Skip to main content Accesibility Help
×
×
Home

A within-country study of leadership perceptions and outcomes across native and immigrant employees: Questioning the universality of transformational leadership

  • Ann-Louise Holten (a1), Anne Bøllingtoft (a2), Isabella Gomes Carneiro (a3) and Vilhelm Borg (a4)
Abstract

This study investigates the universality of transformational leadership with respect to employee perceptions and three outcomes: job satisfaction, self-rated health, and well-being. We do so among employees of different national and cultural backgrounds, yet within a shared national and sectorial setting. Our study has a repeated measures design based on survey data from 2,947 employees (2,836 natives Danes and 111 immigrants) in the Danish elder care sector. While we find no difference between native Danes and immigrants in their perception of transformational leadership, we find that transformational leadership is not a universal predictor of outcomes. Although transformational leadership predicts change in none of the outcomes for immigrants, it does predict change in job satisfaction and well-being for native Danes. Based on our findings, we suggest applying a combination of universalistic and contingency paradigms when leading composite employee groups.

Copyright
Corresponding author
Corresponding author: ann-louise.holten@psy.ku.dk
References
Hide All
Antonakis, J. (2012). Transformational and charismatic leadership. In D. V. Day, & J. Antonakis (Eds.), The nature of leadership (2nd ed., pp. 256288). Los Angeles, CA: SAGE.
Antonakis, J., Avolio, B. J., & Sivasubramaniam, N. (2003). Context and leadership: An examination of the nine-factor full-range leadership theory using the Multifactor Leadership Questionnaire. The Leadership Quarterly, 14(3), 261295.
Ardichvili, A., & Gasparishvili, A. (2001). Leadership profiles of managers in post-communist countries: A comparative study. Leadership & Organization Development Journal, 22(2), 6269.
Arnold, K., Turner, N., Barling, J., Kelloway, E., & Mckee, M. C. (2007). Transformational leadership and psychological well-being: The mediating role of meaningful work. Journal of Occupational Health Psychology, 12(3), 193203.
Avery, D., Tonidandel, S., Volpone, S., & Raghuram, A. (2010). Overworked in America? How work hours, immigrant status, and interpersonal justice affect perceived work overload. Journal of Managerial Psychology, 25(2), 133147.
Avolio, B. J., Reichard, R. J., Hannah, S. T., Walumbwa, F. O., & Chan, A. (2009). A meta-analytic review of leadership impact research: Experimental and quasi-experimental studies. The Leadership Quarterly, 20(5), 764784.
Bass, B. M. (1985). Leadership and performance beyond expectations. New York: The Free Press.
Bass, B. M. (1997). Does the transactional–transformational leadership paradigm transcend organizational and national boundaries? American Psychologist, 52(2), 130139.
Bass, B. M. (1999). Two decades of research and development in transformational leadership. European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology, 8(1), 932.
Bass, B. M., & Avolio, B. J. (1989). Potential biases in leadership measures: How prototypes, leniency, and general satisfaction relate to ratings and rankings of transformational and transactional leadership constructs. Educational and Psychological Measurement, 49(3), 509527.
Bass, B. M., & Bass, R. (2009). The Bass handbook of leadership: Theory, research, and managerial applications. New York, NJ: Free Press.
Bech, P., Olsen, L. R., Kjoller, M., & Rasmussen, N. K. (2003). Measuring well-being rather than the absence of distress symptoms: A comparison of the SF-36 Mental Health Subscale and the WHO-Five Well-Being Scale. International Journal of Methods in Psychiatric Research, 12(2), 8591.
Bennis, W. G. (2009). On becoming a leader. New York: Basic Books.
Bjorner, J. B., Fayes, P., & Idler, E. (2005). Self-rated health. In: P. Fayers & R. Hays (Eds.), Assessing quality of life in clinical trials (2nd ed.) (pp. 309323). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Boal, K. B., & Hooijberg, R. (2001). Strategic leadership research: Moving on. The Leadership Quarterly, 11(4), 515549.
Borrell, L. N., & Dallo, F. J. (2008). Self-rated health and race among Hispanic and non-Hispanic adults. Journal of Immigrant and Minority Health, 10(3), 229238.
Braun, S., Peus, C., Weisweiler, S., & Frey, D. (2013). Transformational leadership, job satisfaction, and team performance: A multilevel mediation model of trust. Leadership Quarterly, 24(1), 270283.
Burns, J. M. (1978). Leadership. New York: Harper & Row.
Carless, S. A., Wearing, A. J., & Mann, L. (2000). A short measure of transformational leadership. Journal of Business and Psychology, 14(3), 389405.
Collins, J. (2006). Level 5 leadership: The triumph of humility and fierce resolve. In D. Mayle (Ed.), Managing Innovation and Change (3rd ed., pp. 234248). London: Sage.
Conger, J., Kanungo, R. N., & Menon, S. (2000). Charismatic leadership and follower effects. Journal of Organizational Behavior, 21(7), 747767.
Day, D. V., & Antonakis, J. (2012). Leadership: Past, present, and future. In D. V. Day, & J. Antonakis (Eds.), The nature of leadership (2nd ed., pp. 325). Los Angeles, CA: Sage.
Day, D. V., & Antonakis, J. (2013). The future of leadership. In H. S. Leonard, R. Lewis, A. M. Freedman, & J. Passmore (Eds.), The Wiley-Blackwell handbook of the psychology of leadership, change and organizational development (pp. 221236). Oxford: John Wiley & Sons.
Den Hartog, D., House, R., Hanges, P., Ruiz-Quintanilla, S., & Dorfman, P. (1999). Culture specific and cross-culturally generalizable implicit leadership theories: Are attributes of charismatic/transformational leadership universally endorsed? The Leadership Quarterly, 10(2), 219256.
DeSalvo, K. B., Fan, V. S., McDonell, M. B., & Fihn, S. D. (2005). Predicting mortality and healthcare utilization with a single question. Health Services Research, 40(4), 12341246.
Dickson, M., Castaño, N., Magomaeva, A., & Den Hartog, D. (2012). Conceptualizing leadership across cultures.Journal of World Business, 47(4), 483492.
Dinh, J. E., Lord, R. G., Gardner, W. L., Meuser, J. D., Liden, R. C., & Hu, J. (2014). Leadership theory and research in the new millennium: Current theoretical trends and changing perspectives. The Leadership Quarterly, 25(1), 3662.
Druskat, V. U. (1994). Gender and leadership style: Transformational and transactional leadership in the Roman Catholic Church. The Leadership Quarterly, 5(2), 99119.
Eagly, A. H., Johannesen-Schmidt, M. C., & Van Engen, M. L. (2003). Transformational, transactional, and laissez-faire leadership styles: A meta-analysis comparing women and men. Psychological Bulletin, 129(4), 569591.
Engelen, A., Schmidt, S., Strenger, L., & Brettel, M. (2014). Top management’s transformational leader behaviors and innovation orientation: A cross-cultural perspective in eight countries. Journal of International Management, 20(2), 124136.
Ergeneli, A., Gohar, R., & Temirbekova, Z. (2007). Transformational leadership: Its relationship to culture value dimensions. International Journal of Intercultural Relations, 31(6), 703724.
Fiedler, F. E. (1986). The contribution of cognitive resources and leader behavior to organizational performance. Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 16(6), 532548.
Gardner, W. L., Avolio, B. J., Luthans, F., May, D. R., & Walumbwa, F. (2005). ‘Can you see the real me?’ A self-based model of authentic leader and follower development. The Leadership Quarterly, 16(3), 343372.
Gerstner, C. R., & Day, D. V. (1994). Cross-cultural comparison of leadership prototypes. The Leadership Quarterly, 5(2), 121134.
Hamlin, R. G. (2007). In support of universalistic models of managerial and leadership effectiveness: Implications for HRD research and practice. Human Resource Development Quarterly, 15(2), 189215.
Hanges, P., Lord, R., & Dickson, M. (2000). An information‐processing perspective on leadership and culture: A case for connectionist architecture. Applied Psychology, 49(1), 133161.
Hersey, P., & Blanchard, K. H. (1969). An introduction to situational leadership. Training and Development Journal, 23, 2634.
Hofstede, G. (1984). Cultural dimensions in management and planning. Asia Pacific Journal of Management, 1(2), 8199.
Hosoda, M., & Stone-Romero, E. (2010). The effects of foreign accents on employment-related decisions. Journal of Managerial Psychology, 25(2), 113132.
House, R., Javidan, M., Hanges, P., & Dorfman, P. (2002). Understanding cultures and implicit leadership theories across the globe: An introduction to project GLOBE. Journal of World Business, 37(1), 310.
Härtel, C. E., & O’Connor, J. M. (2014). Contextualizing research: Putting context back into organizational behavior research. Journal of Management & Organization, 20(4), 417422.
Javidan, M., Dorfman, P. W., de Luque, M. S., & House, R. J. (2006). In the eye of the beholder: Cross cultural lessons in leadership from project GLOBE. The Academy of Management Perspectives, 20(1), 6790.
Jepson, D. (2009). Studying leadership at cross-country level: A critical analysis. Leadership, 5(1), 6180.
Judge, T. A., & Piccolo, R. F. (2004). Transformational and transactional leadership: A meta-analytic test of their relative validity. Journal of Applied Psychology, 89(5), 755768.
Jung, D., Yammarino, F. J., & Lee, J. K. (2009). Moderating role of subordinates’ attitudes on transformational leadership and effectiveness: A multi-cultural and multi-level perspective. The Leadership Quarterly, 20(4), 586603.
Jung, D. I., & Avolio, B. J. (1999). Effects of leadership style and followers’ cultural orientation on performance in group and individual task conditions. Academy of Management Journal, 42(2), 208218.
Jung, D. I., Bass, B. M., & Sosik, J. J. (1995). Bridging leadership and culture: A theoretical consideration of transformational leadership and collectivistic cultures. Journal of Leadership & Organizational Studies, 2(4), 318.
Jung, D. I., & Yammarino, F. J. (2001). Perceptions of transformational leadership among Asian Americans and Caucasian Americans: A level of analysis perspective. Journal of Leadership & Organizational Studies, 8(1), 321.
Karakitapoglu-Aygun, Z., & Gumusluoglu, L. (2013). The bright and dark sides of leadership: Transformational vs. non-transformational leadership in a non-Western context. Leadership, 9(1), 107133.
Klimoski, R. (2013). Commentary: When it comes to leadership, context matters. In M. G. Rumsey (Ed.), The Oxford handbook of leadership (pp. 267–287). New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
Kouzes, J., & Posner, B. (2012). The leadership challenge: How to make extraordinary things happen. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
Kumar, R., & Chhokar, J. S. (2012). Cross-cultural leadership. In M. G. Rumsey (Ed.), The Oxford Handbook of Leadership (pp. 225-242). New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
Kuoppala, J., Lamminpää, A., Liira, J., & Vainio, H. (2008). Leadership, job well-being, and health effects – a systematic review and a meta-analysis. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Medicine, 50(8), 904915.
Lankau, M. J., & Chung, B. G. (2009). A comparison of American and international prototypes of successful managers. Journal of Leadership Studies, 3(1), 718.
Leong, L. Y. C., & Fischer, R. (2011). Is transformational leadership universal? A meta-analytical investigation of multifactor leadership questionnaire means across cultures. Journal of Leadership & Organizational Studies, 18(2), 164174.
Lonner, W. J. (1980). The search for psychological universals. In H. C. Triandis & W. W. Lambert (Eds.), Handbook of cross-cultural psychology (Vol. 1, pp. 143-204). Boston: Allyn & Bacon.
Lowe, K. B., Kroeck, K. G., & Sivasubramaniam, N. (1996). Effectiveness correlates of transformational and transactional leadership: A meta-analytic review of the MLQ literature. The Leadership Quarterly, 7(3), 385425.
Marin, G., Triandis, H. C., Betancourt, H., & Kashima, Y. (1983). Ethnic affirmation versus social desirability explaining discrepancies in bilinguals’ responses to a questionnaire. Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology, 14(2), 173186.
Miao, Q., Newman, A., & Lamb, P. (2012). Transformational leadership and the work outcomes of Chinese migrant workers: The mediating effects of identification with leader. Leadership, 8(4), 377395.
Muczyk, J. P., & Holt, D. T. (2008). Toward a cultural contingency model of leadership. Journal of Leadership & Organizational Studies, 14(4), 277286.
Nyberg, A., Bernin, P., & Theorell, T. (2005). The impact of leadership on the health of subordinates. Stockholm: National Institute for Working Life (Arbetslivsinstitutet).
Olesen, K., Carneiro, I. G., Jørgensen, M. B., Rugulies, R., Rasmussen, C. D., Søgaard, K., & Flyvholm, M.-A. (2012). Associations between psychosocial work environment and hypertension among non-Western immigrant and Danish cleaners. International Archives of Occupational and Environmental Health, 85(7), 829835.
Ortega, A., Carneiro, I. G., & Flyvholm, M.-A. (2010). A descriptive study on immigrant workers in the elderly care sector. Journal of Immigrant and Minority Health, 12(5), 699706.
Osborn, R. N., Hunt, J. G., & Jauch, L. R. (2002). Toward a contextual theory of leadership. The Leadership Quarterly, 13(6), 797837.
Popper, M., & Druyan, N. (2001). Cultural prototypes? Or leaders’ behaviors? A study on workers’ perceptions of leadership in an electronics industry. Journal of Managerial Psychology, 16(7), 549558.
Rosmond, R., Lapidus, L., & Björntorp, P. (1996). A comparative review of psychosocial and occupational environment in native Swedes and immigrants. Scandinavian Journal of Public Health, 24(4), 237242.
Shamir, B. (2012). Leadership in context and context in leadership studies. In M. G. Rumsey (Ed.), The Oxford Handbook of Leadership (pp. 343–355). New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
Shamir, B., House, R., & Arthur, M. B. (1993). The motivational effects of charismatic leadership – A self-concept based theory. Organization Science, 4(4), 577594.
Shamir, B., & Howell, J. M. (1999). Organizational and contextual influences on the emergence and effectiveness of charismatic leadership. The Leadership Quarterly, 10(2), 257283.
Shelton, E. J. (2007). Transformational leadership: Its impact on Hispanic immigrant workers in a production/processing plant environment. PhD dissertation, Capella University.
Soares, A. M., Farhangmehr, M., & Shoham, A. (2007). Hofstede’s dimensions of culture in international marketing studies. Journal of Business Research, 60(3), 277284.
Steers, R. M., Sanchez-Runde, C., & Nardon, L. (2012). Leadership in a global context: New directions in research and theory development. Journal of World Business, 47(4), 479482.
Stogdill, R. M. (1974). Handbook of leadership. A survey of the literature. New York: Free Press.
Terrell, S. R., & Rosenbusch, K. (2013). How global leaders develop. Journal of Management Development, 32(10), 10561079.
Theorell, T., Nyberg, A., Bernin, P., Oxenstierna, G., Romanowska, J., & Westerlund, H. (2010). Leadership and employee health: A challenge in the contemporary workplace. In J. Houdmont, & S. Leka (Eds.), Contemporary occupational health psychology: Global perspectives on research and practice (Vol. 1, pp. 4658). Oxford, UK: Wiley-Blackwell.
Topp, C. W., Østergaard, S. D., Søndergaard, S., & Bech, P. (2015). The WHO-5 Well-Being Index: A systematic review of the literature. Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics, 84(3), 167176.
Van Knippenberg, D., & Sitkin, S. B. (2013). A critical assessment of charismatic – Transformational leadership research: Back to the drawing board? The Academy of Management Annals, 7(1), 160.
Vroom, V. H., & Jago, A. G. (2007). The role of the situation in leadership. American Psychologist, 62(1), 1724.
Walumbwa, F. O., & Lawler, J. J. (2003). Building effective organizations: Transformational leadership, collectivist orientation, work-related attitudes and withdrawal behaviours in three emerging economies. International Journal of Human Resource Management, 14(7), 10831101.
Walumbwa, F. O., Lawler, J. L., & Avolio, B. J. (2007). Leadership, individual differences, and work-related attitudes: A cross-culture investigation. Applied Psychology: An International Review, 56(2), 212230.
Walumbwa, F. O., Orwa, B., Wang, P., & Lawler, J. J. (2007). Transformational leadership, organizational commitment, and job satisfaction: A comparative study of Kenyan and U.S. financial firms. Human Resource Development Quarterly, 16(2), 235256.
Walumbwa, F. O., & Wernsing, T. (2012). From transactional and transformational leadership to authentic leadership. In M. G. Rumsey (Ed.), The Oxford Handbook of Leadership (pp. 392–400). New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
Wanasika, I., Howell, J.P., Littrell, R., & Dorfman, P. (2011). Managerial leadership and culture in sub-Saharan Africa. Journal of World Business, 46(2), 234241.
Wright, T. A., & Staw, B. M. (1999). Affect and favorable work outcomes: Two longitudinal tests of the happy-productive worker thesis. Journal of Organizational Behavior, 20(1), 123.
Yan, J., & Hunt, J. G. J. (2005). A cross cultural perspective on perceived leadership effectiveness. International Journal of Cross Cultural Management, 5(1), 4966.
Yukl, G. (2002). Leadership in organizations (5th ed.), Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Journal of Management & Organization
  • ISSN: 1833-3672
  • EISSN: 1839-3527
  • URL: /core/journals/journal-of-management-and-organization
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Keywords

Metrics

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed