Skip to main content
×
Home
    • Aa
    • Aa

The phylogeny of the ornithischian dinosaurs

  • Richard J. Butler (a1), Paul Upchurch (a2) and David B. Norman (a3)
  • DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/S1477201907002271
  • Published online: 01 March 2008
Abstract
SYNOPSIS

Ornithischia is a familiar and diverse clade of dinosaurs whose global phylogeny has remained largely unaltered since early cladistic analyses in the mid 1980s. Current understanding of ornithischian evolution is hampered by a paucity of explicitly numerical phylogenetic analyses that consider the entire clade. As a result, it is difficult to assess the robustness of current phylogenetic hypotheses for Ornithischia and the effect that the addition of new taxa or characters is likely to have on the overall topology of the clade.

The new phylogenetic analysis presented here incorporates a range of new basal taxa and characters in an attempt to rigorously test global ornithischian phylogeny. Parsimony analysis is carried out with 46 taxa and 221 characters. Although the strict component consensus tree shows poor resolution in a number of areas, application of reduced consensus methods provides a well-resolved picture of ornithischian interrelationships. Surprisingly, Heterodontosauridae is placed as the most basal group of all well-known ornithischians, phylogenetically distant from a stem-defined Ornithopoda, creating a topology that is more congruent with the known ornithischian stratigraphical record. There is no evidence for a monophyletic ‘Fabrosauridae’, and Lesothosaurus (the best-known ‘fabrosaur’) occupies an unusual position as the most basal member of Thyreophora. Other relationships within Thyreophora remain largely stable. The primitive thyreophoran Scelidosaurus is the sister taxon of Eurypoda (stegosaurs and ankylosaurs), rather than a basal ankylosaur as implied by some previous studies.

The taxonomic content of Ornithopoda differs significantly from previous analyses and basal relationships within the clade are weakly supported, requiring further investigation. ‘Hypsilophodontidae’ is paraphyletic, with some taxa (Agilisaurus, Hexinlusaurus, Othnielia) placed outside of Ornithopoda as non-cerapodans. Ceratopsia and Pachycephalosauria are monophyletic and are united as Marginocephalia; however, the stability of these clades is reduced by a number of poorly preserved basal taxa.

This analysis reaffirms much of the currently accepted ornithischian topology. Nevertheless, instability in the position and content of several clades (notably Heterodontosauridae and Ornithopoda) indicates that considerable future work on ornithischian phylogeny is required and causes problems for several current phylogenetic definitions.

Copyright
Corresponding author
* E-mail: R.Butler@nhm.ac.uk;
Email: P.Upchurch@ucl.ac.uk;
Email: dn102@esc.cam.ac.uk
Linked references
Hide All

This list contains references from the content that can be linked to their source. For a full set of references and notes please see the PDF or HTML where available.

R. T. Bakker & P. M. Galton 1974. Dinosaur monophyly and a new class of vertebrates. Nature 248: 168172.

P. M. Barrett , R. J. Butler & F. Knoll 2005. Small-bodied ornithischian dinosaurs from the Middle Jurassic of Sichuan, China. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 25: 823834.

S. C. Bennett 1996. The phylogenetic position of the Pterosauria within the Archosauromorpha. Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society 118: 261308.

O. R. P. Bininda-Emonds , H. N. Bryant & A. P. Russell 1998. Supraspecific taxa as terminals in cladistic analysis: implicit assumptions of monophyly and a comparison of methods. Biological Journal of the Linnean Society 64: 101133.

K. Bremer 1988. The limits of amino-acid sequence data in angiosperm phylogenetic reconstruction. Evolution 42: 795803.

B. Brown & E. M. Schlaikjer 1940. The structure and relationships of Protoceratops.Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 40: 133266.

H. N. Bryant 1992. The role of permutation tail probability tests in phylogenetic systematics. Systematic Biology 41: 258263.

R. J. Butler 2005. The ‘fabrosaurid’ ornithischian dinosaurs of the Upper Elliot Formation (Lower Jurassic) of South Africa and Lesotho. Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society 145: 175218.

J. M. Carpenter 1992. Random cladistics. Cladistics 8: 147153.

K. Carpenter 2004. Redescription of Ankylosaurus magniventris Brown 1908 (Ankylosauridae) from the Upper Cretaceous of the Western Interior of North America. Canadian Journal of Earth Sciences 41: 961986.

S. Chatterjee 1984. A new ornithischian dinosaur from the Triassic of North America. Naturwissenschaften 71: 630631.

B. Chinnery 2004. Description of Prenoceratops pieganensis gen. et sp. nov. (Dinosauria: Neoceratopsia) from the Two Medicine Formation of Montana. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 24: 572590.

R. A. Coria & L. Salgado 1996. A basal iguanodontian (Ornithischia: Ornithopoda) from the Late Cretaceous of South America. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 16: 445457.

R. A. Coria & J. O. Calvo 2002. A new iguanodontian ornithopod from Neuquen Basin, Patagonia, Argentina. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 22: 503509.

A. W. Crompton & A. J. Charig 1962. A new ornithischian from the Upper Triassic of South Africa. Nature 196: 10741077.

J. Dzik 2003. A beaked herbivorous archosaur with dinosaur affinities from the early Late Triassic of Poland. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 23: 556574.

R. F. Ewer 1965. The anatomy of the thecodont reptile Euparkeria capensis Broom. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, Series B 248: 379435.

D. P. Faith & P. S. Cranston 1991. Could a cladogram this short have arisen by chance alone? – On permutation tests for cladistic structure. Cladistics 7: 128.

C. A. Forster 1990. The postcranial skeleton of the ornithopod dinosaur Tenontosaurus tilletti. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 10: 273294.

P. M. Galton 1972. Classification and evolution of ornithopod dinosaurs. Nature 239: 464466.

P. M. Galton 1973 a. The cheeks of ornithischian dinosaurs. Lethaia 6: 6789.

P. M. Galton 1977. The ornithopod dinosaur Dryosaurus and a Laurasia–Gondwanaland connection in the Upper Jurassic. Nature 268: 230232.

P. M. Galton 1978. Fabrosauridae, the basal family of ornithischian dinosaurs (Reptilia: Ornithopoda). Paläontologische Zeitschrift 52: 138159.

P. M. Galton 1981. Dryosaurus, a hypsilophodontid dinosaur from the Upper Jurassic of North America and Africa: postcranial skeleton. Paläontologische Zeitschrift 55: 271312.

P. M. Galton 1982 a. Juveniles of the stegosaurian dinosaur Stegosaurus from the Upper Jurassic of North America. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 2: 4762.

P. M. Galton 1985. British plated dinosaurs (Ornithischia, Stegosauria). Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 5: 211254.

P. M. Galton & P. Taquet 1982. Valdosaurus, a hypsilophodontid dinosaur from the Lower Cretaceous of Europe and Africa. Géobios 15: 147159.

C. W. Gilmore 1909. Osteology of the Jurassic reptile Camptosaurus, with a revision of the species of the genus, and a description of two new species. Proceedings of the United States National Musuem 36: 197332.

C. W. Gilmore 1915. Osteology of Thescelosaurus, an orthopodous dinosaur from the Lance Formation of Wyoming. Proceedings of the United States National Musuem 49: 591616.

C. W. Gilmore 1931. A new species of troödont dinosaur from the Lance Formation of Wyoming. Proceedings of the United States National Musuem 79: 16.

C. E. Gow 1975. A new heterodontosaurid from the Red Beds of South Africa showing clear evidence of tooth replacement. Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society 57: 335339.

D. J. Gower & E. Weber 1998. The braincase of Euparkeria, and the evolutionary relationships of birds and crocodilians. Biological Reviews 73: 367411.

R. V. Hill , L. M. Witmer & M. A. Norell 2003. A new specimen of Pinacosaurus grangeri (Dinosauria: Ornithischia) from the Late Cretaceous of Mongolia: ontogeny and phylogeny of ankylosaurs. American Museum Novitates 3395: 129.

J. A. Hopson 1980. Tooth function and replacement in early Mesozoic ornithischian dinosaurs: implications for aestivation. Lethaia 13: 93105.

J. R. Horner & D. B. Weishampel 1988. A comparative embryological study of two ornithischian dinosaurs. Nature 332: 256257.

R. B. Irmis , W. G. Parker , S. J. Nesbitt & J. Liu 2007. Early ornithischian dinosaurs: the Triassic record. Historical Biology 19: 322.

M. Kearney & J. M. Clark 2003. Problems due to missing data in phylogenetic analyses including fossils: a critical review. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 23: 263274.

F. Knoll 2002 a. New skull of Lesothosaurus (Dinosauria: Omithischia) from the Upper Elliot Formation (Lower Jurassic) of southern Africa. Géobios 35: 595603.

F. Knoll 2002 b. Nearly complete skull of Lesothosaurus (Dinosauria: Ornithischia) from the Upper Elliot Formation (Lower Jurassic: Hettangian) of Lesotho. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 22: 238243.

M. C. Langer 2006. Early dinosaurs: a phylogenetic study. Journal of Systematic Palaeontology 4: 309358.

Y. N. Lee 1996. A new nodosaurid anklosaur (Dinosauria: Ornithischia) from the Paw Paw formation (late Albian) of Texas. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 16: 232245.

S. C. R. Maidment , S. Wei & D. B. Norman 2006. Re-description of the postcranial skeleton of the middle Jurassic stegosaur Huayangosaurus taibaii. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 26: 944956.

P. J. Makovicky & M. A. Norell 2006. Yamaceratops dorngobiensis, a new primitive ceratopsian (Dinosauria: Ornithischia) from the Cretaceous of Mongolia. American Museum Novitates 3530: 142.

G. A. Mantell 1825. Note on the Iguanodon, a newly discovered fossil reptile, from the sandstone of Tilgate Forest, in Sussex. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London 115: 179186.

K. C. Nixon & J. M. Carpenter 1996. On consensus, compatibility, and clade concordance. Cladistics 12: 305322.

D. B. Norman 1990. A review of Vectisaurus valdensis, with comments on the family Iguanodontidae. Pp. 147161inK. Carpenter & P. J. Currie (eds) Dinosaur Systematics; Approaches and Perspectives. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

D. B. Norman 1998. On Asian ornithopods (Dinosauria: Ornithischia). 3. A new species of iguanodontid dinosaur. Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society 122: 291348.

D. B. Norman 2002. On Asian ornithopods (Dinosauria: Ornithischia). 4. Probactrosaurus Rozhdestvensky, 1966. Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society 136: 113144.

D. B. Norman 2004. Basal Iguanodontia. Pp. 413437inD. B. Weishampel , P. Dodson & H. Osmólska (eds) The Dinosauria, Second Edition. University of California Press, Berkeley.

D. B. Norman , L. M. Witmer & D. B. Weishampel 2004 a. Basal Ornithischia. Pp. 325334inD. B. Weishampel , P. Dodson & H. Osmólska (eds) The Dinosauria, Second Edition. University of California Press, Berkeley.

D. B. Norman , L. M. Witmer & D. B. Weishampel 2004 b. Basal Thyreophora. Pp. 335342inD. B. Weishampel , P. Dodson & H. Osmólska (eds) The Dinosauria, Second Edition. University of California Press, Berkeley.

D. B. Norman , H.-D. Sues , L. M. Witmer & R. A. Coria 2004 c. Basal Ornithopoda. Pp. 393412inD. B. Weishampel , P. Dodson & H. Osmólska (eds) The Dinosauria, Second Edition. University of California Press, Berkeley.

D. B. Norman , R. J. Butler & S. C. R. Maidment 2007. Reconsidering the status and affinities of the ornithischian dinosaur Tatisaurus oehleri Simmons, 1965. Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society 150: 865–874.

F. E. Novas 1993. New information on the systematics and postcranial skeleton of Herrerasaurus ischigualastensis (Theropoda: Herrerasauridae) from the Ischigualasto Formation (Upper Triassic) of Argentina. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 13: 400423.

F. E. Novas 1996. Dinosaur monophyly. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 16: 723741.

K. Padian 1989. Presence of the dinosaur Scelidosaurus indicates Jurassic age for the Kayenta Formation (Glen Canyon Group, northern Arizona). Geology 17: 438441.

W. G. Parker , R. B. Irmis , S. J. Nesbitt , J. W. Martz & L. S. Browne 2005 a. The Late Triassic pseudosuchian Revueltosaurus callenderi and its implications for the diversity of early ornithischian dinosaurs. Proceedings of the Royal Society Series B 272: 963969.

L. Prendini 2001. Species or supraspecific taxa as terminals in cladistic analysis? Groundplans versus exemplars revisited. Systematic Biology 50: 290300.

L. Salgado , R. A. Coria & S. E. Heredia 1997. New materials of Gasparinisaura cincosaltensis (Ornithischia, Ornithopoda) from the Upper Cretaceous of Argentina. Journal of Paleontology 71: 933940.

A. P. Santa Luca , A. W. Crompton & A. J. Charig 1976. A complete skeleton of the late Triassic ornithischian Heterodontosaurus tucki. Nature 264: 324328.

J. L. Sanz , J. V. Santafé & L. Casanovas 1983. Wealden ornithopod dinosaur Hypsilophodon from the Capas Rojas Formation (lower Aptian, Lower Cretaceous) of Morella, Castellón, Spain. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 3: 3942.

H. G. Seeley 1887. On the classification of the fossil animals commonly named Dinosauria. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London 43: 165171.

P. C. Sereno 1990 b. New data on parrot-beaked dinosaurs (Psittacosaurus). Pp. 203210inK. Carpenter & P. J. Currie (eds) Dinosaur Systematics: Approaches and Perspectives. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

P. C. Sereno 1991 a. Lesothosaurus, “fabrosaurids,” and the early evolution of Ornithischia. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 11: 168197.

P. C. Sereno 1991 b. Basal archosaurs: phylogenetic relationships and functional implications. Memoirs of the Society of Vertebrate Paleontology 2: 151.

P. C. Sereno 1993. The pectoral girdle and forelimb of the basal theropod Herrerasaurus ischigualastensis. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 13: 425450.

P. C. Sereno 1997. The origin and evolution of dinosaurs. Annual Review of Earth and Planetary Science 25: 435489.

P. C. Sereno 1999 a. The evolution of dinosaurs. Science 284: 21372147.

P. C. Sereno 1999 b. A rationale for dinosaurian taxonomy. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 19: 788790.

P. C. Sereno & A. B. Arcucci 1993. Dinosaurian precursors from the Middle Triassic of Argentina: Lagerpeton chanarensis. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 13: 385399.

P. C. Sereno & A. B. Arcucci 1994. Dinosaurian precursors from the Middle Triassic of Argentina: Marasuchus lilloensis, gen. nov. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 14: 5373.

P. C. Sereno & Z. Dong 1992. The skull of the basal stegosaur Huayangosaurus taibaii and a cladistic diagnosis of Stegosauria. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 12: 318343.

P. C. Sereno & F. E. Novas 1993. The skull and neck of the basal theropod Herrerasaurus ischigualastensis. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 13: 451476.

P. C. Sereno , S. Chao , Z. Cheng & C. Rao 1988. Psittacosaurus meileyingensis (Ornithischia; Ceratopsia) a new psittacosaur from the Lower Cretaceous of Northeastern China. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 8: 366377.

R. M. Sullivan 2003. Revision of the dinosaur Stegoceras Lambe (Ornithischia, Pachycephalosauridae). Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 23: 181207.

J. L. Thorley & R. D. M. Page 2000. RadCon: phylogenetic tree comparison and consensus. Bioinformatics 16: 486487.

R. A. Thulborn 1970 b. The systematic position of the Triassic ornithischian dinosaur Lycorhinus angustidens. Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society 49: 235245.

R. A. Thulborn 1971. Origin and evolution of ornithischian dinosaurs. Nature 234: 7578.

R. A. Thulborn 1974. A new heterodontosaurid dinosaur (Reptilia: Ornithischia) from the Upper Triassic Red Beds of Lesotho. Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society 55: 151175.

M. K. Vickaryous , T. Maryańska & D. B. Weishampel 2004. Ankylosauria. Pp. 363392inD. B. Weishampel , P. Dodson & H. Osmólska (eds) The Dinosauria, Second Edition. University of California Press, Berkeley.

M. K. Vickaryous , A. P. Russell , P. J. Currie & X. J. Zhao 2001. A new ankylosaurid (Dinosauria: Ankylosauria) from the Lower Cretaceous of China, with comments on ankylosaurian relationships. Canadian Journal of Earth Sciences 38: 17671780.

D. B. Weishampel 2004. Ornithischia. Pp. 323324inD. B. Weishampel , P. Dodson & H. Osmólska (eds) The Dinosauria, Second Edition. University of California Press, Berkeley.

D. B. Weishampel & R. E. Heinrich 1992. Systematics of Hypsilophodontidae and basal Iguanodontia (Dinosauria: Ornithopoda). Historical Biology 6: 159184.

D. B. Weishampel , C.-M. Jianu , Z. Csiki & D. B. Norman 2003. Osteology and phylogeny of Zalmoxes (N. G.), an unusual euornithopod dinosaur from the latest Cretaceous of Romania. Journal of Systematic Palaeontology 1: 65123.

J. J. Wiens 1998. The accuracy of methods for coding and sampling higher-level taxa for phylogenetic analysis: a simulation study. Systematic Biology 47: 397413.

M. Wilkinson 1994. Common cladistic information and its consensus representation: reduced Adams and reduced cladistic consensus trees and profiles. Systematic Biology 43: 343368.

M. Wilkinson 1995 a. Arbitrary resolutions, missing entries, and the problem of zero-length branches in parsimony analysis. Systematic Biology 44: 108111.

M. Wilkinson 1995 b. More on reduced consensus methods. Systematic Biology 44: 435439.

M. Wilkinson 1995 c. Coping with abundant missing entries in phylogenetic inference using parsimony. Systematic Biology 44: 501514.

M. Wilkinson 1996. Majority-rule reduced consensus methods and their use in bootstrapping. Molecular Biology and Evolution 13: 437444.

M. Wilkinson 2003. Missing entries and multiple trees: instability, relationships and support in parsimony analysis. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 23: 311323.

M. Wilkinson , J. L. Thorley & P. Upchurch 2000. A chain is no stronger than its weakest link: double decay analysis of phylogenetic hypotheses. Systematic Biology 49: 754776.

T. E. Williamson & T. D. Carr 2002. A new genus of derived pachycephalosaurian from western North America. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 22: 779801.

D. A. Winkler , P. A. Murry & L. L. Jacobs 1997. A new species of Tenontosaurus (Dinosauria : Ornithopoda) from the Early Cretaceous of Texas. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 17: 330348.

X. Xu , X.-L. Wang & H.-L. You 2001. A juvenile ankylosaur from China. Naturwissenschaften 88: 297300.

X. Xu , C. A. Forster , J. M. Clark & J. Mo 2006. A basal ceratopsian with transitional features from the Late Jurassic of northwestern China. Proceedings of the Royal Society B 273: 21352140.

X. Xu , P. J. Makovicky , X.-L. Wang , M. A. Norell & H.-L. You 2002. A ceratopsian dinosaur from China and the early evolution of Ceratopsia. Nature 416: 314317.

A. M. Yates 2003. A new species of the primitive dinosaur Thecodontosaurus (Saurischia: Sauropodomorpha) and its implications for the systematics of early dinosaurs. Journal of Systematic Palaeontology 1: 142.

Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Journal of Systematic Palaeontology
  • ISSN: 1477-2019
  • EISSN: 1478-0941
  • URL: /core/journals/journal-of-systematic-palaeontology
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Keywords: