Skip to main content

The Emperor Has No Clothes: The Limits of OPEC in the Global Oil Market

  • Jeff D. Colgan

Scholars have long debated the causal impact of international institutions such as the World Trade Organization or the International Monetary Fund. This study investigates Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC), an organization that purports to have significant influence over the market for the world's most important commodity–petroleum. Using four empirical tests, I find that OPEC has little or no impact on its members' production levels. These findings prompt the question of why so many people, including scholars, believe in OPEC's influence over the world's oil supply. The idea of OPEC as a cartel is a “rational myth” that supports the organization's true principal function, which is to generate political benefits for its members. One benefit it generates is international prestige. I test this idea using data on diplomatic representation and find that OPEC membership is associated with increased international recognition by other states. Overall, these findings help one to better understand international regimes and the process of ideational change in world politics.

Hide All
Adelman, Morris. 1982. OPEC as a Cartel. In OPEC Behavior and World Oil Prices, edited by Griffin, James M. and Teece, David J., 3763. London: Allen and Unwin.
Alhajji, A.F., and Huettner, David. 2000. OPEC and Other Commodity Cartels: A Comparison. Energy Policy 28 (15):1151–64.
Alt, James E., Calvert, Randall L., and Humes, Brian D.. 1988. Reputation and Hegemonic Stability: A Game-Theoretic Analysis. American Political Science Review 82 (2):445–66.
Baccini, Leonardo, Lenzi, Veronica, and Thurner, Paul. 2013. Global Energy Governance: Trade, Infrastructure, and the Diffusion of International Organizations. International Interactions 39 (2):192216.
Barnett, Michael N., and Finnemore, Martha. 1999. The Politics, Power, and Pathologies of International Organizations. International Organization 53 (4):699732.
Barsky, Robert B., and Kilian, Lutz. 2004. Oil and the Macroeconomy Since the 1970s. Journal of Economic Perspectives 18 (4):115–34.
Bayer, Resat. 2006. Diplomatic Exchange Dataset, v2006.1. Available at <>. Accessed 10 November 2013.
Bentzen, Jan. 2007. Does OPEC Influence Crude Oil Prices? Testing for Co-movements and Causality Between Regional Crude Oil Prices. Applied Economics 39 (11):1375–85.
Blaydes, Lisa. 2004. Rewarding Impatience: A Bargaining and Enforcement Model of OPEC. International Organization 58 (2):213–37.
Blyth, Mark. 2002. Great Transformations: Economic Ideas and Institutional Change in the Twentieth Century. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Boiral, Olivier. 2007. Corporate Greening Through ISO 14001: A Rational Myth? Organization Science 18 (1):127–46.
Botcheva, Liliana, and Martin, Lisa L.. 2001. Institutional Effects on State Behavior: Convergence and Divergence. International Studies Quarterly 45 (1):126.
Brémond, Vincent, Hache, Emmanuel, and Mignon, Valerie. 2012. Does OPEC Still Exist as a Cartel? An Empirical Investigation. Energy Economics 34 (1):125–31.
Bronson, Rachel. 2006. Thicker than Oil: America's Uneasy Partnership with Saudi Arabia. New York: Oxford University Press.
Brown, Anthony Cave. 1999. Oil, God, and Gold: The Story of Aramco and the Saudi Kings. Boston: Houghton Mifflin.
Cairns, Robert, and Calfucura, Enrique. 2012. OPEC: Market Failure or Power Failure? Energy Policy 50:570–80.
Chwieroth, Jeffrey M. 2009. Capital Ideas: The IMF and the Rise of Financial Liberalization. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Claes, Dag Harald. 2001. The Politics of Oil-Producer Cooperation. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
Clayton, Blake, and Levi, Michael. 2012. The Surprising Sources of Oil's Influence. Survival 54 (6):107–22.
Clinton, Bill. 2005. My Life. New York: Random House.
Colgan, Jeff D. 2009. The International Energy Agency: Challenges for the Twenty-first Century. GPPI Policy Paper Series No. 6. Berlin: Global Public Policy Institute.
Colgan, Jeff D., Keohane, Robert O., and Van de Graaf, Thijs. 2012. Punctuated Equilibrium in the Energy Regime Complex. Review of International Organizations 7 (2):117–43.
Crémer, Jacques, and Salehi-Isfahani, Djavad. 1980. A Theory of Competitive Pricing in the Oil Market: What Does OPEC Really Do? CARESS Working Paper 80–4. Pittsburgh: University of Pennsylvania.
Crémer, Jacques, and Salehi-Isfahani, Djavad. 1991. Models of the Oil Market. Amsterdam: Harwood.
Dahl, Carol, and Yücel, Mine. 1991. Testing Alternative Hypotheses of Oil Producer Behavior. Energy Journal 12 (4):117–38.
Darden, Keith A. 2009. Economic Liberalism and Its Rivals the Formation of International Institutions Among the Post-Soviet States. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Demirer, Riza, and Kutan, Ali M.. 2006. Does OPEC Matter After 9/11? OPEC Announcements and Oil Price Stability. Unpublished manuscript, Southern Illinois University–Edwardsville.
Doran, Charles. 1977. Myth, Oil, and Politics. New York: Free Press (MacMillan).
Doran, Charles. 1980. OPEC Structure and Cohesion: Exploring the Determinants of Cartel Policy. Journal of Politics 42 (1):82101.
Downs, George W., Rocke, David M., and Barsoom, Peter N.. 1996. Is the Good News About Compliance Good News About Cooperation? International Organization 50 (3):379406.
Duffield, John S. 1994. NATO's Functions After the Cold War. Political Science Quarterly 109 (5):763–87.
Epstein, Edward Jay. 1983. OPEC: The Cartel That Never Was. The Atlantic, March.
Fox, Michael. 2006. President Chavez Hosts 141st OPEC Meeting in Caracas., 3 June. Available at <>. Accessed 18 October 2011.
Frech, H.E. III, and Lee, William C.. 1987. The Welfare Cost of Rationing-by-Queuing Across Markets: Theory and Estimates from the US Gasoline Crises. Quarterly Journal of Economics 102 (1):97108.
Gartzke, Erik, and Jo, Dong-Joon. 2009. Bargaining, Nuclear Proliferation, and Interstate Disputes. Journal of Conflict Resolution 53 (2):209–33.
Gholz, Euegene, and Press, Daryl G.. 2010. Protecting “The Prize”: Oil and the US National Interest. Security Studies 19 (3):453–85.
Gilpin, Robert. 1981. War and Change in World Politics. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Goldstein, Judith L, Rivers, Douglas, and Tomz, Michael. 2007. Institutions in International Relations: Understanding the Effects of the GATT and the WTO on World Trade. International Organization 61 (1):3767.
Goldthau, Andreas, and Witte, Jan Martin. 2011. Assessing OPEC's Performance in Global Energy. Global Policy 2 (s1):3139.
Griffin, James M. 1985. OPEC Behavior: A Test of Alternative Hypotheses. American Economic Review 75 (5):954–63.
Gray, Julia. 2011. Life, Death, or Zombies? The Survival and Revival of International Organizations. Unpublished manuscript, University of Pennsylvania, Pittsburgh.
Greene, David L, and Leiby, Paul N.. 1993. The Social Costs to the US of Monopolization of the World Oil Market, 1972–1991. Oak Ridge, TN: Oak Ridge National Laboratory.
Greene, David L, Leiby, Paul N., Patterson, Philip D., Plotkin, Steven E., and Singh, Margaret K.. 2007. Oil Independence: Achievable National Goal or Empty Slogan? Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board 2017:4753.
Gülen, Salih Gürcan. 1996. Is OPEC a Cartel? Evidence from Cointegration and Causality Tests. Energy Journal 17 (2):4358.
Hafner-Burton, Emilie M., and Ron, James. 2009. Seeing Double: Human Rights Impact Through Qualitative and Quantitative Eyes. World Politics 61 (2):360401.
Hufbauer, Gary, Schott, Jeffrey, Elliott, Kimberly, and Oegg, Barbara. 2007. Economic Sanctions Reconsidered. Washington, DC: Peter G. Peterson Institute for International Economics.
Hyndman, Kyle. 2008. Disagreement in Bargaining: An Empirical Analysis of OPEC. International Journal of Industrial Organization 26 (3):811–28.
Ikenberry, G. John. 1988. Reasons of State: Oil Politics and the Capacities of American Government. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
Jensen, Nathan M. 2006. Nation-States and the Multinational Corporation: A Political Economy of Foreign Direct Investment. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Jensen, Nathan M., and Johnston, Noel P.. 2011. Political Risk, Reputation, and the Resource Curse. Comparative Political Studies 44 (6): 662–88.
Jervis, Robert. 2010. Why Intelligence Fails: Lessons from the Iranian Revolution and the Iraq War. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
Johany, Ali. 1980. The Myth of the OPEC Cartel: The Role of Saudi Arabia. Dhahran, Saudi Arabia: University of Petroleum and Minerals.
Jones, Bart. 2008. Hugo! The Hugo Chavez Story from Mud Hut to Perpetual Revolution. Hanover, NH: Steerforth.
Kalt, Joseph. 1981. The Economics and Politics of Oil Price Regulation: Federal Policy in the Post-Embargo Era. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Kaufmann, Robert K., Bradford, Andrew, Belanger, Laura H., McLaughlin, John P., and Miki, Yosuke. 2008. Determinants of OPEC Production: Implications for OPEC Behavior. Energy Economics 30 (2):333–51.
Kaufmann, Robert K., Dees, Stephan, Karadeloglou, Pavlos, and Sanchez, Marcelo. 2004. Does OPEC Matter? An Econometric Analysis of Oil Prices. Energy Journal 25 (4):6790.
Keohane, Robert. 1984. After Hegemony: Cooperation and Discord in the World Political Economy. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Kohl, Wilfrid L. 2002. OPEC Behavior, 1998–2001. Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance 42 (2):209–33.
Koremenos, Barbara, Lipson, Charles, and Snidal, Duncan. 2001. Rational Design: Looking Back to Move Forward. International Organization 55 (4):1051–82.
Krasner, Stephen D. 1974. Oil is the Exception. Foreign Policy 14:6884.
Leech, Garry. 2001. The Chávez Factor. Colombia Journal. 26 March. Available at <>. Accessed 18 October 2011.
Legro, Jeffrey. 2005. Rethinking the World: Great Power Strategies and International Order. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
Lesage, Dries, Van de Graaf, Thijs, and Westphal, Kirsten. 2010. Global Energy Governance in a Multipolar World. Surrey, UK: Ashgate.
Li, Quan. 2009. Democracy, Autocracy, and Expropriation of Foreign Direct Investment. Comparative Political Studies 42 (8):1098–127.
Lieber, Robert J. 1992. Oil and Power after the Gulf War. International Security 17 (1):155–76.
MacAvoy, Paul W. 1982. Crude Oil Prices as Determined by OPEC and Market Fundamentals. Pensacola, FL: Ballinger.
Mankiw, N. Gregory. 2011. Principles of Economics. Mason, OH: South-Western Cengage Learning.
Martin, Lisa L, and Simmons, Beth. 1998. Theories and Empirical Studies of International Institutions. International Organization 52 (4):729–57.
McNamara, Kathleen. 2002. Rational Fictions: Central Bank Independence and the Social Logic of Delegation. West European Politics 25 (1):4776.
Meyer, John W., and Rowan, Brian. 1977. Institutionalized Organizations: Formal Structure as Myth and Ceremony. American Journal of Sociology 83 (2):340–63.
Moran, Theodore H. 1982. Modeling OPEC Behavior: Economic and Political Alternatives. In OPEC Behavior and World Oil Prices, edited by Griffin, James. M. and Teece, David J., 94130. London: Allen and Unwin.
Moran, Theodore H. 1987. Managing an Oligopoly of Would-Be Sovereigns: The Dynamics of Joint Control and Self-control in the International Oil Industry Past, Present, and Future. International Organization 41 (4):575607.
Morrison, James Ashley. 2012. Before Hegemony: Adam Smith, American Independence, and the Origins of the First Era of Globalization. International Organization 66 (3):395428.
Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC). 2010. OPEC Bulletin. October. Vienna, Austria: OPEC. OPEC Bulletin, October 2010: 810.
Osborne, D.K. 1976. Cartel Problems. American Economic Review 66 (5):835–44.
Parra, Francisco. 2004. Oil Politics: A Modern History of Petroleum. New York: I.B. Tauris.
Qaimmaqami, Linda, and Keefer, Edward, eds. 2011. Foreign Relations of the United States, 1969–1976, Volume 36, Energy Crisis, 1969–1974. Washington, DC: US Government Printing Office.
Reinker, Kenneth S. 2005. Recent Development: NOPEC: The No Oil Producing and Exporting Cartels Act of 2004. Harvard Journal on Legislation 42 (Winter): 285.
Reynolds, Douglas B., and Pippenger, Michael K.. 2010. OPEC and Venezuelan Oil Production: Evidence Against a Cartel Hypothesis. Energy Policy 38 (10):6045–55.
Richardson, Bill. 2005. Between Worlds: The Making of an American Life. New York: Penguin.
Rose, Andrew K. 2004. Do We Really Know That the WTO Increases Trade? American Economic Review 94 (1):98114.
Rose, Andrew K. 2007. Do We Really Know That the WTO Increases Trade? Reply. American Economic Review 97 (5):2019–25.
Ross, Michael, and Voeten, Erik. 2011. Unbalanced Globalization in the Oil Exporting States. Paper presented at the 107th annual meeting of the American Political Science Association, 3 September, Seattle, WA.
Rudra, Nita, and Jensen, Nathan M.. 2011. Globalization and the Politics of Natural Resources. Comparative Political Studies 44 (6):639–61.
Sampson, Anthony. 2009 [1974]. The Seven Sisters: The Great Oil Companies and the World They Shaped. London: PFD.
Seymour, Ian. 1980. OPEC: Instrument of Change. New York: Macmillan.
Shaffer, Brenda. 2009. Energy Politics. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
Sikkink, Kathryn. 2011. The Justice Cascade: How Human Rights Prosecutions Are Changing World Politics. 1st ed. New York: Norton.
Simmons, Beth A., and Hopkins, Daniel J.. 2005. The Constraining Power of International Treaties: Theory and Methods. American Political Science Review 99 (4):623–31.
Simpson, John L. 2008. Do the Major Oil Companies Anticipate OPEC Production Allocations? Paper presented at the 21st Australasian Finance and Banking Conference, August, Sydney, Australia. Available at <>. Accessed 12 July 2012.
Skeet, Ian. 1991. OPEC: Twenty-Five Years of Prices and Politics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Smith, James. 2005. Inscrutable OPEC? Behavioral Tests of the Cartel Hypothesis. Energy Journal 26 (1):5182.
Smith, James. 2008. Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC). In The New Palgrave Dictionary of Economics, edited by Durlauf, Steven N. and Blume, Lawrence E., 229–32. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Smith, James. 2009. World Oil: Market or Mayhem? Journal of Economic Perspectives 23 (3):145–64.
Snidal, Duncan. 1985. Coordination Versus Prisoners' Dilemma: Implications for International Cooperation and Regimes. American Political Science Review 79 (4):923–42.
Sovacool, Benjamin K. 2011. The Routledge Handbook of Energy Security. New York: Routledge.
Stobaugh, Robert B. 1975. The Oil Companies in the Crisis. Daedalus 104 (4):179202.
Teece, David J. 1982. OPEC Behavior: An Alternative View. In OPEC Behavior and World Oil Prices, edited by Griffin, James. M. and Teece, David J., 6493. London: Allen and Unwin.
Verrastro, Frank, Pumphrey, David, Hegburg, Alan S., and Nannes, Marshall. 2011. “NOPEC” Legislation and US Energy Security. Washington, DC: Center for Strategic and International Studies. Available at <>. Accessed 5 November 2011.
Victor, David. 2008. OPEC Is Irrelevant: The Once All-Powerful Oil Cartel Now Mostly Just Rides the Waves of Supply and Demand. Newsweek. 1 August.
von Stein, Jana. 2005. Do Treaties Constrain or Screen? Selection Bias and Treaty Compliance. American Political Science Review 99 (4):611–22.
Waghorn, Jonathan, Lanstone, Matthew, Lacey, Mark A., and Murti, Arjun N.. 2006. Global Energy: 125 Projects to Change the World. Goldman Sachs Group.
Wallander, Celeste. 2000. Institutional Assets and Adaptability: NATO After the Cold War. International Organization 54 (4):705–35.
Wilpert, Gregory. 2007. Changing Venezuela: The History and Policies of the Chavez Government. London: Verso.
Woolsey, R. James, and Korin, Anne. 2008. How to Break Both Oil's Monopoly and OPEC's Cartel. Innovations: Technology, Governance, Globalization 3 (4):3538.
Yergin, Daniel. 2008. The Prize: The Epic Quest for Oil, Money, and Power. New York: Free Press.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

International Organization
  • ISSN: 0020-8183
  • EISSN: 1531-5088
  • URL: /core/journals/international-organization
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
Type Description Title
Supplementary materials

Colgan Supplementary Material
Supplementary Material

 Unknown (176.5 MB)
176.5 MB


Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 89
Total number of PDF views: 663 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 2716 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 21st March 2018. This data will be updated every 24 hours.