Skip to main content

Lines of Demarcation: Causation, Design-Based Inference, and Historical Research

  • Matthew A. Kocher and Nuno P. Monteiro

Qualitative historical knowledge is essential for validating natural experiments. Specifically, the validity of a natural experiment depends on the historical processes of treatment assignment and administration, including broader macro-historical dynamics. But if validating a natural experiment requires trust in the ability of qualitative evidence to establish the causal processes through which the data were generated, there is no good reason for natural experiments to be considered epistemically superior to historical research. To the contrary, the epistemic status of natural experiments is on a par with that of the historical research on which their validation depends. They are two modes of social-scientific explanation, each with its own pros and cons; neither is privileged. We illustrate this argument by re-examining an important recent contribution to the literature on violent conflict: Ferwerda and Miller’s 2014 natural experiment estimating the causal effect of the German decision to devolve authority to the Vichy French government on violent resistance during World War II.

Hide All
Alary Eric. 2003. La Ligne de Demarcation (1940–1944). Paris: Perrin.
Alary Eric. 2007. “La Ligne de Démarcation.” Revue d’Histoire du Pays Chatelleraudais 13: 523.
American Society of International Law. 1940. “Armistice between France and Germany.” American Journal of International Law (Supplement: Official Documents) 34(4): 173–78.
André Philippe. 2013. La Résistance confisquée? Les délégués militaires du général de Gaulle de Londres à la Libération. Paris: Éditions Perrin.
Angrist Joshua D. and Pischke Jorn-Steffen. 2010. “The Credibility Revolution in Empirical Economics: How Better Research Design is Taking the Con out of Econometrics.” Journal of Economic Perspectives 24(2): 330.
Böhme Hermann. 1966. Der deutschfranzösische Waffenstillstand im zweiten Weltkrieg. Stuttgart: Deutsche Verlagsanstalt.
Calmon Jean-Henri. 2000. Occupation, Résistance, et Libération dans la Vienne en 30 Questions. La Crèche: Geste Éditions.
Caughey Devin and Sekhon Jasjeet. 2011. “Elections and the Regression Discontinuity Design: Lessons from Close U.S. House Races, 1942–2008.” Political Analysis 19(4): 385408.
Collier David, Brady Henry E., and Seawright Jason. 2004. “Sources of Leverage in Causal Inference.” In Rethinking Social Inquiry: Diverse Tools, Shared Standards, ed. Brady H. and Collier D.. Rowman & Littlefield.
Dunning Thad. 2012. Natural Experiments in the Social Sciences: A Design-Based Approach. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Dunning Thad. 2014. “Improving Process Tracing: The Case of Multi-Method Research.” In Process Tracing: From Metaphor to Analytic Tool, ed. Bennett Andrew and Checkel Jeffrey. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Durand Paul. 1968. La S.N.C.F. pendant la guerre: sa résistance à l’occupant. Paris: Presses Universitaires de France.
Ferwerda Jeremy and Miller Nicholas L.. 2014. “Political Devolution and Resistance to Foreign Rule: A Natural Experiment.” American Political Science Review 108(3): 642–60.
Ferwerda Jeremy and Miller Nicholas L.. 2015. “Rail Lines and Demarcation Lines.” Working paper.
Freedman David A. 1991. “Statistical Models and Shoe Leather.” Sociological Methodology 21: 291313.
Général de la Barre de Nanteuil, ed. 1973–1986. Historique des Unités Combattantes de la Résistance 1940–1944. Vols. 1, 9, 11, 12, 18, 20. Vincennes: Ministère des Armées, Etat-major de l’Armée de Terre, Service Historique.
Gerber Alan S. and Green Donald P.. 2012. Field Experiments: Design, Analysis, and Interpretation. New York: W.W. Norton & Co.
Germany, Auswärtiges Amt. 1961. Archives secretes de la Wilhelmstrasse. Vol. 9, pt. 2. Trans. Tournier Michel. Paris: Éditions Plon.
Gildea Robert. 2002. Marianne in Chains: In Search of the German Occupation, 1940–1945. London: Macmillan.
Gildea Robert. 2015. Fighters in the Shadows: A New History of the French Resistance. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Hyde Susan D. 2007. “The Observer Effect in International Politics: Evidence from a Natural Experiment.” World Politics 60(1): 3763.
Jäckel Eberhard. 1968. La France dans l’Europe de Hitler. Trans. Meunier Denise. Paris: Librairie Arthème Fayard.
Jackson Julian. 2001. France, The Dark Years, 1940–1944. New York: Oxford University Press.
Kedward H. R. 1978. Resistance in Vichy France: A Study of Ideas and Motivation in the Southern Zone 1940–1942. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Kedward H. R. 1985. Occupied France: Collaboration and Resistance 1940–1944. Oxford: Basil Blackwell, Ltd.
Kedward H. R. 1993. In Search of the Maquis: Rural Resistance in Southern France, 1942–1944. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Keele Luke and Titiunik Rocío. 2014. “Geographic Boundaries as Regression Discontinuities.” Political Analysis 23(1): 127–55.
King Gary, Keohane Robert O., and Verba Sidney. 1994. Designing Social Inquiry: Scientific Inference in Qualitative Research. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Kocher Matthew Adam, Lawrence Adria K., and Monteiro Nuno P.. 2013. “The Rabbit in the Hat: Nationalism and Resistance to Foreign Occupation.” Working paper, Yale University.
Lachapelle Georges. 1936. Elections legislatives, 26 avril & mai, 1936: résultats officiels. Paris: Le Temps.
Mahoney James. 2010. “After KKV: The New Methodology of Qualitative Research.” World Politics 62(1): 120–47.
Michel Henri. 1950. Histoire de la Résistance en France (1940–1944). Paris: Presses Universitaires de France.
Overy Richard J. 1973. “Transportation and Rearmament in the Third Reich.” Historical Journal 16(2): 389409.
Paxton Robert O. 2001[1972]. Vichy France: Old Guard and New Order, 1940–1944. New ed. New York: Columbia University Press.
Przeworski Adam. 2007. “Is the Science of Comparative Politics Possible?” In The Oxford Handbook of Comparative Politics, ed. Boix Carles and Stokes Susan. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
République Française, Direction de la Statistique Générale. 1938. Résultats statistique du recensement générale de la population effectué le 8 mars 1936. 3 vols. Paris: Imprimerie Nationale.
Samii Cyrus. 2016. Causal Empiricism in Quantitative Research. Journal of Politics 78(3): 941–55.
Sekhon Jasjeet S. 2009. “Opiates for the Matches: Matching Methods for Causal Inference.” Annual Review of Political Science 12: 487508.
Van Creveld Martin. 1977. Supplying War: Logistics from Wallenstein to Patton. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Veyret Patrick. 2001. Mémoire de la Résistance en Saône-et-Loire: Maquis, Forces Spéciales, et SAS. Châtillon-sur-Chalaronne: Editions La Taillanderie.
Wright Gordon. 1962. “Reflections on the French Resistance (1940–1944).” Political Science Quarterly 77(3): 336–49.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Perspectives on Politics
  • ISSN: 1537-5927
  • EISSN: 1541-0986
  • URL: /core/journals/perspectives-on-politics
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
Type Description Title
Kocher Supplementary Material

Kocher Supplementary Material
Kocher Supplementary Material

 Unknown (506 KB)
506 KB


Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 18
Total number of PDF views: 622 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 1494 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between 28th December 2016 - 23rd February 2018. This data will be updated every 24 hours.