Skip to main content

Contrasting prototypes and dimensions in the classification of personality pathology: evidence that dimensions, but not prototypes, are robust

  • N. R. Eaton (a1), R. F. Krueger (a1), S. C. South (a2), L. J. Simms (a3) and L. A. Clark (a4)...

DSM-5 may mark the shift from a categorical classification of personality pathology to a dimensional system. Although dimensional and categorical conceptualizations of personality pathology are often viewed as competing, it is possible to develop categories (prototypes) from combinations of dimensions. Robust prototypes could bridge dimensions and categories within a single classification system.


To explore prototype structure and robustness, we used finite mixture modeling to identify empirically derived personality pathology prototypes within a large sample (n=8690) of individuals from four settings (clinical, college, community, and military), assessed using a dimensional measure of normal and abnormal personality traits, the Schedule for Nonadaptive and Adaptive Personality (SNAP). We then examined patterns of convergent and discriminant external validity for prototypes. Finally, we investigated the robustness of the dimensional structure of personality pathology.


The resulting prototypes were meaningful (externally valid) but non-robust (sample dependent). By contrast, factor analysis revealed that the dimensional structures underlying specific traits were highly robust across samples.


We interpret these results as further evidence of the fundamentally dimensional nature of an empirically based classification of personality pathology.

Corresponding author
*Address for correspondence: N. R. Eaton, M.A., Department of Psychology, 75 East River Road, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN 55455-0344, USA. (Email:
Hide All
Abdi H (2007). RV coefficient and congruence coefficient. In Encyclopedia of Measurement and Statistics (ed. Salkind N.), pp. 849853. Sage: Thousand Oaks, CA.
Andershed H, Köhler D, Louden JE, Hinrichs G (2008). Does the three-factor model of psychopathy identify a problematic subgroup of young offenders? International Journal of Law and Psychiatry 31, 189198.
APA (1994). Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 4th edn. American Psychiatric Association: Washington, DC.
Asendorpf JB, Borkenau P, Ostendorf F, Van Aken MAG (2001). Carving personality description at its joints: confirmation of three replicable personality prototypes for both children and adults. European Journal of Personality 15, 169198.
Ashton MC, Lee K (2009). An investigation of personality types within the HEXACO personality framework. Journal of Individual Differences 30, 181187.
Block J (1971). Lives Through Time. Bancroft Books: Berkeley, CA.
Brown TA (2006). Confirmatory Factor Analysis for Applied Research. Guilford Press: New York.
Browne MW (2001). An overview of analytic rotation in exploratory factor analysis. Multivariate Behavioral Research 36, 111150.
Burt C (1948). Factor analysis and canonical correlations. British Journal of Psychology 1, 95–106.
Casillas A, Clark LA (2002) Dependency, impulsivity, and self-harm: traits hypothesized to underlie the association between Cluster B personality and substance abuse disorders. Journal of Personality Disorders 16, 424436.
Clark LA (1993). Schedule for Nonadaptive and Adaptive Personality (SNAP): Manual for Administration, Scoring, and Interpretation. University of Minnesota Press: Minneapolis, MN.
Clark LA (2007). Assessment and diagnosis of personality disorder: perennial issues and an emerging reconceptualization. Annual Review of Psychology 58, 227257.
Clark LA, Simms LJ, Wu KD, Casillas A (in press). Schedule for Nonadaptive and Adaptive Personality – Second Edition (SNAP-2). University of Minnesota Press: Minneapolis, MN.
Clark LA, Vittengl J, Kraft D, Jarrett RJ (2003). Separate personality traits from states to predict depression. Journal of Personality Disorders 17, 152172.
Costa PT Jr., McCrae RR (1992). Revised NEO Personality Inventory (NEO-PI-R) and NEO Five-Factor Inventory (NEO-FFI) Professional Manual. Psychological Assessment Resources: Odessa, FL.
Crocker L, Algina J (2006). Introduction to Classical and Modern Test Theory. Thomson Custom Solutions: Mason, OH.
De Fruyt F, Mervielde I, Van Leeuwen K (2002). The consistency of personality type classification across samples and five-factor measures. European Journal of Personality 16, S57S72.
Eaton NR, South SC, Krueger RF (2010). The meaning of comorbidity among common mental disorders. In Contemporary Directions in Psychopathology, 2nd edn (ed. Millon T., Krueger R. and Simonsen E.), pp. 223241. Guilford Press: New York.
Falkenbach D, Poythress N, Creevy C (2008). The exploration of subclinical psychopathic subtypes and the relationship with types of aggression. Personality and Individual Differences 44, 821832.
Fiedler ER, Oltmanns TF, Turkheimer E (2004). Traits associated with personality disorders and adjustment to military life: predictive validity of self and peer reports. Military Medicine 169, 207211.
Fraley C, Raftery AE (1998). How many clusters? Which clustering method? Answers via model-based cluster analysis. The Computer Journal 41, 578588.
Fraley C, Raftery AE (2002). Model-based clustering, discriminant analysis, and density estimation. Journal of the American Statistical Association 97, 611631.
Fraley C, Raftery A (2008). MCLUST: Multivariate Normal Mixture Modeling and Model-Based Clustering, version 3.1-1 ( Accessed 12 March 2010.
Frances A (1993). Dimensional diagnosis of personality: not whether, but when and which. Psychological Inquiry 4, 110111.
Harlan E, Clark LA (1999). Short-forms of the Schedule for Nonadaptive and Adaptive Personality (SNAP) for self and collateral ratings: development, reliability, and validity. Assessment 6, 131146.
Harkness AR, McNulty JL (1994). The Personality Psychopathology Five (PSY-5): issue from the pages of a diagnostic manual instead of a dictionary. In Differentiating Normal and Abnormal Personality (ed. Strack S. and Lorr M.), pp. 291315. Springer: New York.
Harkness AR, McNulty JL, Ben-Porath YS (1995). The Personality Psychopathology Five (PSY-5): constructs and MMPI-2 scales. Psychological Assessment 7, 104114.
Hettema JM, Neale MC, Myers JM, Prescott CA, Kendler KS (2006). A population-based twin study of the relationship between neuroticism and internalizing disorders. American Journal of Psychiatry 163, 857864.
Hicks BM, Markon KE, Patrick CJ, Krueger RF, Newman JP (2004). Identifying psychopathy subtypes on the basis of personality structure. Psychological Assessment 16, 276288.
John OP, Robins RW (1994). Traits and types, dynamics and development: no doors should be closed in the study of personality. Psychological Inquiry 5, 137142.
Kamphuis JH, Noordhof A (2009). On categorical diagnoses in DSM-V: cutting dimensions at useful points? Psychological Assessment 21, 294301.
Kendell R, Jablensky A (2003). Distinguishing between the validity and utility of psychiatry diagnoses. American Journal of Psychiatry 160, 4–12.
Krueger RF, Eaton NR, South SC, Clark LA, Simms LJ (in press). Dimensions, prototypes, and disorders: conceptualizing personality and personality disorders for DSM-V. In Evolution of the DSM-V Conceptual Framework: Development, Dimensions, Disability, Spectra, and Gender/Culture (ed. Regier D. A., Narrow W. E., Kuhl E. A. and Kupfer D. J.). American Psychiatric Association: Arlington, VA.
Krueger RF, Skodol AE, Livesley WJ, Shrout P, Huang Y (2007). Synthesizing dimensional and categorical approaches to personality disorders: refining the research agenda for DSM-V Axis II. International Journal of Methods in Psychiatric Research 16, S65S73.
Lahey BB (2009). Public health significance of neuroticism. American Psychologist 64, 241256.
Lenzenweger MF, Clarkin JF, Yeomans FE, Kernberg OF, Levy KN (2008). Refining the borderline personality disorder phenotype through finite mixture modeling: implications for classification. Journal of Personality Disorders 22, 313331.
Lenzenweger MF, McLachlan G, Rubin DB (2007). Resolving the latent structure of schizophrenia endophenotypes using expectation-maximization-based finite mixture modeling. Journal of Abnormal Psychology 116, 1629.
Lubke G, Muthén B (2007). Performance of factor mixture models as a function of model size, covariate effects, and class-specific parameters. Structural Equation Modeling 14, 2647.
McCrae RR, Terracciano A, Costa PT Jr., Ozer DJ (2006). Person-factors in the California Adult Q-Set: closing the door on personality trait types? European Journal of Personality 20, 2944.
McLachlan G, Peel D (2000). Finite Mixture Models. John Wiley & Sons, Inc.: New York.
Morey LC, Hopwood CJ, Gunderson JG, Skodol AE, Shea MT, Yen S, Stout RL, Zanarini MC, Grilo CM, Sanislow CA, McGlashan TH (2007). Comparison of alternative models for personality disorder. Psychological Medicine 37, 983994.
Morey LC, Warner MB, Shea MT, Gunderson JG, Sanislow CA, Grilo C, Skodol AE, McGlashan TH (2003). The representation of four personality disorders by the Schedule for Nonadaptive and Adaptive Personality dimensional model of personality. Psychological Assessment 15, 326332.
Mun EY, von Eye A, Bates ME, Vaschillo EG (2008 a). Finding groups using model-based cluster analysis: heterogeneous emotional self-regulatory processes and heavy alcohol use risk. Developmental Psychopathology 44, 481495.
Mun EY, Windle M, Schainker LM (2008 b). A model-based cluster analysis approach to adolescent problem behaviors and young adult outcomes. Development and Psychopathology 20, 291318.
Muthén B (2006). Should substance use disorders be considered as categorical or dimensional? Addiction 101 (Suppl. 1), 6–16.
Muthén LK, Muthén BO (2009). Mplus User's Guide, 5th edn. Muthén & Muthén: Los Angeles, CA.
Oltmanns TF, Turkheimer E (2006). Perceptions of self and others regarding pathological personality traits. In Personality and Psychopathology (ed. Krueger R. F. and Tackett J. L.), pp. 71111. Guilford Press: New York.
Raftery AE (1995). Bayesian model selection in social research. Sociological Methodology 25, 111163.
Raftery AE, Dean N (2006). Variable selection for model-based clustering. Journal of the American Statistical Association 101, 168178.
Ready RE, Clark LA (2002). Correspondence of psychiatric patient and informant ratings of personality traits, temperament, and interpersonal problems. Psychological Assessment 14, 3949.
Ready RE, Clark LA, Watson D, Westerhouse K (2000). Self- and peer-reported personality: agreement, trait ratability, and the ‘self-based heuristic’. Journal of Research in Personality 34, 208244.
Ready RE, Stierman L, Paulsen JS (2001). Ecological validity of neuropsychological and personality measures of executive function. Clinical Neuropsychologist 15, 314323.
Reynolds SK, Clark LA (2001). Predicting personality disorder dimensions from domains and facets of the five-factor model. Journal of Personality 69, 199222.
Robins RW, John OP, Caspi A, Moffitt TE, Stouthamer Loeber M (1996). Resilient, overcontrolled, and undercontrolled boys: three replicable personality types. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 70, 157171.
Samuel DB, Widiger TA (2008). A meta-analytic review of the relationships between the five-factor model and DSM-IV-TR personality disorders: a facet level analysis. Clinical Psychology Review 28, 13261342.
Simms LJ, Casillas A, Clark LA, Watson D, Doebbeling D (2005). Psychometric evaluation of the Restructured Clinical scales of the MMPI-2. Psychological Assessment 17, 345358.
Simms LJ, Turkheimer E, Clark LA (2007). Novel approaches to the structure of personality disorder. In Symposium III, 21st Annual Meeting of the Society for Research in Psychopathology, Iowa City, IA (
Skeem J, Johansson P, Andershed H, Kerr M, Louden JE (2007). Two subtypes of psychopathic violent offenders that parallel primary and secondary variants. Journal of Abnormal Psychology 116, 395409.
Tackett JL, Silberschmidt AL, Krueger RF, Sponheim SR (2008). A dimensional model of personality disorder: incorporating DSM Cluster A characteristics. Journal of Abnormal Psychology 117, 454459.
Tellegen A, Ben-Porath YS (1993). Code-type comparability of the MMPI and MMPI-2: analysis of recent findings and criticism. Journal of Personality Assessment 61, 489500.
Tellegen A, Ben-Porath YS, McNulty JL, Arbisi PA, Graham JR, Kaemmer B (2003). The MMPI-2 Restructured Clinical (RC) Scales: Development, Validation, and Interpretation. University of Minnesota Press: Minneapolis, MN.
Trull TJ, Durrett CA (2005). Categorical and dimensional models of personality disorder. Annual Review of Clinical Psychology 1, 355380.
Tucker LR (1951). A Method for the Synthesis of Factor Analysis Studies. Personnel Research Section Report No. 984. Department of the Army: Washington, DC.
Turkheimer E, Ford DC, Oltmanns TF (2008). Regional analysis of self-reported personality disorder criteria. Journal of Personality 76, 15871622.
Vittengl JR, Clark LA, Owen-Salters E, Gatchel RJ (1999). Diagnostic change and personality stability following functional restoration treatment in a chronic low back pain patient sample. Assessment 6, 7992.
Watson D, Clark LA, Chmielewski M (2008). Structures of personality and their relevance to psychopathology: II. Further articulation of a comprehensive unified trait structure. Journal of Personality 76, 15451585.
Widiger TA, Samuel DB (2005). Diagnostic categories or dimensions? A question for the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders–Fifth Edition. Journal of Abnormal Psychology 114, 494504.
Widiger TA, Simonsen E (2005). Alternative dimensional models of personality disorder: finding a common ground. Journal of Personality Disorders 19, 110130.
Widiger TA, Simonsen E, Krueger R, Livesley W, Verheul R (2005). Personality disorder research agenda for DSM-V. Journal of Personality Disorders 19, 315338.
Widiger TA, Trull TJ (2007). Plate tectonics in the classification of personality disorder: shifting to a dimensional model. American Psychologist 62, 7183.
Wu KD, Clark LA (2003). Relations between personality traits and self-reports of daily behavior. Journal of Research in Personality 37, 231256.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Psychological Medicine
  • ISSN: 0033-2917
  • EISSN: 1469-8978
  • URL: /core/journals/psychological-medicine
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *



Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 3
Total number of PDF views: 83 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 287 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 18th November 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.