Skip to main content

The Mindsets of Political Compromise

  • Amy Gutmann (a1) and Dennis Thompson (a2)

Political compromise is difficult in American democracy even though no one doubts it is necessary. It is difficult for many reasons, including the recent increase in political polarization that has been widely criticized. We argue that the resistance to compromise cannot be fully appreciated without understanding its source in the democratic process itself, especially as conducted in the U.S. The incursion of campaigning into governing in American democracy—the so called “permanent campaign”—encourages political attitudes and arguments that make compromise more difficult. These constitute what we call the uncompromising mindset, characterized by politicians' standing on principle and mistrusting opponents. This mindset is conducive to campaigning, but not to governing, because it stands in the way of necessary change and thereby biases the democratic process in favor of the status quo. The uncompromising mindset can be kept in check by an opposite cluster of attitudes and arguments—the compromising mindset—that inclines politicians to adapt their principles and respect their opponents. This mindset is more appropriate for governing, because it enables politicians more readily to recognize and act on opportunities for desirable compromise. We explore the dynamics of these mindsets by examining the processes that led to the compromises on tax reform in 1986 and health care reform in 2010.

Hide All
Abramowitz Alan I. 2010. The Disappearing Center: Engaged Citizens, Polarization and American Democracy, New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
Alter Jonathan. 2010. The Promise: President Obama, Year One, New York: Simon & Schuster.
Baker Peter, and Hulse Carl. 2010. “Off Script, Obama and the G.O.P. Vent Politely,” New York Times (January 30): A1.
Benditt Theodore M. 1979. “Compromising Interests and Principles.” In NOMOS XXI: Compromise in Ethics, Law and Politics, eds. Pennock J. Roland and Chapman John W.. New York: New York University Press.
Benjamin Martin. 1990. Splitting the Difference: Compromise and Integrity in Ethics and Politics. Lawrence, KS: University Press of Kansas.
Besson Samantha. 2005. The Morality of Conflict: Reasonable Disagreement and the Law. Oxford and Portland, OR: Hart Publishing.
Birnbaum Jeffrey, and Murray Alan. 1988. Showdown at Gucci Gulch. New York: Vintage.
Blumler Jay G., and Gurevitch Michael. 2001. “‘Americanization’ Reconsidered: U.K.–U.S. Campaign Communications Across Time.” In Mediated Politics, eds. Bennett W. Lance and Entman Robert M.. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Boehner John. 2009. “Taxpayer-Funded Abortion Is Not Health-Care Reform.” National Review Online (July 23). (, accessed September 3, 2010.
Bohman James. 1996. Public Deliberation: Pluralism, Complexity, and Democracy. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Bradley Bill. 2009. “Tax Reform's Lesson for Health Care Reform.” New York Times (August 30): WK9.
Brady David, and Fiorina Morris. 2000. “Congress in the Era of the Permanent Campaign.” In The Permanent Campaign and Its Future, eds. Mann Thomas and Ornstein Norman. Washington, DC: American Enterprise Institute.
Brownstein Ronald. 2007. The Second Civil War: How Extreme Partisanship Has Paralyzed Washington and Polarized America. New York: The Penguin Press.
Bush George H. W. 1988. “Address Accepting the Presidential Nomination at the Republican National Convention in New Orleans, August 18, 1988.” (, accessed September 3, 2010.
Carens Joseph H. 1979. “Compromise in Politics.” In NOMOS XXI: Compromise in Ethics, Law and Politics, eds. Pennock J. Roland and Chapman John W.. New York: New York University Press.
Chong Dennis, and Druckman James N.. 2007. “Framing Theory.” Annual Review of Political Science 10: 103–26.
Cohn Jonathan. 2010. “How They Did It: The Inside Account of Health Care Reform's Triumph.” The New Republic (June 10): 1425.
Conlan Timothy J., Wrightson Margaret T., and Beam David R.. 1989. Taxing Choices: The Politics of Tax Reform. Washington, DC: Congressional Quarterly Press.
DeLay Tom. 2006. Farewell Address, U.S. House of Representatives (June 8). Congressional Quarterly Transcripts,, accessed September 3, 2010.
Demer Lisa. 2009. “Murkowski: Don't Tell Lies about the Health-Care Reform Bill.” Anchorage Daily News (August 11). (, accessed September 3, 2010.
Disch Lisa, Aldrich John H., Carothers Thomas, and Dalton Russell J.. 2009. “Parties, Partisanship, and Democratic Politics.” Review symposium for On the Side of the Angels: An Appreciation of Parties and Partisanship, by Nancy Rosenblum. Perspectives on Politics 7(3): 621629.
Dobel J. Patrick. 1990. Compromise and Political Action. Savage, MD: Rowman and Littlefield.
Druckman James N. 2010. “What's It All About? Framing in Political Science.” In Perspectives on Framing, ed. Keren Gideon. New York: Psychology Press/Taylor & Francis.
Dworkin Ronald. 1986. Law's Empire. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Fiorina Morris P., and Abrams Samuel J.. 2008. “Political Polarization in the American Public.” Annual Review of Political Science 11: 563588.
Fiorina Morris P., Abrams with Samuel J., and Pope Jeremy C.. 2010. Culture War? The Myth of a Polarized America. 3rd ed. New York: Longman.
Gutmann Amy, and Thompson Dennis. 1996. Democracy and Disagreement. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Gutmann Amy, and Thompson Dennis. 2004. Why Deliberative Democracy? Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Hacker Jacob S. 2010. “The Road to Somewhere: Why Health Reform Happened Or Why Political Scientists Who Write about Public Policy Shouldn't Assume They Know How to Shape It.” Perspectives on Politics 8(4): 861876.
Hatch Orrin. 2009. “Statement by Senator Orrin Hatch on the Passing of Senator Ted Kennedy August 26, 2009.” (, accessed September 3, 2010.
Heclo Hugh. 2000. “Campaigning and Governing: A Conspectus.” In The Permanent Campaign and Its Future, eds. Mann Thomas and Ornstein Norman. Washington, DC: American Enterprise Institute.
Ignatieff Michael. 2007. “Getting Iraq Wrong.” New York Times Magazine (August 5). (, accessed September 3, 2010.
Jones Charles O. 1998. Passages to the Presidency: From Campaigning to Governing. Washington, DC: The Brookings Institute Press.
Kuflik Arthur. 1979. “Morality and Compromise.” In NOMOS XXI: Compromise in Ethics, Law and Politics, eds. Pennock J. Roland and Press John W. Chapman. New York University, 3865.
Kuttner Robert. 2000. “Comment: Why Liberals Need Radicals.” American Prospect (May 22). (, accessed September 3, 2010.
Lizza Ryan. 2009. “The Gatekeeper: Rahm Emanuel on the Job.” New Yorker 85 (March 2). (, accessed September 3, 2010.
Mansbridge Jane, Bohman with James, Chambers Simone, Estlund David, Føllesdal Andreas, Fung Archon, Lafont Cristina, Manin Bernard, and Martí José Luis. 2010. “The Place of Self-Interest and the Role of Power in Deliberative Democracy.” Journal of Political Philosophy 18(1): 64100.
Margalit Avishai. 2009. On Compromise and Rotten Compromises. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
May Simon Căbulea. 2005. “Principled Compromise and the Abortion Controversy.” Philosophy & Public Affairs 33(4): 317348.
McCarty Nolan, Poole Keith, and Rosenthal Howard. 2008. Polarized America: The Dance of Ideology and Unequal Riches. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Mill John Stuart. 1977. “On Liberty. In Collected Works of John Stuart Mill.” XVIII: Essays on Politics and Society, ed. Robson J. M.. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
Mouffe Chantelle. 2009. The Democratic Paradox. London: Verso.
Muirhead Russell. 2006. “A Defense of Party Spirit.” Perspectives on Politics 4(4): 713727.
Muirhead Russell. 2009. “Respectable Partisanship.” In The Arts of Rule, eds. Krause S. and McGrail M. A.. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.
Murray Shailagh. 2010. “Republicans urge Democrats to Start All Over on Health Care.” Washington Post (January 31). (, accessed September 3, 2010.
Nyhan Brendan. 2010. “Why the ‘Death Panel’ Myth Wouldn't Die: Misinformation in the Health Care Reform Debate.” The Forum 8(1). (, accessed May 5, 2010.
Organizing for America. 2008. “Obama Speeches.” (, accessed September 3, 2010.
Ornstein Norman J., and Mann Thomas E., eds. 2000. The Permanent Campaign and Its Future. Washington, DC: American Enterprise Institute.
Plasser Fritz, and Plasser Gunder. 2002. Global Political Campaigning. Westport, CT: Praeger.
Richardson Henry. 2002. Democratic Autonomy: Public Reasoning about the Ends of Policy. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Robertson Lori, Henig Jessica, Jackson Brooks, and Bank Justin. 2007. “Clinton vs. Obama: Who's Right on Health Care, Social Security?” (, accessed September 3, 2010.
Rosenblum Nancy. 2008. On the Side of Angels: An Appreciation of Parties and Partisanship. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Seelye Katherine Q. 2009. “Ads Question Opponents' Motives.” New York Times (August 18). (, accessed September 3, 2010.
Smith Ben. 2009. “Health reform foes plan Obama's ‘Waterloo.’” Politico (July 17). (, accessed September 3, 2010.
Staff of The Washington Post. 2010. Landmark: The Inside Story of America's New Health-Care Law and What it Means for Us All. New York: PublicAffairs Books.
Strahan Randall. 1989. “Members' Goals and Coalition-Building Strategies in the US House: The Case of Tax Reform.” Journal of Politics 51(2): 373384.
Thompson Dennis F. 2007. “Mill in Parliament: When Should a Philosopher Compromise?” In J.S. Mill's Political Thought, eds. Urbinati N. and Zakaras A.. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Thompson Leigh, Wang Jiunwen, and Gunia Brian C.. 2010. “Negotiation.” Annual Review of Psychology 61: 491515.
Tilly Charles, and Tarrow Sidney. 2006. Contentious Politics. Boulder, CO: Paradigm Publishers.
Witte John F. 1991. “The Tax Reform Act of 1986: A New Era in Tax Politics?American Politics Research 19(4): 438–57.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Perspectives on Politics
  • ISSN: 1537-5927
  • EISSN: 1541-0986
  • URL: /core/journals/perspectives-on-politics
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *


Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 8
Total number of PDF views: 169 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 535 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 22nd January 2018. This data will be updated every 24 hours.