Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home

Aid, ethics, and the Samaritan's dilemma: strategic courage in constitutional entrepreneurship

  • EMILY C. SKARBEK (a1)

Abstract

Private constitutional rules can mitigate the Samaritan's Dilemma, a widespread cause of failure of aid and humanitarian efforts. To understand how private organizations can adopt rules that help overcome this dilemma, I provide evidence on an association formed to govern poor relief in urban Chicago from the 1850s to 1880s. I show how a particular set of shared ethical values led to the adoption of constitutional rules governing the organization. I then show that these rules were specific in their ability to mitigate the Samaritan's Dilemma problem inherent to administering aid. The argument advances the understanding of private institutional structures by demonstrating how rules can be designed in the private spheres to solve specific social dilemmas that plague state-led efforts to achieve similar goals.

Copyright

Corresponding author

References

Hide All
Aligica, P. D. and Tarko, V. (2013), ‘Co-production, Polycentricity, and Value Heterogeneity: The Ostroms’ Public Choice Institutionalism Revisited’, American Political Science Review, 107 (04): 726741.
Andreas, A. T. (1884a), History of Chicago: From the Earliest Period to the Present Time in Three Volumes. Volume II: from 1857 until the Fire of 1871, Chicago: University of Michigan Libraries, A.T. Alexander.
Andreas, A. T. (1884b), History of Chicago: From the Earliest Period to the Present Time in Three Volumes. Volume III: from 1857 until the Fire of 1871 until 1885, Chicago: University of Michigan Libraries, A.T. Alexander.
Besley, T. and Ghatak, M. (2003), ‘Competition and Incentives with Motivated Agents’, LSE STICERD Research Paper No. TE465.
Boettke, P., Palagashvili, L. and Lemke, J. (2013), ‘Riding in Cars with Boys: Elinor Ostrom's Adventures with the Police’, Journal of Institutional Economics, 9 (04): 407425.
Boone, P. (1996), ‘Politics and the Effectiveness of Foreign Aid’, European Economic Review, 40 (2): 289329.
Brautigam, D. and Knack, S. (2004), ‘Foreign Aid, Institutions and Governance in Sub-Saharan Africa’, Economic Development and Cultural Change, 52 (2): 255286.
Brennan, G. and Pettit, P. (2004), The Economy of Esteem: An Essay on Civil and Political Society, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Brown, J. (1941), The History of Public Assistance in Chicago, 1833–1893, Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Brumm, H. J. (2003), ‘Aid, Policies and Growth: Bauer was Right’, Cato Journal, 23 (2): 167174.
Buchanan, J. M. (1965), ‘An Economic Theory of Clubs’, Economica, 32 (125): 114.
Buchanan, J. M. [1975], ‘The Samaritan's Dilemma’, in The Collected Works of James M. Buchanan Volume 1: The Logical Foundations of Constitutional Liberty, Indianapolis: Liberty Fund.
Buchanan, J. M. and Tullock, G. (1962), The Calculus of Consent: The Logical Foundations of Constitutional Democracy, Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
Buchanan, J. M. and Vanberg, V. J. (2002), ‘Constitutional Implications of Radical Subjectivism’, The Review of Austrian Economics, 15 (2–3): 121129.
Buchanan, J., Chai, D. H. and Deakin, S. (2014), ‘Empirical Analysis of Legal Institutions and Institutional Change: Multiple-methods Approaches and Their Application to Corporate Governance Research’, Journal of Institutional Economics, 10 (01): 120.
Chamlee-Wright, E. (2010), The Cultural and Political Economy of Recovery: Social Learning in a Post-Disaster Environment, New York: Routledge.
Chamlee-Wright, E. and Storr, V. (2009), ‘Club Goods and Post-Disaster Community Return’, Rationality and Society, 21 (4): 429458.
Chamlee-Wright, E. and Storr, V. (2010), ‘Expectations of Government Response to Disaster’, Public Choice, 144 (1–2): 253274.
Chamlee-Wright, E. and Storr, V. (2011), ‘Social Capital as Collective Narratives and Post-Disaster Community Recovery’, Sociological Review, 59 (2): 266282.
Chicago Relief and Aid Society (1871a), Records of the Proceedings of the General Relief Commission, Chicago: Chicago Historical Society.
Chicago Relief and Aid Society (1871b), Report of the Chicago Relief and Aid Society of Disbursement of Contributions for the Sufferers by the Chicago Fire, Chicago: First special report.
Chicago Relief and Aid Society (1872), Report of the Chicago Relief and Aid Society of Disbursement of Contributions for the Sufferers by the Chicago Fire, Chicago: Fourteenth annual report.
Chicago Relief and Aid Society (1873), Report of the Chicago Relief and Aid Society of Disbursement of Contributions for the Sufferers by the Chicago Fire, Chicago: Fifteenth annual report.
Chicago Relief and Aid Society (1874), Report of the Chicago Relief and Aid Society of Disbursement of Contributions for the Sufferers by the Chicago Fire, Chicago: Special report.
Chicago Relief and Aid Society (1875), Report of the Chicago Relief and Aid Society of Disbursement of Contributions for the Sufferers by the Chicago Fire, Chicago: Sixteenth annual report.
Chicago Relief and Aid Society Correspondence (1872a), The Case of Lawrence Saddler, 1; Approved Application, 1872 (ichi-63784), Chicago: Chicago Historical Museum.
Chicago Relief and Aid Society Correspondence (1872b), The Case of Lawrence Saddler, 2; Letter from Reverend J. Cate, January 29, 1872 (ichi-63782), Chicago: Chicago Historical Museum.
Chicago Relief and Aid Society Correspondence (1872c), The Case of Lawrence Saddler, 3; Letter from T. F. Phillips, January 29, 1872 (ichi-63781), Chicago: Chicago Historical Museum.
Chicago Relief and Aid Society Correspondence (1872d), The Case of Lawrence Saddler, 4; Letter from Alex Bengley, January 30, 1872 (ichi-63783), Chicago: Chicago Historical Museum.
Chicago Relief and Aid Society Correspondence (1872e), The Case of Kate Moran, 1; Application, 1872 (ichi-63799), Chicago: Chicago Historical Museum.
Chicago Relief and Aid Society Correspondence (1872f), The Case of Kate Moran, 2; Letter of John Kennedy, 1872 (ichi-63798), Chicago: Chicago Historical Museum.
Chicago Relief and Aid Society Correspondence (1872g), The Case of Kate Moran, 3; Report of a Relief and Aid Society Visitor, 1872 (ichi-63796), Chicago: Chicago Historical Museum.
Chicago Relief and Aid Society Correspondence (1872h), The Case of Kate Moran, 4; Rejection of Application, February 26, 1872 (ichi-63797), Chicago: Chicago Historical Museum.
Chicago Tribune (1872), Article February 1, 1872; ProQuest Historical Newspapers Chicago Tribune (1840–1986), p. 5.
Cook County Board of Commissioners (1872), Proceedings from the General Commission: 7 March, Chicago: Chicago Historical Society.
Coyne, C. (2013), Doing Bad by Doing Good: Why Humanitarian Action Fails, California: Stanford University Press.
Coyne, C. J. and Ryan, M. E. (2009), ‘With Friends Like These, Who Needs Enemies? Aiding the World's Worst Dictators’, The Independent Review, 14 (1): 2644.
Coyne, C. and Williamson, C. R. (2015), ‘Foreign Aid and the Culture of Contracting’, Eastern Economic Journal, 41 (1): 102125.
Djankov, S., Montalvo, J. G. and Reynal-Querol, M. (2006), ‘Does Foreign Aid Help?’, Cato Journal, 26 (1): 128.
Djankov, S., Montalvo, J. G. and Reynal-Querol, M. (2008), ‘The Curse of Aid’, Journal of Economic Growth, 13 (3): 169194.
Easterly, W. (2006), The White Man's Burden: Why the West's Efforts to Aid the Rest Have Done So Much Ill and So Little Good, New York: Penguin Press.
Easterly, W. (2014), The Tyranny of Experts: How the Fight Against Global Poverty Suppressed Individual Rights, New York: Perseus Books Group.
Easterly, W., Levine, R. and Roodman, D. (2004), ‘New Data, New Doubts: A Comment on Burnside and Dollar's ‘Aid, Policies, and Growth’, American Economic Review, 94 (3): 774780.
Easterly, W. and Williamson, C. (2011), ‘Rhetoric versus Reality: The Best and Worst of Aid Agency Practices’, World Development, 39 (11): 19301949.
Gibson, C. C., Andersson, K. and Shivakumar, S. (2005), The Samaritan's Dilemma: The Political Economy of Development Aid, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Glaeser, E. L. and Shleifer, A. (2001), ‘Not-for-profit Entrepreneurs’, Journal of Public Economics, 81 (1): 99115.
Hartford, T. and Klein, M. (2005), ‘Aid and the Resource Curse’, The World Bank Group No. 291.
Heckelman, J. and Knack, S. (2008), ‘Foreign Aid and Market-Liberalizing Reform’, Economica, 75 (299): 542548.
Henderson, J. V. and Lee, Y. (2011), ‘Organization of disaster aid delivery: spending your donations’, NBER Working Paper No. 17707.
Iannaccone, L. R. and Berman, E. (2006), ‘Religious Extremism: The Good, the Bad, and the Deadly’, Public Choice, 128 (1–2): 109129.
Knack, S. (2001), ‘Aid Dependence and the Quality of Governance: Cross-country Empirical Tests’, Southern Economic Journal, 68 (2): 310329.
Leeson, P. T. (2007), ‘An-arrgh-chy: The Law and Economics of Pirate Organization’, Journal of Political Economy, 115 (6): 10491094.
Leeson, P. T. (2011), ‘Government, Clubs, and Constitutions’, Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, 80 (2): 301308.
Leeson, P. T. and Sobel, R. S. (2008), ‘Weathering Corruption’, Journal of Law and Economics, 51 (4): 667681.
Martin, A. and Thomas, D. (2013), ‘Two-Tiered Political Entrepreneurship and the Congressional Committee System’, Public Choice, 154 (1–2): 2137.
McCloskey, D. N. (2010), The Bourgeois Virtues: Ethics for an Age of Commerce, Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Naylor, T. J. (1975), ‘Responding to the Fire: The Work of the Chicago Relief and Aid Society’, Science and Society, 39 (4): 450464.
Nelson, O. (1966), ‘The Chicago Relief and Aid Society, 1850–1874’, Journal of the Illinois State Historical Society (1908–1984), 59 (1): 4866.
North, D. C. and Weingast, B. R. (1989), ‘Constitutions and Commitment: The Evolution of Institutions Governing Public Choice in Seventeenth-Century England’, The Journal of Economic History, 49 (04): 803832.
Ostrom, E. (2005), Understanding Institutional Diversity, Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Ostrom, E. (2010a), ‘Beyond Markets and States: Polycentric Governance of Complex Economic Systems’, American Economic Review, 100 (3): 641672.
Ostrom, E. (2010b), ‘Organizational Economics: Applications to Metropolitan Governance’, Journal of Institutional Economics, 6 (1): 109115.
Ostrom, E. and Basurto, X. (2011), ‘Crafting Analytical Tools to Study Institutional Change’, Journal of Institutional Economics, 7 (3): 317343.
Ostrom, E., Walker, J. and Gardner, R. (1992), ‘Covenants With and Without a Sword: Self-governance Is Possible’, American Political Science Review, 86 (2): 404417.
Ovaska, T. (2003), ‘The Failure of Development Aid’, Cato Journal, 23 (2): 175188.
Pedersen, K. R. (2001), ‘The Samaritan's Dilemma and the Effectiveness of Development Aid’, International Tax and Public Finance, 8 (5–6): 693703.
Pennington, M. (2010), Robust Political Economy: Classical Liberalism and the Future of Public Policy, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.
Pennington, M. (2013), ‘Elinor Ostrom and the Robust Political Economy of Common-pool Resources’, Journal of Institutional Economics, 9 (4): 449468.
Rawls, J. (2009), A Theory of Justice, Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Reed, C. R. (2005), ‘Black Chicago's first century: 1833-1900, volume 1’, Columbia, Missouri: University of Missouri Press.
Sawislak, K. (1995), Smoldering City: Chicagoans and the Great Fire, 1871–1874, Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Schmidtchen, D. (2002), ‘To Help or Not to Help: The Samaritan's Dilemma Revisited’, in Brennan, G., Kliemt, H. and Tollison, R. (eds.), Method and Morals in Constitutional Economics: Essays in Honor of James M. Buchanan, New York: Springer.
Shughart, W. F. II. (2006), ‘Katrinanomics: The Politics and Economics of Disaster Relief’, Public Choice, 127 (1–2): 3153.
Shughart, W. F. II. (2011), ‘Disaster Relief as Bad Public Policy’, The Independent Review, 15 (4): 519539.
Skarbek, E. (2010), ‘Coordinating the Reconstruction of Haiti’, Journal of International Peace Operations, 6 (2): 2527.
Skarbek, E. (2014), ‘The Chicago Fire of 1871: A Bottom Up Approach to Disaster Relief’, Public Choice, 160 (1): 155180.
Skarbek, D. (2011), ‘Governance and Prison Gangs’, American Political Science Review, 105 (04): 702716.
Skarbek, D. and Leeson, P. T. (2009), ‘What Can Aid Do?’, Cato Journal, 29 (2): 391.
Small, M. L. (2009), ‘How Many Cases Do I Need? On Science and the Logic of Case Selection in Field-Based Research’, Ethnography, 10 (1): 538.
Smith, A. C., Skarbek, D. B. and Wilson, B. J. (2012), ‘Anarchy, Groups, and Conflict: An Experiment on the Emergence of Protective Associations’, Social Choice and Welfare, 38 (2): 325353.
Sobel, R. and Leeson, P. (2006), ‘Government's Response to Hurricane Katrina: a Public Choice Analysis’. Public Choice, 127 (1–2): 5573.
Sobel, R. and Leeson, P. (2007), ‘The Use of Knowledge in Natural Disaster Relief Management’, The Independent Review, 11 (4): 519532.
Stringham, E. (2003), ‘The Extralegal Development of Securities Trading in Seventeenth-Century Amsterdam’, The Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance, 43 (2): 321344.
Sutter, D. (1998), ‘Constitutions and the Growth of Government’, Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, 34 (1): 2942.
Svensson, J. (1999), ‘Aid and Growth: Does Democracy Matter?’, Economics and Politics, 11 (3): 275297.
Svensson, J. (2000), ‘Foreign Aid and Rent-Seeking’, Journal of International Economics, 51 (1): 437461.
Tabellini, G. (2010), ‘Culture and Institutions: Economic Development in the Regions of Europe’, Journal of the European Economic Association, 8 (4): 677716.
Tarko, V. (2015), ‘The Challenge of Empirically Assessing the Effects of Constitutions’, Journal of Economic Methodology, 22 (1): 4676.
Thomas, D. and Thomas, M. (2014), ‘Entrepreneurship: Catallactic and Constitutional Perspectives’, The Review of Austrian Economics, 27 (1): 1122.
Tilly, C. (1985), ‘War Making and State Making as Organized Crime’, in Evans, P., Rueschemeyer, D. and Skocpol, T. (eds.), Bringing the State Back In, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Vanberg, G. (2011), ‘Substance versus Procedure: Constitutional Enforcement and Constitutional Choice’, Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, 80 (2): 309318.
Vigdor, J. (2008), ‘The Economic Aftermath of Hurricane Katrina’, The Journal of Economic Perspectives, 22 (4): 135154.
Williamson, C. R. (2008), ‘Foreign Aid and Human Development: The Impact of Foreign Aid to the Health Sector’, Southern Economic Journal, 75 (1), 188207.
Yamamura, E. (2014), ‘Impact of Natural Disaster on Public Sector Corruption’, Public Choice, 161 (1–2): 385405.

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed