Skip to main content

Evaluativity across adjective and construction types: An experimental study 1


An adjectival construction is evaluative if and only if it conveys that the property associated with the adjective exceeds a relevant threshold. The questions of which adjectival constructions are evaluative and why have formed the foundation for semantic theories of these constructions and of adjectives themselves (Klein 1980, von Stechow 1984), although it has been alleged that these theories are based on an incomplete picture of the phenomenon of evaluativity (Bierwisch 1989, Rett 2008a). We present the first experimental tests of the scope and nature of evaluativity across adjectival constructions and adjective types. These studies confirm that evaluativity is conditioned by adjective type (relative or absolute, Kennedy & McNally 2005) and is not restricted to the positive construction. However, they also show several new and surprising aspects of evaluativity: that it is perhaps better characterized as a gradable property than a binary one; that the ways in which relative and absolute adjectives differ in their evaluativity vary across construction; and that, contrary to standard intuitions, subjects are willing to attribute evaluativity to the subject position of comparative constructions like Sue is taller than Bill. We show that this last particularly surprising result reveals a lot about how subjects interpret contextually sensitive constructions, and we discuss its consequences for experimental studies and semantic theories of adjectival evaluativity as well as context-sensitive phenomena more generally.

Corresponding author
Author’s address: University of California, Santa Cruz, 1156 High Street, Santa Cruz, CA 95064, USA,
Author’s address: University of California, 3103L Campbell Hall, Los Angeles, CA 90095, USA
Hide All

We thank three anonymous Journal of Linguistics reviewers for their comments, as well as Sam Cumming, Donka Farkas, Chris Kennedy, Megan Moodie, Floris Van Vugt, Kaeli Ward, and Lauren Winans for discussion and advice. The usual disclaimers apply.

Hide All
Armstrong S., Gleitman L. R. & Gleitman H.. 1983. What some concepts might not be. Cognition 13, 263308.
Bale Alan. 2008. A universal scale of comparison. Linguistics and Philosophy 31, 155.
Barker Chris. 2002. The dynamics of vagueness. Linguistics and Philosophy 25, 136.
Barner David & Snedeker Jesse. 2008. Compositionality and statistics in adjective acquisition: 4-year-olds interpret tall and short based on the size distributions of novel noun referents. Child Development 79, 594608.
Bartsch Renate & Vennemann Theo. 1972. The grammar of relative adjectives and comparison. Linguistische Berichte 20, 1932.
Bierwisch Manfred. 1989. The semantics of gradation. In Bierwisch M. & Lang E. (eds.), Dimensional adjectives: Grammatical structure and conceptual interpretation, 71237. Springer.
Bochnak M. Ryan & Bogal-Allbritten Elizabeth. 2014. Investigating gradable predicates, comparison, and degree constructions in underrepresented languages. In Bochnak M. Ryan & Matthewson Lisa (eds.), Methodologies in semantic fieldwork. Oxford University Press.
Bogal-Allbritten Elizabeth. 2013. Decomposing notions of adjectival transitivity in Navajo. Natural Language & Semantics 21, 277314.
Bogal-Allbritten Elizabeth. 2015. Slightly coerced: Processing evidence for adjectival coercion by minimizers. Proceedings of the 48th Meeting of the Chicago Linguistic Society (CLS 48): Parasession on Meaning and Cognition. Chicago: CLS Publications,
Breakstone Micha. 2012. In Aguilar Ana, Chernilovskaya Anna & Nouwen Rick (eds.), Inherent evaluativity (Proceedings of sinn und bedeutung 16), MITWPL.
Burnett Heather. 2012. The grammar of tolerance: On vagueness, context-sensitivity, and the origin of scale structure. Ph.D. thesis, University of California.
Cappelen Herman & Lepore Ernest. 2005. Insensitive semantics. Wiley-Blackwell.
Christensen Rune Haubo Bojesen. 2012. ordinal – regression models for ordinal data. R package version 2012.09-11,
Clark Herbert. 1969a. Influence of language on solving three-term series problems. Journal of Experimental Psychology 82, 205215.
Clark Herbert. 1969b. Linguistic processes in deductive reasoning. Psychological Review 76, 387404.
Clark Herbert. 1972. Difficulties people have answering the question, ‘Where is it?’ Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior 11, 265277.
Cobreros Pablo, Égré Paul, Ripley David & van Rooij Robert. 2012. Tolerant, classical, strict. Journal of Logic 41, 347385.
Cresswell Max. 1976. The semantics of degree. In Partee B. (ed.), Montague grammar. Academic Press.
Cruse D. Alan. 1976. Three classes of antonyms in English. Lingua 38, 281292.
Cruse D. Alan. 1980. Antonyms and gradable complementaries. In Kastovsky D. (ed.), Perspektiven der lexikalischen semantik: Beiträge zum wuppertaler semantikkolloquium vom 2Ű3, Dec. 1977, 1425. Bouvier.
Cruse D. Alan. 1986. Lexical semantics. Cambridge University Press.
Cummins Chris & Katsos Napoleon. 2010. Comparative and superlative quantifiers: Pragmatic effects of comparison type. Journal of Semantics 27, 271305.
Doetjes Jenny, Constantinescu Camelia & Součková Kateřina. 2009. A neo-Kleinian approach to comparatives. In Satoshi Ito Ed Cormany & Lutz David (eds.), Proceedings of SALT XIX, 124141. CLC Publications.
Doetjes Jenny, Guevara A., Chernilovskaya A. & Nouwen R.. 2012. On the (in)compatibility of non neutral adjectives and measure phrases. Proceedings of SUB 16. MITWPL.
Donaldson Margaret. 1963. A study of children’s thinking. Tavistock.
Doran R., Baker R., McNabb Y., Larson M. & Ward G.. 2009. On the non-unified nature of scalar implicature: An empirical investigation. International Review of Pragmatics 1, 211248.
Flores D’Arcais Giovanni  B. 1970. Linguistic structure and focus of comparison in processing of comparative sentences. In Flores D’Arcais G. B. & Levelt W. J. M. (eds.), Advances in psycholinguistics. North-Holland.
Grano Thomas. 2012. Mandarin henand universal markedness in gradable adjectives. Natural Language & Linguistic Theory 30, 513565.
Hansen Nat & Chemla Emmanuel. 2013. Experimenting on contextualism. Mind and Language 28, 286321.
Haspelmath Martin & Buchholz Oda. 1998. Equative and similative constructions in the languages of Europe. In van der Auwera Johan (ed.), Adverbial constructions in the languages of Europe, 277334. Mouton de Gruyter.
Hellan Lars. 1981. Towards an integrated analysis of comparatives. Tübingen: Narr.
Higgins E. Tory. 1977. The varying presuppositional nature of comparatives. Journal of Psycholinguistic Research 6, 203222.
Horn Larry. 1972. On the semantic properties of the logical operators in English. Ph.D. dissertation, University of California.
Kamp Hans. 1975. Two theories of adjectives. In Keenan E. (ed.), Formal semantics of natural language, 123155. Cambridge University Press.
Kamp Hans. 1981. The paradox of the heap. In Mönnich U. (ed.), Aspects of philosophical logic. Reidel.
Kamp Hans & Rossdeutscher Antje. 1994. Drs-construction and lexically driven inferences. Theoretical linguistics 20, 165235.
Kennedy Chris & Levin Beth. 2008. Measure of change: The adjectival core of degree achievements. In McNally Louise & Kennedy Christopher (eds.), Adjectives and adverbs: Syntax, semantics and discourse. Oxford University Press.
Kennedy Chris & McNally Louise. 2005. Scale structure, degree modification and the semantic typology of gradable predicates. Language 81.2, 345381.
Kennedy Christopher. 1999. Projecting the adjective: The syntax and semantics of gradability and comparison. Garland Press.
Kennedy Christopher. 2007. Vagueness and grammar: The semantics of relative and absolute gradable predicates. Linguistics and Philosophy 30, 145.
Kennedy Christopher. 2009. Modes of comparison. CLS 43 Proceedings, 141165. Chicago.
Kim Christina, Xiang Ming & Kennedy Chris. 2013. Context dependence and shiftability in two classes of gradable adjectives. Utrecht: XPrag poster.
Klein Ewan. 1980. A semantics for positive and comparative adjectives. Linguistics and Philosophy 4, 145.
Klein Ewan. 1982. The interpretation of adjectival comparatives. The Journal of Linguistics 18, 113136.
Kubota Yusuke & Matsui Ai. 2010. Modes of comparison and Question under Discussion: Evidence from ‘contrastive comparison’ in Japanese. In Li Nan & Lutz David (eds.), Proceedings of SALT 20, 5775. CLC Publications.
Lehrer Adrienne. 1985. Markedness and antonymy. Journal of Linguistics 21, 397429.
McNabb Y. 2012. Standard fixing and context manipulation: An experimental investigation of degree modification. In Aguilar-Guevara Ana, Chernilovskaya Anna & Nouwen Rick (eds.), Proceedings of sinn und bedeutung, vol. 16. MITWPL.
McNally Louise. 2011. The relative role of property type and scale structure in explaining the behavior of gradable adjectives. (Lecture Notes in Computer Science 6517), 151168. Springer.
Morzycki Marcin. 2009. Degree modification of gradable nouns: Size adjectives and adnominal degree morphemes. Natural Language & Semantics 17, 175207.
Morzycki Marcin. 2012. Adjectival extremeness: Degree modification and contextually restricted scales. Natural Language & Linguistic Theory 30, 567609.
Neeleman Ad, van de Koot Hans & Doetjes Jenny. 2004. Degree expressions. The Linguistic Review 21, 166.
Paradis Carita. 2001. Adjectives and boundedness. Cognitive Linguistics 12.1, 4765.
Paradis Carita & Willners Caroline. 2006. Antonymy and negation – the boundedness hypothesis. Journal of Pragmatics 38, 10511080.
Piaget J. 1928. Judgment and reasoning in the child. Paul Kegan.
Pinkal Manfred. 1989. Imprecise concepts and quantification. In Bartsch R., van Benthem J. & van Emde Boas P. (eds.), Semantics and contextual expression, 221265. Foris.
Potts Christopher. 2012. Conventional implicature and expressive content. In Maienborn C., von Heusinger K. & Portner P. (eds.), Semantics: An international handbook of natural language meaning, vol. 3, 25162536. Mouton de Gruyter.
R Core Team. 2013. R: A language and environment for statistical computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing Vienna, Austria.
Rett Jessica. 2008a. Antonymy and evaluativity. In Gibson Masayuki & Friedman Tova (eds.), Proceedings of SALT XVII. CLC Publications.
Rett Jessica. 2008b. Degree modification in natural language. Ph.D. dissertation, Rutgers University.
Rett Jessica. 2014. Measure phrase equatives and modified numerals. Journal of Semantics, Online first, doi:10.1093/jos/ffu004. Published 2015, volume 32 (3), pages 425–475.
Rett Jessica. 2015. The semantics of evaluativity. Oxford University Press.
van Rooij Robert. 2008. Comparatives and quantifiers. In Bonami O. & Cabredo Hofherr P. (eds.), Empirical issues in formal syntax and semantics, vol. 7, 423444. Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (CNRS).
van Rooij Robert. 2011. Implicit versus explicit comparatives. In Egré Paul & Klinedinst Nathan (eds.), Vagueness and language use,  vol. 7, 5172. New York: Palgrave MacMillan.
Rotstein Carmen & Winter Yoad. 2004. Total adjectives vs. partial adjectives: Scale structure and higher-order modifiers. Natural Language & Semantics 12, 259288.
Sassoon Galit. 2012a. A slightly modified economy principle: Stable properties have nonstable standards. In Cohen Evan (ed.), Proceedings of the Israel Association of Theoretical Linguistics (IATL), vol. 27. MITWPL.
Sassoon Galit W. 2012b. A typology of multidimensional adjectives. Journal of Semantics 146; Advance Access Aug. 9 2012, doi:10.1093/jos/ffs012. Published 2013, volume 30 (3), pages 335–380.
Sassoon Galit W. & Zevakhina Natalia. 2012. Granularity shifting: Experimental evidence from degree modifiers. Proceedings of SALT 22. University of Chicago.
Sawada Osamu. 2009. Pragmatic aspects of implicit comparison: An economy-based approach. Journal of Pragmatics 41, 10791103.
Schwarzschild Roger. 2012. Directed scale segments. In Chereches A. (ed.), Proceedings of SALT XXII, 6582. CLC Publications.
Seuren P. A. M. 1984. The comparative revisited. Journal of Semantics 3, 109141.
Solt Stephanie & Gotzner Nicole. 2012. Experimenting with degree. In Chereches Anca (ed.), Proceedings of SALT 22. Cornell University.
Sperber Dan & Wilson Deirdre. 1986. Relevance. New York: Basil Blackwell.
Stanley Jason & Szabo Zoltan. 2002. On quantifier domain restriction. Mind and Language 15, 219261.
Stassen Leon. 1985. Comparison and Universal Grammar: An essay in universal grammar. Basil: Blackwell.
von Stechow Arnim. 1984. Comparing semantic theories of comparison. Journal of Semantics 3, 177.
Syrett Kristin, Kennedy Chris & Lidz Jeffrey. 2010. Meaning and context in children’s understanding of gradable adjectives. Journal of Semantics 27, 135.
Toledo A. & Sassoon Galit. 2011. Absolute vs. relative adjectives – variance within vs. between individuals. Proceedings of SALT XXI, 135154. CLC Publications.
Tonhauser Judith, Beaver David, Roberts Craige & Simons Mandy. 2013. Toward a taxonomy of projective content. Language 89, 66109.
Tribushinina Elena. 2011. Piecemeal acquisition of boundedness. Belgian Journal of Linguistics 25, 93116.
Tribushinina E. & Gillis S.. 2012. The acquisition of scalar structures: Production of adjectives and degree markers by Dutch-speaking children and their caregivers. Linguistics 50.2, 241268.
Whorf Benjamin Lee. 1956. The relation of habitual thought and behavior to language. Language, thought, and reality, 134159. MIT Press.
Yoon Youngeun. 1996. Total and partial predicates and the weak and strong interpretations. Natural Language Semantics 4, 217236.
Zevakhina Natalia & Geurts Bart. 2011. Scalar diversity. Ms., National Research University at Nijmegen.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Journal of Linguistics
  • ISSN: 0022-2267
  • EISSN: 1469-7742
  • URL: /core/journals/journal-of-linguistics
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *



Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 6
Total number of PDF views: 75 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 558 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between 21st June 2017 - 23rd February 2018. This data will be updated every 24 hours.