999), pp. 3–15Google Scholar.

130 Erickson, Amy Louise, ‘Possession – and the other one-tenth of the law: assessing women's ownership and economic roles in early modern England’, Women's History Review, 16 (2007), pp. 369–85, at p. 379CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

131 ‘A general list of negroes on Hope estate, 1 Jan. 1813’, HL, ST West Indies, box 1 (12).

132 Marriage settlement of Anna Eliza …, HL, STG personal, box 12 (4), p. 27.