Skip to main content
×
Home

Demilitarisation and neutralisation of Svalbard: how has the Svalbard regime been able to meet the changing security realities during almost 100 years of existence?

  • Timo Koivurova (a1) and Filip Holiencin (a1)
Abstract
ABSTRACT

Norway will soon celebrate that 100 years ago, the former ‘no-man's land’ of the Svalbard archipelago was placed under its sovereignty. However, this paper focuses on another important and often omitted element also brought about by the 1920 Svalbard Treaty regarding its demilitarisation and neutralisation. We ask how has the Svalbard security regime been able to meet the various challenges it has faced over almost 100 years of existence? Also, given that the treaty was drafted at the beginning of the 20th century, are the security provisions of this regime already obsolete or are they seen still as valid, and more importantly functional against the backdrop of rapidly changing security realities? This paper then goes further and while it uses Svalbard as a case study, it tries to assess the role of demilitarisation and neutralisation in the modern context by trying to infer possible lessons from two similar regimes, which apply to Antarctica and the Åland Islands.

Copyright
References
Hide All
Aarø J.T. 2015. En milepæl i norsk petroleumsvirksomhet [A milestone in the Norwegian petroleum business]. e24.no, 20 January 2015. URL: http://e24.no/energi/regjeringen-utlyser-23-konsesjonsrunde/23377907, (accessed 15 February 2016).
Ahlström C. 1997. Demilitarised and neutralised territories in European perspective. In: Hannikainen L. and Horn F. (editors). Autonomy and demilitarisation in international law: the Åland Islands in a changing Europe. The Hague: Kluwer Law International: 4656.
Ahlström C. 2004. Demilitarised and neutralised territories in Europe. Mariehamn: Åland Islands Peace Institute.
Almond H.H. Jr 1985. Demilitarization and arms control: Antarctica. Case Western Reserve Journal of International Law 17 (2): 229284.
Archer C. and Scrivener D.. 1982. Frozen Frontiers and resource wranglers: conflict and cooperation in northern waters. International Affairs 59 (1): 5976.
Arlov T.B. 1989. A short history of Svalbard. Oslo: Norsk Polarinstitutt.
ASPI. 2013. Cold calculations: Australia's Antarctic challenges. Barton: The Australian Strategic Policy Institute. URL: https://www.aspi.org.au/publications/strategic-insights-66-cold-calculations-australias-antarctic-challenges/SI66_Antarctic.pdf, (accessed 8 April 2016).
Åtland K. and Pedersen T.. 2014. Cold War legacies in Russia's Svalbard policy. In: Hoogensen G.G., Bazely D., Goloviznina M. and Tanentzap A. (editors). Environmental human security in the Arctic. Abington: Routledge: 1736.
Åtland K. 2003. Russisk nordområdepolitikk etter den kalde krigen: forholdet mellom næringsinteresser og militærstrategiske interesser [Russian north policy after Cold War: the relationship between industry interests and military strategic interests]. Oslo: Norwegian Defence Research Establishment.
Åtland K. and Bruusgaard V.. 2009. When security speech acts misfire – Russia and the Elektron Incident. Security Dialogue 40 (3): 333353.
Bailes A. 2011. Spitsbergen in a sea of change. In: Wallis D. and Steward A. (editors). The Spitsbergen Treaty: multilateral governance in the Arctic. Helsinki: Arctic Papers 1: 3437.
Bankes N. 2009. Climate change and the regime for the conservation of polar bears. In: Koivurova T., Keskitalo E.C.H. and Bankes N. (editors). Climate governance in the Arctic. Berlin: Springer.
Chillaud M. 2006. Territorial disarmament in Northern Europe: the epilogue of a success story? Policy Paper No. 13. Stockholm: SIPRI.
Churchill R. and Ulfstein G.. 2010. The disputed maritime zones around Svalbard. In: Nordquist M.H., Heidar T.H. and Moore J.N. (editors). Changes in the Arctic environmental and the law of the sea. Leiden: Nijhoff, 551593.
Coffey L. and Kochis D.. 2015. The Baltic States: the United States must be prepared to fulfil its NATO Treaty obligations. Washington: The Heritage Foundation.
Convention between Great Britain, France, and Russia respecting the Åland Islands of 30 March 1856 (46 BSP 23).
Convention relating to the non-fortification and neutralisation of the Aaland Islands of 20 October 1921 (9 LNTS 213).
Darby A. 2014. China's Antarctica satellite base plans spark concerns. The Sydney Morning Herald, 12 November 2014. URL: http://www.smh.com.au/world/chinas-antarctica-satellite-base-plans-spark-concerns-20141112-11l3wx.html, (accessed 10 October 2015).
Dekanozov R.V. 1966. International legal position of Spitsbergen. Sverdlovsk.
Dekanozov R.V. 1968. Demilitarisation and neutralisation of Spitsbergen. Soviet Yearbook of International Law: 192194.
Fleischer C.A. 1978. Le régime d'exploitation du Spitsberg (Svalbard). Annuaire Français De Droit International 24 (1): 275300.
Fløistad B. 2008. Controversy over the legal regime outside Svalbard's territorial waters. Focus North 6-2008. Oslo: Den Norske Atlanterhavs Komite.
Johnsen A.B. 2015. Russland protesterer mot oljeboring i Svalbard-sonen [Russia protests against oil drilling in the Svalbard zone] (interview with Geir Ulfstein). Verdens Gang, 2 May 2015. URL: http://www.vg.no/nyheter/innenriks/norsk-politikk/russland-protesterer-mot-oljeboring-i-svalbard-sonen/a/23444540/, (accessed 5 February 2016).
Godzimirski J. 2007. High stakes in the High North: Russian-Norwegian relations and their implications for the EU. Paris: Russia/NIS Center.
Grydehøj A. 2013. Informal diplomacy in Norway's Svalbard policy: the intersection of local community development and Arctic international relations. Global Change, Peace and Security 26 (1): 4154.
Hannikainen L. 1994. The continued validity of the demilitarised and neutralised status of the Åland islands. Zeitschrift für Ausländisches Öffentliches Recht und Völkerrecht 54: 614651.
Henriksen T. and Ulfstein G.. 2011. Maritime delimitation in the Arctic: the Barents Sea Treaty. Ocean Development and International Law 42: 121.
Holst J.J. 1967. Norsk sikkerhetspolitikk i strategisk perspektiv [Norwegian security policy in strategic perspective]. Oslo: Norsk Utenrikspolitisk Institutt.
Holtsmark S.G. 1993. A Soviet grab for the High North, USSR, Svalbard and northern Norway 1920–1953. Oslo: Institutt for Forsvarsstudier.
Jensen Ø. and Rottem S.V.. 2010. The politics of security and international law in Norway's Arctic waters. Polar Record 46 (236): 7583.
Jørgensen J.H. 2003. Russisk Svalbard-politikk. Eksterne og interne forklaringsfaktorer [Russian Svalbard-politics. External and internal explanatory factors]. Oslo: Institutt for statsvitenskap, Universitetet i Oslo.
Laruelle M. 2014. Russia's Arctic strategies and the future of the Far North. New York: M.E. Sharpe.
Lucas E. 2015. The coming storm. Baltic Sea Security Report. Washington and Warszawa: Center for European Policy Analysis.
Lüdecke C. 2011. Parallel precedents for the Antarctic Treaty. In: Berkman P.A., Lang M.A., Walton D.W.H. and Young O.R. (editors). Science diplomacy: Antarctica, Science, and the governance of international spaces. Washington: Smithsonian Institution: 253263.
Machowski J. 1995. Scientific activities on Spitsbergen in the light of the international legal status of the archipelago. Warsaw: Polish Polar Research, Institute of International Law, Warsaw University.
Mathisen T. 1951. Svalbard i internasjonal politikk 1871–1925 [Svalbard in the international politics 1871–1925]. Oslo: Aschehoug.
MFA (Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Norway). 2005. Report No. 30 (2004–2005) to the Storting. Opportunities and challenges in the North. Oslo: Government of Norway. URL: https://www.regjeringen.no/globalassets/upload/kilde/ud/stm/20042005/0001/ddd/pdts/stm200420050001ud_dddpdts.pdf, (accessed 15 March 2016).
MFA (Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Norway). 2006. Recommendation No. 264 (2004–2005) to the Storting from the Standing Committee on Foreign Affairs concerning opportunities and challenges in the High North. Oslo: Government of Norway. URL: https://www.regjeringen.no/globalassets/upload/UD/Vedlegg/strategien.pdf, (accessed 20 March 2016).
MJP (Norwegian Ministry of Justice and the Police). 1999. Report No. 9 to the Storting (1999–2000). Recommendation of 29 October 1999 by the Ministry of Justice and the Police. URL: https://www.regjeringen.no/en/dokumenter/report-no-9-to-the-storting-/id456868/, (accessed 14 March 2016).
MJP (Norwegian Ministry of Justice and the Police). 2009. Report No. 22 to the Storting (2008–2009). Recommendation of 17 April 2009 by the Ministry of Justice and the Police. URL: https://www.regjeringen.no/contentassets/e70b04df32ad45f483f2619939c5636d/en-gb/pdfs/stm200820090022000en_pdfs.pdf, (accessed 15 March 2016).
Moe A. 2010. Russian and Norwegian petroleum strategies in the Barents Sea. Polhøgda: Fridtjof Nansen Institute.
Molenaar E.J. 2012. Fisheries regulation in the maritime zones of Svalbard. The International Journal of Marine and Coastal Law 27: 358.
Motsak M.V. 2000. O natsional'nykh interesakh Rossii v Arktike [Russia's national interests in the Arctic]. Vojennaja Mysl’ 6.
Nilsen T. 2013. Oil hunger not reason for Barents treaty. Barents Observer, 12 August 2013. URL: http://barentsobserver.com/en/energy/2013/08/oil-hunger-not-reason-barents-treaty-12-08, (accessed 10 December 2015).
Numminen L. 2011. A history and functioning of the Spitsbergen Treaty. In: Wallis D. and Steward A. (editors). The Spitsbergen Treaty: multilateral governance in the Arctic. Helsinki: Arctic Papers 1, 720.
Oreshenkov A. 2010. Arctic square of opportunities. North Pole and “Shelf” of Svalbard cannot be Norwegian. Russia in Global Affairs 4.
Østhagen A. 2011. Debating the EU's role in the Arctic: a report from Brussels. Washington: The Arctic Institute, Centre for Circumpolar Security Studies.
Østreng W. 1974. Svalbards situasjon i storpolitisk perspektiv [Svalbard in the perspective of high politics]. Internasjonal politikk 3: 679701.
Østreng W. 1977. Politics in high latitudes. The Svalbard archipelago. London: C. Hurst and Company.
Østreng W. 1978. The exercise of Norwegian authority on Svalbard. Background and conditions for change. In: Spitsbergen symposium. Groeningen: Arctic Centre, 113127.
Østreng W. and Sollie F.. 1977. Betydningen av Svalbard-traktatens artikkel 9 i relasjon til den miliær-strategiske utvikling i Svalbard-Barentshav-området [The meaning of Article 9 of the Svalbard Treaty in relation to the military strategic development in the Barents Sea area]. Internasjonal Politikk 4: 653691.
Pechurov A.V. 1983. Shpitsbergen [Spitsbergen]. Moscow: Mysl’.
Pedersen P. 2006. The Svalbard continental shelf controversy: legal disputes and political rivalries. Ocean Development and International Law 37 (3–4): 339358.
Pedersen T. 2008a. Conflict and order in Svalbard waters. Tromsø: University of Tromsø.
Pedersen T. 2008b. The dynamics of Svalbard diplomacy. Diplomacy and Statecraft 19 (2): 236262.
Pedersen T. 2008c. The constrained politics of the Svalbard offshore area. Marine Policy 32: 913919.
Pedersen T. 2009a. Denmark's policies toward the Svalbard area. Ocean Development and International Law 40 (4): 319332.
Pedersen T. 2009b. Norway's rule on Svalbard tightening the grip on the Arctic islands. Polar Record 45 (233): 147152.
Pedersen T. 2011. International law and politics in US policymaking: the United States and the Svalbard Dispute. Ocean Development and International Law 42 (1–2): 120135.
Pettersen T. 2016a. Russian military instructors plan to land on Svalbard. Barents Observer, 7 April 2016. URL: http://thebarentsobserver.com/security/2016/04/russian-military-instructors-plan-land-svalbard, (accessed 15 April 2016).
Pettersen T. 2016b. Chechen special forces instructors landed on Svalbard. Barents Observer, 13 April 2016. URL: http://thebarentsobserver.com/2016/04/chechen-special-forces-instructors-landed-svalbard, (accessed 15 April 2016).
PST (Politiets sikkerhetstjenestes). 2010. Trusselvurdering 2010 [National Threat Assessment 2010]. URL: http://www.pst.no/media/utgivelser/trusselvurdering-2010, (accessed 14 April 2016).
PST (Politiets sikkerhetstjenestes). 2016. Trusselvurdering 2016 [National Threat Assessment 2016]. URL: http://www.pst.no/media/81093/PST_Brosjyre_Trussel_ENG.pdf, (accessed 14 April 2016).
Rivetov P. 2003. Shpitsbergen: forpost NATO pod nosom Rossii [Spitsbergen: NATO's outpost under Russia's nose]. Pravda, 19 April 2003. URL: http://www.pravda.ru/politics/19-04-2003/838627-0/, (accessed on 11 January 2016).
Saul B. and Stephens T.. 2015. Antarctic in international law. Oxford: Hart Publishing.
Singh E.C. and Saguirian A.A.. 1993. The Svalbard archipelago: the role of surrogate negotiators. In: Young O.R. and Sherenko G. (editors). Polar politics. Creating international environmental regimes. Ithaca and London: Cornell University Press.
Staalesen A. 2014. Exploring Spitsbergen shelf. Barents Observer, 22 July 2014. URL: http://barentsobserver.com/en/energy/2014/07/exploring-spitsbergen-shelf-22-07, (accessed 10 February 2016).
Staalesen A. 2015. New reality for Norwegian defence. Barents Observer, 30 April 2015. URL: http://barentsobserver.com/en/security/2015/04/new-reality-norwegian-defence-30-04, (accessed 10 February 2016).
Statistics Norway. 2016. Population of Svalbard, 1 January 2016. Oslo: The Royal Norwegian Ministry of Finance. URL: https://ssb.no/en/befolkning/statistikker/befsvalbard/halvaar/2016-04-07#content, (accessed 13 April 2016).
The Antarctic Treaty of 1 December 1959 (402 UNTS 71).
Timchenko L.D. 1992. Spitsbergen: history and modern day. Kharkov: Osnova.
Treaty concerning the Archipelago of Spitsbergen of 9 February 1920 (2 LNTS 7).
Ulfstein G. 1995. The Svalbard Treaty: from terra nullius to Norwegian sovereignty. Oslo: Scandinavian University Press.
Vegstein L.U.L. 2015. Bitter oljestrid om Svalbard [Bitter oil-controversy about Svalbard] (interview with Jakub Godzimirski). Klassekampen, 28 February 2015. URL: www.klassekampen.no/article/20150228/ARTICLE/150229811, (accessed November 2015).
Vyleghanin A.N. and Zilanov V.K.. 2007. Legal régime of adjacent marine areas. The Hague: Eleven International Publishing.
Lieungh E. 2011. Professor: satellittstasjonen på Svalbard kan være problematisk [Professor: satellite stations on Svalbard can be problematic] (interview with Willy Østreng). NRK, 9 November 2011. URL: http://www.nrk.no/troms/professor_-_-kan-vaere-problematisk-1.7866534, (accessed 4 November 2015).
White Paper. 1975. Report No. 39 to the Storting (1974–1975) on Svalbard.
White Paper. 1985. Report No. 40 to the Storting (1985–1986) on Svalbard.
Wormdal B. 2011. The satellite war: how new installations in the Arctic areas transforms the war. CreateSpace Independent Publishing Platform.
Wråkberg U. 2006. Nature conservationism and the Arctic commons of Spitsbergen 1900–1920. Acta Borealia 23 (1): 123.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Polar Record
  • ISSN: 0032-2474
  • EISSN: 1475-3057
  • URL: /core/journals/polar-record
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×
Type Description Title
UNKNOWN
Supplementary Materials

Koivurova and Holiencin supplementary material
Supplementary Figure

 Unknown (4.1 MB)
4.1 MB

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 11
Total number of PDF views: 69 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 410 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between 25th January 2017 - 18th November 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.