Hostname: page-component-6b989bf9dc-vmcqm Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-15T01:40:33.677Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Nineteenth-Century Schools between Community and State: The Cases of Prussia and the United States

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  24 February 2017

Jurgen Herbst
Jurgen Herbst*
Affiliation:
University of Wisconsin-Madison
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Forty years ago Bernard Bailyn remarked that American historians of education had carried out their work “in a special atmosphere of professional purpose” and had made the history of the public school the focus of their investigations. Lawrence Cremin seconded that observation and added that, for all intents and purposes, the history of American education had been “the history of the public school realizing itself over time.” In the tradition of Ellwood Patterson Cubberley that self-realization of the American public school was portrayed as a progression from local roots to state-wide systems. It became synonymous with the evolution of school government from local control on the district and ward levels to direction and oversight by state administrators. For many school professionals and historians that progression meant progress. They saw it as overcoming local control which they regarded as a relic of the past denoting an endorsement of inequality, discrimination, and special privilege. It persuaded them to see the solution to the schools' problems in strengthened state and, eventually, federal control.

Type
Articles
Information
History of Education Quarterly , Volume 42 , Issue 3 , Fall 2002 , pp. 317 - 341
Copyright
Copyright © 2002 by the History of Education Society 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Bailyn, Bernard Education in the Forming of American Society (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1960), 8.Google Scholar

2 Cremin, Lawrence A. The Wonderful World of Ellwood Patterson Cubberley (New York: Teachers College, Columbia University, 1965), 25.Google Scholar

3 Plank, David N. and Sykes, Gary “How Choice Changes the Education System: A Michigan Case Study,“ International Review of Education 45 (May/June 1999): 386.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

4 Kaestle, Carl F. Pillars of the Republic: Common Schools and American Society, 1780-1860 (New York: Hill and Wang, 1983), 225.Google Scholar

5 Kaestle, Carl F. and Smith, Marshall S. “The Historical Context of the Federal Role in Education,“ Harvard Educational Review 52 (November 1982): 408.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

6 Potash, Jeffrey “State Government and Education: ‘For the Due Encouragement of Learning and the Better Regulating and Ordering of School,'“ Vermont History 65 (Winter 1997): 62.Google Scholar

7 Schmale, Wolfgang and Dodde, Nan L. eds., Revolution des Wissens? Europa und seine Schulen im Zeitalter der Aufklärung, 1150-1825 (Bochum: Dieter Winkler, 1991), 13–31.Google Scholar

8 See Herbst, Jurgen The Once and Future School (New York: Routledge, 1996), 11–12.Google Scholar

9 Kaestle, Carl F. The Evolution of an Urban School System: New York City, 1750-1850 (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1973), 27.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

10 See Teaford, Jon “The Transformation of Massachusetts Education 1670-1780,“ in The Social History of American Education, eds. Edward McClellan, B. and Reese, William J. (Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 1988), 29–34.Google Scholar

12 Deutsche Schulgesetzgebung, 1763-1952 eds. Froese, Leonhard und Krawietz, W. 2nd ed. (Weinheim: Julius Beltz, 1968), 91, 94, 105-111. See also Lewin, Heinrich Geschichte der Entwicklung der preußischen Volksschule (Leipzig: Dürr'sche Buchhandlung, 1910), 42-91.Google Scholar

13 Heinemann, Schule im Vorfeld, 24–25.Google Scholar

14 Zedlitz's proposals, “Vorschläge zur Verbesserung des Schulwesens in den Königlichen Landen,” were first published in the Berlinische Monatsschrift, 10 (1787): 97-116. They have been conveniently reprinted in Staat und Schule oder Staatsschule? Stellungnahmen von Pädagogen und Schulpolitikern zu einem unerledigten Problem, 1781-1889 ed. Berg, Christa (Königstein: Athenäum, 1980), 1–9. They are discussed in Heinemann, Schule im Vorfeld, 152-156.Google Scholar

15 Froese, und Krawietz, (eds.), Deutsche Schulgesetzgebung, 2nd ed., 23, and Lewin, Geschichte der Entwicklung, 142-146.Google Scholar

16 Heinemann, Schule im Vorfeld, 168.Google Scholar

17 See Baumgart, Franzjörg Zwischen Reform und Reaktion: Preußische Schulpolitik 1806-1859 (Darmstadt: Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft, 1990), 22–24.Google Scholar

18 (ed.), Berg Staat und Schule oder Staatsschule?, xviii–xix and 22-36.Google Scholar

19 Humboldt, Wilhelm von “Ideen zu einem Versuch, die Grenzen der Wirksamkeit des Staats zu bestimmen (1792),“ in Werke in Fünf Bänden, eds. Flitner, Andreas and Giel, Klaus vol. I (Darmstadt: Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft, 1960), 56–233. [Section on public education in chapter VI appears on pp. 103-109.] See also the English language edition, The Limits of State Action, ed. Burrow, J. W. (Indianapolis: Liberty Fund, 1993), 46-52.Google Scholar

20 Jefferson, Thomas “Bill for the General Diffusion of Knowledge,“ in The Papers of Thoman Jefferson, ed. Boyd, Julian, vol. II (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1950), 526–535.Google Scholar

21 Pierre Samuel du Pont de Nemours, National Education in the United States of America (Newark: University of Delaware Press, 1923), 147–148.Google Scholar

22 Quoted in Scurla, Herbert Wilhelm von Humboldt: Werden und Wirken (Berlin: Verlag der Nation, 1970), 81 and 201.Google Scholar

23 Cf. the interpretation advanced in Krautkrämer, Ursula Staat und Erziehung: Begründung öffentlicher Erziehung bei Humboldt, Kant, Fichte, Hegel und Schleiermacher (München: Johannes Berchmans Verlag, 1979), 77.Google Scholar

24 Educational reforms introduced in times of crisis or war appear to have been a constant in history. See Smith, Kaestle and “The Historical Context,“ 390–392.Google Scholar

25 Herbst, Jurgen “Thomas Jefferson und Wilhelm von Humboldt: Universitäts- und Schulgründer,“ Humboldt International: Der Export des deutschen Universitätsmodells im 19. und 20. Jahrhundert ed. Christoph Schwinges, Rainer (Basel: Schwabe & Co. AG, 2001), 273–287.Google Scholar

26 See Conant, James B. Thomas Jefferson and the Development of American Public Education (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1963).CrossRefGoogle Scholar

27 See Hansen, Allan Oscar Liberalism and American Education in the Eighteenth Century (New York: Octagon Books, 1977) and Essays on Education in the Early Republic, ed. Rudolph, Frederick (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1965).Google Scholar

28 Moroney, Siobhan “Birth of a Canon: The Historiography of Early Republican Educational Thought,“ History of Education Quarterly, 39 (Winter 1999): 486.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

29 See Kaestle, Carl F. and Vinovskis, Maris A. Education and Social Change in Nineteenth-Century Massachusetts (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1980), 9–27.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

30 See Herbst, Jurgen From Crisis to Crisis: American College Government, 1636-1819 (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1982), 139, 168-169.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

31 See Abbott, Frank C. Government Policy and Higher Education: A Study of the Regents of the University of the State of New York, 1784-1949 (Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1958), passim, and Herbst, Jurgen “The Regents of the University of the State of New York, 1784-1920: Secondary Education Emerges in the New Nation,” in “The Colonial Experience in Education,” eds. Novoa, Antonio Depaepe, Marc and Johanningmeier, Erwin V. in Paedagogica Historica, Supplementary Series, I (1995), 317-333.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

32 See Herbst, The Once and Future School, 55–56, 60.Google Scholar

33 Tyack, David B. The One Best System: A History of American Urban Education (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1974), 33–34.Google Scholar

34 For an account and analysis of the 1840 school board election see Vinovskis, Kaesde and Education and Social Change, 213–232.Google Scholar

35 See Vinovskis, Maris A. The Origins of Public High Schools: A Reexamination of the Beverly High School Controversy (Madison: University of Wisconsin Press, 1985), 111.Google Scholar

36 For a description of the developments in New York see the section called, “First School War” in Diane Ravitch, The Great School Wars, New York City, 1805-1973 (New York: Basic Books, 1974), 3–76.Google Scholar

37 Lannie, Vincent P. Public Money and Parochial Education: Bishop Hughes, Governor Seward, and the New York School Controversy (Cleveland: Press of Case Western University, 1968), especially chapter 12.Google Scholar

38 Tyack, David and Hansot, Elisabeth Managers of Virtue: Public School Leadership in America, 1820-1980 (New York: Basic Books, 1982), 78.Google Scholar

39 See Heckel, Hans Schulrecht und Schulpolitik: Der Einfluß des Rechts auf die Zielsetzung und den Erfolg in der Bildungspolitik (Neuwied/Berlin: Hermann Luchterhand Verlag, 1967), 49.Google Scholar

40 See Baumgart, Zwischen Reform und Reaktion, 55.Google Scholar

41 Anderson, Eugene “The Prussian Volksschule in the 19th Century,“ in Entstehung und Wandel der modernen Gesellschaft, Festschrift für Hans Rosenberg (Berlin: DeGruyter, 1970), 261–270.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

42 Leschinsky, Achim and Roeder, Peter Martin Schule im historischen Prozeß: Zum Wechselverhältnis von institutioneller Erziehung und gesellschaftlicher Entwicklung (Stuttgart: Ernst Klett, 1976), 127.Google Scholar

43 Nipperdey, Thomas “Volksschule und Revolution im Vormärz,“ in Politische Ideologien und Nationalstaatliche Ordnung: Studien zur Geschichte des 19. und 20. Jahrhunderts, Festschrift für Theodor Schieder, eds. Kluxen, Kurt und Mommsen, Wolfgang J. (München und Wien: R. Oldenbourg, 1968), 117–142.Google Scholar

44 Roeder, Peter Martin “Gemeindeschule in Staatshand: Zur Schulpolitik des Preußischen Abgeordnetenhauses,“ Zeitschrift für Pädagogik, 12 (1966): 539–569.Google Scholar

45 See Jeismann, Karl-Ernst “Preußische Bildungspolitik vom ausgehenden 18. bis zur Mitte des 19. Jahrhunderts. Thesen und Probleme,“ in Zur Bildungs- und Schulgeschichte Preußens, ed. Arnold, Udo (Lüneburg: Nordostdeutsches Kulturwerk, 1988), 11–13.Google Scholar

46 Kuhlemann, Frank-Michael Modernisierung und Disziplinierung: Sozialgeschichte des preußischen Volksschulwesens 1794-1872 (Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, 1992), 78 and 86.Google Scholar

47 In her State, Society, and the Elementary School in Imperial Germany (New York: Oxford University Press, 1989), Marjorie Lamberti points out that even though clergymen served as agents of the state (p. 16), the church in effect functioned together with community and state as a third “social entity with legitimate interests and formal rights in the public schools.” (p. 13).Google Scholar

48 See Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel, Georg Grundlinien der Philosophie des Rechts, ed. Hoffmeister, Johannes 4th ed. (Hamburg: Felix Meiner, 1955), 294, 256-257, and Krautkrämer, Staat und Erziehung, 245-249.Google Scholar

49 Altenstein to all consistories and provincial governments, July 24, 1822, Rep. 92, #25, 311-314, Geheimes Staats Archiv Berlin-Dahlem.Google Scholar

50 Friedrich Wilhelm III to Altenstein, 15 June 1822, and Richter memorandum, 10 February 1822, Rep. 76, VII, neue Sektion 1C, Teil 1, Nr. 1, Bd. 1, Zentrales Staats Archiv Merseburg.Google Scholar

51 See Deutscher, Eckhard K. Private Schulen in der deutschen Bildungsgeschichte: Ein Beitrag zum Verhältnis von Schule und Staat (Frankfurt: Johann Wolfgang Goethe Universität, Inauguraldissertation, 1976), 135–136.Google Scholar

52 Müller, Detlef K. “The process of systematisation: the case of German secondary education,“ in Müller, Detlef K. Ringer, Fritz and Simon, Brian The Rise of the Modern Educational System: Structural Change and Social Reproduction, 1870-1920 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1987), 23.Google Scholar

53 Müller, “The process of systematisation,“ 24.Google Scholar

54 See Jacobi-Dittrich, Juliane 'Deutsche’ Schulen im Mittleren Westen der Vereinigten Staaten von Amerika (München: Minerva, 1988), 141, 187.Google Scholar

55 Friedrich Wilhelm Wander, Karl “Aufruf an Deutschlands Lehrer,“ in Der Kampf um die Schule: Bildungspolitische und Pädagogische Schriften, vol. 2 (Berlin: Volk und Wissen, 1979), 50–52; “Beschlüsse der 1. Versammlung des Allgemeinen Deutschen Lehrervereins in Eisenach (1848),” in Berthold Michael und Heinz-Hermann Schepp, Politik und Schule von der Französischen Revolution bis zur Gegenwart, vol. 1 (Frankfurt: Athenäum Fischer Taschenbuch, 1973), 384-385; and Wander, “Die alte Volksschule und die Neue,” in Der Kampf um die Schule, II, 35-36.Google Scholar

56 Wander, “Was hat der nach Amerika auswandernde Lehrer dort als solcher zu erwarten?,“ in Der Kampf um die Schule, II, 176–178, 182.Google Scholar

57 Dulon, Rudolph Aus Amerika über Schule, deutsche Schule, amerikanische Schule und deutsch-amerikanische Schule (Leipzig und Heidelberg: C. F. Winter, 1866), 236, 238-239, 245-251, 254.Google Scholar

58 See Goldberg, Bettina “The Forty-Eighters and the School System in America: The Theory and Practice of Reform,“ in The German Forty-Eighters in the United States, ed. Brancaforte, Charlotte L. (New York: Peter Lang, 1989), 207–208.Google Scholar

59 The term “educators in overalls” is Wayne Fuller's. See his The Old Country School: The Story of Rural Education in the Middle West (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1982), chapter 5.Google Scholar

60 Fuller, Old Country School, 155.Google Scholar

61 See Herbst, Once and Future School, 79–91.Google Scholar

62 For rural opposition to the schoolmen see Fuller, Old Country School, 115–119.Google Scholar

63 Chapter 493, The Laws of Wisconsin, 1909 (Madison: State Printer, 1909), 617–623.Google Scholar

64 Fuller, Old Country School, 235.Google Scholar

65 Ibid., 245.Google Scholar

66 See Schafer, Joseph Four Wisconsin Counties Prairie and Forest (Madison: State Historical Society of Wisconsin, 1927), 235–237.Google Scholar

67 For an account of German schools in Wisconsin see Jacobi-Dittrich, “Deutsche” Schulen, 115–210.Google Scholar

68 Tyack, One Best System, 127.Google Scholar

69 See documents in Schepp, Michael and Politik und Schule, vol. 1 pp. 414–421. For a detailed and illuminating discussion of the German school wars see Albisetti, James C. Secondary School Reform in Imperial Germany (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1983), 140–291. The quotations from the Emperor's speech are taken from Albisetti, Secondary School Reform, 211 and 3.Google Scholar

70 Albisetti, Secondary School Reform, 292 and 311.Google Scholar

71 Schacht, Ludwig Über die Gleichberechtigung der Realschule I.Ordnung mit dem Gymnasium (Elberfeld: Lucas, 1878), 66.Google Scholar

72 Herrlitz, Hans-Georg Hopf, Wulf and Titze, Hartmut Deutsche Schulgeschichte von 1800 bis zur Gegenwart: Eine Einführung (Weinheim und München: Juventa, 1993), 107.Google Scholar

73 Herrlitz, Hopf, and Titze, Deutsche Schulgeschichte, 109.Google Scholar

74 Kaestle, Pillars of the Republic, 77.Google Scholar

75 Oelkers, Jürgen Reformpädagogik: Eine Kritische Dogmengeschichte, 3rd ed. (Weinheim und München: Juventa, 1996), 15.Google Scholar