Skip to main content
×
×
Home

The role of low-calorie sweeteners in the prevention and management of overweight and obesity: evidence v. conjecture

  • Peter J. Rogers (a1)
Abstract

By virtue of reducing dietary energy density, low-calorie sweeteners (LCS) can be expected to decrease overall energy intake and thereby decrease body weight. Such effects will be limited by the amount of sugar replaced by LCS, and the dynamics of appetite and weight control (e.g., acute compensatory eating, and an increase in appetite and decrease in energy expenditure accompanying weight loss). Consistent with these predictions, short-term intervention studies show incomplete compensation for the consumption of LCS v. sugar, and longer-term intervention studies (from 4 weeks to 40 months duration) show small decreases in energy intake and body weight with LCS v. sugar. Despite this evidence, there are claims that LCS undermine weight management. Three claims are that: (1) LCS disrupt the learned control of energy intake (sweet taste confusion hypothesis); (2) exposure to sweetness increases desire for sweetness (sweet tooth hypothesis); (3) consumers might consciously overcompensate for ‘calories saved’ when they know they are consuming LCS (conscious overcompensation hypothesis). None of these claims stands up to close examination. In any case, the results of the intervention studies comparing LCS v. sugar indicate that the effect of energy dilution outweighs any tendency LCS might conceivably have to increase energy intake.

Copyright
Corresponding author
Corresponding author: P. J. Rogers, email peter.rogers@bristol.ac.uk
References
Hide All
1. Roberts A (2016) The safety and regulatory process for low calorie sweeteners in the United States. Physiol Behav 164, 439444.
2. Steiner JE, Glaser D, Hawilo ME et al. (2001) Comparative expression of hedonic impact: affective reactions to taste by human infants and other primates. Neurosci Biobehav Rev 25, 5374.
3. Beauchamp GK (2016) Why do we like sweet taste: a bitter tale? Physiol Behav 164, 432437.
4. Booth DA, Higgs S, Schneider J et al. (2010) Learned liking versus inborn delight: can sweetness give sensual pleasure or is it just motivation? Psychol Sci 21, 16561663.
5. Jordano P, Forget P-M, Lambert JE et al. (2011) Frugivores and seed dispersal: mechanisms and consequences for biodiversity of a key ecological interaction. Biol Lett 7, 321323.
6. Guevara EE, Veilleux CC, Saltonstall K et al. (2016) Potential arms race in the coevolution of primates and angiosperms: brazzein sweet proteins and gorilla taste receptors. Am J Phys Anthropol 161, 181185.
7. Smith JC & Sclafani A (2002) Saccharin as a sugar surrogate revisited. Appetite 38, 155160.
8. Rogers PJ & Brunstrom JM (2016) Appetite and energy balancing. Physiol Behav 164, 465471.
9. Woods SC (1991) The eating paradox: how we tolerate food. Psychol Rev 98, 488505.
10. Schubert MM, Desbrow B, Sabapathy S et al. (2013) Acute exercise and subsequent energy intake. A meta-analysis. Appetite 63, 92104.
11. Mela DJ & Rogers PJ (1998) Food, Eating and Obesity: The Psychobiological Basis of Appetite and Weight Control. London: Chapman and Hall.
12. Rogers PJ (1985) Returning ‘cafeteria-fed’ rats to a chow diet: negative contrast and effects of obesity on feeding behaviour. Physiol Behav 35, 493499.
13. Rogers PJ (1999) Eating habits and appetite control: a psychobiological perspective. Proc Nutr Soc 58, 5967.
14. Polidori D, Sanghvi A, Seeley RJ et al. (2016) How strongly does appetite counter weight loss? Quantification of feedback control of human energy intake. Obesity 24, 22892295.
15. Levitsky DA & Pacanowski CR (2013) Effect of skipping breakfast on subsequent energy intake. Physiol Behav 119, 916.
16. Rogers PJ, Ferriday D, Jebb SJ et al. (2016) Connecting biology and psychology to make sense of appetite control. Nutr Bull 41, 344352.
17. Gibson S, Ashwell M, Arthurs J et al. (2017) What can the food and drink industry do to help achieve the 5% free sugars goal? Perspect Public Health 137, 237247.
18. Miller PE & Perez V (2014) Low-calories sweeteners and body weight and composition: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials and prospective cohort studies. Am J Clin Nutr 100, 765777.
19. Rogers PJ, Hogenkamp PS, de Graaf C et al. (2016). Does low-energy sweetener consumption affect energy intake and body weight? A systematic review, including meta-analyses, of the evidence from human and animal studies. Int J Obes 40, 381394.
20. Gadah NS, Kyle LA, Simth JE et al. (2016) No difference in compensation for sugar in a drink versus sugar in semi-solid and solid foods. Physiol Behav 156, 3542.
21. Gadah NS, Brunstrom JM & Rogers PJ (2016) Cross-over studies underestimate energy compensation: the example of sucrose- versus sucralose-containing drinks. Appetite 107, 398405.
22. Te Morenga L, Mallard S & Mann J (2013) Dietary sugar and body weight: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials and cohort studies. BMJ 346, e7492.
23. Pan A, Malik VS, Hao T et al. (2013) Changes in water and beverage intake and long-term weight changes: results from three prospective cohort studies. Int J Obes 37, 13781385.
24. Fowler SP, Williams K, Resendez RG et al. (2008) Fueling the obesity epidemic. Artificially sweetened beverages use and long-term weight gain. Obesity 16, 18941900.
25. Swithers SE, Martin AA & Davidson TL (2010) High-intensity sweeteners and energy balance. Physiol Behav 100, 5562.
26. Hampton T (2008) Sugar substitutes linked to weight gain. JAMA 299, 21372138.
27. Ludwig DS (2009) Artificially sweetened beverages: cause for concern. JAMA 302, 24772478.
28. Yang Q (2010) Gain weight by ‘going diet’? Artificial sweeteners and the neurobiology of sugar cravings: neuroscience 2010. Yale J Med Biol 83, 101108.
29. Boakes RA, Kendig MD, Martire SI et al. (2016). Sweetening yoghurt with glucose, but not with saccharin, promotes weight gain and increased fat pad mass in rats. Appetite, 105, 114128.
30. Swithers SE (2015) Not so sweet revenge: unanticipated consequences of high-intensity sweeteners. Behav Anal 38, 117.
31. Boakes RA, Martire SI, Rooney KB et al. (2016) Individual differences in saccharin acceptance predict rats’ food intake. Physiol Behav 164, 151156.
32. Palframan KM & Myers KP (2016) Modern ‘junk food’ and minimally-processed ‘natural food’ cafeteria diets alter the response to sweet taste but do not impair flavour-nutrient learning in rats. Physiol Behav 157, 146157.
33. van Dongen MV, van der Berg MC, Vink N et al. (2012) Taste-nutrient relationships in commonly consumed foods. Br J Nutr 108, 140147.
34. Lease H, Hendrie GA & Poelman AAM (2016) A sensory-diet database: a tool to characterise the sensory qualities of diets. Food Qual Pref 49, 2032.
35. van Langveld AB, Gibbons S, Koelliker Y et al. (2017) The relationship between taste and nutrient content in commercially available foods from the United States. Food Qual Pref 57, 17.
36. Mattes RD & Popkin BM (2009) Nontutritive sweetener consumption in humans: effects on appetite and food intake and their putative mechanisms. Am J Clin Nutr 89, 114.
37. Public Health England (2015) Sugar Reduction: The Evidence for Action. Annexe 5: Food Supply. London: Public Health England.
38. Peters JC, Wyatt HR, Foster GD et al. (2014) The effects of water and non-nutritive sweetened beverages on weight loss during a 12-week weight loss treatment program. Obesity 22, 14151421.
39. Tate DF, Turner-McGrievy G, Lyons E et al. (2012) Replacing caloric beverages with water or diet beverages for weight loss in adults: main results of the Choose Healthy Options Consciously Everyday (CHOICE) randomized clinical trial. Am J Clin Nutr 95, 555563.
40. Piernas C, Tate DF, Wang X et al. (2013) Does diet-beverage intake affect dietary consumption patterns? Results from the Choose Healthy Options Consciously Everyday (CHOICE) randomized clinical trial. Am J Clin Nutr 97, 604611.
41. Rolls BJ, Hetheringtom M & Burley VJ (1988) Sensory stimulation and energy density in the development of satiety. Physiol Behav 44, 727733.
42. Rogers PJ & Hardman CA (2015) Food reward. What it is and how to measure it. Appetite 90, 115.
43. Wise PM, Nattress L, Flammer LJ et al. (2016) Reduced dietary intake of simple sugars alters perceived sweet taste intensity but not perceived pleasantness. Am J Clin Nutr 103, 5060.
44. Liem DG & de Graaf C (2004) Sweet and sour preferences in young children and adults: role of repeated exposure. Physiol Behav 83, 421429.
45. Appleton K, Mela D, Bertenshaw E et al. (2016) Sweet taste exposures: effect on acceptance and preference for sweet taste in the diet. PROSPERO CRD42016051840.
46. Madjd A, Taylor MA, Delavari A et al. (2015) Effects on weight loss in adults of replacing diet beverages with water during a hypoenergetic diet: a randomized, 24-wk clinical trial. Am J Clin Nutr 102, 13051312.
47. Peters JC, Beck J, Cardel M et al. (2016) The effects of water and non-nutritive sweetened beverages on weight loss and weight maintenance: a randomized clinical trial. Obesity 24, 297304.
48. Provencher V, Polivy J & Herman CP (2009) Perceived healthiness of food. If it's healthy, you can eat more! Appetite 52, 340344.
49. Sinclair SE, Cooper M & Mansfield ED (2014) The influence of menu labelling on calories selected or consumed: a systematic review and meta-analysis. J Acad Nutr Diet 114, 13751388.
50. Rolls BJ, Laster LJ & Summerfelt A (1989) Hunger and food intake following consumption of low-calories foods. Appetite 13, 115127.
51. Mattes R (1990) Effects of aspartame and sucrose on hunger and energy intake in humans. Physiol Behav 47, 10371044.
52. Rogers PJ, Lambert TC, Alikanizadeh LA et al. (1990) Intense sweeteners and appetite: responses of informed and uninformed subjects consuming food sweetened with aspartame or sugar. Int J Obes 14, 105.
53. Lavin JH, French SJ & Read NW (1997) The effect of sucrose- and aspartame-sweetened drinks on energy intake, hunger and food choice of female, moderately restrained eaters. Int J Obes 21, 3742.
54. Reid M, Hammersley R, Hill AJ et al. (2007) Long-term dietary compensation for added sugar: effects of supplementary sucrose drinks over a 4-week period. Br J Nutr 97, 193203.
55. Blackburn GL, Kanders BS, Lavin PT et al. (1997) The effect of aspartame as part of a multidisciplinary weight-control program on short- and long-term control of body weight. Am J Clin Nutr 65, 409418.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Proceedings of the Nutrition Society
  • ISSN: 0029-6651
  • EISSN: 1475-2719
  • URL: /core/journals/proceedings-of-the-nutrition-society
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Keywords:

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 20
Total number of PDF views: 191 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 3317 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between 23rd November 2017 - 25th February 2018. This data will be updated every 24 hours.