Skip to main content
×
Home
    • Aa
    • Aa

Costs and Benefits: A Review of Research on Take-up of Income-Related Benefits*

Abstract
ABSTRACT

This paper reviews recent research on take-up with a view to identifying the most promising lines of further enquiry. In the late 1970s take-up research seemed to be foundering in the face of the complexity of the factors affecting claiming decisions. Progress came via the development of models of the claiming process. The most influential postulated a series of thresholds which claimants must pass in a set sequence on the way to claiming a benefit. One question for future research is whether this model is still the best starting point or whether there are others which capture the key factors and their interaction more fully and accurately. Another approach is to look at claiming decisions indirectly by applying multivariate techniques to continuous survey data to examine the relationship between variables such as age, income and housing tenure and differing probabilities of claiming. A second question is what the two approaches can offer each other. Overhanging all the issues facing take-up research is the problem of sampling a population—eligible non-recipients—for which, almost by definition, no suitable sampling frame exists. The paper concludes by examining various options for identifying this elusive group.

Copyright
References
Hide All
Altman R.A. (1981), Take-up of Supplementary Benefit by Male Pensioners, SSRC Programme on Taxation, Incentives and the Distribution of Income, Discussion Paper 25, London School of Economics.
Ashenfelter O. (1983), ‘Determining participation in income-tested social programmes’, Journal of the American Statistical Association, 78, 517–25.
Atkinson A.B. (1984), Take-up of Social Security Benefits, ESRC Programme on Taxation, Incentives and the Distribution of Income Discussion Paper 65, London School of Economics.
Atkinson A.B. (1987), ‘Income maintenance and social insurance’, Auerback A. and Feldstein M. (eds), A Handbook of Public Economics, North-Holland, Elsevier.
Atkinson A.B. (1991), The Development of State Pensions in the UK, Welfare State Programme Discussion Paper 58, London School of Economics.
Atkinson A.B. with Champion B. (1989), ‘Family income supplement and two-parent families, 1971–1980’, in Atkinson A.B., Poverty and Social Security, Harvester, Hemel Hempstead
Atkinson A.B. and Micklewright J. (1983), ‘On the reliability of income data in the Family Expenditure Survey 1970–1977’, Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, 146, 3361.
Blundell R., Fry V. and Walker I. (1987), Modelling the Take-up of Means-Tested Benefits: the Case of Housing Benefits in the UK, Working Paper 87/3, Institute for Fiscal Studies, London.
Bradshaw J. and Beadham R. (1987), The Take-up of Housing Rebates by Families with Children, Social Policy Research Unit, York.
Bradshaw J. and Millar J. (1991), Lone Parent Families in the UK, HMSO, London.
Bradshaw M. and Davies R. (1986), Not a Penny to Call My Own. Poverty Among Residents in Mental Illness and Mental Handicap Hospitals, Disability Alliance/King's Fund, London.
Broad P. (1977), Pensioners and Their Needs, OPCS, London.
Brown J. (1987), The Future of Family Income Support, Studies of the Social Security System No. 15, PSI, London.
Brown J. (1988), Child Benefit. Investing in the Future, CPAG, London.
Brown R. (1985), Money Matters for People with a Mental Handicap, Disablement Income Group, London.
Buckland S. and Dawson P. (1989), ‘Household claiming behaviour’, Social Policy and Administration, 23, 6071.
Bull D. (ed.) (1971), Family Poverty. Programme for the Seventies, CPAG/Duckworth, London.
Corden A. (1981a), The Process of Claiming Family Income Supplement: Background Paper I, Social Policy Research Unit, York.
Corden A. (1981b), The Process of Claiming Family Income Supplement: Background Paper II, Social Policy Research Unit, York.
Corden A. (1983), Taking up a Means Tested Benefit. The Process of Claiming Family Income Supplement, HMSO, London.
Corden A. (1985a), The Process of Claiming Family Income Supplement, Study 3: Increasing Take-Up in Cumbria, Social Policy Research Unit, York.
Corden A. (1985b), Operational Aspects of the Family Credit Scheme, Social Policy Research Unit, York.
Corden A. (1985c), The Process of Claiming Family Income Supplement. Proposals for Further Research, Social Policy Research Unit, York.
Corden A. (1987a), Disappointed Applicants. A Study of Unsuccessful Claims for Family Income Supplement, Avebury, Aldershot.
Corden A. (1987b), ‘Claiming behaviour and take-up: a model for people with mental handicap’, British Journal of Mental Handicap, 33, 5765.
Corden A. and Craig P. (1991), Perceptions of Family Credit, HMSO, London.
Cowell F.A. (1986), Welfare Benefits and the Economics of Take-Up, ESRC Programme on Taxation. Incentives and the Distribution of Income, Discussion Paper 89, London School of Economics.
Davies C. and Ritchie J. (1988), Tipping the Balance. A Study of Non-Take-Up of Benefits in an Inner City Area, HMSO, London.
Dawson P., Buckland S. and Gilbert N. (1990), ‘Expert systems and the public provision of benefit advice’, Policy and Politics, 18, 4354.
Deacon A. and Bradshaw J. (1983), Reserved for the Poor. The Means Test in British Social Policy, Martin Robertson, Oxford.
DHSS Statistics and Research Division (1987), Family Income Supplement Take-Up, 1983–4—Technical Note, DHSS, London.
DHSS Statistics and Research Division (nd). Supplementary Benefit Take-Up, 1983, DHSS, London.
DSS (1991), Social Security 1990, HMSO, London.
DSS Analytical Services Division (1989a), Family Income Supplement Take-Up 1985–86. Technical Note, DSS, London.
DSS Analytical Services Division (1989b), Housing Benefit Take-Up 1985. Technical Note, DSS, London.
DSS Analytical Services Division (1989c), Supplementary Benefit Take-Up 1985. Technical Note, DSS, London.
Dilnot A.W., Kay J.A. and Morris C.N. (1984), The Reform of Social Security, OUP, Oxford.
Falkingham F. (1985a), Local Authority Approaches to Take-Up, Benefits Research Unit, Nottingham University.
Falkingham F. (1985b), Take-Up of Benefits: A Literature Review, Benefits Research Unit, Review paper 1:85, Nottingham University.
Falkingham F. (1986), ‘Local authority initiatives on increasing take-up of benefits’, Municipal Review, 665, 211.
Ferguson D.G. (1985), Take-Up of Family Income Supplement, Msc Thesis, Ulster University.
Ferguson D.G. (1986), Take-Up of Family Income Supplement, DHSS, Stormont.
Fry V. and Stark G. (1987), ‘The take-up of supplementary benefit: gaps in the safety net’, Fiscal Studies, 8, 114.
Godfrey N. (1986), Merseyside County Council 1983 ‘Claim it Now’ Campaign, Final Report, Merseyside County Council, Liverpool.
Graham J. (1984), Take-Up of FIS. Knowledge, Attitudes and Experience—Claimants and Non-Claimants, PPRU Occasional Paper 2, PPRU, Stormont.
Harris A.I., Smith C.R.W. and Head E. (1972), Income and Entitlement to Supplementary Benefit of Impaired People in Great Britain, HMSO, London.
Henwood M. and Wicks M. (1986), Benefit or Burden? The Objectives and Impact of Child Support, Occasional Paper 3, Family Policy Studies Centre, London.
Kerr S. (1982a), Differential Take-Up of Supplementary Pensions. Final Report, Department of Psychology, Edinburgh University.
Kerr S. (1982b), ‘Deciding about supplementary pensions: a provisional model’, Journal of Social Policy, 11, 505–17.
Kerr S. (1983), Making Ends Meet: An Investigation Into the Non-Claiming of Supplementary Pensions, Bedford Square Press, London.
Knight I. (1981), Family Finances, OPCS Occasional Paper 26, OPCS, London.
Lister R. (1974), Take-Up of Means Tested Benefits, Poverty Pamphlet 18, CPAG, London.
McClements L. (1978), The Economics of Social Security, Heinemann, London.
Manchester City Council Welfare Rights Service (1985), Claim It Now. Take-Up Campaigns in Manchester 1982–4, Manchester City Council.
Millar J. (1983), Take-Up of Means Tested Benefits in Work, Working Paper 3, DHSS Cohort Study of Unemployed Men, DHSS, London.
Millar J. and Cooke K. (1984), A Study of the Take-Up of One Parent Benefit in Hackney, Social Policy Research Unit, York.
Millar J., Cooke K. and McLaughlin E. (1988), The Employment Lottery. Risk and Social Security Benefits, paper presented to Employment and Unemployment Workshop, Department of Employment, 20 May.
Millar J., Cooke K. and McLaughlin E. (1989), Work and Welfare Benefits, Avebury, Aldershot.
Moffitt R. (1980), ‘Participation in the AFDC programme and the stigma of welfare receipt’, Southern Economic Journal, 47, 753–62.
Moffitt R. (1983), ‘An economic model of welfare stigma’, American Economic Review, 73, 1023–35.
National Audit Office (1985), DHSS: Arrangements For Delivering Social Security Benefits, HC 235, HMSO, London.
National Consumer Council (1976), Means Tested Benefits. A Discussion Paper, National Consumer Council, London.
van Oorschott W. (1990), Non-Take-Up of Social Security Benefits in Europe, paper presented to the Social Policy Association Conference, University of Bath.
Page D. and Weinberger B. (1975), Birmingham Rent Rebate and Allowance Study, Centre for Urban and Regional Studies Research Memorandum 44, Birmingham University.
Richardson A. and Naidoo J. (1978), The Take-Up of Supplementary Benefits: A Report on a Survey of Claimants, DHSS, London/London University.
Ritchie J. (1989), The Take-Up of Income-Related Benefits. A Review of Recent Research Evidence on Factors Affecting the Take-Up of Income-Related Benefits, unpublished paper.
Ritchie J. and Matthews A. (1982), Take-Up of Rent Allowances. An In Depth Study, Social and Community Planning Research, London.
Social Security Advisory Committee (1988), Sixth Report of the Social Security Advisory Committee, HMSO, London.
Strauss R.P. (1977), ‘Information and participation in a public transfer programme’, Journal of Public Economics, 8, 385–96.
Supplementary Benefits Commission (1978), Take-Up of Supplementary Benefits, Supplementary Benefits Administration Paper 7, HMSO, London.
Taylor-Gooby P. (1976), ‘Rent benefits and tenants’ attitudes. The Batley rent rebate and allowance study’, Journal of Social Policy, 5, 3348.
Walker R. (1980), ‘Temporal aspects of claiming behaviour: renewal of rent allowances’, Journal of Social Policy, 9, 207–22.
Weisbrod B.A. (1970), On the Stigma Effect and the Demand for Welfare Programmes—a Theoretical Note, Institute for Research on Poverty Discussion paper 82–70, University of Wisconsin, Madison.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Journal of Social Policy
  • ISSN: 0047-2794
  • EISSN: 1469-7823
  • URL: /core/journals/journal-of-social-policy
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 25 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 237 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 23rd October 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.