Skip to main content Accessibility help

Does Futures Speculation Destabilize Spot Prices? New Evidence for Commodity Markets

  • Martin T. Bohl (a1) and Patrick M. Stephan (a1)

Motivated by repeated price spikes and crashes over the last decade, we investigate whether the growing market shares of futures speculators destabilize commodity spot prices. We approximate conditional volatility and analyze how it is affected by speculative open interest. In this context, we split our sample into two equally long subperiods and document whether the speculative impact on conditional volatility increases. With respect to six heavily traded agricultural and energy commodities, we do not find robust evidence that this is the case. We thus conclude that the financialization of raw material markets does not make them more volatile.

Hide All
Adrangi, B., and Chatrath., A.Futures Commitments and Exchange Rate Volatility.” Journal of Business Finance & Accounting 25(1998): 501-20.
Algieri, B. “Price Volatility, Speculation and Excessive Speculation in Commodity Markets: Sheep or Shepherd Behaviour?" CDR Discussion Paper No. 166, 2012.
Aulerich, N.M., Irwin, S.H., and Garcia., P. “Bubbles, Food Prices, and Speculation: Evidence from the CFTC's Daily Large Trader Data Files.” Working Paper, 2012.
Bessembinder, H., and Seguin., P.J.Price Volatility, Trading Volume, and Market Depth: Evidence from Futures Markets.” Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis 28(1993):2139.
Bhar, R., and Hamori., S.Causality in Variance and the Type of Traders in Crude Oil Futures.” Energy Economics 27(2005):527–39.
Board, J., Sandmann, G., and Sutcliffe., C.The Effect of Futures Market Volume on Spot Market Volatility.” Journal of Business Finance & Accounting 28(2001):799819.
Bohl, M.T., Javed, F., and Stephan., P.M.Do Commodity Index Traders Destabilize Agricultural Futures Prices?Applied Economics Quarterly (2013): forthcoming.
Bollerslev, T., and Wooldridge., J.M.Quasi-Maximum Likelihood Estimation and Inference in Dynamic Models with Time-Varying Covariances.” Econometric Reviews 11(1992):143–72.
Brorsen, B.W., and Irwin., S.H.Futures Funds and Price Volatility.” Review of Futures Markets 6(1987): 119-35.
Brunetti, C., Büyüksahin, B., and Harris., J.H.Speculators, Prices and Market Volatility.” SSRN Working Paper, 2011.
Bryant, H.L., Bessler, D.A., and Haigh., M.S.Causality in Futures Markets.” Journal of Futures Markets 26(2006): 1039-57.
Büyüksahin, B., and Harris., J.H.Do Speculators Drive Crude Oil Futures Prices?The Energy Journal (Cambridge, Mass.) 32(2011): 167202.
CFTC. Staff Report on Commodity Swap Dealers & Index Traders with Commission Recommendations. Washington, DC: Commodity Futures Trading Commission, 2008.
Chang, E.C., Pingear, J.M., and Schachter., B.Interday Variations in Volume, Variance and Participation of Large Speculators.” Journal of Banking & Finance 21(1997):797810.
Chatrath, A., and Song., F.Futures Commitments and Commodity Price Jumps.” Financial Review 34(1999):95112.
Crain, S.J., and Lee., H.H.Volatility in Wheat Spot and Futures Markets, 1950-1993: Government Farm Programs, Seasonality, and Causality.” The Journal of Finance 51(1996):325–43.
Daigler, R.T., and Wiley., M.K.The Impact of Trader Type on the Futures Volatility-Volume Relation.” The Journal of Finance 54(1999): 2297–316.
DeLong, J.B., Shleifer, A., Summers, L.H., and Waldmann., R.J.Noise Trader Risk in Financial Markets.” Journal of Political Economy 98(1990):703–39.
Du, X., Yu, C.L., and Hayes., D.J.Speculation and Volatility Spillover in the Crude Oil and Agricultural Commodity Markets: A Bayesian Analysis.” Energy Economics 33(2011):497503.
Gilbert, C.L., and Morgan., C.W.Food Price Volatility.” Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological Sciences 365(2010):3023-34.
Haigh, M.S., Hranaiova, J., and Overdahl., J.Hedge Funds, Volatility, and Liquidity Provision in Energy Futures Markets.” Journal of Alternative Investments 9(2007): 1038.
Hamilton, J.D.Understanding Crude Oil Prices.” The Energy Journal (Cambridge, Mass.) 30(2009): 179206.
Hammoudeh, S., Li, H., and Jeon., B.Causality and Volatility Spillovers among Petroleum Prices of WTI, Gasoline and Heating Oil in Different Locations.” The North American Journal of Economics and Finance 14(2003):89114.
Hodrick, R., and Prescott., E.Postwar US Business Cycles: An Empirical Investigation.” Journal of Money, Credit and Banking 29(1997): 116.
Irwin, S.H.Does the Masters Hypothesis Explain Recent Food Price Spikes?” SPAA Network Working Paper No. 2012-11, 2012.
Irwin, S.H., and Holt., B.R.The Effect of Large Hedge Funds and CTA Trading on Futures Market Volatility.” Commodity Trading Advisors: Risk, Performance Analysis and Selection. Gregoriou, G.N., Karavas, V., Rouah, F.D., L'Habitant, F.-S., eds. New York, NY: Wiley, 2004, pp. 151–82.
Irwin, S.H., and Sanders., D.R.The Impact of Index and Swap Funds in Commodity Futures Markets.” OECD Food, Agriculture and Fisheries Working Papers No. 27, 2010.
Irwin, S.H., and Sanders., D.R.Index Funds, Financialization, and Commodity Futures Markets.” Applied Economic Perspectives and Policy 33(2011): 131.
Irwin, S.H., and Sanders., D.R.Financialization and Structural Change in Commodity Futures Markets.” Journal of Agricultural and Applied Economics 44(2012a): 371–96.
Irwin, S.H., and Sanders., D.R.Testing the Masters Hypothesis in Commodity Futures Markets.” Energy Economics 34(2012b):256–69.
Irwin, S.H., and Yoshimaru., S.Managed Futures, Positive Feedback Trading, and Futures Price Volatility.” Journal of Futures Markets 19(1999):759–76.
Karpoff, J.M.The Relation between Price Changes and Trading Volume: A Survey.” Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis 22(1987): 109–26.
Kaufmann, R.K., and Ullman., B.Oil Prices, Speculation, and Fundamentals: Interpreting Causal Relations among Spot and Futures Prices.” Energy Economics 31(2009):550–58.
Kilian, L.The Economic Effects of Energy Price Shocks.” Journal of Economic Literature 46(2008):871909.
Kocagil, A.E.Does Futures Speculation Stabilize Spot Prices? Evidence from Metals Markets.” Applied Financial Economics 7(1997): 115-25.
McPhail, L.L., Du, X., and Muhammad., A.Disentangling Corn Price Volatility: The Role of Global Demand, Speculation, and Energy.” Journal of Agricultural and Applied Economics 44(2012) :401–10.
Morgan, C.W.Futures Markets and Spot Price Volatility: A Case Study.” Journal of Agricultural Economics 50(1999):247–57.
Powers, M.J.Does Futures Trading Reduce Price Fluctuations in the Cash Markets?American Economic Review 60(1970) :460–64.
Reichsfeld, D.A., and Roache., S.K.Do Commodity Futures Help Forecast Spot Prices?” IMF Working Paper WP/11/254, 2011.
Sanders, D.R., and Irwin., S.H.The Impact of Index Funds in Commodity Futures Markets: A Systems Approach.” Journal of Alternative Investments 14(2011):4049.
Silvério, R., and Szklo., A.The Effect of the Financial Sector on the Evolution of Oil Prices: Analysis of the Contribution of the Futures Market to the Price Discovery Process in the WTI Spot Market.” Energy Economics 34(2012): 1799–808.
Stein, J.C.Informational Externalities and Welfare-Reducing Speculation.” Journal of Political Economy 95(1987): 1123-45.
Stoll, H.R., and Whaley., R.E.Volatility and Futures: Message versus Messenger.” Journal of Portfolio Management 14(1988):2022.
Stoll, H.R., and Whaley., R.E.Commodity Index Investing and Commodity Futures Prices.” Journal of Applied Finance (JAF) 20(2010):746.
Tang, K., and Xiong., W.Index Investment and Financialization of Commodities.” NBER Working Paper No. 16385, 2010.
Wang, C.The Effect of Net Positions by Type of Trader on Volatility in Foreign Currency Futures Markets.” Journal of Futures Markets 22(2002):427–50.
Yang, J., Balyeat, R.B., and Leatham., D.J.Futures Trading Activity and Commodity Cash Price Volatility.” Journal of Business Finance & Accounting 31(2005):297323.
Yang, J., Bessler, D.A., and Leatham., D.J.Asset Storability and Price Discovery in Commodity Futures Markets: A New Look.” Journal of Futures Markets 21(2001):279300.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Journal of Agricultural and Applied Economics
  • ISSN: 1074-0708
  • EISSN: 2056-7405
  • URL: /core/journals/journal-of-agricultural-and-applied-economics
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *



Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed