Skip to main content
×
Home

The Impact of Committee Composition and Agendas on Women's Participation: Evidence from a Legislature with Near Numerical Equality

  • Kendall D. Funk (a1), Laura Morales (a1) and Michelle M. Taylor-Robinson (a1)
Abstract

Previous studies of women's participation in legislative debates could not disentangle the possible effect of institutionalized gender discrimination from the effect of gendered patterns because of women lacking seniority and leadership posts. Costa Rica's Legislative Assembly offers an opportunity to control for seniority and leadership. The prohibition on immediate reelection means that no legislators have seniority. The country's successful gender quota, presence of an equal number of men and women committee presidents, and election of the first woman president in 2010 all point to women having relatively equal access to formal positions of power. In this context, unequal debate participation between men and women legislators would indicate that it is very difficult to change the gendered nature of an institution. We use multilevel modeling to analyze repeated observations of individual-level participation in three of six standing committees during the 2010–14 term (Agriculture, Economics, and Social Issues) to explore differences in patterns of participation under various conditions (sex ratios, discussion topics, sex of committee leaders). Findings indicate that women are active participants in committees with both stereotypically feminine and masculine policy jurisdictions, but also that women are more active when the gender composition of the committee is less skewed.

Copyright
References
Hide All
Acker Joan. 1992. “From Sex Roles to Gendered Institutions.” Contemporary Sociology 21 (5): 565–69.
Aparicio Francisco Javier, and Langston Joy. 2009. “Committee Leadership Selection without Seniority: The Mexican Case.” Working Paper 217, CIDE. http://investigadores.cide.edu/aparicio/Aparicio&Langston_CommLeadershipMex_DTEP217_09.pdf (accessed June 14, 2016).
Arias Ramírez Bernal. 2008. “Estudio comparativo de normativa parlamentaria.” http://estadonacion.or.cr/files/biblioteca_virtual/014/Estudio-comparativo-Arias-2008.pdf (accessed June 14, 2016).
Baekgaard Martin, and Kjaer Ulrik. 2012. “The Gendered Division of Labor in Assignments to Political Committees: Discrimination or Self-Selection in Danish Local Politics?Politics & Gender 8 (4): 465–82.
Beckwith Karen. 2005. “A Common Language of Gender?Politics & Gender 1 (1): 128–37.
Beckwith Karen. 2007. “Numbers and Newness: The Descriptive and Substantive Representation of Women.” Canadian Journal of Political Science/Revue canadienne de science politique 40 (1): 2749.
Bicquelet Aude, Albert Weale, and Bara Judith. 2012. “In a Different Parliamentary Voice? Politics & Gender 8 (1): 83121.
Bird Karen. 2005. “Gendering Parliamentary Questions.” British Journal of Politics and International Relations 7 (3): 353–70.
Bratton Kathleen A. 2005. “Critical Mass Theory Revisited: The Behavior and Success of Token Women in State Legislatures.” Politics & Gender 1 (1): 97125.
Broughton Sharon, and Palmieri Sonia. 1999. “Gendered Contributions to Parliamentary Debates: The Case of Euthanasia.” Australian Journal of Political Science 34 (1): 2945.
Cammisa Anne Marie, and Reingold Beth. 2004. “Women in State Legislatures and State Legislative Research: Beyond Sameness and Difference.” State Politics & Policy Quarterly 4 (2): 181210.
Carey John M. 1996. Term Limits and Legislative Representation. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Carey John M. 1997. “Strong Candidates for a Limited Office: Presidentialism and Political Parties in Costa Rica.” In Presidentialism and Democracy in Latin America, eds. Mainwaring Scott and Soberg Shugart Matthew. New York: Cambridge University Press, 199224.
Catalano Ana. 2009. “Women Acting for Women? An Analysis of Gender and Debate Participation in the British House of Commons 2005–2007.” Politics & Gender 5 (1): 7998.
Chaney Paul. 2006. “Critical Mass, Deliberation and the Substantive Representation of Women: Evidence from the UK's Devolution Programme.” Political Studies 54 (4): 691714.
Childs Sarah, and Withey Julie. 2004. “Women Representatives Acting for Women: Sex and the Signing of Early Day Motions in the 1997 British Parliament.” Political Studies 52 (3): 552–64.
Deere Carmen Diana. 1978. “The Differentiation of the Peasantry and Family Structure: A Peruvian Case Study.” Journal of Family History 3 (4): 422–38.
Deere Carmen Diana. 1982. “The Division of Labor by Sex in Agriculture: A Peruvian Case Study.” Economic Development and Cultural Change 30 (4): 795811.
Deere Carmen Diana, and León de Leal Magdalena. 1987. “Introduction.” In Rural Women and State Policy: Feminist Perspectives on Latin American Agricultural Development, eds. Carmen Deere Diana and León de Leal Magdalena. Boulder, CO: Westview Press, 35.
Diamond Irene. 1977. Sex Roles in the State House. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
Dovidio John F., Brown Clifford E., Heltman Karen, Ellyson Steve L., and Keating Caroline F.. 1988. “Power Displays between Women and Men in Discussions of Gender-Linked Tasks: A Multichannel Study.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 55 (4): 580–87.
Duerst-Lahti Georgia. 2005. “Institutional Gendering: Theoretical Insights into the Environment of Women Officeholders.” In Women and Elective Office, eds. Thomas Sue and Wilcox Clyde. New York: Oxford University Press, 230–43.
Edelson Meredyth Goldberg, Hokoda Audrey, and Ramos-Lira Luciana. 2007. “Differences in Effects of Domestic Violence between Latina and Non-Latina Women.” Journal of Family Violence 22 (1): 110.
Escobar-Lemmon Maria C., and Taylor-Robinson Michelle M., eds. 2014. Representation: The Case of Women. New York: Oxford University Press.
Escobar-Lemmon Maria C., Schwindt-Bayer Leslie A., and Taylor-Robinson Michelle M.. 2014. “Representing Women: Empirical Insights from Legislatures and Cabinets in Latin America.” In Representation: The Case of Women, eds. Escobar-Lemmon Maria C. and Taylor-Robinson Michelle M.. New York: Oxford University Press, 205–24.
Frisch Scott A., and Kelly Sean Q.. 2003. “A Place at the Table: Women's Committee Requests and Women's Committee Assignments in the U.S. House.” Women & Politics 25 (3): 126.
Funk Kendall D. 2015. “Gendered Governing? Women's Leadership Styles and Participatory Institutions in Brazil.” Political Research Quarterly 68 (3): 564–78.
Galanti Geri-Ann. 2003. “The Hispanic Family and Male-Female Relationships: An Overview.” Journal of Transcultural Nursing 14 (3): 180–85.
Gutiérrez Saxe Miguel, and Straface Fernando, eds. 2008. Democracia estable alcanza? Analisis de la gobernabilidad en Costa Rica. Washington, DC: Inter-American Development Bank.
Hall Rick L. 1996. Participation in Congress. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
Hawkesworth Mary. 2003. “Congressional Enactments of Race-Gender: Toward a Theory of Raced-Gendered Institutions.” American Political Science Review 97 (4): 529–50.
Heath Roseanna Michelle, Schwindt-Bayer Leslie A., and Taylor-Robinson Michelle M.. 2005. “Women on the Sidelines: Women's Representation on Committees in Latin American Legislatures.” American Journal of Political Science 49 (2): 420–36.
Henderson Alisa. 2005. “Forging a New Political Culture: Plenary Behaviour in the Scottish Parliament.” Journal of Legislative Studies 11(2): 275301.
Holli Anne Maria. 2012. “Does Gender Have an Effect on the Selection of Experts by Parliamentary Standing Committees? A Critical Test of ‘Critical’ Concepts.” Politics & Gender 8 (3): 341–66.
Kanter Rosabeth Moss. 1977. “Some Effects of Proportions on Group Life: Skewed Sex Ratios and Responses to Token Women.” American Journal of Sociology 82 (5): 965–91.
Kanthak Kristin, and Krause George A.. 2010. “Valuing Diversity in Political Organizations: Gender and Token Minorities in the U.S. House of Representatives.” American Journal of Political Science 54 (4): 839–54.
Karpowitz Christopher F., and Mendelberg Tali. 2014. The Silent Sex: Gender, Deliberation, and Institutions. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Kathlene Lyn. 1994. “Power and Influence in State Legislative Policymaking: The Interaction of Gender and Position in Committee Hearing Debates.” American Political Science Review 88 (3): 560–76.
Kenney Sally J. 1996. “New Research on Gendered Political Institutions.” Political Research Quarterly 49 (2): 445–66.
Kerevel Yann P., and Atkeson Lonna Rae. 2013. “Explaining the Marginalization of Women in Legislative Institutions.” Journal of Politics 75 (4): 980–92.
Latu Ioana M., Mast Marianne Schmid, Lammers Joris, and Bombari Dario. 2013. “Successful Female Leaders Empower Women's Behavior in Leadership Tasks.” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 49 (3): 444–48.
Lawless Jennifer L., and Fox Richard L.. 2005. It Takes a Candidate: Why Women Don't Run for Office. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
León de Leal Magdalena. 1987. “Rural Women and the Neoliberal Model in Chile.” In Rural Women and State Policy: Feminist Perspectives on Latin American Agricultural Development, eds. Deere Diana Carmen and León de Leal Magdalena. Boulder, CO: Westview Press, 2134.
Long J. Scott, and Freese Jeremy. 2006. Regression Models for Categorical Dependent Variables Using Stata. College Station, TX: Stata Press.
Mackey Fiona. 2011. “Conclusion: Towards a Feminist Institutionalism?” In Gender, Politics and Institutions: Towards a Feminist Institutionalism, eds. Krook Mona Lena and Mackey Fiona. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 181–96.
Mansbridge Jane, and Shames Shauna L.. 2008. “Toward a Theory of Backlash: Dynamic Resistance and the Central Role of Power.” Politics & Gender 4 (4): 623–34.
Miguel Luis Felipe. 2012. “Policy Priorities and Women's Double Bind in Brazil.” In The Impact of Gender Quotas, eds. Franceschet Susan, Krook Mona Lena, and Piscopo Jennifer M.. New York: Oxford University Press, 103–18.
Murray Rainbow. 2010a. “Linear Trajectories or Vicious Circles? The Causes and Consequences of Gendered Career Paths in the National Assembly.” Modern and Contemporary France 18 (4): 445–59.
Murray Rainbow. 2010b. “Second among Unequals? A Study of Whether France's ‘Quota Women’ Are Up to the Job.” Politics & Gender 6 (1): 93118.
Pearson Kathryn, and Dancey Logan. 2011. “Elevating Women's Voice in Congress: Speech Participation in the House of Representatives.” Political Research Quarterly 64 (4): 910–23.
Pearson Kathryn, and Dancey Logan. 2012. “Speaking for the Underrepresented in the House of Representatives: Voicing Women's Interests in a Partisan Era.” Politics & Gender 7 (4): 493519.
Penchaszadeh Victor B. 2001. “Genetic Counseling Issues in Latinos.” Genetic Testing 5 (3): 193200.
Piscopo Jennifer M. 2011. “Rethinking Descriptive Representation: Rendering Women in Legislative Debates.” Parliamentary Affairs 64 (3): 338–72.
Piscopo Jennifer M. 2015. “Toward Gender Balance in Government: Women's Political Representation in Costa Rica.” Presented at the Women and Leadership in Latin America Conference, Rice University, Houston, TX.
Reingold Beth. 2008. “Women as Officeholders: Linking Descriptive and Substantive Representation.” In Political Women and American Democracy, eds. Wolbrecht Christina, Beckwith Karen, and Baldez Lisa. New York: Cambridge University Press, 128–47.
Rosenthal Cindy Simon. 1997. “A View of Their Own: Women's Committee Leadership Styles and State Legislatures.” Policy Studies Journal 25 (4): 585600.
Rosenthal Cindy Simon. 2005. “Women Leading Legislatures: Getting There and Getting Things Done.” In Women and Elective Office: Past, Present, and Future, 2nd ed., eds. Thomas Sue and Wilcox Clyde. New York: Oxford University Press, 197212.
Sabogal Fabio, Marín Gerardo, Otero-Sabogal Regina, Marín Barbara Vanoss, and Perez-Stable Eliseo J.. 1987. “Hispanic Familism and Acculturation: What Changes and What Doesn't?Hispanic Journal of Behavioral Sciences 9 (4): 397412.
Saint-Germain Michelle A., and Chavez Metoyer Cynthia. 2008. Women Legislators in Central America: Politics, Democracy, and Policy. Austin: University of Texas Press.
Saint-Germain Michelle A., and Morgan Martha I.. 1991. “Equality: Costa Rican Women Demand ‘The Real Thing.’Women & Politics 11 (3): 2375.
Schwindt-Bayer Leslie A. 2005. “The Incumbency Disadvantage and Women's Election to Legislative Office.” Electoral Studies 24 (2): 227–44.
Schwindt-Bayer Leslie A. 2010. Political Power and Women's Representation in Latin America. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Schwindt-Bayer Leslie A., and Taylor-Robinson Michelle M.. 2011. “The Meaning and Measurement of Women's Interests: Introduction.” Politics & Gender 7 (3): 417–46.
Steenbergen Marco R., and Jones Bradford S.. 2002. “Modeling Multilevel Data Structures.” American Journal of Political Science 46 (1): 218–37.
Steidel Angel G. Lugo, and Contreras Josefina M.. 2003. “A New Familism Scale for Use with Latino Populations.” Hispanic Journal of Behavioral Sciences 25 (3): 312–30.
Swers Michele L. 2001. “Research on Women in Legislatures: What Have We Learned, Where Are We Going?Women & Politics 23 (1/2): 167–85.
Swers Michele L. 2014. “Unpacking Women's Issues: Gender and Policymaking on Health Care, Education, and Women's Health in the U.S. Senate.” In Representation: The Case of Women, eds. Escobar-Lemmon Maria C. and Taylor-Robinson Michelle M.. New York: Oxford University Press, 158–82.
Taylor Michelle M. 1992. “Formal versus Informal Incentive Structures and Legislator Behavior: Evidence from Costa Rica.” Journal of Politics 54 (4): 1053–71.
Taylor-Robinson Michelle M., and Heath Roseanna M.. 2003. “Do Women Legislators Have Different Policy Priorities than Their Male Colleagues? A Critical Case Test.” Women & Politics 24 (4): 77101.
Taylor-Robinson Michelle M., and Ross Ashley. 2011. “Can Formal Rules of Order Be Used as an Accurate Proxy for Behavior Internal to a Legislature? Evidence from Costa Rica.” Journal of Legislative Studies 17 (4): 479500.
Thomas Sue. 1994. How Women Legislate. New York: Oxford University Press.
Towns Ann. 2003. “Understanding the Effects of Larger Ratios of Women in National Legislatures: Proportions and Gender Differentiation in Sweden and Norway.” Women & Politics 25 (1/2): 129.
Volden Craig, Wiseman Alan, and Wittmer Dana. 2013. “When Are Women More Effective Lawmakers than Men?American Journal of Political Science 57 (2): 327–41.
Wood Wendy, and Karten Stephen J.. 1986. “Sex Differences in Interaction Style as a Product of Perceived Sex Differences in Competence.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 50 (2): 341–47.
Zetterberg Pär. 2008. “The Downside of Gender Quotas? Institutional Constraints on Women in Mexican State Legislatures.” Parliamentary Affairs 61 (3): 442–60.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Politics & Gender
  • ISSN: 1743-923X
  • EISSN: 1743-9248
  • URL: /core/journals/politics-and-gender
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 6
Total number of PDF views: 91 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 409 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 21st November 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.