Skip to main content

Conflict and complementarity of paleontological and molecular chronologies?

  • Ofir Katz (a1)

Evolutionary history studies depend on having reliable chronologies of macroevolutionary processes. Construction of such chronologies often yields discrepancies between paleontological and molecular dates, which are sometimes viewed as conflicting. Nevertheless, each macroevolutionary process is composed of two main phases: emergence of a trait or clade and success of that trait or clade, which differ in mechanisms, drivers, and types of evidence. Moreover, emergence may be observed as gene divergence (which may be trait-coding or trait-unrelated genes), trait emergence, and clade emergence; whereas success can be observed as increase in abundance, diffusion, and/or diversity or as overall persistence over geologic time. Therefore, to fully and correctly understand any macroevolutionary process, it is of paramount importance to understand what event each date refers to, and how dates of various events and their integration reveal the complexity of macroevolutionary processes. I demonstrate this through three examples: the chronological gap between oxygenic photosynthesis emergence and the Great Oxidation Event, the chronological gap between paleontological and molecular dates of angiosperm emergence, and the evolution of plant silicon accumulation.

Hide All
Bapst, D. W., Wright, A. M., Matzke, N. J., and Lloyd, G. T.. 2016. Typology, divergence dates, and macroevolutionary inferences vary between different tip-dating approaches applied to fossil theropods (Dinosauria). Biology Letters 12:20160237.
Baron, M. G., Norman, D. B., and Barrett, P. M.. 2017. A new hypothesis of dinosaur relationships and early dinosaur evolution. Nature 543:501507.
Benton, M. J. 2010. The origins of modern biodiversity on land. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London B 365:36673679.
Berendse, F., and Scheffer, M.. 2009. The angiosperm radiation revisited, an ecological explanation to Darwin's “abominable mystery.” Ecology Letters 12:865872.
Berman-Frank, I., Lundgern, P., and Falkowski, P.. 2003. Nitrogen fixation and photosynthetic oxygen evolution in cyanobacteria. Research in Microbiology 154:157164.
Bouchenak-Khelldai, Y., Verbooom, G. A., Savolainen, V., and Hodjinson, T. R.. 2010. Biogeography of the grasses (Poaceae): a phylogenetic approach to reveal evolutionary history in geographical space and geological time. Botanical Journal of the Linnean Society 162:543557.
Bowe, L. M., Coat, G., and dePamphilis, C. W.. 2000. Phylogeny of seed plants based on all three genomic compartments: extant gymnosperms are monophyletic and Gnetales’ closest relatives are conifers. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 97:40924097.
Brower, A. V. Z., and DeSalle, R.. 1998. Patterns of mitochondrial versus nuclear DNA sequence divergence among nymphalid butterflies: the utility of wingless as a source of characters for phylogenetic inference. Insect Molecular Biology 7:7382.
Buick, R. 2008. When did oxygenic photosynthesis evolve? Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London B 363:27312734.
Butlin, R., Debelle, A., Kerth, C., Snook, R. R., Beukeboom, L. W., Castillo Cajas, R. F., Diao, W., Maan, M. E., Paolucci, S., Weissing, F. J., Van de Zande, L., Hoikkala, A., Geuverink, E., Jennings, J., Kankare, M., Knott, K. E., Tyukmaeva, V. I., Zoumadakis, C., Ritchie, M. G., Barker, D., Immonen, E., Kirkpatrick, M., Noor, M., Macias, C., Schmitt, T., and Schilthuizen, M.. 2012. What do we need to know about speciation? Trends in Ecology and Evolution 27:2739.
Crampton, J. S., Beu, A. G., Cooper, R. A., Jones, C. M., Marshall, B., and Maxwell, P. A.. 2003. Estimating the rock volume bias in paleobiodiversity studies. Science 310:358360.
Crepet, W. L., Nixon, K. C., and Gandolfo, M. A.. 2004. Fossil evidence and phylogeny: the age of major angiosperm clades based on mesofossil and macrofossil evidence from Cretaceous deposits. American Journal of Botany 91:16661682.
Davies, T. J., Smith, G. F., Bellstedt, D. U., Boatwright, J. S., Bytebier, B., Cowling, R. M., Forest, F., Harmon, L. J., Muasya, A. M., Schrire, B. D., Steenkamp, Y., van der Bank, M., and Savolainen, V.. 2011. Extinction risk and diversification are linked in plant biodiversity hotspots. PLoS Biology 9:e1000620.
De Baets, K., Antonelli, A., and Donoghue, P. C. J.. 2016. Tectonic blocks and molecular clocks. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London B 371:20160098.
Dominguez Lozano, F., and Schwartz, M. W.. 2005. Patterns of rarity and taxonomic group size in plants. Biological Conservation 126:146154.
Donoghue, M. J. 2005. Key innovations, convergence, and success: macroevolutionary lessons from plant phylogeny. Paleobiology 31:7793.
Edwards, S. V., and Beerli, P.. 2000. Gene divergence, population divergence, and the variance in coalescence time in phylogeographic studies. Evolution 54:18391854.
Erwin, D. H., Laflamme, M., Tweedt, S. M., Sperling, E. A., Pisani, D., and Peterson, K. J.. 2011. The Cambrian conundrum: early divergence and later ecological success in the early history of animals. Science 334:10911097.
Forest, F. 2009. Calibrating the tree of life: fossils, molecules and evolutionary timescales. Annals of Botany 104:789794.
Gandolfo, M. A., Nixon, K. C., and Crepet, W. L.. 2008. Selection of fossils for calibration of molecular dating models. Annals of the Missouri Botanical Garden 95:3442.
Gheerbrandt, E., and Rage, J. C.. 2006. Paleobiogeography of Africa: how distinct from Gondwana and Laurasia? Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 241:224246.
Godsoe, W. 2010. I can't define the niche but I know it when I see it: a formal link between statistical theory and the ecological niche. Oikos 119:5360.
Goldblatt, C., Lenton, T. M., and Watson, A. J.. 2006. Bistability of atmospheric oxygen and the Great Oxidation. Nature 443:683686.
Goswami, A., Milne, N., and Wroe, S.. 2010. Biting through constraints: cranial morphology, disparity and convergence across living and fossil carnivorous mammals. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B. doi:10.1098/rspb.2010.2031.
Graur, D., and Martin, W.. 2004. Reading the entrails of chickens: molecular timescales of evolution and the illusion of precision. Trends in Genetics 20:8086.
Hansen, T. F., and Orzack, S. H.. 2005. Assessing current adaptation and phylogenetic inertia as explanations of trait evolution: the need for controlled comparisons. Evolution 59:20632072.
Harnik, P. G. 2011. Direct and indirect refracts of biological factors on extinction risk in fossil bivalves. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 108:1359413599.
Harnik, P. G., Simpson, C., and Payne, J. L.. 2012. Long-term differences in extinction risk among the seven forms of rarity. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B 279:49694976.
Heard, S. B., and Hauser, D. L.. 1995. Key evolutionary innovations and their ecological mechanisms. Historical Biology 10:151173.
Heckman, D. S., Geiser, D. M., Eidell, B. R., Stauffer, R. L., Kardos, N. L., and Hedges, S. B.. 2001. Molecular evidence for the early colonization of land by fungi and plants. Science 293:11291133.
Hedges, S. B., and Kumar, S.. 2004. Precision of molecular time estimates. Trends in Genetics 20:242247.
Herendeen, P. S., Friis, E. M., Pedersen, K. R., and Crane, P. R.. 2017. Palaeobotanical redux: revisiting the age of the angiosperms. Nature Plants 3:17015.
Ho, S. Y. W., and Phillips, M. J.. 2009. Accounting for calibration uncertainty in phylogenetic estimation of evolutionary divergence times. Systematic Biology 58:367380.
Hohmann-Marriott, M. F., and Blankenship, R. E.. 2011. Evolution of photosynthesis. Annual Review of Plant Biology 62:515548.
Hug, L. A., and Roger, A. J.. 2007. The impacts of fossils and taxon sampling on ancient molecular dating analyses. Molecular Biology and Evolution 24:18891897.
Hughes, N. C., and Chapman, R. E.. 2001. Morphometry and phylogeny in the resolution of paleobiological problems—unlocking the evolutionary significance of an assemblage of Silurian trilobites. Pp. 2954 in Adrian, J. M., Edgecomb, G. D., and Lieberman, B. S., eds. Fossils, phylogeny, and form. Topics in Geobiology, Vol. 19. Springer, New York.
Hunter, J. P. 1998. Key innovations and the ecology of macroevolution. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 13:3136.
Jablonski, D. 2008a. Biotic interactions and macroevolution: extensions and mismatches across scales and level. Evolution 62:715739.
Jablonski, D. 2008b. Extinction and the spatial dynamics of biodiversity. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 105(Suppl. 1):1152811535.
Katz, O. 2014. Beyond grasses: the potential benefits of studying silicon accumulation in non-grass species. Frontiers in Plant Sciences 5:376.
Katz, O. 2015. Silica phytoliths in angiosperms: phylogeny and early evolutionary history. New Phytologist 208:642646.
Katz, O. 2018. Extending the scope of Darwin's “abominable mystery”: integrative approaches to understanding angiosperm origins and species richness. Annals of Botany 121:18.
Kodandaramaiah, U. 2011. Tectonic calibrations in molecular dating. Current Zoology 57:116124.
Kolbe, S. E., Lockwood, R., and Hunt, G.. 2011. Does morphological variation buffer against extinction? A test using veneroid bivalves from the Plio-Pleistocene of Florida. Paleobiology 37:355368.
Krassilov, V., and Silantieva, N.. 2005. Plant evolution in the Late Cretaceous (Turonian) of the southern Negev, Israel. Israel Journal of Plant Sciences 53:5564.
Lamsdell, J. C. 2015. Horseshoe crab phylogeny and independent colonizations of fresh water: ecological invasion as a driver for morphological innovation. Palaeontology 59:181194.
Li, Q., Gao, K. Q., Vinther, J., Shawkey, M. D., Clarke, J. A., D'Alba, L., Meng, Q., Briggs, D. E. G., and Prum, R. O.. 2010. Plumage color patterns of an extinct dinosaur. Science 327:13691372.
Lockwood, R. 2003. Abundance not linked to survival across the end-Cretaceous mass extinction: patterns in North American bivalves. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 100:24782482.
Lyons, T. W., Reinhard, C. T., and Planavsky, N. J.. 2014. The rise of oxygen in Earth's early ocean and atmosphere. Nature 506:307315.
Ma, J. F., and Yamaji, N.. 2015. A cooperative system of silicon transport in plants. Trends in Plant Science 20:435442.
Magallon, S. A. 2004. Dating lineages: molecular and paleontological approaches to the temporal framework of clades. International Journal of Plant Sciences 165:S7S21.
Magallon, S., and Castillo, A.. 2009. Angiosperm diversification through time. American Journal of Botany 96:349365.
Magallon, S., Gomez-Acevedo, S., Sanchez-Reyes, L. L., and Hernandez-Hernandez, T.. 2015. A metacalibrated time-tree documents the early rise of flowering plants phylogenetic diversity. New Phytologist 207:437453.
Marjanovic, D., and Laurin, M.. 2007. Fossils, molecules, divergence times, and the origins of lissamphibians. Systematic Biology 56:369388.
McKay, T. F. C. 2001. The genetic architecture of quantitative traits. Annual Review of Genetics 35:303339.
McKinney, M. L. 1997. Extinction vulnerability and selectivity: combining ecological and paleontological views. Annual Reviews of Ecology and Systematics 28:495516.
Nichols, R. 2001. Gene trees and species trees are not the same. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 16:358364.
Parham, J. F., Donoghue, P. C. J., Bell, C. J., Calway, T. D., Head, J. J., Holroyd, P. A., Inoue, J. G., Irmis, R. B., Joyce, W. G., Tsepka, D.T., Patane, J. S. L., Smith, N. D., Tarver, J. E., van Tuinen, M., Yang, Z., Angielczyk, K. D., Greenwood, J. M., Hipsley, C. A., Jacobs, L., Makovicky, P. J., Müller, J., Smith, K. T., Theodor, J. M., Warnock, R. C. M., and Benton, M. J.. 2012. Best practices for justifying fossil calibrations. Systematic Biology 61:346359.
Payne, J. L., and Finnegan, S.. 2007. The effect of geographic range on extinction risk during background and mass extinction. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 104:1050610511.
Pennell, M. W., Harmon, L. J., and Uyeda, J. C.. 2014. Is there room for punctuated equilibrium in macroevolution? Trends in Ecology and Evolution 29:2332.
Pigliucci, M. 2005. Evolution of phenotypic plasticity: where are we going now? Trends in Ecology and Evolution 20:481486.
Pigliucci, M. 2008. What, if any, is an evolutionary novelty? Philosophy of Science 75:887898.
Pigliucci, M., Murren, C. J., and Schlichting, C. D.. 2006. Phenotypic plasticity and evolution by genetic assimilation. Journal of Experimental Biology 209:23622367.
Planavsky, N. J., Asael, D., Hofmann, A., Reinhard, C. T., Lalonde, S. V., Knudsen, A., Wang, X., Ossa Ossa, F., Pecoits, E., Smith, A. J. B., Beukes, N. J., Bekker, A., Johnson, T. M., Konhauser, K. O., Lyons, T. W., and Rouxel, O. J.. 2014. Evidence for oxygenic photosynthesis half a billion years before the Great Oxidation Event. Nature Geosciences 7:283286.
Poulin, E., Palma, A. T., and Feral, J. P.. 2002. Evolutionary versus ecological success in Antarctic benthic invertebrates. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 17:218222.
Prieto-Marquez, A. 2010. Global historical biogeography of hadrosaurid dinosaurs. Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society 159:503525.
Pulquerio, M. J. F., and Nichols, R. A.. 2007. Dates from the molecular clock: how wrong can we be? Trends in Ecology and Evolution 22:180184.
Purvis, A., Agapow, P. M., Gittleman, J. L., and Mace, G. M.. 2000. Nonrandom extinction and the loss of evolutionary history. Science 288:328330.
Pyron, A. A. 2011. Divergence time estimation using fossils as terminal taxa and the origins of lissamphibia. Systematic Biology 60:466481.
Qiu, Y. L., Lee, J., Bernasconi-Quadroni, F., Soltis, D. E., Soltis, P. S., Zanis, M., Zimmer, E. A., Chen, Z., Savolainen, V., and Chase, M. W.. 1999. The earliest angiosperms: evidence from mitochondrial, plastid and nuclear genomes. Nature 402:404407.
Quental, T. B., and Marshall, C. R.. 2010. Diversity dynamics: molecular phylogenies need the fossil record. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 25:434441.
Rannala, B., and Yang, Z.. 2003. Bayes estimation of species divergence times and ancestral population sizes using DNA sequences from multiple loci. Genetics 164:16451656.
Rasmussen, B., Fletcher, I. R., Brocks, J. J., and Kilburn, M. R.. 2008. Reassessing the first appearance of eukaryotes and cyanobacteria. Nature 455:11011104.
Rohde, R. A., and Muller, R. A.. 2005. Cycles in fossil diversity. Nature 434:208210.
Rodriguez-Trelles, F., Tarrio, R., and Ayala, J. F.. 2002. A methodological bias toward overestimation of molecular evolutionary time scales. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 99:81128115.
Roth-Nebelsick, A., Grimm, G., Mosburger, V., Hass, H., and Kerp, H.. 2000. Morphometric analysis of Rhynia and Asteroxylon: testing functional aspects of early land plant evolution. Paleobiology 26:405418.
Rudkin, D. M., and Young, G. A.. 2009. Horseshoe crabs—an ancient ancestry revealed. Pp. 2544 in Tanacredi, J., Botton, M., and Smith, D., eds. Biology and conservation of horseshoe crabs. Springer, New York.
Russell, G. J., Brooks, T. M., McKinney, M. M., and Anderson, C. G.. 2008. Present and future taxonomic selectivity in bird and mammal extinctions. Conservation Biology 12:13651376.
Rutschmann, F. 2006. Molecular dating of phylogenetic trees: a brief review of current methods that estimate divergence times. Diversity and Distributions 12:3548.
Rutschmann, F., Eriksson, T., Schönenberger, J., and Conti, E.. 2004. Did Crypteroniaceae really disperse out of India? Molecular dating evidence from rbcL, ndhF, and rpl16 intron sequences. International Journal of Plant Sciences 165:S69S83.
Sanderson, M. J. 2015. Back to the past: a new take on the timing of flowering plant diversification. New Phytologist 207:257259.
Sansom, R. S. 2015. Bias and sensitivity in the placement of fossil taxa resulting from interpretations of missing data. Systematic Biology 64:256266.
Sansom, R. S., Gabbott, S. E., and Purnell, M. A.. 2010. Non-random decay of chordate characters causes bias in fossil interpretation. Nature 463:797800.
Schiffels, S., and Durbin, R.. 2014. Inferring human population size and separation history from multiple genome sequences. Nature Genetics 46:919925.
Schirrmeister, B. E., Gugger, M., and Donoghue, P. J. C.. 2015. Cyanobacteria and the Great Oxidation Event: evidence from genes and fossils. Palaeontology 58:769785.
Schluter, D. 2009. Evidence for ecological speciation and its alternatives. Science 323:737741.
Schopf, J. W. 2012. The fossil record of cyanobacteria. Pp. 1536 in Whitton, B. A., ed. Ecology of cyanobacteria II: their diversity in space and time. Springer, Berlin.
Sen, S. 2013. Dispersal of African mammals in Eurasia during the Cenozoic: ways and whys. Geobios 46:159172.
Shaw, K. L. 2002. Conflict between nuclear and mitochondrial DNA phylogenies of a recent species radiation: what mtDNA reveals and conceals about modes of speciation in Hawaiian crickets. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 99:1612216127.
Small, R. L., Cronn, R. C., and Wendel, J. F.. 2004. Use of nuclear genes for phylogeny reconstruction in plants. Australian Systematic Botany 17:145170.
Sole-Cava, A. M., and Wörheide, G.. 2007. The perils and merits (or the good, the bad and the ugly) of DNA barcoding of sponges—a controversial discussion. Pp. 603612 in Custodio, M. R., Lobo-Hajdu, G., Hajdu, E., and Muricy, G., eds. Porifera research: biodiversity, innovation and sustainability. Museu Nacional, Rio de Janeiro.
Soltis, D. E., and Soltis, P. S.. 1998. Choosing an approach and an appropriate gene for phylogenetic analysis. Pp. 142 in Soltis, D. E., Soltis, P. S., and Doyle, J. J., eds. Molecular systematics of plants II: DNA sequencing. Springer, New York.
Strömberg, C. A. E., Di Stilio, V. S., and Song, Z.. 2016. Functions of phytoliths in vascular plants: an evolutionary perspective. Functional Ecology 30:12861297.
Struck, T. H., Feder, J. L., Bendiksby, M., Birkeland, S., Cerca, J., Gusarov, V. I., Kistenich, S., Larsson, K. H., Liow, L. H., Nowak, M. D., Stedje, B., Bachmann, L., and Dimitrov, D.. 2018. Finding evolutionary processes hidden in cryptic species. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 33:153163.
Trembath-Reichert, E., Wilson, J. P., McGlynn, S. E., and Fischer, W. W.. 2015. Four hundred million years of silica biomineralization in land plants. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 112:54495454.
Wacey, D. 2010. Stromatolites in the ~3400 Ma Strelley Pool Formation, Western Australia: examining biogenicity from the macro- to the nano-scale. Astrobiology 10:381395.
Wall, J. D. 2003. Estimating ancestral population sizes and divergence times. Genetics 163:395404.
Whitman, D. W., and Agrawal, A. A.. 2009. What is phenotypic plasticity and why is it important? Pp. 163 in Whitman, D. W., and Ananthakrishnan, T. N., eds. Phenotypic plasticity of insects: mechanisms and consequences. CRC Press, Boca Raton, Fla.
Wiens, J. J. 2004. Speciation and ecology revisited: phylogenetic niche conservatism and the origin of species. Evolution 58:193197.
Wiens, J. J., and Donoghue, M. J.. 2004. Historical biogeography, ecology and species richness. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 19:639644.
Wignall, P. B., and Benton, M. J.. 1999. Lazarus taxa and fossil abundance at times of biotic crisis. Journal of the Geological Society 156:453456.
Wilson, E. O. 1987. Causes of ecological success: the case of the ants. Journal of Animal Ecology 56:19.
Woodward, S. R., Weyand, N. J., and Bunnell, M.. 1994. DNA sequences from Cretaceous period bone fragments. Science 226:12291232.
Xiong, J., Fischer, W. M., Inoue, K., Nakahara, M., and Bauer, C. E.. 2000. Early evolution of photosynthesis. Science 289:17241730.
Zavada, M. S. 2007. The identification of fossil angiosperm pollen and its bearing on the time and place of the origin of angiosperms. Plant Systematics and Evolution 263:117134.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

  • ISSN: 0094-8373
  • EISSN: 1938-5331
  • URL: /core/journals/paleobiology
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *


Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed