Skip to main content Accessibility help

Why does the United Kingdom (UK) have inconsistent preferences on financial regulation? The case of banking and capital markets

  • Scott James (a1) and Lucia Quaglia (a2)


What explains national preferences concerning international and regional financial regulation? This article focusses on one of the main financial jurisdictions worldwide, the United Kingdom (UK). It is puzzling that since the crisis this jurisdiction has pursued stringent harmonised regulation in certain areas (banking), but not others (capital markets). We explain this in terms of how the demands of powerful economic interests are mediated by the political process and regulatory institutions. In banking, there was strong political pressure to restore financial stability, and regulatory institutions were significantly strengthened. This enabled UK regulators to resist industry lobbying and pursue more stringent harmonised rules at the international and European Union levels (“trading up”). In the case of capital markets, by contrast, UK regulators lacked political support for tougher regulation and were institutionally much weaker. As a result, the industry was far more effective in shaping UK preferences aimed at protecting the sector’s competitiveness (“trading down”).



Hide All
Alessandri, P. and Haldane, A. (2009) Banking on the State. Bank of England, 6 November.
Bailey, A. (2017) Why Free Trade and Open Markets in Financial Services Matter. Speech Given at Reuters Newsmaker Event, 6 July, (accessed 20 August 2017).
Baker, A. (1999) Nebuleuse and the “Internationalization of the State” in the UK? The Case of HM Treasury and the Bank of England. Review of International Political Economy 6(1): 79100.
Baker, A. (2010) Restraining Regulatory Capture? Anglo-America, Crisis Politics and Trajectories of Change in Global Financial Governance. International Affairs 86(3): 647663.
Baker, A. (2013) The New Political Economy of the Macroprudential Ideational Shift. New Political Economy 18(1): 112139.
Baker, A. (2015) Varieties of Economic Crisis, Varieties of Ideational Change: How and Why Financial Regulation and Macroeconomic Policy Differ. New Political Economy 20(3): 342366.
Baker, A. and Widmaier, W. (2014) The Hidden Institutionalist Roots of Macroprudential Ideas: Veblen and Galbraith on Regulation, Policy Success and Overconfidence. New Political Economy 19(4): 487506.
Bank of England (2017) Bank of England Average FTE Headcount, (accessed 20 August 2017).
Bell, S. and Hindmoor, A. (2015) ‘Taming the City? Ideas, Structural Power and the Evolution of British Banking Policy Amidst the Great Financial Meltdown. New Political Economy 20(3): 454474.
Bell, S. and Hindmoor, A. (2016) Structural Power and the Politics of Bank Capital Regulation in the United Kingdom. Political Studies 65(1): 103121.
Bennett, R. and Kottasz, R. (2012) Public Attitudes Towards the UK Banking Industry Following the Global Financial Crisis. International Journal of Bank Marketing 30(2): 128147.
Borio, C. (2011) Implementing a Macroprudential Framework: Blending Boldness and Realism. Capitalism and Society 6(1): 123.
Busch, A. (2004) National Filters: Europeanization, Institutions and Discourse in the Case of Banking Regulation. West European Politics 27(2): 310333.
Carney, M. (2015) Building Real Markets for the Good of the People, Mansion House Speech, June.
Carney, M. (2017a) Oral evidence, Treasury Committee, House of Commons, 11 January.
Carney, M. (2017b) Speech: The High Road to a Responsible, Open Financial System, 7 April.
ComRes (2014) TSB Party Conference Research, September, (accessed 20 August 2017).
Conservative Party (2009) From Crisis to Confidence: Plan for Sound Banking (London: Conservative Party).
Culpepper, P. (2011) Quiet Politics and Business Power: Corporate Control in Europe and Japan. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Culpepper, P. and Reinke, R. (2014) Structural Power and Bank Bailouts in the United Kingdom and the United States. Politics and Society 42(4): 427454.
Downs, A. (1957) An Economic Theory of Democracy. New York: Harper.
European Commission (2009) Proposal for a Directive of the European Parliament and of the Council on Alternative Investment Fund Managers, 30 April.
Farrell, H. and Newman, A. L. (2010) Making Global Markets: Historical Institutionalism in International Political Economy. Review of International Political Economy 17(4): 609638.
Financial Services Authority (FSA) (2009) The Turner Review: A Regulatory Response to the Global Banking Crisis, March, London.
Fioretos, O. (2010) Capitalist Diversity and the International Regulation of Hedge Funds. Review of International Political Economy 17(3): 696723.
Fioretos, O. (2011) Creative Reconstructions: Multilateralism and European Varieties of Capitalism after 1950. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
Grossman, E. and Woll, C. (2013) Saving the Banks: The Political Economy of Bailouts. Comparative Political Studies 47(4): 574600.
Group of Twenty (G20) (2009a) Declaration on Strengthening the Financial System, London, 2 April.
Haldane, A. (2013) Macroprudential Policies: When and How to Use them? Paper at Re-Thinking Macro II Conference, IMF Washington, 16–17 April.
Hopkin, J. and Shaw, K. A. (2016) Organized Combat or Structural Advantage? The Politics of Inequality and the Winner-Take-All Economy in the United Kingdom’. Politics & Society 44(3): 345371.
House of Lords (2010) European Union Committee – Third Report: Directive on Alternative Investment Fund Managers. London: Stationery Office.
Howarth, D. and Quaglia, L. (2013) Banking on Stability: The Political Economy of New Capital Requirements in the European Union. Journal of European Integration 35(3): 333346.
Howarth, D. and Quaglia, L. (2016) The Comparative Political Economy of Basel III in Europe. Policy and Society 35(3): 205214.
Independent Commission on Banking (ICB) (2011) Final Report Recommendations. September, London.
James, S. (2016) The Domestic Politics of Financial Regulation: Informal Ratification Games and the EU Capital Requirement Negotiations. New Political Economy 21(2): 187203.
James, S. (2017) The Structural-Informational Power of Business: Credibility, Signalling and the UK Banking Reform Process. Journal of European Public Policy. Early View
Jenkins, R. (2011) Lessons in Lobbying. Speech by Robert Jenkins, 22 November, Bank of England.
Kapstein, E. B. (1989) Resolving the Regulator’s Dilemma: International Coordination of Banking Regulations. International Organization 43(2): 323347.
King, M. (2010) Banking: From Bagehot to Basel, and Back Again: The Second Bagehot Lecture. Buttonwood Gathering, 25 October, New York City, NY.
Miles, D., Yang, J. and Marcheggiano, G. (2011) Optimal Bank Capital, External MPC Unity. Discussion Paper No. 31, January, London.
Moran, M. (1991) The Politics of the Financial Services Revolution: The USA, UK and Japan. Basingstoke: Macmillan.
Moravcsik, A. (1993) Preferences and Power in the European Community: A Liberal Intergovernmentalist Approach. Journal of Common Market Studies 31(4): 473524.
Moravcsik, A. (1998) The Choice for Europe. Social Purpose and State Power from Messina to Maastricht. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
Moschella, M. and Tsingou, E. (2013) Regulating Finance After the Crisis: Unveiling the Different Dynamics of the Regulatory Process. Regulation & Governance 7(4): 407416.
Mügge, D. (2012) From Pragmatism to Dogmatism. EU Governance, Policy Paradigms, and Financial Meltdown. New Political Economy 16(2): 185206.
Newman, A. and Posner, E. (2016) Transnational Feedback, Soft Law, and Preferences in Global Financial Regulation. Review of International Political Economy 23(1): 123152.
Osborne, G. (2010) Speech by the Chancellor of the Exchequer. 16 June, Mansion House London.
Pagliari, S. (2011) Who Governs Finance? The Shifting Public-Private Divide in the Regulation of Derivatives, Rating Agencies and Hedge Funds. European Law Journal 18(1): 4461.
Pagliari, S. (2013) Public Salience and International Financial Regulation. Explaining the International Regulation of OTC Derivatives, Rating Agencies, and Hedge Funds. PhD Dissertation, University of Waterloo, Waterloo.
Pagliari, S. (2017) Financial Regulatory Arbitrage After Brexit: How Feasible?. CITYPERC Policy Report, May.
Pagliari, S. and Young, K. L. (2014) Leveraged Interests: Financial Industry Power and the Role of Private Sector Coalitions. Review of International Political Economy 21(3): 575610.
Quaglia, L. (2010) Completing the Single Market in Financial Services: The Politics of Competing Advocacy Coalitions. Journal of European Public Policy 17(7): 1007.
Quaglia, L. (2011) The “Old” and “New” Political Economy of Hedge Funds Regulation in the European Union. West European Politics 34(4): 665682.
Quaglia, L. (2012) The “Old” and “New” Politics of Financial Services Regulation in the European Union. New Political Economy 17(4): 515535.
Quaglia, L. (2014) The European Union and Global Financial Regulation. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Quaglia, L. (2017) The Political Economy of Post-Crisis International Standards for Resolving Financial Institution. New Political Economy 22(5): 595609.
Quaglia, L. and Spendzharova, A. (2017) Post-Crisis Reforms in Banking: Regulators at the Interface Between Domestic and International Governance. Regulation and Governance. Early View
Singer, D. A. (2004) Capital Rules: The Domestic Politics of International Regulatory Harmonization. International Organization 58(3): 531565.
Singer, D. A. (2007) Regulating Capital: Setting Standards for the International Financial System. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
The CityUK (2012) Hedge Funds 2012, March, London.
Treasury Committee (2006) Private Equity. Tenth Report of Session 2006-07, Volume II, London.
Tucker, P., Hall, S. and Pattani, A. (2013) Macroprudential Policy at the Bank of England. Bank of England Quarterly Bulletin, Q3, 192–200.
Turner, A. (2011) Reforming Finance: Are We Being Radical Enough? Clare Distinguished Lecture in Economics and Public Policy, Cambridge, 18 February.
Way, C. (2000) Central Banks, Partisan Politics, and Macroeconomic Outcomes. Comparative Political Studies 33(2): 196224.
Westrup, J. (2007) The Politics of Financial Regulatory Reform in Britain and Germany. West European Politics 30(5): 10961119.
Woll, C. (2013) Lobbying Under Pressure: The Effect of Salience on European Hedge Fund Regulation. Journal of Common Market Studies 51(3): 555572.
Woll, C. (2014) The Power of Inaction: Bank Bailouts in Comparison. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
YouGov (2013) Public Trust in Banking. Spring Symposium, April.
Young, K. L. (2012) Transnational Regulatory Capture? An Empirical Examination of the Transnational Lobbying of the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision. Review of International Political Economy 19(4): 663688.


Why does the United Kingdom (UK) have inconsistent preferences on financial regulation? The case of banking and capital markets

  • Scott James (a1) and Lucia Quaglia (a2)


Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed