Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
×
Home

Psychopathy and Culpability: How Responsible Is the Psychopath for Criminal Wrongdoing?

  • Adam R. Fox, Trevor H. Kvaran and Reid Griffith Fontaine
Abstract

Recent research into the psychological and neurobiological underpinnings of psychopathy has raised the question of whether, or to what degree, psychopaths should be considered morally and criminally responsible for their actions. In this article, we review the current empirical literature on psychopathy, focusing particularly on deficits in moral reasoning, and consider several potential conclusions that could be drawn based on this evidence. Our analysis of the empirical evidence on psychopathy suggests that while psychopaths do not meet the criteria for full criminal responsibility, they nonetheless retain some criminal responsibility. We conclude, by introducing the notion of rights as correlative, that even if psychopaths were to be fully nonresponsible, imposing some form of civil commitment would still be warranted.

Copyright
References
Hide All
American Law Institute. 1985. Model Penal Code and Commentaries. Philadelphia, PA: American Law Institute.
American Psychiatric Association. 2000. Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 4th ed. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.
Arrigo, Bruce. A., and Shipley, Stacey. 2001. The Confusion over Psychopathy (I): Historical Considerations. International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology 45:325–44.
Bandura, Albert. 2002. Selective Moral Disengagement in the Exercise of Moral Agency. Journal of Moral Education 31 (2): 101–19.
Bandura, Albert. 2006. Toward a Psychology of Human Agency. Perspectives on Psychological Science 1 (2): 164–80.
Blair, James R. 1995. A Cognitive Developmental Approach to Morality: Investigating the Psychopath. Cognition 57:129.
Blair, James R. 1996. Brief Report: Morality in the Autistic child. Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders 26:571–79.
Blair, James R. 1997. Moral Reasoning in the Child with Psychopathic Tendencies. Personality and Individual Differences 22:731–39.
Blair, James R. 2004. The Roles of Orbital Frontal Cortex in the Modulation of Antisocial Behavior. Brain and Cognition 55:198208.
Blair, James R. 2005. Applying a Cognitive Neuroscience Perspective to the Disorder of Psychopathy. Developmental Psychopathology 17:865–91.
Blair, James R. 2007. Aggression, Psychopathy and Free Will from a Cognitive Neuroscience Perspective. Behavioral Sciences and the Law 25:321–31.
Blair, James R., and Cipolotti, L. 2000. Impaired Social Response Reversal: A Case of “Acquired Sociopathy.” Brain 123:1122–41.
Blair, James R., Jones, L., Clark, F., and Smith, M. 1995. Is the Psychopath Morally Insane? Personality and Individual Differences 19 (5): 741–52.
Blair, James R., Mitchell, D., Leonard, A., Budhani, S., Peschardt, K. S., and Newman, C. 2004. Passive Avoidance Learning in Psychopathic Individuals: Modulation by Reward but Not by Punishment. Personality and Individual Differences 37 (6): 1179–92.
Blair, James R., Mitchell, D., Peschardt, K. S., Colledge, E., Leonard, R. A., Shine, J. H., Murray, L. K., and Perrett, D. I. 2004. Reduced Sensitivity to Others' Fearful Expressions in Psychopathic Individuals. Personality and Individual Differences 37 (6): 1111–22.
Blair, K. S., Richell, R. A., Mitchell, Derek, Leonard, A., Morton, J., and Blair, James R. 2006. They Know the Words, but Not the Music: Affective and Semantic Priming in Individuals with Psychopathy. Biological Psychology 73:114–23.
Cima, Maaike, Tonnaer, Franca, and Hauser, Marc D. 2010. Psychopaths Know Right from Wrong but Don't Care. Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience 5 (1): 5967.
Cleckley, Hervey. 1941. The Mask of Sanity. St. Louis, MO: Mosby.
Cushman, Fiery, Young, Liane, and Greene, Joshua. 2008. “Our Multi‐System Moral Psychology: Towards a Consensus View.” In The Oxford Handbook of Moral Psychology, ed. Doris, J., Harman, G., Nichols, S., Prinz, J., Sinnott‐Armstrong, W., and Stich, S., 4771. New York: Oxford University Press.
DeMatteo, D., and Edens, J. F. 2006. The Role and Relevance of the Psychopathy Checklist‐Revised in Court: A Case‐law Survey of U.S. Courts (1991–2004). Psychology, Public Policy, and Law 12:214–41.
De Oliveira‐Souza, R., Ignácio, F. A., and Moll, J. 2008. “The Antisocial Amid Us.” In Moral Psychology, ed. Sinnott‐Armstrong, W., 151–58. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
De Oliveira‐Souza, R., Ignácio, F. A., Moll, J., and Hare, R. D. 2008. Psychopathy in a Civil Psychiatric Outpatient Sample. Criminal Justice and Behavior 35 (4): 427–37.
Flor, Herta, Birbaumer, Niels, Hermann, Christiane, Ziegler, Silvio, and Patrick, Christopher. 2002. Aversive Pavlovian Conditioning in Psychopaths: Peripheral and Central Correlates. Psychophysiology 394:505–18.
Fontaine, Reid Griffith. 2007. Disentangling the Psychology and Law of Instrumental and Reactive Subtypes of Aggression. Psychology, Public Policy, and Law 143 (13): 143–65.
Fontaine, Reid Griffith. 2009a. Adequate (Non) Provocation and Heat of Passion as Excuse, Not Justification. University of Michigan Journal of Law Reform 43 (1): 2751.
Fontaine, Reid Griffith. 2009b. On Passion's Potential to Undermine Rationality: A Reply. University of Michigan Journal of Law Reform 43:207–44.
Fontaine, Reid Griffith. 2010. An Attack on Self‐Defense. American Criminal Law Review 47:5789.
Goldberg, John C. P., and Zipursky, Benjamin C. 2007. Tort Law and Moral Luck. Cornell Law Review 92:1123–76.
Gordon, H. L. 2004. Functional Differences among Those High and Low on a Trait Measure of Psychopathy. Biological Psychiatry 56:516–21.
Greene, Joshua. 2005. “Cognitive Neuroscience and the Structure of the Moral Mind.” In The Innate Mind: Structure and Contents, ed. Laurence, S., Carruthers, P., and Stich, S., 338–52. New York: Oxford University Press.
Greene, Joshua, and Haidt, Jonathan. 2002. How (and Where) Does Moral Judgment Work? Trends in Cognitive Sciences 6 (12): 517–23.
Greene, Joshua, Nystrom, Leigh, Engell, A. D., Darley, John, and Cohen, Jonathan. 2004. The Neural Bases of Cognitive Conflict and Control in Moral Judgment. Neuron 44 (2): 389400.
Greene, Joshua, Sommerville, R. B., Nystrom, Leigh, Darley, John, and Cohen, J. D. 2001. An fMRI Investigation of Emotional Engagement in Moral Judgment. Science 293 (5537): 2105–8.
Hare, Robert D. 1980. A Research Scale for the Assessment of Psychopathy in Criminal Populations. Personality and Individual Differences 12:111–19.
Hare, Robert D. 1996. Psychopathy and Antisocial Personality Disorder: A Case of Diagnostic Confusion. Psychiatric Times 13 (2): 3940.
Hare, Robert D. 2003. Manual for the Hare Psychopathy Checklist—Revised, 2d ed. Toronto: Multi‐Health Systems.
Hare, Robert D. 2006. Psychopathy: A Clinical and Forensic Overview. Psychiatric Clinics of North America 29:709–24.
Hare, Robert D., and Jutai, Jeffrey. 1988. Psychopathy and Cerebral Asymmetry in Semantic Processing. Personality and Individual Differences 9 (2): 329–37.
Harpur, Timothy, Hakstian, Ralph, and Hare, Robert D. 1989. Two‐Factor Conceptualization of Psychopathy: Construct Validity and Assessment Implications. Psychological Assessment 11:617.
Hart, S. D., and Hare, R. D. 1996. Psychopathy and Antisocial Personality Disorder. Current Opinion in Psychiatry 9:129–32.
Ishikawa, S. S., Raine, A., Lencz, T., Bihrl, S., and Lacasse, L. 2001. Autonomic Stress Reactivity and Executive Functions in Successful and Unsuccessful Criminal Psychopaths from the Community. Journal of Abnormal Psychology 110:423–32.
Kiehl, K. A., Smith, A. M., Hare, R. D., Forster, B. B., Brink, J., and Liddle, P. F. 2001. Limbic Abnormalities in Affective Processing by Criminal Psychopaths as Revealed by Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging. Biological Psychiatry 50:677–84.
Koenigs, Michael, Young, Liane, Adolphs, Ralph, Tranel, Daniel, Cushman, Fiery, Hauser, Marc, and Damasio, Antonio. 2007. Damage to the Prefrontal Cortex Increases Utilitarian Moral Judgments. Nature 446 (7138): 908–11.
LeDoux, J. 1998. The Emotional Brain. New York: Weidenfeld & Nicolson.
Levenston, G. K., Patrick, C. J., Bradley, M. M., and Lang, P. J. 2000. The Psychopath as Observer: Emotion and Attention in Picture Processing. Journal of Abnormal Psychology 109:373–86.
Mitchell, Derek, Avny, Shelley, and Blair, James R. 2006. Divergent Patterns of Aggressive and Neurocognitive Characteristics in Acquired versus Developmental Psychopathy. Neurocase 12:164–78.
Morse, Stephen. 2003. Diminished Rationality, Diminished Responsibility. Ohio State Journal of Criminal Law 1:289308.
Morse, Stephen. 2004. Reason, Results, and Criminal Responsibility. University of Illinois Law Review 2:363444.
Morse, Stephen. 2008. Psychopathy and Criminal Responsibility. Neuroethics 1:205–12.
Mullins‐Nelson, J. L., Salekin, R. T., and Leistico, A. R. 2006. Psychopathy, Empathy, and Perspective‐Taking Ability in a Community Sample: Implications for the Successful Psychopathy Concept. International Journal of Forensic Mental Health 5:133–49.
Prichard, J. C. 1835. A Treatise on Insanity and Other Disorders Affecting the Mind. London: Sherwood, Gilbert, & Piper.
Ray, James V., Poythress, Norman G., Weir, John M., and Rickelm, Angela. 2009. Relationships between Psychopathy and Impulsivity in the Domain of Self‐Reported Personality Features. Personality and Individual Differences 46 (2): 8387.
Rilling, James, Glenn, Andrea, Jairam, Meeta, Pagnoni, Giuseppe, Goldsmith, David, Elfenbein, Hanie, and Lilienfeld, Scott. 2007. Neural Correlates of Social Cooperation and Noncooperation as a Function of Psychopathy. Biological Psychiatry 61 (11): 1260–71.
Scott, Elizabeth S., and Steinberg, Laurence. 2003. Blaming Youth. Texas Law Review 81 (3): 799840.
Smetana, J. G., and Braeges, L. J. 1990. The Development of Toddlers' Moral and Conventional Judgments. Merrill-Palmer Quarterly 36:329–46.
Turiel, Elliot. 1983. The Development of Social Knowledge: Morality and Convention. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Elst, Van, Tebartz, L., Woermann, F. G., Lemieux, L., Thompson, P. J., and Trimble, M. R. 2000. Affective Aggression in Patients with Temporal Lobe Epilepsy: A Quantitative MRI Study of the Amygdala. Brain 123:234–43.
Vitacco, M. J., and Rogers, R. 2001. Predictors of Adolescent Psychopathy: The Role of Impulsivity, Hyperactivity, and Sensation Seeking. Journal of the American Academy of Psychiatry and Law 29 (4): 374–82.
Atkins v. Virginia, 536 U.S. 304 (2002).
Jacobsen v. Massachusetts, 521 U.S. 346 (1997).
Kansas v. Hendricks, 197 U.S. 26 (1905).
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Law & Social Inquiry
  • ISSN: 0897-6546
  • EISSN: 1747-4469
  • URL: /core/journals/law-and-social-inquiry
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Metrics

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed