Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home

Tell Me Your Story: How Recruitment Practices Implementing Affirmative Action Laws May Undermine the Laws’ Goals

  • Lisa Buchter

Abstract

Scholars pointed out that antidiscrimination laws do not fully undermine workplace discrimination and that affirmative action policies mostly benefit overqualified or advantaged individuals within minorities. To elucidate this paradox, this case study analyzes how some companies adopted specific selection and assessment processes for job seekers after the reinforcement of a quota for workers with disabilities in France. I observed the creation of alternative recruitment channels, the hiring of disability experts for recruitment, the refusal of resume sorting as a prescreening tool, and an emphasis on face-to-face interviews. While these changes circumvented practices that could have excluded people with disabilities (resume screening as a preselection tool, inaccessible venues for recruitment), they changed these practices only in limited spaces within the organizations. Additionally, while they did help more people get hired, they also compelled more personal disclosure that led to a more emotional assessment of job seekers and enabled “refined statistical discrimination” within pools of job seekers with disabilities. This research therefore reveals recruitment practices that may increase the number of individuals with disabilities hired but that, at the same time, may facilitate overselectivity and trigger significant risks associated with emotional recruitment of individuals with disabilities.

Copyright

Footnotes

Hide All

Thank you to Brayden King, Sophie Dubuisson-Quellier, Bruce Carruthers, Joshua Basseches, Grace Augustine, and all of the members of the social movement workshop at Northwestern University and the members of the disability section of the Society for the Study of Social Problems for their careful review on previous iterations of this work. Thank you also for the anonymous reviewers of Law & Social Inquiry for their comments to shape this version of the article.

Footnotes

References

Hide All
Barnay, Thomas, Duguet, Emmanuel, Le Clainche, Christine, and Videau, Yann. 2016. An Evaluation of the 1987 French Disabled Workers Act: Better Paying than Hiring. St. Louis, MO: Federal Reserve Bank of St Louis.
Barnes, Colin, Oliver, Michael, and Barton, Len. 2002. Disability Studies Today. Cambridge, UK: Polity Press.
Barral, Catherine. 2008. “Reconfiguration Internationale du Handicap et Loi du 11 Février 2005.La lettre de l’enfance et de l’adolescence 73: 95102. https://doi.org/10.3917/lett.073.0095.
Baudot, Pierre-Yves. 2018. “Layering Rights: The Case of Disability Policies in France (2006–2016).Social Policy and Society 17, no. 1: 117–31. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1474746417000392.
Baudot, Pierre-Yves, Borelle, Céline, and Revillard, Anne. 2013. “Politiques du Handicap.Terrains & Travaux 23, no. 2: 515.
Berrey, Ellen. 2015. The Enigma of Diversity. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Bertrand, Louis, Caradec, Vincent, and Eideliman, Jean-Sébastien. 2014. “Devenir Travailleur Handicapé. Enjeux Individuels, Frontières Institutionnelles.Sociologie 5, no. 2: 121–38.
Bertrand, Marianne, and Mullainathan, Sendhil. 2004. “Are Emily and Greg More Employable Than Lakisha and Jamal: A Field Experiment on Labor Market Discrimination.American Economic Review 94, no. 4: 9911013.
Blatge, Marion. 2010. “Le Handicap : Objet de Négociation Collective ou de Communication ?La Revue de l’Ires 67, no. 4: 123–36.
Buchter, Lisa. 2019. ‘Companies Can Do Better than the Law’: Securing Rights for Minorities as an Insider Activist in French Corporations. In Legal Intermediation: A Processual Approach to Law and Economic Activity, by Sebastian Billows, Lisa Buchter, and Jérôme Pélisse, 81: 11–44. Studies in Law, Politics, and Society. Bingley, England: Emerald Publishing Limited.
Bureau, Marie-Christine, and Rist, Barbara. 2012. “Les Figures de la Participation des Usagers dans les Commission d’Attribution des Droits aux Personnes Handicapées.ERES, Vie Sociale 4: 8196.
Buton, François, 2009. L’Administration des Faveurs : L’État, les Sourds et les Aveugles (1789–1885). Rennes : Presses Universitaires de Rennes.
Cahill, Spencer E., and Eggleston, Robin. 1994. “Managing Emotions in Public: The Case of Wheelchair Users.Social Psychology Quarterly 57, no. 4: 300–12. https://doi.org/10.2307/2787157.
Calvès, Gwénaële. 2016. La Discrimination Positive. Que sais-je ? 4th ed. Paris: Presses Universitaires de France.
Carbado, Devon W. 2013. “Intraracial Diversity.UCLA Law Review 60, no. 5: 1130–83.
Carbado, Devon W., and Gulati, Mitu. 2013. Acting White?: Rethinking Race in “Post-Racial” America. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Chrisman, Wendy L. 2011. “A Reflection on Inspiration: A Recuperative Call for Emotion in Disability Studies.Journal of Literary and Cultural Disability Studies 5, no. 2: 173–84.
Collins, Erika C. 2012. “Global Diversity Initiatives.International Lawyer 46, no. 4: 9871006.
Cortéséro, Régis, Kerbourc’h, Sylvain, Mélo, David, and Poli, Alexandra. 2013. “Recruteurs Sous Tensions. Discrimination et Diversité au Prisme de Registres Argumentaires Enchevêtrés.Sociologie Du Travail 55, no. 4: 431543.
Dalle-Nazébi, Sophie, and Kerbourc’h, Sylvain. 2013. “L’invisibilité du ‘Travail en plus’ de Salariés Sourds.Terrains & Travaux 23, no. 2: 159–77.
Daly, Kerry. 2007. Qualitative Methods for Family Studies and Human Development. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
DARES (Direction de l’Animation de la Recherche, des Études et des Statistiques). 2014. “L’obligation d’emploi des Travailleurs Handicapés en 2012.” Ministère du Travail 83: 8p. http://dares.travail-emploi.gouv.fr/dares-etudes-et-statistiques/etudes-et-syntheses/dares-analyses-dares-indicateurs-dares-resultats/article/l-obligation-d-emploi-des-travailleurs-handicapes-en-2012.
DARES (Direction de l’Animation de la Recherche, des Études et des Statistiques). 2018. “L’obligation d’emploi des Travailleurs Handicapés en 2016, Légère Hausse du Taux d’emploi Direct en Équivalent Temps Plein.” Dares Résultats 51: 8p.
Défenseur des Droits. 2012. “Accès à l’Emploi des Personnes Handicapées dans le Secteur Privé.” https://www.defenseurdesdroits.fr/sites/default/files/atoms/files/151016_-_qr_maquette_2012-09-06.pdf.
Dobbin, Frank. 2009. Inventing Equal Opportunity. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Dobbin, Frank, and Kalev, Alexandra. 2013. The Origins and Effects of Corporate Diversity Programs. Oxford: Oxford University Press. https://dash.harvard.edu/handle/1/32970016.
Dobbin, Frank, Kim, Soohan, and Kalev, Alexandra. 2012. “Progressive Corporations at Work: The Case of Diversity Programs.” https://dash.harvard.edu/handle/1/11315416.
Dobbin, Frank, Schrage, Daniel, and Kalev, Alexandra. 2015. “Rage against the Iron Cage.American Sociological Review 80, no. 5: 1014–44.
Dobbin, Frank, and Sutton, John R.. 1998. “The Strength of a Weak State: The Rights Revolution and the Rise of Human Resources Management Divisions 1.American Journal of Sociology 104, no. 2: 441–76.
Dujin, Anne, and Maresca, Bruno. 2010. “La Question du Maintien dans l’Emploi après une Longue Maladie dans les Entreprises Françaises” (The issue of job retention after a long illness in the French companies). La Revue de l’Ires 67: 3958.
Edelman, Lauren B. 1991. Employers’ Handling of Discrimination Complaints: The Transformation of Rights in the Workplace. University of Wisconsin Madison Disputes Processing Research Program Working Papers no. 10-8. Madison: Institute for Legal Studies, University of Wisconsin Madison.
Edelman, Lauren B. 1992. “Legal Ambiguity and Symbolic Structures: Organizational Mediation of Civil Rights Law.American Journal of Sociology 97, no. 6: 1531–76.
Edelman, Lauren B. 2016. Working Law: Courts, Corporations, and Symbolic Civil Rights. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Edelman, Lauren B., Krieger, Linda H., Eliason, Scott R., Albiston, Catherine R., and Mellema, Virginia. 2011. “When Organizations Rule: Judicial Deference to Institutionalized Employment Structures.American Journal of Sociology 117, no. 3: 888954. https://doi.org/10.1086/661984.
Edelman, Lauren B., Leachman, Gwendolyn, and McAdam, Doug. 2010. “On Law, Organizations, and Social Movements.Annual Review of Law and Social Science 6: 653–85.
Edelman, Lauren B., Fuller, Sally Riggs, and Mara‐Drita, Iona. 2001. “Diversity Rhetoric and the Managerialization of Law.American Journal of Sociology 106, no. 6: 15891641. https://doi.org/10.1086/321303.
Engel, David M., and Munger, Frank W.. 2007. “Narrative, Disability, and Identity.Narrative 15, no. 1: 8594.
Everaere, Christophe. 2010. “Insertion et Maintien dans l’Emploi des Personnes Handicapées : Le Cas des Grandes Surfaces de Bricolage.Revue Française de Gestion 36, no. 202: 1131.
Eymard-Duvernay, François, and Marchal, Emmanuelle. 2000. “Qui Calcule Trop Finit par Déraisonner : Les Experts du Marché du Travail.Sociologie du Travail 42, no. 3: 411–32. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0038-0296(00)01088-8.
Ewick, Patricia, and Silbey, Susan. 1998. The Commonplace of Law: Stories from Everyday Life. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Fiedler, Leslie. 1982. “Pity and Fear: Images of the Disabled in Literature and the Popular Arts.Salmagundi 57: 5769.
Fishkin, Joseph. 2014. Bottlenecks: A New Theory of Equal Opportunity. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Gardien, Ève. 2010. “L’Émergence en France des Mouvements de Pairs-représentants.Journal des anthropologues. Association française des anthropologues 122–23: 87114. https://doi.org/10.4000/jda.5369.
Goffman, Erving. 1959. The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life. Rev. ed. New York: Anchor Books/Doubleday.
Heyer, Katharina. 2005. “Rights or Quotas? The ADA as a Model for Disability Rights.” In Handbook of Employment Discrimination Research, Laura, B. Nielsen and Robert, L. Nelson (eds.), 237–57. Amsterdam: Springer.
Heyer, Katharina 2015. Rights Enabled: The Disability Revolution, from the US, to Germany and Japan, to the United Nations. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press. https://doi.org/10.3998/mpub.5946811.
Kalev, Alexandra, and Dobbin, Frank. 2006. “Enforcement of Civil Rights Law in Private Workplaces: The Effects of Compliance Reviews and Lawsuits over Time.Law and Social Inquiry 31, no. 4: 855903.
Karpik, Lucien. 2007. L’économie Des Singularités : Bibliothèque des Sciences Humaines. Paris: Gallimard.
Loseke, Donileen R. 2007. “The Study of Identity as Cultural, Institutional, Organizational, and Personal Narratives: Theoretical and Empirical Integrations.Sociological Quarterly 48, no. 4: 661–88.
Maggi-Germain, Nicole. 2010. “Les Accords ‘Libératoires’ sur l’Emploi des Travailleurs Handicapés.La Revue de l’Ires 67, no. 4: 99121.
Manago, Bianca, Davis, Jenny L., and Goar, Carla. 2017. “Discourse in Action: Parents’ Use of Medical and Social Models to Resist Disability Stigma.Social Science and Medicine 184: 169–77. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.socscimed.2017.05.015.
Måseide, Per, and Grøttland, Håvar. 2015. “Enacting Blind Spaces and Spatialities: A Sociological Study of Blindness Related to Space, Environment and Interaction.Symbolic Interaction 38, no. 4: 594610. https://doi.org/10.1002/symb.194.
Monchatre, Sylvie. 2014. “Petits Arrangements avec la Diversité. Le Recrutement entre Marché et Mobilisation Salariale.Revue française de sociologie 55, no. 1: 4172.
Munnell, Alicia H., Browne, Lynn E., and Mceneaney, James. 1996. “Mortgage Lending in Boston: Interpreting HMDA Data.American Economic Review 86, no. 1: 2553.
Oliver, Michael. 1990. The Politics of Disablement: A Sociological Approach. New York: St. Martin’s Press.
Oliver, Michael 2013. “The Social Model of Disability: Thirty Years On.Disability and Society 28, no. 7: 1024–26. https://doi.org/10.1080/09687599.2013.818773.
Ovichegan, Samson K. 2015. Faces of Discrimination in Higher Education in India: Quota Policy, Social Justice and the Dalits. London: Routledge.
Pager, Devah, and Shepherd, Hana. 2008. “The Sociology of Discrimination: Racial Discrimination in Employment, Housing, Credit, and Consumer Markets.Annual Review of Sociolgy 34: 181209.
Pedriana, Nicholas, and Stryker, Robin. 2004. “The Strength of a Weak Agency: Enforcement of Title VII of the 1964 Civil Rights Act and the Expansion of State Capacity, 1965–1971.American Journal of Sociology 110, no. 3: 709–60.
Polletta, Francesca. 1999. “‘Free Spaces’ in Collective Action.Theory and Society 28, no. 1: 138.
Rieucau, Géraldine, and Marchal, Emmanuelle. 2010. Le Recrutement. Paris : Éditions La Découverte.
Rivera, Lauren A. 2012a. “Diversity within Reach: Recruitment versus Hiring in Elite Firms.Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 639: 7190.
Rivera, Lauren A. 2012b. “Hiring as Cultural Matching: The Case of Elite Professional Service Firms.American Sociological Review 77, no. 6: 9991022.
Rivera, Lauren A. 2015. “Go with Your Gut: Emotion and Evaluation in Job Interviews.American Journal of Sociology 120, no. 5: 1339–89.
Rivera, Lauren A., and Tilcsik, András. 2016. “Class Advantage, Commitment Penalty.American Sociological Review 81, no. 6: 10971131.
Rodríguez, Cristina. 2008. “Against Individualized Consideration.Faculty Scholarship Series, January. https://digitalcommons.law.yale.edu/fss_papers/4339.
Romien, P. 2005. “À l’Origine de la Réinsertion Professionnelle des Personnes Handicapées : La Prise en Charge des Invalides de Guerre.Revue Française des Affaires Sociales 2: 229–47.
Royster, Deirdre. 2009. Race and the Invisible Hand. Berkeley: University of California Press. http://www.ucpress.edu/ebook.php?isbn=9780520937376.
Santos, Maria Helena, Amâncio, Lígia, and Alves, Hélder. 2013. “Gender and Politics: The Relevance of Gender on Judgements about the Merit of Candidates and the Fairness of Quotas.Portuguese Journal of Social Science 12, no. 2: 133–49. https://doi.org/10.1386/pjss.12.2.133_1.
Sarfati, François. 2014. “L’alternance au risque de la sur-sélectivité.Revue Française de Socio-Économie 14, no. 2: 7192.
Segon, Michaël, and Le Roux, Nathalie. 2013. “Parcours de Formation et d’Accès à l’emploi Des Anciens Étudiants Handicapés, Recours aux Dispositifs et Dynamiques Identitaires.Presse de Sciences Po, Agora Débat/Jeunesses 65, no. 3 : 7792.
Sénac, Réjane. 2012. L’Invention de La Diversité. Le Lien Social. Paris: Presses universitaires de France.
Shakespeare, Tom. 2014. Disability Rights and Wrongs Revisited. 2nd ed. London: Routledge.
Stryker, Robin. 2001. “Disparate Impact and the Quota Debates: Law, Labor Market Sociology, and Equal Employment Policies.Sociological Quarterly 42, no. 1: 1346. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1533-8525.2000.tb02027.x.
Sunstein, Cass. 1991. “Why Markets Don’t Stop Discrimination.Social Philosophy and Policy 8, no. 2: 2237.
Décret relatif à la reconnaissance de la lourdeur du handicap (Decree related to the acknowledgement of the heaviness of disabilities), no. 2012-896, July 19th, 2012.
Décret relatif à la reconnaissance de la lourdeur du handicap (Decree related to the acknowledgement of the heaviness of disabilities), no 2016-100, February 2nd, 2016.
Loi sur le Reclassement des Travailleurs Handicapés (law on the reclassifying of disabledworkers), no. 57-1223, November 23rd, 1957.
Loi d’Orientation en Faveur des Personnes Handicapées (orientation law in favor of people with disabilities), no. 75-534, June 30th, 1975
Loi en faveur de l’emploi des travailleurs handicapés (law in favor of the employment of disabled workers), no. 87-517July 10th, 1987
Loi pour l’Égalité des Droits et des Chances, la Participation et la Citoyenneté des Personnes Handicapées (law for the equality of rights and chances, the participation and the citizenship of people with disabilities), no. 2005-102, February 11th, 2005
Loi de finances pour 2011 (finance law for 2011), no 2010-1657, December 29th, 2010.
Social Security Code, July 1, 2018

Tell Me Your Story: How Recruitment Practices Implementing Affirmative Action Laws May Undermine the Laws’ Goals

  • Lisa Buchter

Metrics

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed