Hostname: page-component-cc8bf7c57-n7qbj Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-09T20:40:54.507Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Currents in Contemporary Ethics: The Tuberculosis Scare in Retrospect

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 January 2021

Abstract

Image of the first page of this content. For PDF version, please use the ‘Save PDF’ preceeding this image.'
Type
JLME Column
Copyright
Copyright © American Society of Law, Medicine and Ethics 2007

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Naylor, C. D. Chantler, C. Griffiths, S., “Learning from SARS in Hong Kong and Toronto,” JAMA 291, no. 20 (2004): 2483–7, available at <http://jama.ama-assn.org/cgi/content/full/29l/20/2483> (last visited October 3, 2007); Pickles, H., “Using Lessons from the Past to Plan for Pandemic Flu,” BMJ332, no. 7544 (2006): 783–6, available at <http://www.bmj.com/cgi/content/full/332/7544/783> (last visited October 10, 2007).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Markel, H. Gostin, L. O. Fidler, D. P., “Extensively Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis: An Isolation Order, Public Health Powers, and a Global Crisis,” JAMA 298, no. 1 (2007): 83–6, available at <http://jama.ama-assn.org/cgi/content/full/298/1/83> (last visited October 3, 2007).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sebok, A. J., “The Attorney Who Boarded Planes after a Tuberculosis Diagnosis: Why the Other Passengers Are Likely to Be Able to Recover Damages for Fear of Infection,” June 13, 2007, available at <www.findlaw.com> (last visited October 3, 2007).+(last+visited+October+3,+2007).>Google Scholar
But still under the Denver Public Health isolation order until July 26.Google Scholar
Altman, L. K., “Traveler's TB Not as Severe as Officials Thought,” New York Times, July 4, 2007, available at <http://www.nytimes.com/2007/07/04/health/04tb.html?ex=1341201600&en=98bf436e457548df&ei=5088&partner=rssnyt&emc=rss> (last visited October 3, 2007).Google Scholar
See Sebok, , supra note 3.Google Scholar
Reuters Foundation, U.S. Homeland Security Probes TB Fugitive Case, News Release, available at <http://www.alertnet.org/thenews/newsdesk/N31202777.htm> (last visited October 3, 2007); O'Connor, A. Holusha, J., “TB Patient Is Related to C.D.C. Expert on Disease,” New York Times, May 31, 2007, available at <http://www.nytimes.com/2007/05/31/health/31cnd-tb.html?ex=1189224000&en=efe5fb406d57d400&ei=5070> (last visited October 3, 2007).Google Scholar
ABC News, “Exclusive: TB Patient Asks Forgiveness but Defends Travel,” ABC News Web site, June 1, 2007, available at <http://abcnews.go.com/GMA/OnCall/story?id=3231184&page=1> (last visited October 3, 2007).+(last+visited+October+3,+2007).>Google Scholar
See Markel, Gostin, Fidler, , supra note 2.Google Scholar
The Associated Press, TB Patient Questions CDC Timeline, MSNBC Web site, available at <http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/19630992/> (last visited October 3, 2007).+(last+visited+October+3,+2007).>Google Scholar
Giacalone, D., “Should They Disbar TuberculEsq?” available at <http://blogs.law.harvard.edu/ethicalesq/2007/06/01/should-they-disbar-tuberculesq/> (last visited October 3, 2007).+(last+visited+October+3,+2007).>Google Scholar
State Bar of Georgia, Georgia Rules of Professional Conduct § 8.4 (2001) available at <http://www.gabar.org/handbook/part_iv_after_january_1_2001_-_georgia_rules_of_professional_conduct/rule_84_misconduct/> (last visited October 3, 2007).+(last+visited+October+3,+2007).>Google Scholar
Id. “It shall be a violation of the Georgia Rules of Professional Conduct for a lawyer to…: Engage in professional conduct involving dishonesty, fraud, deceit or misrepresentation”; Georgia Rules of Professional Conduct § 8.4 a).Google Scholar
American Bar Association, Model Rules of Professional Conduct § 8.4 (2000), available at <http://www.abanet.org/cpr/mrpc/mrpc_toc.html> (last visited October 9, 2007).+(last+visited+October+9,+2007).>Google Scholar
A ninth person listed in the class action is related to one of the passengers but was not on the flight.Google Scholar
Tabri, Nassim Urbanova, Ludmela Sustkova, Eva et al. v. Speaker, Andrew, Motion to Institute Proceedings [2007] Superior Court of Quebec.Google Scholar
Baudouin, J-L. Deslauriers, P., eds., La responsabilité civile (Civil Responsibility), 6th ed. (Cowansville, Quebec: Éditions Yvon Blais, 2003): at 397.Google Scholar
Legatos, J., “TB Patient's Fellow Passengers Launch Lawsuit,” National Post, July 12, 2007, available at <http://www.canada.com/nationalpost/news/story.html?id=ca8b1b9b-0b72–44e2–8857-dc3453607e26&k=14187> (last visited October 3, 2007). However, according to the Motion, one of the passengers did receive a positive result in an initial tuberculosis skin test. See Tabri, Nassim Urbanova, Ludmela Sustkova, Eva et al. v. Speaker, Andrew, supra note 16.Google Scholar
Especially since even in the case of a physical injury (e.g., one of the passengers testing positive for tuberculosis), causality would be extremely difficult to prove.Google Scholar
See Tabri, Nassim Urbanova, Ludmela Sustkova, Eva et al. v. Speaker, Andrew, supra note 16.Google Scholar
Civil Code of Québec, R.S.Q. ch. C-1991, § 1457 (1991).Google Scholar
Benedek, D., “Non-Pecuniary Damages: Defined, Assessed and Capped,” Revue juridique Thémis 32 (1998): 607–61.Google Scholar
See Civil Code of Québec, supra note 22, at § 3126.Google Scholar
State power to issue public health detention orders is rooted in state police power; Gibbons v. Ogden, 22 U. S. 1 (1824).Google Scholar
Regulations to Control Communicable Diseases, 42 U.S.C. § 264 (a) (2005).Google Scholar
Sampathkumar, P., “Dealing with Threat of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis: Background Information for Interpreting the Andrew Speaker and Related Cases,” Mayo Clinic Proceedings 82, no. 7 (2007): 799802, available at <http://www.mayoclinicproceedings.com/inside.asp?AID=4425&UID=> (last visited October 3, 2007).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gerberding, J. L., “Recent Case of Extensively Drug Resistant TB: CDC's Public Health Response,” statement before the Committee on Homeland Security, United State House of Representatives, June 6, 2007.Google Scholar
See Markel, Gostin, Fidler, , supra note 2.Google Scholar
Five frameworks for public health ethics are laid out in Bensimon, C. M. Upshur, R. E. G., “Evidence and Effectiveness in Decisionmaking for Quarantine,” American Journal of Public Health 97, Supplement 1, no. S1 (2007): 44–8, available at <http://www.ajph.org/cgi/content/abstract/97/Supplement_1/S44> (last visited October 3, 2007).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
See Sampathkumar, , supra note 27.Google Scholar
For a more detailed analysis of treatment orders, see Verma, G. Upshur, R. E. G. Rea, E. Benatar, S. R., “Critical Reflection on Evidence, Ethics and Effectiveness in the Management of Tuberculosis: Public Health and Global Perspectives,” BMC Medical Ethics 5, no. 2 (2004), available at <http://www.biomedcentral.com/1472–6939/5/2> (last visited October 3, 2007).Google Scholar
See Bensimon, Upshur, , supra note 30.Google Scholar
See Coker, R., “Tuberculosis, Non-Compliance and Detention for the Public Health,” Journal of Medical Ethics 26, no. 3 (2000): 157–9, available at <http://jme.bmj.com/cgi/content/full/26/3/157> (last visited October 3, 2007); Coker, R., “Public Health, Civil Liberties, and Tuberculosis,” BMJ 318, no. 7196 (1999): 1434–5, available at <http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articlerender.fcgi?artid=1115825andLerner> (last visited October 3, 2007); Lerner, B. H., “Catching Patients: Tuberculosis and Detention in the 1990s,” Chest 115, no. 1 (1999): 236–41, available at <http://www.chestjournal.org/cgi/content/abstract/115/1/236> (last visited October 3, 2007).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Id. (Coker, 2000 and 1999).Google Scholar
See Lerner, , supra note 37.Google Scholar
See Verma, Upshur, Rea, Benatar, , supra note 31.Google Scholar
See Night, S. S., Public Health Emergencies and HIPAA: When Is the Disclosure of Individual Health Information Lawful? Health Law Policy Institute, available at <http://www.law.uh.edu/Healthlaw/perspectives/2007/(SN)SpeakerHIPAA.pdf> (last visited October 4, 2007), where the author does an analysis of whether HIPPA privacy rule was violated in the release of Speaker's name.Google Scholar
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, “Fact Sheet: Legal Authorities for Isolation and Quarantine,” available at <http://www.cdc.gov/ncidod/dq/fact-sheetlegal.htm> (last visited October 3, 2007).+(last+visited+October+3,+2007).>Google Scholar
See Markel, Gostin, Fidler, , supra note 2.Google Scholar